Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • Breht_and_Alyson_(Imperialism).mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

Alyson and Breht were invited to join Robbie on the Upstream podcast to talk about Lenin's "Imperialism: The Highest Stage of Capitalism". 

Capitalism, imperialism, monopoly—far from being separate concepts that just happen to take shape parallel to one another or to overlap from time to time, these terms all really refer to the exact same overall process. We call it capitalism because it’s not always practical to call it “monopoly capitalism in its imperialist stage” or something like that, but really, capitalism is, as we’ll see, inevitably monopolistic and imperialist.

The process of capitalism’s historical evolution from its so-called, and somewhat fabricated stage of free-enterprise to monopoly capitalism, and then further into what we refer to as imperialism, was outlined both theoretically and empirically by Vladamir Lenin well over a century ago in his classic text, Imperialism, The Highest Stage of Capitalism. The connection between monopoly and imperialism might not seem quite straightforward to you at first, and an understanding of imperialism itself as a process grounded in political economy may seem somewhat counterintuitive—especially if you’re used to thinking of imperialism and empire in the more popular sense of the words. But that’s why we’ve brought on two guests to walk us through this crucial text and help us make sense of it all. 

Alyson Escalante and Breht O’Shea are the hosts of Red Menace, a podcast that explains and analyzes revolutionary theory and then applies its lessons to our contemporary conditions, and they’re both return guests of the show. In fact, they’ve been on a number of times to talk about other texts by Lenin but also to explore a wide variety of topics from trans liberation to revolutionary Buddhism. Breht is also the host of the terrific podcasts Revolutionary Left Radio and Shoeless in South Dakota. 

In this episode, we unpack Lenin’s Imperialism, The Highest Stage of Capitalism. This episode is an excellent introduction to the text but it also takes deep dives and gets granular at times, picking apart the nuances and various interpretations of the text. We explore the historical context in which Lenin wrote this book and then trace capitalism’s history from its early stages into its monopoly form. We explore how finance capital emerged and became similarly concentrated, how this merging of concentrated finance and industrial capital began to spread out from capitalist countries into the periphery and began to carve up the world, and how this process led to what we now understand to be capitalism’s final and highest stage: imperialism. And, of course, we apply the text to a variety of current events and explore how we can apply Lenin’s ideas in ways that help us grow and strengthen our socialist movements globally. 

Learn more about Upstream HERE

Files

Comments

reee reee

I don't like this, it's just not for me sorry but if there is another podcast episode about this I'd like to listen to it

Chaim Jones

Thank you all for a really engaging discussion. Regarding the role of unions and the labor aristocracy in imperialism, a concrete example is the way the urgent and repeated appeals of Palestinian unions for solidarity action to stop the genocide have been ignored. There is solidarity organizing among the rank and file of some unions, but the unions have done, effectively, nothing.

Lefty In Training

Can't be emphasized enough that capitalism is a process with a logic that inevitably leads to all of the supposedly anti-capitalistic horrors we have been dealing with since the age of capitalist imperialism. This is definitely what I try to get across to my friends who think capitalism can be tweaked, returned to a better form, or just have the "bad guys removed." Unfortunately, some of them definitely think of me as akin to a conspiracy theorist when i talk about economic systems having an internal logic to yhe extent Marx presents, so maybe I need to work on my delivery haha

Steven Phillips

It’s always good to return to this crucial book. Well done. 👍🏼

Ren

The ILA example is interesting - a friend of mine talked to workers on the picket line in New Jersey (so east coast ILA) and it seems like it’s actually a separate contract that dictates their labor around weapons shipments. So I think there’s a way in which this is also a question of the labor movement operating within a super conservative legal framework as well, which may be something we’re forced to break away from under a Trump NLRB. To me, the two main tasks ahead for those of us fighting for our unions to stand in solidarity with Palestine (and against US imperialism more broadly) are to 1) gain rank and file power/ wrest our unions out of the hands of a true labor aristocracy and 2) break away ultimately from a legal / more timid approach to organizing and workplace action. I think what we can’t do tho (not that I think any of you were doing this) is assume that a unions official position reflects rank and file sentiment

Ren

But anyway i think Brehts answer to Robbie’s question on that was really good

Onur

Great episode! Which conference did you and Alyson meet at in 2018?

Benny Boy

Re: Labour Aristocracy in the Imperial core: I would recommend reading George Orwell's 'The Road to Wigan Pier' (1930s) and Tressell's 'The Ragged Trousered Philanthropists' (Pre-WWI) as persuasive evidence that this analysis (whatever Lenin's intention) could not have applied to all members of the working class in the UK (at least). The living conditions for most workers and their families were shocking.

Jeremiah

George Orwell wrote something decent?? Tf

Jeremiah

When it comes to any analysis I think it's worth asking "If this is true, then what?" And if it's true that the whole working class or even the majority of it in the imperial core is "bought off," then there's nothing for Marxist-Leninists in the imperial core to do (and, for that matter, there shouldn't be Marxist-Leninists in the imperial core at all). So it's essentially a defeatist, anti-worker line. If we haven't managed to earn leadership of the advanced sections of the class that's on us. Blaming the masses for not being what we want them to be flies in the face of everything Mao wrote about contradictions among the people and the role of Communists. At base I think it's q classic ultra-left case of misidentifying your allies as your enemies. The Sakai-style settler colonial analysts make the same mistake when they regard all white and even African-American and Chicano workers as "settlers." Naturally this goes hand in hand with the error of misidentifying the principal contradiction. To anyone who says that the working class as a whole in the imperial core is "bought off," i.e. they reap too many benefits from imperialism, they're fat and content, I say speak for yourself.

Foko

There’s a red menace episode from 2018 on the same book!

Rev Left Radio

I am very sympathetic to this line of argumentation for sure. I do not think the ENTIRE working class in the core is bought off in this way, merely aspects of it. The Labor aristocracy is important here cuz its a segment of the proletariat that is "bought off". But poor and working people in the US suffering and struggling to get by, having no access to healthcare, no access to affordable or stable housing, living paycheck to paycheck, etc I have a very hard time seeing how they benefit from this system in any way. IN fact, many working people are hurt by it via, among other things, their taxes going to support the imperial death machine instead of being funneled into social services for them. So the exploitation of the proletariat at home and the exploitation of the proletariat abroad are connected.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, ive read the Road to Wigan Pier years ago and liked it a lot.

Rev Left Radio

It was the Marxist Center conference in Colorado Springs, Boots Riley was a speaker and we all watched his film Sorry to Bother You in a big auditorium, etc.

Jeremiah

Agreed 100%. Certainly most people living in the US have it better in many ways than those in places exploited by imperialism. I also subscribe to the analysis that Chicanos and African-Americans in the US constitute oppressed nations, and their national territories exist as practically internal colonies of the US. So in that sense it's particularly white workers who are more likely to be, if not "bought off," then at least duped into supporting imperialism. But I think a lot of activists and ultra-left commentators take that to mean that white workers in the US are the enemy, on the basis that they're settlers or colonizers, which would preclude any possibility of a strategic alliance between the multinational working class, including working whites, and the oppressed nations, which as far as I can see is the only hope of achieving revolution in this country. Obviously this isn't a perfect analogy but the ultra-left trend of mistaking white workers for the enemy reminds me of Trotsky's line of viewing the peasants of Russia as the enemy because they supposedly had no revolutionary potential. In a struggle against such powerful forces as monopoly capitalism and the US imperial machine, we can't afford to have a faulty analysis of who our friends are and who are enemies are. Anyway thanks for replying with your thoughts, really love your work. Both you and Alyson 🙌