Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht listens to, reflects on, and critically engages with a public lecture by the late philosopher Michael Sugrue entitled "Nietzsche and the Death of God". He discusses the philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche, the politics of modern day Nietzscheans, the death of god and consumer capitalism as a form a nihilism, the ongoing nature of human civilizational and spiritual evolution, the biography of Nietzsche, what the next step of human evolution might be, the synthesis of religion and science,  scientific and ontological materialism, the limits of atheism, the importance of spiritual struggle, and much more. 

Professor Sugrue passed away last year, and Breht has always found his free, public lectures on philosophy to be helpful and really well done. In the spirit of free and open access to education, Breht offers his knowledge of philosophy alongside this offering by Professor Sugrue.
The use of this lecture series falls under the protections of the Fair Use doctrine. 

Outro Music: "Temple Grandin Too" by AJJ

Check out all our other episodes on Nietzsche HERE

Follow RLR on IG HERE

Make a one-time donation to Rev Left at BuyMeACoffee.com/revleftradio

 

Files

Comments

Jihad

Loved this as well, I’d be interested in more as long as you’re up for it. In general, I think there’s something really interesting and generative when existentialism meets political economy, so any future review that has those two topics collide has my vote

Rev Left Radio

I definitely aim to do a Phil Series ep on existentialism some point soon! Glad you are enjoying these, and thank you for supporting the show fr.

Max

Very good, both the lecture and your reflections! Nietzsche will forever be the central philosopher of humanity’s adolescence. God did not die. What has perished is merely the childish vision of a paternalistic God who watches over the world from outside. Your relation to your father changes when you grow up. You have to break free in a more or less rebellious fashion, but that does not mean you need to sever the connection. We must beat our own path through the universe, but we are not forsaken. The spirit is still around us as a guiding light in times that may seem dark and empty. In a sense, God, in his true form as uncovered by his image, is only just starting to become alive.

Jolene Bresney

i love when you delve into philosophy. it reveals metaphysics as a divergence and avoidance of material conditions. obv not all philosophers but enough of them are avoiding analysis of tangible problems and systemic solutions. 🕯️

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

These philosophy episodes are really helpful for me when it comes to learning philosophy since I don’t have the time to sit down and read about it. On the comment about how people who consider themselves to believe in God, I agree that it’s not the same as it was in the past. People who call themselves believers, unless they’re fundamentalist, are open to different interpretations of what God means which obviously wouldn’t have been the case in the time of Nietzsche. However, I think the majority of religion in the US now is just spiritual materialism. It’s an identity component to make one stand out in a world that increasingly identifies as non-believing. These people that engage with spirituality on an egotistical level likely have no genuine beliefs beyond their little Bible quote on their Instagram profile. What really irks me is athletes who make a big show about their “belief” in God - crossing themselves before a game, claiming that God helped them win. So God likes your team over your opponent? I could go on but most of America is only religious insofar that it makes them stand out and look good. Beyond that these people are vapid spiritually. (Note that I am only talking from a Christian perspective. I can’t speak for other religions.)

Rev Left Radio

Beautifully and perfectly said. I could not agree more!! I have an upcoming episode on Spinoza where I want to delve into what this higher understanding of god might be! Stay tuned! :)

Rev Left Radio

Could not agree more, my friend! Spot on. Your point about most christians being so in a spiritually materialist and ego-centric way hits the nail on the head and its exactly why we have tens of millions of so-called christians in America but it remains one of the most nihilistic, anti-christian, spiritually empty societies on earth!

Rev Left Radio

Yes! AS marx said "philosophers have only hitherto interpreted the world..." I appreciate Nietzsche's attempt to bring philosophy back down to earth and avoid metaphysical speculation, even if I disagree with much of his philosophy.

Lana

Please please please continue the philosophy series!! 👌🏻 also wondering, does Rev Left have a Discord?

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Lana, I will! :) I do not. TBH I try to keep my online activity to a reasonable minimum. WE used to have a discord, but I never joined it and a particularly shady and self-serving anon took advantage of my absence to self-promote and whatnot and it was all very gross so I just nuked it lol. I have thought about starting a book club or something on rev left where we meet on zoom once a month to discuss a book we are all reading together. Would that be interesting to you?

Lana

Oh hell yea!! I’m so in for a book club.

LeftoverComputer

I'm still listening to the intro but wanted to comment before I forget- yes, love the philosophy series and appreciate being able to learn about these topics from someone with the same political and ideological views as me

Juche Stalin

Breht, your rants are like 80% of why I love your show. Love and solidarity.

Rev Left Radio

That truly means a lot to me. thank you! And thank you for supporting the show. <3

Curtis

I truly want you to continue this philosophy series. Also, you nailed the music choice. AJJ is the perfect musician to place with a Nietchze episode on a leftist podcast. Well played, good sir.. well played.

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate that very much! I really enjoy doing these type of episodes so its great to hear that its useful for others!

Lefty In Training

The whole "you plebs should be honorored to lift up a superior person like me" is why I can't stand aristocratic thinkers even when they say other things worth pondering. It's such an obvious contradiction with their hyper individualistic, will to power mindset to need or expect assistance from supposedly lesser people. They think they are so great, but need loads of supposedly unskilled workers to build their skyscraper? Sounds like those workers are closer to being Uberminches than the aristocrat, since they are actually accomplishing something. If Uberminches can't accomplish anything themselves, in what way are they materially better?

Rev Left Radio

SPEAK ON IT!!! hahaha yes you are spot on. Everytime the issue gets brought up I try to make that point in one way or another. Its ego-mania, and Nietzsche quite literally suffered from meglomania in the lead up to his mental collapse. All true spiritual growth is the transcendence of the ego and the deep-seeing of interdependence. There is no you without everyone else, historically and presently. You can see how Nietzsche's ideas were picked up by both state fascists AND ayn randian libertarian dorks.

Rev Left Radio

haha so glad you appreciated that combination! I was quite proud of it!

Rev Left Radio

Just a matter of finding the time. Trying to become a teacher and got small children, im always stressed and busy. But its on the top of my list for the medium term!

Adam

Whole time I was listening to this all I could think is GG Allin is Nietzsche in practice! If you don't who it is listen to his time on Jerry Springer or Jane Whitney for something to laugh at. Dude was a lost menace to society, such a terrible person I can't listen to anything he says without erupting in laughter. Keep up the good shit man!

Jasper Foley

I'm not sure how much you're just playing it up for the audience, but you speak of atheism with the same disdain as you claim atheists speak of religion, I dunno if it's just a self hatred of your own past new atheists self, but I don't think it's the healthiest way to conduct the conversation

Josh Ruston

You just made me want to reread totem and taboo…

JK

More good stuff Brett. So I was thinking, now with the ACP falling apart and their leadership starting to talk about how disingenuous the party was, it would be a good time to talk about the errors of Stalinism. Its sort of a great example how Stalinism always leads to these cults of personality and the party/bureaucracy getting elevated above the rank and file and the masses. Can't exactly say anyone is surprised they are falling apart even before the 1 year mark XD

Rev Left Radio

The ACP falling apart and being exposed as a cult ran by an egomaniac is no surprise, but what do you mean by Stalinism? The ACP is more of an eclectic org with duganist and social chauvinist elements as far as I can tell. Not sure what stalinism means in that context.

Rev Left Radio

Naw I just think atheism has its limits, is often too dismissive of genuine spirituality, is the product of historical factors, and is often held dogmatically. There is an arrogance in claiming you know whether or not god exists, and an epistemic myopia that flies in the face of the radical humility we should have when thinking about the enormity and profundity and radical mystery of the cosmos. But I have nothing against atheists, like I have nothing against monotheists. I just disagree with the implied certainty of holding those positions. But in a lot of ways I could be described as an agnostic-atheist buddhist with a love and respect for Christ. So I dont see myself as totally outside these traditions or entirely hostile to them.

Rev Left Radio

never heard of him but will check him out!! glad you enjoyed the ep, my friend! Thanks for the support!

Adam

Most of his stuff is kinda incoherent. I grew outta that kinda metal. He has an outlaw country album that kills it tho! Feel like a bad father to two daughters when I listen to it but oh well. He saw the violent insanity of the world and became the epitome of it. He spoke it out loud but didn't do a fraction of the damage our societal elite do... Take care breht man!

JK

Yeah, I can see the elements of Duganism you picked up on. It just seemed to me, from the leaked "politburo" meetings these clowns had, they had built this cult of personality around Haz much in the same way Stalin had surrounded himself with his Yes-Men and Bureaucratic clique which elevated itself above the masses and rest of the party. Hell, they even go so far as to call anyone who questioned leadership a Trotskyist LOL. It just struck me as being similar to these other Stalinist type orgs, where leadership was/is unquestionable. And finally...seeing how these events are panning out, seems like they are going to dissolve as well like the other Stalinists of the past. But like you hinted at, good riddance to these fucking clowns. A disgraceful group to taint the term Communist....

Max

I dont think it is helpful to vulture over another organisation's internal troubles, even if you may disagree with its approach. Nor do I think it is particularly enlighting to jump to self-affirming conclusions at first chance before something has fully enveloped. Going from a parasocial streamer standpoint and the shout-down online debate culture to building a real world political organization will bear with it expectable infantile disorders to which the nascent party may our may not succumb to, but which don't shed a lot of light on the foundational principles of Marxism-Leninism. These people have very little experience in organising and some very naive ideas (like party businesses) which are bound to cause a mess in the beginning. However, this does not dissprove their theoretical standpoint. When I first came across Haz, I started to read his essay on why Marxism is not woke, expecting to amuse myself. I have to admit though, that I was thouroughly impressed by its philosophical substance. A lot of it is unripe, but the more I have dealt with these thoughts the more I am conviced that he has a point. "Left conservatism" is a phenomenon that is gaining traction in many places globally (e.g. here in Germany very recently) and I think it has something to it. While Haz often presents itself in a manner that is quite off-putting, I think it nevertheless may yield something philosophically to approach what he says with an open mind.

Rev Left Radio

Interesting points from both of you. But Max, its not that they dont have any decent things to bring up or insights to offer, its the way they carry themselves. Calling people slurs (F*****, R*****, etc.), fixating on their "online enemies" and organizing social media drama, having no standards for who is let in the org because its all about quantity over quality to grow the org, the unearned titles of "chairman" and "party" without putting in any of the work to build mass support, letting obvious opportunists and self-advancers like Hinkle who have no real principles and will do anything to get attention and clout, their outright bigoted behavior toward gay and trans people, their promotion of american nationalism, etc. etc. etc. This is NOT an admirable way to conduct ourselves as communists and its not an effective way either. Their organization isnt doing the work of even the DSA or PSL. Its cool if you find a thing or two that is worthwhile and I wouldnt assume they are wrong about everything, especially their critique of liberalism and the way liberal aesthetics and cultural posturing on the radical left is a detriment to it and isolates people on the left from the working class. But their reactionary, terminally online, immature, machismo posturing isolates just as many if not more people. Overall, principled, effective organizations that serve the masses and build mass support simply do not act like this. There is no honor or dignity in such behavior, and there is no real results to show for that approach. They are about as advanced as Black Hammer got: some real world mutual aid stuff and protesting, plus getting on some stages and platforms, but thats overshadowed by insane, perpetual online drama, and the maintaince of the inflated ego of its leaders. I do not spend my time shitting on real orgs doing real work. Youll notice I almost never do, and if I do its pirncipled and respectful. I dont think this right-deviated pseudo-cult is worthy of that respect, nor do I see them as being on "our side". They are hostile to literally everyone else on the socialist and communist left, putting themselves above everyone else in really arrogant ways. You have to give respect to earn it, and you need to be humble in this work. When you lack those qualities, its hard for me to respect it in any way.

JK

Well said, completely agree. Their conduct is pitiful. And like you said, not even worth the time to give them more than a glancing thought.

Bill

That was great. Please do more philosophy! I particularly appreciated connecting the dots between Christianity >Dualism (dominion over nature)> Science> death of god> Neitzche’s Ubermensch> Capitalism. Funny how one may seem to supplant the other over time but instead here we are centuries later still subjected to this insane mix of Christianity and Capitalism. Couldn’t agree with you more that we need the non-duality mindset of Buddhism and the pragmatism of science to prevail in order to expedite the removal of Christofascism and capitalism before they destroy us.

Max

I very much see your points and I share your evaluation of their practical work. (I do disagree on the question of nationalism.) However, immaturity can be cured with time and their aggressiveness against the existing left (while firstly mutual) may just as well be a necessary byproduct of their fission from the predominant (left) liberal culture. A pubescent overcompensation to shape oneself in differentiation (akin maybe to early maoist hostility towards soviet ML and vice versa). I do not expect anyone to associate with them or even just to tolerate their behaviour. Only to leave a single shaky bridge dangling. Because, insufferable as they may be, I think they might have hit onto something.

Rev Left Radio

Well said, Bill, as always!! Glad it resonated with you! Ill def be doing more of these types of episodes because they are fun to make and folks like you seem to find some value in them!

Dirt Fox

I always appreciate the philosophy episodes of RevLeft

Monty O’Blivion

Really enjoyed this one Breht, the “ubermenschen” actually being a bunch of losers had me rolling. It’s accurate across the board, Andrew Tate, Jordy Penerson, Elon Musk, the idea that these absolute clowns somehow transcend the rest of us is hilarious.

Mexican Stalin

The Buddha and Jesus could be seen as leftists breaking from centuries of oppressive conservative systems. In Buddhism, they taught that everyone has a piece of divinity within them and can achieve enlightenment in this life, with this body. Similarly, in Christianity, Jesus proclaimed that the kingdom of God is within all men. It reminds me of the Soviets' concept of the "New Soviet Man"—the idea that creating a society that meets people's needs and teaches them skills can help them become better, more altruistic individuals. But Marxism has lost its romance. It's all utilitarian now; it no longer inspires people to sacrifice for the greater good. Instead, it's become focused on maximizing material gains for ourselves. Why, for example, aren’t workers in the chocolate industry striking for better wages for their fellow workers in the Global South? Or dock workers shutting down the economy for Palestine. If we can create a kinder society and teach people to be kind, their desires will fade away, and with them, their suffering. Look at what happened after the collapse of the Soviet Union. People were tempted by desire—by the allure of an American lifestyle. But what has that lifestyle brought us? Miserable suffering: obesity, medical problems that we ignore because we cant afford to treat them, our own sickness caused by overconsumption. We’re poisoned by microplastics from the cheap trinkets we desire but don’t need. We need to become new Soviet men—kinder, selfless, and dedicated to the well-being of all society.

MLDad

Great episode like the marx one... Looking forward to the rest of the series!! Bring kierkegaard, Schopenhauer, hegel, espinoza... Invite matthew furlong as a guest commentator! L&S

Radiant Sun Warrior

I heard the criticism of atheism, or it's disdain, more as a disdain for dogmatism or chauvinism. The holding Atheism as the absolute truth, because it's the most modern or because it's the evolution after Christianity, is naive. It's the rigid clinging to metaphysical truth here that's under attack in my opinion. Though on the surface it can look like a dissing on atheists. I think there is still place for individual christians, atheists, and in a way pantheonic pagans. It's a separate question of social practice and the stage of development of our beliefs about the structures of the world are at. To say that the atheist, dead universe mythos is the end of the evolution of belief in cosmic sructure, is a hard sell. I think that's more the point being made.

Radiant Sun Warrior

I just started reading Hegel, and while it's really dense and hard to understand, it really creates a backdrop for conversations like this one. Understanding a thing also creates an understanding of what it is not. Hearing Nietzsche again after having read more/other thinkers really shows that his ideas are brilliant but in a direction and flavor. There are other foundations to philosophy that give us an answer to the death of God, and his response to it is by no means THE response to it. If one only reads Nietzsche, they might be tempted to see that as the take away, dispite Nietzsche himself advocating against that. I loved this episode, it's dripping in the philosophical sauce that I dip my daily bread into. Keep it coming!

Nick

Nietzche sounds like an incel projecting his insecurities out onto the world. His collapse into insanity seems like the logical conclusion of a life devoid of virtue (and therefore meaning). He prolly woulda went crazy on r/atheism tho 😉

Thomas Paul Ranz

Thanks for these philosophy sessions. Are you planning on tackling eastern thought like Taoism or Confucianism? Thanks!

Wes Rich

I really appreciated this episode. When I was an edgy younger man I was incredibly anti-Christian, which now in hindsight I can see as an incredibly privileged stance, and someone suggested I look into Nietsche and I disagreed with much of what I read. That was at this point decades ago and to be honest I just completely ignored him so it’s nice to get some insight that not only informs my distaste but also offers some historical context to his writing that went completely over my head.

Olivia

I love this series. Thanks for the episode!

Tiffani McCoy

Keep the philosophy series coming!!

Haazen

JK: I get the the sense that your framing of Stalin as a cult of personality and calling his marxist-leninist applications as Stalinism come from a western marxist point of view. The man made mistakes, but he wasn't the head of a cult nor did he morph maxist-leninism philosophy into Stalinism. I would urge you to learn more about Stalin and how he's made out to be this black figure in history. He himself rejected any sort of blind admiration of him (i.e. head of a cult) from the party. Now released CIA documents also discuss how he was not a cult of personality. Misrepresenting him as a cult leader and regurgitating the term Stalinism only helps the capitalist class. One can critique Stalin and the period of governance without resorting to revisionism of history. I cant recommend the Stalin Eras series by Proles Pod enough, they address this in their hours long series.

Derek

Hey Breht, just listening to your episode on Neitzsche, and I was so moved by your long digression on mystical unity/ego collapse vs the "egocentrism at the core of our civilizational problem." I'm sure you get 100 pitches for episode ideas for every 1 you can do, but I wonder if you would see any value for your listeners in a conversation about the philosophical paradox or contradiction (at least, from my perspective) at the heart of ML thought. In this same moment in the podcast, you laid out the contrast between a "dominion over" mentality versus a "harmony with" approach, and characterized it as humanity needing to movng from an adolescent phase to an adult phase. And I loved how you put it: "We cannot take the same mentality... that got us here... and create a happy, sustainable world for everybody." But isn't the very idea of the dictatorship of the proletariat in its essence a "dominion over" approach, one that is obsessed with seizing state power? And then once you have it, maintaining it at all odds against class enemies? I know this is thought of in progressive terms, because you empower the vast majority at the expense of the tiny minority, but to me the philosophical beating heart beneath it is an assertion that we can, indeed, build the better, sane world on a foundation of subjugation. Even if it's a much "better, more just" subjugation for the masses, doesn't it feed a will to power as well? And once fed and sustained in creating and maintaining the forces of the state, how on earth will that will be dismantled? I don't feel that actually existing socialism has been able to answer this essential question. If Marxist theorists have attempted to, I'd love to read their take. Marx himself was at his most idealist when dismissing this contradiction as the eventual withering away of the state and achievement of a fully equal communism. (I get why at that historical moment, the focus was on seizure of power and not much beyond.) But as we know, the state as an institution then has its own drive of survival that as a machinery is much bigger than the human cogs that make it up. It's very similar to how once you have a capitalist machine, everyone within it becomes enslaved to forces much bigger than themselves, including the capitalists. I find this paradox interesting and more than a little necessary to grapple with seriously, and have often wondered how you reconcile it, as I've listened for years to RevLeft and your other work, and I hear in you an earnest mystical appreciation and love for all humanity, the dignity of all, mixed with (at times) a bit of a vengeful "I can't wait to put the boot on your neck, motherfuckers, when it's our turn" framing that seems so contradictory, though I totally fucking get it on a visceral level. But again, the question is, can one of these diametrically opposed, though natural, human impulses truly be used to accomplish the other, or is that wishful thinking? Seems to me that since there will always be hostile forces somewhere (internal, external), socialism will never be able to yield state power and the repression it entails. A world without contradictions has never existed, and in my view never will. We are all a bundle of forces, drives, and values, some of them inevitably contradictory.