Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht presents a lecture on historical materialism that he wrote and is slated to give to a group of local organizers, and then to the general public, as part of a political education initiative connected to local coalitional organizing efforts in Omaha... and he asks for your feedback on it to make it as good and accessible as possible!

Files

Comments

Lukas Jaekel

I think there’s an opportunity to mention the concept of capitalist realism. Certainly a book and thought that helped me when I first started learning about Marxism. But I loved the lecture as it is already. Just brainstorming

Sean Sullivan

Hey Breht! I gave this a couple listens in hopes of coming across some helpful critiques. Honestly all I have is that the addition of a few real world examples of non-Marxist social movements and their failings could help drive those points home. Aside from that, I’ve spent the last month or so obsessed with all of your shows as I graduated in December and wanted to continue my education. I can’t thank you enough for your contribution to my personal growth. Your episodes on mysticism guided me towards spirituality and meditation, putting me on a road towards real mental clarity and freedom from all addictions. I still struggle with determining where I should go from here. Of course you touch on it in episodes I’ve heard but I’m curious if you have more on how to better organize for effective change or can point me towards other sources for enhancing this skill in detail. Much love and solidarity :) Edit: finishing up this second listen I’m hearing that you already touched on my own advice lol

Rev Left Radio

Hey Sean, thank you for putting so much time into this one, and I value your feedback that I am on the right track!!! As for your kind words about the show, it means the world to me to hear that. Truly. Nothing more rewarding then to hear someone say that our show has helped them and inspired them. Thank you so much for your support, my friend!!! As for where to go from here, its dependent on so many variables its hard to say, other than to urge you to organize in whatever capacity you can given your location, free time, other responsibilities, etc. I have a veteran organizer from the 60s and 70s coming on soon and we will discuss that in detail which you may find helpful. But joining any left organization in your community is a good start, one learns so much just from doing, and you can build community in the meantime. In any case, keep learning, keep pursuing your spiritual path, continue to break free from any addictions, get your mind and body in a healthy place, and do what you can! Love and Solidarity!

Rev Left Radio

At teh very least it would be perfect to add to the recommendation list for the lecture for sure! Great point! Its a really helpful concept, and ill see if I can slide it in w the superstructure part of the discussion. Appreciate your support and feedback Lukas!

Trish Kanous

You quoted Star Trek making it a perfect lecture 😁

Saya Clarke

Hey Breht, Two things came to mind while I was listening but first I’ll say I think it’s great and obviously you have a huge amount of experience delivering these topics so it comes across very forthright and confident which I think is good. People are a lot more likely to take an argument seriously if they believe the person delivering it has done their homework and can speak authoritatively so good job on that. So for my two suggestions, first I would say that the section where you kind of argue against anarchist horizontalism and leaderless movements without naming anarchism specifically was delivered with a hint of snark. Doesn’t bother us on Patreon of course because we are familiar with the argument and how obvious this point is once you have a thorough understanding of leftist struggle in the 20th century and contemporary anarchist texts like ‘Desert’ but maybe be careful to watch your delivery during that section. I find that well meaning left sympathizing people who are new to organizing might have passively absorbed these ideas and it feels intuitive to them when starting from a general, “Fuck the government, fuck authority” sentiment without any theoretical grounding. Or they may just straight up be people who like the aesthetics of anarchism and it could be better to be more delicate when trying to bring people of these varieties over to our side. Second, I don’t know exactly where a section like this would go but something I have noticed in my year and a half of organizing is that a *huge* amount of people come to organizing because they are particularly upset by something happening in the news and they want to help for that reason. For example, they see the fall of Roe v. Wade, they see Palestinians being slaughtered, they see police brutality and the slaying of black youth or they see trans people being demonized and they think, “I want to fight this. I want to help people.” Basically they come to organizing by way of *social justice* So my constant struggle is how to take these new and starry eyes, enthusiastic people who are coming from this place and get them to see the larger picture of how all of these struggles are interconnected by way of social and economic conditions of the base and superstructure. I never want to tell people that simply fighting for social justice is not enough and that only focusing on these fights is like trying to control the fire instead of putting it out. I think then I would suggest a section that addresses social justice by name and praises advancements towards that end but then concisely demonstrates the need for the broader struggle the ideological war for dominance. Sorry if that’s a lot and I hope you understand what I’m getting at. I love organizing, I love struggling with these issues and I love meeting new people who have finally had enough of the decaying world order and have decided to finally to something about it. Anyways, good luck comrade. Thanks as always for everything you do. Solidarity.

SprocketMusic

I'm going to leave comments as I listen rather than try to compile them afterwards. I love how in the very beginning you ask the listener to put aside preconceived notions about what Marxism is and is not. You do a really good job of getting ahead of people's doubts and skepticism. This opener comes off as really reasonable and authentic. Criticism: somewhere around 10:40-11:20 you use terms like "historical materialism", "base and superstructure" and "modes of production" before defining them. If I had never heard these terms before, I would feel like I was falling behind already, and lag a bit to think about them and figure out if I actually understood what you were saying. I recommend either avoiding these terms in your prologue entirely, or just say, "and don't worry folks, if you don't know what these terms mean I'll be defining these terms for you as we explore them, and I'll get to that in just a moment."

A Gardener

Thanks, Breht, this was great. Lots of thoughts. I’ll share just one here, but Im going back for a 2nd listen... 🎧 IMHO the first section has great pacing, specificity, use of examples, and conceptual breakdowns. Lecturing for retention is nearly always better than lecturing for “coverage”, and you exemplify that here. As the lecture develops and widens scope, it also picks up pace as a listener. There is a lot to keep track of. My suggestion is to keep that snowballing content load in mind as you revise—all of us have limited RAM. Visuals (as you noted in the podcast) can also help listeners stay orientated. Looking forward to iterations. Solidarity!

A Gardener

Breht, experienced lecturer here. 👋 I currently draft, edit, and revise stuff for a living. If it would be helpful—and if none of your much more brilliant and published comrades are available lol—I’m happy to volunteer to review drafts. DMs open. Solidarity.

Norman Bethune

Hello comrade! Long time listener but this my first time commenting. First let me say that your show(s) not only have been extremely influential in my political development but also they have been deeply helpful in understanding other aspects of my life (your talks on meditation, religion etc). Even though I have been listening to your pods for years I have really only been studying Marxism in a serious way for the past 6 months. I attended a revolutionary study this past fall that I had discovered from a show you did in August. In my humble opinion, as a beginner in revolutionary theory, and based on my experience in that study, this past fall, I would recommend using the question of modes of production bleeding into each other and the example of chattel slavey in the USA as a discussion question. The reason being is that it is a question that will generate real conversation as opposed to a question that will likely only lead to making a list. I really love the work that you do. I am constantly inspired by you! As an aside, a number of the comrades from that structured study this past fall have formed an independent reading group. We read revolutionary books on zoom. We always are looking for guest hosts to talk to our group. For example we will have JMP as a guest host on March 9th to introduce The Wretched of the Earth which is the next book we are going to read. I know that you are super busy, so I totally understand if you can't, but I have to ask: at some point would you want to join as a guest host for a brief discussion with my revolutionary study group? In solidarity, Graydon

Wes Rich

I loved it. It’s very well put together and I really can’t think of anything I’d add, which I know isn’t super helpful. I did think of a question that might be worth asking: what do you think are the main objections to a socialist mode of production? I always find it wild when someone objects to an egalitarian set of relations so maybe it will get the students thinking about how just insane it is that anyone would choose capitalism over Marxism.

Wes Rich

I also think your idea about asking what elements of previous modes of production lingered into the next phase because I think that would really help the students think about the distinctions and similarities between the current and previous modes of production

Brad Northcote

Wracking my brain for something to add, but it's a well-delivered intro! Examples are good, but examples your audience can brainstorm are great. That said, the contrast between historical materialism and reactionary idealizing of a skewed representation of the past really merits emphasis now as much as ever.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I liked the lecture! First question: does this political education initiative have social media pages yet? I would like to follow your group's progress. Feedback: First, I agree with what other commentators have said about defining terms. Second, when you give this lecture the first time, you will obviously be giving it to people with extensive background knowledge in leftist political theory. They will already be familiar with much of what you are going to say. However, given that the goal of this initiative is to bring in new people who may or may not have the same background knowledge - this is my teacher brain speaking, - would it be helpful to provide your audience with a brief outline of the lecture including key terms, or even guided notes? In teaching you never assume your students know anything about the topic they are learning about. An outline would be a great reference, especially during breakout groups, and it's something they can refer to in their outside organizing or use if they want to explore more. Plus, you throw a lot at the audience in this and it might help them with following along. Last, any chance you'll be able to record this presentation for the Patreon? :)

Spiderdijo7

That was ace Breht! Suggestions: You could possibly bring up real working examples of post capitalist societies. "Socialist experiments" (hate that term personally). Though I think you did hint at the end of capitalism somewhere, can't remember if you mentioned socialism. As you're teaching in America perhaps it would be fitting to bring up Native American's mode of production? I like how you mentioned the superstructural and base elements can bleed into a society's subsequent modes of production. It's great left alone as it is though tbh

JK

Sounds really solid comrade. I think it would be useful to make a point that Marxism is an international movement. As he said, workers have no country and we’ve all witnessed the failing of “Socialism in one country”. You can quickly point out how Capitalism is a global system and so a socialist revolution must be international as well. I’m sure you’ll get a standing ovation when you finally get to present it

Raquelle Jac

Thanks for this episode, just wondering, if you have time, was there a reason why the episode art is ai? I really respect and am grateful for your work in educating people (including me, a newbie leftist) about leftism but I wonder if using ai art distracts /undermines the message? Obvi it’s an interesting photo but since the episode (so far, I’ve only listened to the fist 20 minutes so far) isn’t related to ai, I wonder if the cheapness of the image distracts from the wealth of knowledge in the episode. I know this isn’t a “canon” episode , but still, I feel like it distracts. I bet - if you’re in need of episode art - many artists / hobbyists/ doodlers would prolly love to donate work to your podcast to help you get some CHOICE episode art. Including me!

Ed Cook

I think this is a great intro, especially for 30 minutes. One thing I was thinking was possibly a little more on the WHY the material drives history as opposed to ideas (e.g. necessity is the mother of invention; invention is not the mother of necessity). The only reason I even mention it is Americans are just so indoctrinated into idealism. But really this is outstanding. As far as chattel slavery, I would not confound this very coherent and succinct overview but would put it to discussion. I think it would, from a pedagogical/andogogical perspective help reinforce the concepts to have people wrestle with it intellectually. Just provide help if they get stuck. Also it maximizes your time. Just my two cents. Great job though. Very impressive.

Rev Left Radio

Great feedback, thank you!! Important point about WHY the material drives history. Ill have to wrestle with how to put that in there but I agree its really important. I more just stated it as a fact instead of explained it. It would absolutely be worth dedicating at least a small paragraph to! Appreicate the support!

Rev Left Radio

Very fair point Raquelle! Its just something I threw together because finding an image of hist mat is difficult cuz its an abstract concept. I get all the criticism of AI and there is an ep a few back here on patreon where I wrestled with left criticism of AI, its social inevitability, etc. which you might disagree with but at least have a fuller argument presented. It was a one-off thing that I needed quickly just to post this on patreon, and trying to reach out and ask artists to make an image would have been time consuming for a relatively unimportant thumbnail to a bonus ep exclusively on patreon. None the less, I take your point - ESPECIALLY FOR ART. Genuinely. If it were a more important or public facing photo perhaps the time and energy to commission something would be worth it. It was admittedly a short cut. In any case, I take your criticism seriously and will keep it firmly in mind going forward. Thank you for your support and feedback.

Rev Left Radio

Great point! Def something I was planning on covering in the next episode on socialist and anti-imperialist revolutions, Lenin's Imperialism, and understanding that imperialism is what capitalism looks like on the global stage! So you are right it is a crucial point! Maybe I can weave it in here tho, or at least in discussion, but it will DEF be addressed! Thank you for the feedback and support JK!!!

Rev Left Radio

haha I love the idea of "experiments"! Curious as to what your criticism of it is! But yes, we do have a full lecture coming next on socialist revolutions AND at the end of the 6 week program we have an entire class period dedicated to wrestling with visions of the future! So while I am not in charge of that one in particular, it is definitely coming and is going to act as the exclamation mark on the whole series! Thank you for your feedback and support!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you! Not yet, as the first program will be more internal to organizers and THEN be introduced to the general public. So I do not think we have socials yet, but may in the future. The program is called "Socialist Nightschool" fwiw. Im sure theres something online about it already, though it is still in its building phase. Great point about outlines. I do have one rather basic one already that could be used for that in conjunction with the visual aid of the PP presentation, but maybe a more robust outline would be ideal! There will be a glossary of terms handed out to everyone that they can consult if they are confused about a term as well. But yes great point all around, ill make sure to focus in on that! As for recording it, im unsure! Ill have to ask some of the other organizers if thats something they are thinking of doing! If so, ill def upload it here :) thank you for the feedback and support!

Rev Left Radio

Great point... contrasting it with reactionary romaniticisation of the past is a great idea, and maybe emphasizing the impossibility of "going back" as well. The only way out is through!

Rev Left Radio

Def! Thats a good question as well! Thank you for the feedback Wesley!!!

Rev Left Radio

Hey Graydon, so happy to hear you have found not only our political stuff helpful, but our spiritual stuff as well. Thats always something that means a lot to hear, and bringing those two aspects together into your life is IDEAL, so props to you for doing just that! I agree with your point about the question too! Thank you! I would be very open to joining as a guest host for a convo in your study group! Email me at: andersonbrett2011@gmail.com when you are ready and we can work out the details!!! :)

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for that offer! Ill keep that in mind as I work toward my final draft, and I really appreicate your feedback on pacing and trying to figure out ways to ENSURE people are keeping up, have other resources at hand, etc. Ill absolutely keep thinking of creative ways to cover that particular base and continue to sharpen my lecturing skills with that in mind! Thank you for the support and the constructive feedback my friend! Truly.

Rev Left Radio

Great points! We will be handing out a glossary of terms for all students in this program up front, so that they can consult them throughout the lecture, but I can also do better at definining them in the lecture AND putting their definitions up on the PowerPoint which will be behind me the whole time, giving them a visual aid as we work through the material! But yes, adding the "dont worry folks, well get to them" line would be very helpful so people dont worry about getting left behind or scrambling prematurely to try and figure out definitions instead of staying with the lecture! Thank you so much for the insight and feedback!

Rev Left Radio

haha I felt it was a helpful and illuminating pop culture reference that everyone can more or less be aquainted with! Thank you!

Rev Left Radio

Hey Saya, great point about the anarchism stuff. Snark was DEF not my intention, but if it reads that way it obvsioulsy snuck in there and I want to avoid that. I didnt want to name anarchism because I didnt want to call it out specifically, but perhaps thats counter-productive here. Ill mull that over and think about how I can say it without any implied snark. Or maybe even put it as a discussion question for people to talk about in break out groups! Great point about social justice movements too. I will def add something in there about that because you are 1000% right that most people get involved on that basis, and showing the connections between struggles and their common root is essential in the educational process for people to realize that these fights are not disparate, but profoundly interconnected!!! Thank you for your incredibly thoughtful feedback rooted in your own organizing experience! Its VERY helpful!!! <3

Rev Left Radio

P.S. I changed the photo! Point taken! :) Appreciate you!

Shane

Man, I'm just glad you're still at it when it comes to your organizing game...I gotta get back at it.

Spiderdijo7

Glad you're doing this kinda thing. You deffo have a talent for it.. I think when you say experiment it seems like those attempts were always doomed to fail, which they most certainly weren't

Rev Left Radio

Its ebbed and flowed through the years (kids, covid, local energy through diff admins) but yea its def picking back up again in the last year or so, espeically since Oct. 7th and then the election.

Sean the worker

I would leave out the part about Marxism not being a dogma, because that could poison the water for the rest of the talk for some listeners. For example if you say "Marxism isn't a dogma", some listeners might here that and think "so marxism has been accused of dogmatism" and such listeners might then only listen to deduce if marxism is a dogma or not. Such listeners might miss the main point of your talk.

Sean the worker

Other than that your talk is golden, my parents and siblings were very receptive to it and now one of them says that they want to be a marxist.

Rosanna Fields

I think your lecture is amazing, but personally I do think that you should explicitly talk about the birth defects of previous modes of production that exist I the next. This can really trip up people who think mechanically and not dialectically, and the idea that they might come to it on their own I think is noble, but risky ya know. Anyways, amazing breht

Bill

Such a great job as always! I think for people looking to deepen their theoretical knowledge of Marxism this is a great start. For activists, this is a great foundation that they need to understand- however, this knowledge must be attached to some sound advice: socialists must be able to communicate to the general public in a way that doesn’t scare them off. When I was involved in DSA most of the members were young college students who lived in a bubble- terms like class stratification, commodification, surplus labor, modes of production, super structure, primitive communism, scientific communism etc were thrown around with ease inside the bubble, but when it actually came time to do the real work of supporting or engaging the working class, the casual use of these terms made eyes cross at best, scared people off at worst. Working class people are leary of ideologues- and they have a keen ear for picking up on overuse of ideological language. This is where and why Bernie actually succeeds in connecting to people- he speaks their language and speaks of the issues that materially affect them- subtly exposing the contradictions of capitalism without sounding ideological. A great book which I just read- Less is More by Jason Hickel succeeds in the same way. He gives one of the best historical outlines of economic development from primitive to feudal to capitalism without politics/ideology. Readers can figure it out for themselves. So I wonder, would a lecture like this be better received if questions were asked first- giving people time to reflect on the answers before the seeds of the lecture are planted? The theory will come easier when they can connect it to their own reflections on economy, politics etc that are prompted by those excellent questions- and not the other way around. Seeds planted on infertile soil fail to grow.

Andrew Blake

It's good, my only suggestion is to do one last revision to simplify language where possible, e.g. "align" instead of "cohere," or "impoverished" instead of "immiserated"

JK

Of course. You’re gonna slay it my man.

Rev Left Radio

All great points! This is a 6 week course and it builds on itself over time, we have visual aids for all lectures, outlines to be handed out, and a glossary of terms handed out for all participants, so they can consult it as we go. Ill also try to do a better job of defining terms throughout - but importantly, this is a concerted political education course meant to bring the consciousness of people upwards through struggling with more complex concepts and terms, unlike Bernie who is running a popular campaign aimed at reaching broad masses. Still, your point holds true. Its a fine line that we are all trying to walk, and this first course, dealing exclusively with organizers and activists, is also being used as a test run for the general public. Therefore we have built in feedback mechanisms at the end of the course to get their feedback and refine everything before moving toward the general public. So its def something we are thinking about and working on, while always maintaining the belief that people can understand these terms and concepts in their own right. Lastly, and to your point, this course does not include any college students as far as I am aware in the organizing of the Nightschool or in the lectures. All the organizers and lecturers are working class adults ranging from late 20s into their 40s! The organizations we are working with will certainly include younger people, but are not centered or based around students. Even most of our audience will be grown working adults, many with children and day jobs! I love students and young people and they are a crucial aspect of any successful movement, but we are not centered on or around them in our current organizing efforts!

Rev Left Radio

Very good and fair point! Ill probably add it into the lecture AND create a discussion question around it. You make a really important point about thinking mechanically vs dialectically as well, its a crucial thing to focus on.

Rev Left Radio

Fair point! Its trying to find that balance between not poisoning the well while also addressing a core bad faith framing of it, even amongst those on the left! But ill def reflect on that!!

David Munkvold

This was great - i will be sending this to my mom to get her up to speed on Marxism 🫡🫡

Radiant Sun Warrior

I love this episode! I think this is a great introduction to Historical Materialism. As a person who doesn't like to be told what to do, whenever I hear "you HAVE to use this method of thinking or you're wrong" I get real defensive. One framing I heard from a ML was historical materialism isn't the right frame of reference, it's the best frame we have discovered. It tracks and predicts history the most accurately compared to other methods of analysis. As a science, it should be acknowledged that it's not somehow perfect in a metaphysical sense, but that it's the best model we have. Just as models of scientific ideas evolve, good 9th grade level example would be the atomic model, so too do models of history evolve. This sort of framing of the framing really made me receptive to learning more and exploring Marxism not as "the radical political ideas of the left" but as a rich science of society, economics, and historical human development, that has been conveniently omitted from my Liberal education. I love what you do. I need this available to link my friends to it ❤️ As always, love and solidarity. ✊

Heart Led Parenting

Hey Breht, this draft is fantastic! A few thoughts: Depth on Contradictions: The capitalism section nails its expansive nature and inequality, but unpacking why those contradictions destabilize it could add rigor. Like, a quick line on overproduction—“Capitalists flood markets with goods to chase profit, but workers can’t buy them, so factories shut down and crises spiral”. Non-Marxist Pitfalls: That section’s a highlight—loved the reformism critique—but terms like “co-optation” or “spontaneity” might trip up newcomers. A vivid example could anchor it, e.g., “Co-optation’s when corporations hijack BLM with slogans but keep wages rotten.” Maybe save Chile 1973 for your revolutions talk and just hint at it here. Modes Overlap: You’re so right to flag slavery’s role in capitalism. I’d make it a discussion question (“How did slavery fuel capitalism’s rise?”) rather than stretching the lecture. Let folks wrestle with it, then you can drop a concise bombshell in the big discussion—like, “Slavery wasn’t just a relic; it was capitalism’s bloody kickstart via cotton and sugar profits.” Overall, this strikes the sweet spot: welcoming for curious locals, hefty enough for organizers. Can’t wait to see it polished and hear how it lands in Omaha—great way to kick off the series!

J H

Another longtime lister and first time commenter here. Really good introduction. As others have mentioned I do think it will be helpful to define difficult terms in as simple and comprehensive as way as possible. And there may be some tension between those two poles but I think it’s best to strive for both. Also, I do think you should go into more depth with respect to how “the ruling ideas in each and every epoch are the ideas of the ruling class.” Really talk more about the mechanics of that process and draw clear lines as to how this occurs. It’s one thing to assert that this is the case but the causality needs to underlined.

Brett

Longtime listener here. Good presentation overall; as usual your skill at breaking down complicated topics into everyday language is on full display. My only real critique is leading off your structured portion of the talk with a segment on super-structure/base. While an important subject, I really don’t think it’s the very first thing people need to know about Marxism or Historical Materialism. I managed (more like struggled) to read all three volumes of Capital, and while I’d never claim to be an expert I can honestly say I only recall Marx even bringing up super-structure/base once across the entirety of those texts. Again, obviously Marx wrote much more than Capital but if it only showed up once in his key text then how crucial is that to understanding his (or Engels’) thought process? Keep up the good work regardless.

Sam Atwood

Hey Breht, I think this lecture is great! The two things that came to my mind while listening were addressing socialism as a science, and providing more context on US history as you mention. When I first learned about transitions between economic modes, grappling with slavery in the U.S. was a point of confusion for me, so I think it’s important to address. I agree this could be saved for the question/discussion as I imagine it will organically come up. Overall though, this is great, and I’m excited to listen to more from this project and share it with friends and family. Thank you for your hard and amazing work!

Rev Left Radio

Hey Brett, fair point and i appreciate the thoughtful feedback! I do think its important cuz it shows the relationship between the base of society and how that societies culture is shaped and expressed by it. If we say that the material base of society is the thing that transforms from one mode of production to another, its helpful to flesh what the material base is and how its determinative wrt its impact on all other aspects of culture, law, religion, education, thought, art, etc. Overall though you do raise an interesting and important point, and its got me thinking about trying to pin down the ancestry of the idea through various Marxist thinkers! I think Marx introduced the basic idea in a Preface to a Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy when he said "In the social production of their existence, men inevitably enter into definite relations, which are independent of their will, namely relations of production appropriate to a given stage in the development of their material forces of production. The totality of these relations of production constitutes the economic structure of society, the real foundation, on which arises a legal and political superstructure and to which correspond definite forms of social consciousness. The mode of production of material life conditions the general process of social, political and intellectual life. It is not the consciousness of men that determines their existence, but their social existence that determines their consciousness. " Engles developed it more in places like Anti-Duhring, Gramsci and Althusser developed it even more through their concepts of Hegemony and Ideological State Apparatus respectively. etc etc.

LumpinLinecook

Howdy Breht, I dug your lecture. I listened to it a couple of times and believe it to be straight to the point for the average worker/ person. on historical materialism what other works would the 6 week program be recommending for people to read individually or does your group have curriculum of marxist theory you will be following. i.e. like book recommendations. thankz for your time & keep up the good work.

Ed Cook

Hi again! How did the lecture go?

yesn't

I know you’ve probably already presented ( I hope it went well). But I just wanted to say I really enjoyed how you infused dialectics into the conversation without speaking on them outright, proposing dualities and discussing their impact.