Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Alyson and Breht welcome Brendan back on the show for the first time in a few years. Together, we dive deep into Leon Trotsky’s Fascism: What It Is and How to Fight It, a sharp and urgent intervention written in the shadow of the Nazi rise to power. We unpack Trotsky’s class analysis of fascism, the role of the petite bourgeoisie, his searing critiques of both sectarian isolationism and liberal class collaboration, and his insistence on the United Front as the only viable revolutionary response. Alongside historical context, we explore in depth whether Trotsky’s framework still applies to today’s far-right movements, neoliberal authoritarianism, Trump's Oligarchic second term, and a decaying capitalist order teetering on the edge. What does fascism look like in 2025—and what must we do to resist it?

Outro Song: May All The Lower Realms Be Empty by Friends in Real Life

Files

Comments

Comrade Cat Артём

Ho chi minh's 3 letters on trots in china should be eye opening for any honest revolutionary or socialism4all's last audio books on trot himself

Rev Left Radio

We learn what we can from anyone and everyone. I'm no fan of Trotsky, and certainly not a fan of Trotskyism, but this work is useful for us regardless to think deeply about the history and present of fascism.

Brad Northcote

This should be interesting...Trotskyists are probably the closest thing to an organized party in my neck of the woods, and they've been leaning into a collaborative united front against Zionism in particular. I'm ambivalent, but will certainly keep an open mind in approaching this episode. If nothing else, that might help with a constructively critical engagement.

Rev Left Radio

This is the perfect approach, principled, curious, and open-minded, but also critical! I wouldnt advocate joining an explicitly trotskyist org necessarily, but working with principled and comradely trotskyists - like we would with anarchists, soc dems, etc. - around particular issues, especially in resisting fascism, is always a good idea!

TheRealJoeySteele

Good episode. The lumpen support for fascism in particular is so wild to me. Ultimately when thinking like a Marxist it makes complete sense, but just listening to dudes who've been locked up or involved in the streets turning over and embracing fascism always seemed so backward to me. I grew up around alot of homies in gangs and it's shocking how many fools are now full blown Trump fanatics and conscious fascists even. I know of two old homeboys who literally are Hitlerites, and these fools are mexican! Shit is crazy. I think it is true historically that black and latino lumpen have been less likely to embrace fascism than their white counterparts. I think the historical crimes of America against their peoples partially explains this, but another important aspect of why black and brown lumpen didnt tend toward fascism in the last century I think is because of the presence of a real political alternative (ussr and the global socialist camp) and the presence of organizations that genuinely tried to improve their conditions and organize them, led by communists and socialists! In the present era I would however push back on the idea that non white lumpen are less likely to embrace fascism. I can only speak from where I'm at in California, but the street politics are highly racialized and lend themselves to backward outlooks and a fascist worldview. I am most familiar with latino gang bangers, but I can say not a small amount are fascist. I feel like it's important to struggle more with Lumpens. Very few orgs I've been apart of have jail outreach or support programs. Ultimately, as someone who used to be a "criminal" I was spiraling looking for a way out. Revolutionary theory really lit the way for me to understand and put together things in a way that actually made sense. Really importantly, it gave me a really strong sense of self and determination to fight back. It also provided me with a way of being political that actually benefited me and the people in my community. We need to be showing street cats Malcolm X, George Jackson, Monster Kody and others who can speak in a real way to their experience and show them another way that actually strikes back at the system that has deprived them of the means to survive without crime. I could go on and on, but anyway thank you for puttin stuff out Breht and Alyson! Been listening forever and will continue to tune in. Red salute 🫡

Lana

Can someone explain the Trotsky hate within the left? Genuine question. I’m not in the loop. 🤷🏼‍♀️

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

10/10 ep. I take the Chris Hedges position on whether Trump is fascist. Trump himself is not fascist. He is an egomaniac, but the people he has surrounded himself with are certainly ideologically fascist. I’ve been watching some town halls, both democrats and republicans. There’s genuine anger on both sides. However, republicans are pissed because they might lose their social security. Democrats are pissed because they’re realizing their party is feckless and not a true opposition. I’ve seen a lot of town halls where voters are calling for a mass movement. However, while this is encouraging, if history has taught us anything when fascism arises, liberal politicians will sell out their own base long before actually opposing fascist threats. EDIT: During one of the Democratic town halls (the representative was some guy from Maryland), his consistent response was that we need to vote in the midterms to win back the House and Senate and then win in the courts but there were many attendees saying they're worried there won't be midterms and a presidential election. I'm not at this point yet, but I could see a false flag during the elections to help Republicans maintain power. Simultaneously, I don't know how many Americans even view our elections as legitimate anymore and that shit goes back to Bush and Gore. Everybody wants to use Nazi Germany as an historical example to explain this moment but the material conditions are drastically different. The Democrat Party is in an historical crisis. It’s leaderless, its base is pissed, and they have no plan. If shit really hits the fan, there’s no armed wing of the DNC coming to save us. I think mutual aid is more important than it’s ever been outside of the covid era.

Rev Left Radio

There are basic ideological rifts of course, as there are between MLs and MLMs and Leftcoms, etc., but the real HATE comes from history. Trotsky was a brilliant but also very arrogant dude, and after he was expelled from the Soviet Union he turned into a bitter critic of the Soviet Union, even as the SU was fighting for its life against opposition from around the world - his critiques were used by imperialists and anti-communists to delegitimize socialist states (not unlike how George Orwell has been used by the enemies of socialism despite being a socialist himself). Trotskyists today are often very sectarian and continue Trotsky's tendency to criticize instead of critically supporting various socialist projects. For example, many Trots will critique the USSR, China under Mao, Cuba, DPRK, etc., often labeling them as bureaucratic deformations, state capitalism, or not truly socialist. They also often frame themselves as the only true inheritors of Marxism-Leninism (again, sectarian and arrogant). This is a deep rabbit hole, but the basic idea is that Trotsky put his ego and arrogance over the global struggle for socialism and fed into lies and slander of the SU, and the legacy of his tendency often carries this toxic trait forward. HAVING SAID THAT, I think there should be some balance here: Trotsky fought in the Bolshevik revolution and served honorably in that capacity, he contributed to marxist theory and practice, and his basic disagreements with MLs and MLMs arent always or inherently in bad faith or even bad. The debate between permanent revolution and socialism in one country is a fair debate to have between marxists, for example. And just as there are insanely dogmatic anarchists, maoists, leninists, and liberals - there are also insanely dogmatic trots. Its not unique to his tendency, and like in every tendency, there are also plenty of decent, open minded, comradely types too. Tho, like anarchists, their tendency to disparage virtually any and all socialist experiments is corrosive. The fact that many young trots in the 60's and 70's grew old and became the core of the Neoconservative Right "spreading democracy to the world" (a weird bastardization and degeneration of the idea of permenant revolution and spreading socialism to the world) is also an interesting development thats worth noting and studying. Again, this can go deeper and there is more to explore, but this is the jist. IF anyone wants to add anything else, one way or the other, feel free!

Rev Left Radio

Totally agree with your analysis of the town halls and the Democratic party. If we know anything about the Dem party and its corporate donor base, we know that all the odds are against them learning their lesson and turning back to the working class. Even if they wanted to, their party is led by conservative elites like Schumer and Jefferys, meaning they would have to dismantle their donor class, their consultant class, and purge the party of probably 75% or more of its members, including its the entirety of its leadership. In lieu of that, the Dem Party will remain the same, slowly become delegitimized, and continue to act as an obstacle to any meaningful change - which means power will continue to have to be built outside of it and in direct and open confrontation with it. The energy of many disaffected Dems is useful to us in our attempts to radicalize people and raise class consciousness. We should never, evver tie ourselves to the Democratic Brand, and we should never waiver even a tiny bit on our open disdain for both parties and how they serve the same interests at the end of the day.

Rev Left Radio

Could not agree more with your analysis and your recommendation of winning over swaths of the lumpen just as we try to win over swaths of other class strata, like the PB. But a focus on the lumpen is crucial, especially the racialized lumpen as I mentioned in the episode. The common lumpen mindset of "getting mine" and fuck everyone else lends itself to reaction in some instances, while the material conditions of the lumpen provide pathways to radicalization toward revolution. This is a struggle we have to be engaged with, in prisons, in poor and racialized communities, etc. But it has to be genuine, meaning that intervention has to come from that community itself. Organizing prisoners, having outreach programs for people who are released, fighting for prisoner rights, etc are all in-roads to reaching this crucial class strata, while also accepting we will never win over 100% of them, just as we will never win over 100% of the proletarian proper or the PB! The struggle continues... and widens!

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

There were several attendees who asked Glenn Ivey (the Dem politician) if he would stop taking money from AIPAC and other corporate donors and he flat out said no, even before the person got done asking the question. It's so disgusting which is why the masses have got to wake up and leave the Democratic Party. When they tell you what they're going to do, you've got to believe them! I know if I was a Republican and/or Democratic politician in Congress right now, I'd be really worried about what the midterms will bring. The writing is on the wall for the Republicans to get wiped out which is why I think the Republicans will have to do some shady shit to maintain power. At the same time center-right Democrats are facing increasing hostility from their base, especially given how so few of them stood up to the Republicans on the recent Continuing Resolution bill. A lot is being made of the Sanders/AOC "Fight Oligarchy" campaign, what do you make of this? I voted for Sanders both times. I canvassed for him in 2016 and donated several times. In many ways I see him as a vapid suit and I feel the same about AOC. I believe if Sanders and AOC were to truly try to change things, they would join the likes of MLK Jr., Malcom X, and Fred Hampton (if you know what I mean).

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I was going to ask this so I'm glad you brought this up. I really like The Grayzone but they, particularly Max Blumenthal, shit on Trotsky all the time. Idk how much Max really knows about Marxist theory and Trotsky specifically but he does it a lot. I don't really hear Aaron Maté do it.

Lana

Appreciate your comprehensive response! Thank you!

Rev Left Radio

yea, I mean I like that there is that energy, that huge swaths of the Democratic base are turning toward the left wing of the party and away from the center and right wings of the party, and I like that they are naming the oligarchy for what it is, and Bernie is even urging people to run as independents instead of Democrats which is an interesting - if very LATE - move on his part. Ultimately, that is tempered by the fact that both Bernie and AOC have proven, again and again, to not be up for the real fight when it comes to crunch time; they have both consistently put their careers above principles, and far too often Shepard energy back into the Democratic Party where it goes to die. Bernie may technically be an independent, but AOC is a democratic careerist through and through. I remain open to the very distant and unlikely possibility that they can change for the better, but remain highly highly skeptical. Plus their votes on Israel have been atrocious and/or cowardly. So ultimately there are things to like about it, things to be concerned about, and things to be pessimistic about. Overall, the energy itself is whats important, and what happens with it, where it gets directed, and what comes of it is more important than the role AOC and Bernie are playing in it. The problem with depending on rich, powerful, comfortable people to lead a mass movement is that they have been made rich, powerful, and comfortable *by this system* and when push comes to shove will tend toward maintaining that status and comfort instead of risking it for something bigger. Bernie had his chance in 2016 and even in 2020 to go hard against the Dem establishment, and chose his comfy career adjacent to the Dem party and his personal friendship with Biden over real change. AOC is weak, unprincipled, and prone to co-optation, idealism, and poor strategic maneuvering. Between the two, Bernie has shown more consistency over time and though he has many flaws, his working class political commitments are beyond doubt. AOC is susceptible to identity politics as we have seen, and doesn't seems to have much credibility with working class people generally. WE shall see... I watch these developments with interest nonetheless.

Saya Clarke

Really fantastic episode with a guest that should also start his own damn podcast man that guy is sharp. A lot of bits stuck out in this episode for me. In particular the section where y’all went back and forth on, as socialists, how we should orient ourselves to the Democratic party. In my chapter there has been a lot of discussion about this Bernie/AOC tour. Denver DSA was passing out flyers at that stop on their tour that, in so many words, tells people to stop putting your faith in these celebrity politicians and get organizing on the ground right now with the people around you. The flyer is extremely generous to them in my opinion but it still ruffled quite a few feathers in my chapter. A lot of people feel strongly about maintaining good relations, not attacking them openly, and avoiding alienating so called “normal” people. “This makes us look bad” they say or “Will this really convince anyone at Bernie/AOC rally?” Comrades say they agree that Bernie/AOC types are not the end all be all of our political goals but think it is actively damaging to our movement to be so harsh on them publicly. I am sympathetic to their views but I can’t help but feel closely aligned with Alyson on this issue. I loathe the idea of working openly with people who actively campaigned for Biden mid genocide, knowing he already has a foot in the grave, of course the sheep-dogging that was mentioned here among many other reasons. Honestly I could go on forever about this but I will just say for now this episode opened me up a bit on that position. Brenden made some very good nuanced points that I will have to chew on for a bit. All around great episode. Not a Trotskyist either but this text still has value and I’ll have to read it/listen to it proper. Last thing! Breht I saw that you will be at Socialism Conference this year. Holy shit I can’t believe I might actually get to meet you after all this time. I went last year because DSA was a sponsor and met so many wonderful people that I admire so much in the intellectual space. A big highlight last year was Ruth Wilson Gilmore! It was one of the best weeks of my life and I said then that I will go every fucking year now and have as much fun as I did that time. Are you doing a panel? If so I guarantee I will be there for that. Solidarity comrade!

Rev Left Radio

Yes, Max and Ben's fall out was interesting to see. I tend to side with Norton and sense a strain of opportunism in Max. Mate seems pretty solid though, and all their analysis is better than 99% of mainstream slop ofc.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I wasn’t aware of a fallout between max and Ben. I assumed Ben just wanted to do his own thing. I mean, the dude is fucking talented. But now that you mention it, it’s true that Ben and Max never feature on each other’s shows.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Great points. There were reports of centrists calling for AOC to primary Schumer. If she had any spine you take that opportunity. But she won’t commit which shows her career comes first. I see her as the next Nancy Pelosi.

Rev Left Radio

Good analysis, and that split in your org is an interesting one. I think we have to remain skeptical and critical, but also understand that Bernie and AOC are highlighting very real working class energy that cannot be ignored. I gave my full analysis of the Bernie AOC tour thing below (in response to the patron named: From the River to the Sea). Thats great that youve been to and are going again to SC! I was supposed to go last year with some local comrades but couldnt make it happen. The only thing that could stop me this year is IF - and its a big IF - I happen to land a teaching job and will have to go into intensive certification process. But that is a long shot atm. Waiting to hear back from one school, so we shall see. But, if that doesnt happen, ill absolutely going in July and we will have to make sure to meet up there and finally meet IRL! :) I havent asked or tried at all to be a speaker or get on a panel, just kinda wanna go as a participant and check it out. My local friends/organizers have been urging me to get on a panel and I would if offered, but im not actively trying. Plenty of other great voices there. In any case, we will see how it all plays out, I hope I am able to go and I hope I see you there! <3

Lefty In Training

Back when Trotsky still had some good analysis. So many good topics in this episode that could spiral off into their own discussion. It's a much longer text on fascism but "Fascism and Social Revolution" from 1934 is the best one I've personally read. Socialism For All made audiobooks of it.

Clinton Fraser

Over here in blighty Britain there's a bitter sectarian divide between trotsky and stalinism,its demoralising and incomprehensible to most working class folk,believe its time to Bury the hatchet and get on with the job at hand,good episode trotsky had somethings right and that grover furr is nuts,but hey what would I know, great debate many thanks 😊

Lindberg

A Nation of Shopkeepers: The Unstoppable Rise of the PB is an interesting and accessible exploration of why the PB, in all its various sects, acts how it acts.

Hitchhiking on the Hermetic Highway

Great episode. Really helped me think through the united front strategy. Honestly would love a series with the 3 of you on a lot of the topics you touched on, especially how current day organizing could be approached.

Rev Left Radio

Interesting! Ive heard of that but never got around to it. Ill check it out!

Rev Left Radio

Glad you enjoyed it and found it useful, Chase. Thats an interesting idea, id love to have Brendan back on for more discussions about this stuff. Appreciate your support

JK

This is great. Very excited to see and hear more Trotsky. You might want to read up some articles on the Revolutionary Communist International site; they have excellent analysis of where we are historically. Would be even better if you had one of their cadres on your show actually

Rev Left Radio

I really like what Socialism for All is up to on YT. Im subb'd. Ill check that out!!

Rev Left Radio

haha i agree with you. people still fighting over this history in 2025 is silly and counter-productive - and as you say, is weird and off-putting to regular working people. Its fine for inter-comrade debates for fun, but the focus needs to be effective organizing in the here and now. The debates between permenant revolution and socialism in one country dont matter if we dont even have a serious socialist movement! These debates become more important over time, but we have to build the damn thing first!

Chaim Jones

Excellent episode! Sparked too many thoughts to touch on them all. One point Brendan brought up that really resonated for me was how the ideas of the far right have been taken up by ostensibly left anti-Zionists, such as that Israel and the Zionists control the USA. Opposing Zionism without putting it in the context of U.S. imperialism seems to me short-sighted and can lead into dangerous conspiracist thinking. I also appreciated the talk about unions in the fight against fascism and imperialism. What role are they playing? What role can they play? Thank you all for the thoughtful discussion.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for listening and teh support! Yes, the idea that Israel "controls" the US is absurd and is dismantled by a materialist analysis of imperialism and how both states mutually benefit from their deep connections, for their own purposes, which often align perfectly. Israel doesnt puppet the US, nor does the US puppet Israel. They are two settler colonial imperialist states with mutual interests and who work together to act as the bulwark against any progressive movements around the world that challenge the hegemony of capitalism-imperialism-colonialism.

Monte-Cristo

I was very excited to listen to this episode, this text was one of the first I read as I turned to marxism and I attempted to us it to analyze the tea party movement. If you're interested in have a conversation with what some in the labor movement are doing to fight back my fellow letter carriers at fightingnalc.com are building a more militant movement inside a business union.

Eduardo Zaragoza

I'm not a big fan of Trotsky but I did love this analysis y'all did on these texts!

JK

Ehh, S4A is a bit of a hot-head and severely lacks any inter-personal skills. That's probably why he never has any guests on his show and just talks to himself. I had the gall to ask him about Trotsky and he not only wrote me a scathing response, but permabanned me from his youtube chat and even his patreon of which I was a subscriber! Honestly, like fuck that dude. He's a strange one

Rev Left Radio

Thats great to hear, Eduardo! THanks for your support, glad you enjoyed how we used the text as a launch for contemporary analysis.

Rev Left Radio

I am taking a month off for personal/family reasons so I am not taking new eps atm, BUT when I return id be very interested in this!

SprocketMusic

So many great perspectives here. I strongly agree with Brendan's point about lone wolf right wing terror. Nazism is, at its core, a nation attempting to colonize itself. That's what the mass mobilization is for - to install settler colonial structures inside a society that does not already have them. America doesn't need to topple anything in order to do that. Sundown towns still exist, and require only the emboldenment of white landowners in order to intensify. The cops will back their play. I am a trans woman living in NYC, arguably the safest place for trans people to be. The number of neighborhoods that I can safely traverse has dropped significantly since November. Not far from me is a block of houses owned primarily by cops and ex-cops. When BLM hit full stride in 2020, they took in all of their blue lives matter flags out of fear. On Election Night 2024, fireworks went off, and the flags came back out again - this time on lampposts as though sanctioned by the city. Since Trump won, local neighborhood apps (that women use to alert one another to danger) are constantly reporting gropings in this area. The terror is already here. It's omnipresent. It just isn't bombastic enough to make headlines.

Andrew Blake

Not to put it all on you but I really think that public-ish people with platforms like you and Alyson are some of our only hope for organizing a vanguard party on a national scale. PSL has some reach and may otherwise be the one group best positioned for this role... but they seem to be mostly about marching and protesting. That shit ain't gonna cut it and I can only hope they're doing some real cadre work out of the public eye.

Steven Phillips

Our local reading group was just in this 👍🏼

PuebloCO Jenin

You haven't listened to the Margaret Kimberly episode, she's a member of the green party as one of the organizing groups

PuebloCO Jenin

There's always more to learn, so I made myself keep listening, even though I don't like Trotsky. Really 😍 your final comments (that poked right at me for almost not listening!!!) about being adults, listening with love in our hearts, and avoiding splintering off in the smaller and smaller narrowminded groups. I also read your reply to Lana, which struck home with me. I really enjoyed the commentary about agreeing with other workers groups where we can to provide that united front, while never giving up our own core beliefs, specifically Brendan's example of left Zionism is just as bad as right Zionism. Then I disagreed with Brandon's analysis of Bernie and really appreciated, Breht, your alternative analysis that Sanders may not see himself as a sheepdog, but that's what he is (I got suckered by him both times, out $6g) I was devastated that they didn't force the healthcare for all vote AND they voted against the striking railroad workers!But it took the genocide for me to swear off Dems for good. I hope you're right and also think that all this energy building up may be how we get the working class united in our freedom struggle! LENIN said we need to create a united front. I listen to a lot of left podcasts which talk about Trosky being a working class traitor, that being the reason Stalin had him killed....

Roving Canine

When Brendan talks about many fascists having backgrounds of domestic abuse but not being vocal about it or justifying it instead of criticizing it like their democratic counterparts it reminds in a bizarre way of how both tucker and mel gibson during trumps campaign trail and endorsements reiterated at several points almost verbatim said "there has to be a point where daddy comes home" and "daddy is coming home and he is taking off his belt, he is mad" and thats both hilarious and tragic with how spot on it is.