Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this powerful episode, we sit down with a frontline activist from Palestine Action, the UK-based direct action network targeting Elbit Systems—the Israeli weapons manufacturer responsible for arming and enabling genocide in Palestine and beyond. We dig into the strategy of physically dismantling the military-industrial complex, the stakes of this fight, and the growing number of political prisoners facing terror charges for their resistance.

Max, from Palestine Action, joins Breht to discuss the organization, the moral responsibility those in the imperial core have toward the victims of imperialism, Palestine Action's tactics and strategy, why they focus on Elbit Systems in particular, the role weapons manufacturers play in the ongoing genocide of Palestinians as well as perpetuating imperialism and colonialism around the planet, The Filton 18 and other political prisoners, the deafening silence and lack of solidarity shown by liberal and mainstream pro-Palestine movements, and much more.

Learn more, support, and donate to Palestine Action HERE

-------------------------------------------------------------

Support 3 families in Gaza HERE

Follow, Subscribe, & Learn more about Rev Left Radio HERE

Outro Beat Prod. by flip da hood

Files

Comments

Jo Vinova

I'm working on a project linking the anti-genocide movement of the 60s/70s with that of today, with an emphasis on direct action (currently reading Spiritual Criminals which highlights the Catholic Left and the Camden 28 as one of the main points of interest). I'm happy to be spoonfed some of the research I'm doing lol thank you for this amazing interview 🙏🏽

Rev Left Radio

Wow, that sounds amazing. Keep me updated on that fr...

Jeremiah

Great episode, Breht. I think just about every type of action is valid at a certain stage of struggle. In the current stage, I think it's important for activists to consider that our forces are still relatively weak, and so our central task should be party-building. The problem with a lot of direct action at this stage is it throws away good comrades for what are, while definitely material, ultimately short-term gains. Even a single, well-consolidated and disciplined comrade represents a huge investment of time and energy for an organization. Of course, comrades face repression in the form of arrest and trumped up charges — a great example of this is the Tampa 5 — but the difference is that campaigns around those arrests are a lot more consolidating for the masses and do a lot more to raise their consciousness and organization than seeing, forgive the term, small numbers of adventurist activists race ahead with ultra-advanced actions only to be arrested, easily convicted, and thrown in the hole. The Tampa 5 eventually had the charges dropped because of the mass movement we were able to build nationally around their case. I think the difference is the Mass Line. I have a lot of respect for Palestine Action and those who have faced repression for it, but I do think their incarceration represents a strategic setback in terms of the growth of our forces, which in the long run slows our progress. Just my take from an M-L perspective. Like I said, great episode and love and solidarity to you and Max 🙏

Jeremiah

Also I think the definition has validity but is lacking the Mass Line component. Adventurism is ultra-left action that is ahead of where the masses are at. It's not so much a question of "turning people pff" — I agree that's a liberal argument — but our three revolutionary tasks should be landing blows against the enemy while winning all that can be won, raising the level of consciousness and organization of the masses, and winning over the advanced activists to Marxism-Leninism. Palestine Action absolutely lands real blows, and these sometimes cash out as wins when, for example, a bank divests from Elbit, but it doesn't involve the masses to a significant degree, but rather races out ahead of them, and when activists do not embed themselves in the masses they are easy pickings for state repression. And since these actions don't elevate the level of organization of the masses or involve them in confrontations with the enemy, they fail to raise their consciousness, and they certainly don't contribute to the project of party-building since you can't recruit from among the masses when you're behind bars. I absolutely support a diversity of tactics and don't charge Palestine Action with putting others in danger, but I do think that in the current period the approach puts short term wins over long term strategic gains. But if history ends up proving me wrong I am perfectly ok with that

Jo Vinova

Will do! Im pretty excited about it, especially now that I'm in discussion with an activist from that era about an interview, which I'll probably release as it's own thing 🤞🏽

Juche Stalin

This podcast episode was incredible. I translated the prisoners page to Spanish to share with my comrades here in Ecuador. I want to try to formalize a process for translating Spanish letters to English so we can send both versions to the e-mails listed for each. For anyone who wants a quick link to the page that talks about each prisoner's contributions: https://palestineaction.org/prisoners/ Super inspiring podcast as always, Breht. Thank you so much to you, Dave, and Max.

Chaim Jones

Deep respect for these solidarity activists’ courage and willingness to sacrifice. I’m curious about whether they have any engagement with workers at these factories, and if so, how the workers respond.

Sai

I've followed Palestine Action "protests" in the UK for a long time. From what I've seen their "activism" seems designed to maximize the number of actionists facing potentially life-ruining charges while minimizing impact on weapons production. Ie splashing paint on the interior of a facility and showing actionists faces on video posted to X. A serious organization would have likely just torched the place and not spammed their own faces for UK authorities to see. (Not a recommendation, just theorizing what would be more effective for applying material friction to genocide) I also saw them park a van in front of a facilities gates and chain more activists arms to it. An easily removed non-destructive impediment to production which likely resulted in another set of serious charges for activists. Catching charges is a huge economic drain on the activist community, as fundraisers for legal defence must be mustered, manpower must be used in the legal system, and of course the actionist is out of commission, sometimes for years or life. They constantly get their people arrested. They post actionists faces everywhere. Their actions barely impede weapons production. The whole enterprise seems so counter-productive it makes one wonder if it's connected to or run by British intelligence as a way to simply drain the resources of pro-palestine movements. When I posed this question to the group on X I was immediately blocked. I know it might be bad to fedjacket or whatever, but this shit is sus as hell.

Sai

"One of the ways we know we're effective is the state is really targeting us" Whether this person knows it or not pal actions overall effect is strengthening the repressive power of the state. Keep your faces covered. Stop getting people charged. If you really mean it, one would think you'd use more permanently destructive methods.

Yohance

I agree that they’re a bit too willing to get thrown in jail and remain a bit too identifiable, but I disagree that they’re having a minimal impact. Elbit has gone from a smooth running death machine to possibly removing production from the country. There isn’t a comparable movement at the moment which is successfully impeding and exposing Israeli arms production in the UK so I disagree that we can argue some other method would have worked better to do this. At the time PA started and until fairly recently it was not unusual for brazen left wing activists to get let off at trial despite being identified at a crime scene, so I imagine this is when their tactics developed. The Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act which came in 2022 is the reason there has been a massive uptick in activists being repressed so severely (including a recent raid on a Quaker meeting house). I imagine the lack of support PA gets from the rest of the movement makes it easier for the state to deal with them in an extreme manner as well.

KK

I also tend to agree with this position: they do seem to be having an impact on Elbit's ability to manufacture, the PCS&CA 2022 has massively changed the landscape and made it much easier to arrest people for simply 'causing a disturbance' (see the arrest of Ben Jamal, head of the PSC, for simply walking the wrong direction) and PalAction they do seem to have broad public support. My real concern is the timidity of the PSC (Ben Jamal and Co) who absolutely DO seem compromised - PSC's national secretary Ben Soffa , who worked for Starmer, expelled Manchester PSC after they spoke up on the rights of Palestinians to resist military on Oct 7th - does this seem like the PSC are speaking for Palestinians or themselves at this point. They also fail to recognise PalAction UK or the work they do - they have no official position on them. Weak. https://electronicintifada.net/blogs/asa-winstanley/uk-palestine-solidarity-campaign-punishes-manchester-branch And now we have the David Miller incident where the mere mention of his name or content (he writes some excellent stuff) is now a BANNED topic by PSC branches because he want to criticize - rightly in my mind - the Zionists that are doing the work for the Imperialist USA. https://tonygreenstein.com/david-miller-has-gone-from-asset-to-liability-for-the-palestine-solidarity-movement/ Are they all plants??!

Rev Left Radio

Im not sure the state needs PalAction to strengthen it repressive powers. All those who partake do so willingly, knowing the costs. Its their decision. They do not bring blowback on people who do not willingly take the risk and understand the stakes and consent to the possibilities of consequences. To say that and then at the same exact time urge them to do even more destructive, illegal things seems counter-intuitive. Do you want them to stop doing direct action cuz it emboldens the repressive apparatus of the state or do you want them to escalate to more "permanently destructive methods"? I believe in diversity of tactics. Nobody is asking you to support them or join them, but to not shit on them? Yes. Thats the decent thing to do imo.

Rev Left Radio

Thats an interesting dynamic. The workers involved in making these weapons also have a responsibility here, and if they shun it, they are making themselves complicit with mass murder. In a real sense its putting a personal paycheck over the lives of other human beings. What are your thoughts?

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for listening and for your support, my friend. Great idea with the translations as well! Good work!!! Solidarity!

Rev Left Radio

Interesting and valid feedback, Jeremiah! On the adventurism question, I think they are 1) landing blows against the enemy in a realy material way and 2) bringing the issue of Palestine to the forefront, which, in the broader eco-system of pro-Palestine action, does contribute meaningfully to raising awareness and consciousness of the issue. I agree party building is essential and should always be the priority, but in the meantime I genuinely support direct action by disciplined cadre who are aware of and consent to the possibility of real consequences without getting innocent people in trouble or hurt. I think PalAction accomplishes that. Getting the masses in the imperial core to rise up against imperialism abroad has always been a very difficult if not impossible task unless and until its impacts them directly in a way they can see and feel. If we have to wait around for the average american or Brit to educate themselves on Palestine and get organized, we will be waiting forever imo. But again, you have principled and fair points and I think you raise the core issues with this approach very well. Im very sympathetic to your overall argument, but still, given the urgency of the moment, I have to support anyone in the imperial core who is willing to step up and try to disrupt the machinery of genocide, with or without the background conditions that would be highly preferred (mass support, party formation, etc.). However, I really appreciate your critical thought on all of this, and I think everyone should wrestle with these tensions, as they are likely to become more relevant, not less, in the coming years.

Rev Left Radio

Criticism is fine, and I can see how someone who disapprove of their high-stakes tactics, and your points about getting arrested and all the material issues that arise from that are fair. But def be hesitant to launch accusations of state-affiliation. People did this in the comment section of our latest PSL interview as well, and I think its really counter-productive and a dangerous instinct to label orgs or groups you disagree with as feds. People are rightfully enraged at the genocide, and its not surprising some take extreme measures and feel personal responsibility to act. Aaron Bushnell self-immolated over it! There is no evidence any of this is set up by intelligence agencies whatsoever, and from the people Ive talked to in PalAction its clear they do it out of deep commitment and principles. Direct action and property destruction has ALWAYS been a current in radical left wing movements. People can listen to episodes like this and come to their own conclusions, engage critically, and decide for themselves what their relationship to this sort of action should be: and in the intro I reiterate that people should not do anything illegal and that these actionists take incredibly high risks that are NOT for 99% of activists. But the least we can do is NOT throw them under the bus, not tie them to the apparatus that is trying to destroy their lives, and not make incredibly serious allegations with no evidence that serves to further isolate them from the movement, making them even more suscepitble to state predation. Launch critiques - but not accusations, please.

Gabriel Alvarado

I certainly understand the criticism and the suspicion around this organization and their actions, but didn’t the Bolsheviks rob banks and have similar direct action campaigns? Obviously within their context. It was considered adventurism by some but in the end they came out on top, well until Kurshev took power. I think we are allowing aspects of our inherent liberalism cloud our judgement on this organization, the same way it does with other orgs like PSL. Obviously things orgs are not above criticism but a org like PSL for example clearly implements self-criticism. We are out of time guys we have to work with what we have right now. After writing this I just noticed Upstream just did a episode with another PA group member. Go over and listen to that one to draw more lessons from these actions

Gabriel Alvarado

They certainly could be a bit more strategic about how they carry out these actions but they do seem to accomplish their goals. The state strengthens its repressive power when good people do nothing (most people). It strengthens its repressive power even when people peacefully protest by framing those protesters as supporting terrorists. The encampments are a great example, the deportations, etc

Chaim Jones

Yes, those workers are more complicitous than most of us, who merely pay the taxes that fund the war machine. I just wonder what they think about what they’re doing, and if Pal Action has tried to find out. If the workers don’t care about the carnage and suffering their work causes, that’s one thing; if they do care but have families to shelter, clothe, and feed, it’s another. Long-term, I think, converting the factories to nonmilitary production is what’s needed. At the same time, there’s a genocide being carried out right now, so I understand the desperation driving the actionists to do what they do. I have more questions than answers.

Hitchhiking on the Hermetic Highway

Inspiring episode. I would argue against the criticism that PAL action are giving excuses for state power to be strengthened. We are there. We are at a point where the state is already on the path of mass surveillance, ai tracking, black bagging, using counterinsurgency and militarized police forces to attack anyone in opposition. The Trump admin doesnt need an excuse, that is one of their main goals. UK as well. Something I think I remember Calla saying was that the property damage laws in the UK were very different than the US and they made some mistakes in that regard. I wouldve liked to hear more on that.

Sai

You're wrong. They constantly post actionists faces online. They get people in trouble needlessly. I'm for direct action, but intelligent direct action. Not what I've seen from this group.

Sai

I know it's bad to fedjacket. If I wasn't seeing them get well meaning actionists charged by needlessly posting their faces online I would be less concerned.

KK

Start your own? I mean, they’re free to setup ;)

Sai

Gets pretty expensive once you start getting literally dozens of your own people thrown in prison lol

annabeth

i just signed up for a palestine action course!! thanks so much for plugging this org!

BammEs

I fully support their actions, but I do think it's dangerous to demand all the attention of the movement like this. Diversity of tactics is super important, and for lower-bar tactics to be effective, they simply CANNOT openly express solidarity with more radical elements. You can't be out in the mass rallies organizing people who for the first time publicly express their discontent when you're an organization that is in open solidarity with people who have terrorism charges. It puts a certain label on you. Diversity of tactics means understanding this about one another, and this accusatory finger-wagging at more moderate mass movements doesn't help anyone. these movements should be able to work in parallel.

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

I've been behind on the podcast, just got around to listening to this episode the other day. Although the term is never used, this was a phenomenal case study of nonviolent direct action (which, yes, sometimes can include property destruction); the value of militancy; and the importance of deploying diversity of tactics, properly understood (crudely summarized: if one tactic/set of tactics fails, try something different). Really great discussion all around.