Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht begins by preparing to read his Night School lecture on Socialist Revolutions, but then gets monumentally sidetracked into an hour long extemporaneous analysis of the Trump Tariffs, Industrial Policy, Manufacturing, neoliberal globalization, the self-immolation of the U.S.'s international reputation, and the possible domestic trajectories over the next half decade: from the hypothetical rise of a new FDR to do a Trump-style takeover of the Democratic Party to techno-fascism in an isolated, reactionary, oligarchic United States to full-on collapse and the conditions for revolution. Somehow he ends up talking about our human nature as socio-linguistic beings, the likely evolutionary ancestry of intelligent aliens, the difference between ants and snakes, Spinoza's God, and the universal cosmic nature of Love... He never quite gets to the lecture. But he will next time. Probably.

Outro Song: "Knafeh" by spinitch

Files

Comments

Saya Clarke

No deep thoughts here just praise! Wasn’t expecting a top 5 solo episode but holy shit. Extended Red Hot Shot let’s fucking go. Only thing I’ll say is yeah stopping weed is the best decision I ever made back in 2023. Can’t believe I ever lived with that level of daily discomfort and anxiety willingly. Glad to hear it’s helped you and I’m looking forward to the guest episode you kept teasing during this one.

Rev Left Radio

Wow! High Praise Saya! Thank you :) I totally relate. I severely underestimated how much it destabilized my mood and baseline emotional state. I always made excuses, told myself it had benefits, etc. But w the clarity of hindsight, I see how much better sobriety really is, and am stunned it took me so long to give it up. I can see myself using it for special occasions once in a blue moon, but the thought of any sort of regular use just makes me cringe at the thought. I used to have cravings like crazy when I tried to quit before, this time, no cravings at all. IN fact, thinking about smoking and getting high really is off-putting.

Adam Schendel

Great stuff here, Breht! Not to go off-topic, but hey, what books are you reading these days? I know you mention this every now and then in these Patreon eps. The last time you did, I sought out the "I Am Dynamite" Nietzsche bio as well as the "Karl Marx: A 19th Century Life" book you were planning to read soon (I'd be curious of your thoughts on this Marx book!) But yeah, as a huge book/history nerd, I am always intrigued by your latest reads and could use a recommendation or two if you've been reading!

Garth Yu

Great that you called out the so called “MAGA communists”. In these difficult times, folks that throw trans people and others under the bus should not be allowed in any socialist or communist spaces. Liberation is for all.

Rev Left Radio

Hey Adam, okay so right now I am readying Mysticism by Simon Critchley, The Dark Interval by Ranier Maria Rilke (its his letters on death and grief), and am about to start The City and The City by China Mieville, a work of fiction I am reading for a collab with the literary podcast The Socialist Shelf! Havent actually gotten around to the Marx book, but plan to soon! :)

Rev Left Radio

Yes, their reactionary attitudes, juvenile rhetoric, ego-maniac leaders, and opportunistic politics have isolated them from the broader movement. Their whole pretense was that they were more real and could relate to "normal workers" better, but find themselves a tiny, isolated sect disconnected from the masses as well as the rest of the revolutionary left. Cause and Effect.

Chris Jones

It’s honestly kinda funny when settlers who have the same fundamental beliefs about the national question try to shit on ACP and “MAGA communism”. As if PSL, FRSO, CPUSA, all don’t have the same exact social fascist fantasy written out in their programs. What is the difference between the rhetoric of ACP and the People’s Forum or BT News besides the PSL fronts having a progressive coat of paint on the settler left populism?

Rev Left Radio

I am not in any of those orgs, cannot speak for them. Ive interviewed PSL folks and have never once found them in support of settler colonialism or against decolonization as an essential feature of any real revolution on this continent fwiw. I do not know much about the FRSO or CPUSA in that regards, and havent done much if any episdoes with them. I just looked it up on PSL's website, under their "Program" and it says the following: "he existing colonial relationships of the United States will be dissolved. The independence of Puerto Rico will be immediately recognized, with full reparations for colonial exploitation, and the right of free travel between the U.S. and Puerto Rico. Samoa, Guam, the Virgin Islands and Mariana Islands will be free to exercise their right to self-determination, up to and including independence, with reparations and the right to free travel between the former colonies and the U.S. mainland. Restitution, including the return of land stolen, will be provided for Native Nations. Further, the socialist government will reaffirm the right of Native Nations to self-determination, up to and including independence. It will honor more than 300 currently-existing treaties with Native nations that have been violated or ignored by the capitalist state — an important starting point for undoing the legacies of settler colonialism." here is the FRSO program and line on the issue titled "Immediate Demands for U.S. Colonies, Indigenous Peoples, and Oppressed Nationalities" found here: https://frso.org/main-documents/immediate-demands-for-u-s-colonies-indigenous-peoples-and-oppressed-nationalities/ The CPUSA program discusses colonialism at length but doesnt seem to offer a specific program on the topic that I could easily link to or summarize. There is certainly room for disagreement and critique here to be sure, but those orgs seem to me to be fundamentally different than what the ACP and MAGA communists advocate for or believe in wrt to the national question and settler colonialism. You can def critique all the organizations mentioned here on this issue, but arguing that they are the same as and hold the same positions as the ACP and are therefore not in a position to criticize the ACP I think is taking it too far. But I am open to your counter-points, ofc!

Brad Northcote

Your deconstruction of the tariff nonsense was refreshing, as in Canada we're getting little more than a barrage of nationalist strategizing from a central banker-turned politician campaiging for election. It's constantly about "productive talks" and how to ride this out with tax cuts. Looking forward to hearing your lecture on socialist revolutions! There is definitely a *lot* to unpack in ~40 minutes. On a personal note, I try to keep referring back to episodes where you discuss marijuana use. I was a "late bloomer" who only tried edibles for the first time last year in some vain pursuit of an escape, and it helps to have reminders that there are less "blunt instruments".

Chris Jones

When you strip away the pretty language it’s the same vision of a socialist United States with a few “liberated” rump states while colonial relations are mostly preserved. None of these Marcyist organizations that you’ve mentioned want to abolish American national identity, (although they always love to talk about opposing normalization of israel!) You can read it yourself throughout PSLs recent book although the giveaway is in the title, “reconstruction”. FRSO just came out with this hit piece but there’s more on their sites and social media. https://fightbacknews.org/articles/marxism-leninism-and-the-theory-of-settler-colonialism-in-the-united-states Although the influence and hegemony that Marcyists and other forms of cryptotrotskyists have been able to win in the past 25 years is a major barrier to the unification of a Communist Party on occupied Turtle Island, the larger problem is that unfortunately what passes for Marxism Leninism and Maoism most of the time in this country is just a crude form of social democracy. Dissident progressives/ liberals, including myself at one point, stumbled into Marxist Leninist aesthetics online and through a larger process of social reproduction and parenti memes crafted an ideology(in the Marxist sense) that suited their alienation and coddled their parasitic interests (as labor aristocrats). These are the cadres and supporters of these organizations, and their mass base is the broader labor aristocracy. The fact that these groups won’t oppose normalization in their own context is to prevent this base from rupturing. Unfortunately for them there are too many conflicting interests. I give PSL another 5-10 years of relevance before the masses of nationally oppressed people outpace it and it loses relevancy

Rev Left Radio

Glad you found it useful, Brad. And yes, the rising nationalism in Canada and Europe in the face of American belligerence and betrayal is interesting to see... The US v. Canada hockey game was admittedly fun to watch in large part cuz it felt personal (silliness of it all fully accepted). But to see the establishment elite playing into it and leveraging that nationalism to advance neoliberal austerity is grotesque. I did an interview the author of Never Enough during my last attempt to quit cannabis several years ago, which you might find interesting. I eventually relapsed ofc, which might add another layer of interest to listening to that episode haha. Being a late bloomer in that regard is good actually, lots of evidence suggest the earlier one starts using cannabis, the worse it is for ya. Like alcohol, pscyhedelics, adderall, etc. Marijuana can play a role in an overall healthy life if used in extreme moderation for specific purposes/celebrations. Its compulsive daily or regular use that becomes an issue and negatively impacts your health. But for that, sobriety must be your baseline! Unlike booze those using marijuana casually - espeically the higher power stuff out today - is rarely an "escape". For most people the sharp increase in self-awareness and hyper self-consciousness is extremely uncomfortable and anxiety inducing haha. It has a tendency to bring things your repressing to the forefront or make you obsessively overthink things. Only with tolerance does that go down for most people. But everyone is different, some I assume can enjoy it causually and itermittently!

Rev Left Radio

Interesting and worthwhile - if admittedly harsh - analysis. The FRSO article you posted was illuminating as to your point. I genuinely appreciate that! Your argument regarding conflicting interests and contradictions within these orgs is principled and worth wrestling with for sure. You may very well end up being correct about the masses of nationally oppressed people outpacing and displacing these formations in teh coming years, especially as the contradictions of capitalism-imperialism-colonialism continue to mount. What organizations do you find the most promising in general, and the most principled wrt the national question and settler colonialism?

Chris Jones

I don’t wanna shill the org I’m involved with in this comments section but I’ll mention some of the ones we work with or would like to work with. There are a lot of small cadre and mass orgs on the local level who are coming round to or already at a more principled stance. Among MLs there’s the formation around the journal Red Clarion. For Maoists of the former CRCPUSA, the RSGs, Half the Sky, RSU, and RMC all have decent lines. There’s also third worldist and revolutionary nationalist orgs, like MIM or the Provisional Government of New Afrika, some of which have barely survived decades of state repression. Having worked with different chapters of PSL I will say that a lot of ppl in the grassroots are at least sympathetic when you talk to them about this. Marcyism is only able to prey on people’s theoretical ignorance with its mass rallies, slick media, calls for a basic welfare state and overtures to “Actually Existing Socialism” up until a certain point.

Dog In Hot Car

This ended up being a great episode. Capitalism forces us to act like ants and it leaves such a spiritual wound

Kolibri

JDPON Don 🇨🇳🫡

Matt Pierce

Please tell me that the Vietnam War episode is gonna be in the best ofs!

Matt Pierce

Welp - my question has just been answered by you pushing it in the public feed lol!

Michael Xin

So far it seems like President Xi is flying everywhere and talking to leaders of every country except the United States. Trump has been ghosted.

Bill

Really great episode! Despite the breadth of ideas that you covered it remained remarkably cogent. Add some climate change into the mix and we’re gonna have a pretty crazy 21st century lol. It’s all coming at a time in my life where I was hoping for some rest. I’m coming upon my 45th year of highly stressful work and am physically/mentally exhausted. I’ve survived though- and I’m currently reading Caliban and the Witch by Silvia Federici. It’s a good reminder of how violent capitalism historically and inherently is. We should be frightened- and yet I hate saying that because it sounds so defeatist.

Rev Left Radio

I agree with you. But while things look grim, we do now know how it will actually play out, so we gotta do what we can, control what we can, accept what we cannot, adjust our expectations, and prepare mentally and emotionally for any number of possibilities. Take care of yourself and know this is a global process as well as a national one, youll still have the bulk of your daily life to yourself even in some of the worse off trajectories. Community, as always, remains crucial. And yes, that is a great book - and an enlightening one as well. It really reframes a whole chunk of history that we never learn almost anywhere else.

Rev Left Radio

AS Xi said "this only isolates the US further". Xi is playing chess and will maximize China's advantages, as the US flails around the makes itself weaker than ever.

Rev Left Radio

Glad you enjoyed it, my friend! appreciate the support!

Bill

Thank you 🙏

Rev Left Radio

Word, I appreciate you taking time to lay out the orgs, and ill keep an eye on them for future interviews/episodes. And of course, if you and your org ever wanna come on, the door is open! Thank you for your perspective fr.

JS

lol you said you always stumble back into talking about love and human consciousness; i think that’s a really beautiful thing though, it shows that it’s what’s at the core of everything you talk about, which is why i think so many people come together to hear you speak on even trivial things. Keep up the good work!

Landis Brown

“Organize through your fucking church” made my day

Chase

Great stuff man, loved it!

Rev Left Radio

I really appreciate that, and I am glad that comes through; staying rooted in genuine love for others is crucial imo.

Wes Rich

Really love these more stream of consciousness feeling episodes. You covered so many topics so well so I have nothing to add but one thing I keep thinking about are the China tariffs. The Cheeto’s going to get so much domestic pressure from his constituents but more importantly his donor class once prices go through the roof so I see him either capitulating or maybe standing his ground and basically fucking over our hegemonic hold over global finance, which of course would have massive ramifications here in the states. He really might break this shit and leave the door wide open to a complete overhaul of our mode of production, although we’ve seen how much this country loves their good ole fashioned American fascism so who knows which direction we’d head in

Alberto García

Well, things don't look quite good for Newsom. They believed their own propaganda so much, all that centrist bullshit, that he did the Charlie Kirk thing and it backfired badly.

Ben

have had some run ins with some ultra lefts lately…seems their primary allure to communism/political education is dunking on those less educated. not a great way to party build imo lmao

spinitch

u the best so stoked to listen<3<3<3

Megan

This is totally off-topic, but in one of your earlier episodes (either here or Shoeless) you mentioned a philosphical theory that argues that humans are the physical manifestation of the universe’s consciousness or something to that affect. Can you tell me what that theory is and who wrote it? I can’t seem to find it doing a quick google search. Thank you comrade! And thank you for all you do!

Shane

All around great episode. You waiting on a hot take for the tariff debacle, shows you're a great historical materialist. It totally can change on a whim as you said.

Jack Sauer

This push to re-shore manufacturing is a prime example of how capitalism undermines itself. The Ukraine-Russia war did not go the way the US elites thought it would. Everyone thought Russia would bulldoze the Ukrainians in a matter of a few weeks or tops a few months; after all, the Russians have all the fancy weapons, the hypersonic missiles, the next-gen fighter jets, the latest drones, etc. But what actually happened was that, in the third decade of the 21st century, the conflict settled into trench warfare. Despite one side having a big advantage in technology, the course of the war was determined by good old-fashioned manufacturing capacity. Russia ground the Ukrainian forces into the ground because they were firing 10 artillery shells for every 1 the Ukrainians fired. The ability of each side to produce enough for attritional, grinding conflict was the key factor, not who had the most advanced weapons. Previous US military orthodoxy stated that we lost in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Vietnam due to the asymmetrical nature of those conflicts, but if we were ever in a "real war", our technology would allow us to flatten any standing army that we faced head-on. The Ukraine conflict shows that modern warfare doesn't look like that. This war changed the American bourgeoisie's calculus in a major way, and they realized that the reason their proxy war failed was because they couldn't out-produce the Russians. So now there is this scramble to repatriate manufacturing capacity, but capitalism has no mechanism through which they can achieve that, so instead we get these tariffs. The US ruling class is freaking out about their defeat in Ukraine, and they are floundering to course-correct, but they can't, because of the anarchy of the market. Wall Street has undermined the material basis of the military that enforced their rule over the world.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Shane, appreciate that Hist Mat compliment ;)

Rev Left Radio

Great analysis, and tbh that might be behind some of the hesitation to start a war with Iran, and for similar reasons. To say nothing about China...

Mark Morrison

Love the episode. Globalization helped capitalists save on labor costs even if they had to spend more to transport shit around the world. Now that the assembly lines and textile production shops are automated, the math has changed. They don’t need the cheap labor that was required in the 90’s and 00’s. Bringing back automated manufacturing will not bring back jobs, but it will help capitalists save on global transport costs.

KK

I’m not sure I follow; everyone thought the Russians would bulldoze the Ukrainians, they out manufactured the Ukrainians, and yet we have trench warfare? Why do we not have a Russian victory already?

Jack Sauer

They didn't out-manufacture the Ukrainians, they out-manufactured the entire NATO bloc. As early as late 2022 NATO was discussing how to overcome the enormous artillery ammunition deficit faced by their Ukrainian proxies, and they never found an answer for this problem. This problem arose because NATO never considered that the war might settle into a stalemate, their assumption was that Russia's overwhelming advantage in technology would allow them to easily crush the Ukrainians, and by doing so they would overextend themselves, and then they would cave under crushing sanctions. When the sanctions failed to hobble the Russian war effort and Russian technology failed to overrun the Ukrainians, the conflict settled into attrition. Attrition is a losing battle for NATO, because its manufacturing base has been hollowed out by decades of neoliberalism. So now, NATO is faced with the fact that it cannot overpower even a much weaker adversary through sheer firepower, because drone warfare has changed how modern wars are fought. So NATO is faced with an inability to win by firepower and an inability to win by attrition, which means they don't stand a chance against China, especially since they failed to topple the Chinese-friendly Russian regime.