Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I am currently enrolled in a Human Geography class and thought you might enjoy reading some of the answers I routinely give to basic assignment questions XD.

1. What did you find most interesting about the major theories of development?
What I found most interesting was how dependency theory and world-systems theory reveal the fundamentally exploitative nature of the global capitalist system. From a Marxist perspective, world-systems theory shows that "development" is not a neutral or benevolent process, but one structured through capitalist accumulation on a world scale, where core countries extract surplus value from the periphery. I was also struck by how environmental determinism, even though it’s discredited, served historically to justify imperialism and colonial domination — naturalizing the exploitation of colonized peoples by portraying it as inevitable or environmentally determined. It reminds me that many mainstream theories of development conceal the class relations and imperialist dynamics that actually produce "underdevelopment."

2. How do you think the United States might improve its Human Development Index in the coming years?
Genuine improvement in the U.S. HDI would require confronting the capitalist relations that generate inequality and suffering domestically and internationally. Internally, that would mean radically restructuring the economy to prioritize public needs like universal healthcare, free and accessible education, living wages, strong social programs, etc., over private profit accumulation. Internationally, it would require dismantling imperialist and neo-colonial policies and structures (from the US empire to the IMF and World Bank, to the EU, and beyond) that drain wealth and resources from the Global South to sustain U.S./Western dominance as well as specific U.S. policies like the brutal sanctions on Venezuela and Iran and the Embargo on Cuba that strangle the economies of countries the U.S. disagrees with, infringing on their soverignty and generating massive and unjust suffering for their people. Without structural changes to the capitalist-imperialist system, any gains would likely be superficial or unevenly distributed. There is a liberal naivety that asserts that these things can be solved by tinkering with the margins of the system and through piece-meal, incremental reforms - without ever confronting the basic premises of these profoundly violent systems. I think that delusion is increasingly dangerous, and represents a stubborn refusal to engage with systemic critiques or to prioritize the liberation of billions of people in the Global South - and huge swaths of poor, marginalized, and working people here at home - over the privilege and comfort many wealthy Western liberals enjoy.

Comments

Lefty In Training

That last part especially. Getting people to recognize the real domestic and international cost of what they do have, even when they feel like they have next to nothing, or getting them to shed their chauvinism when they do know that is a real struggle.

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely. My professor is clearly a progressive minded person, so I am optimistic this stuff strikes a cord with her. She seems to enjoy my presence in class and is cool with even my most radical takes. Im doing my final project on the Omaha chapter of the Black Panther Party too, so its been a full court press all semester XD

John Fritchie

I hope you’re not getting graded on this. Great answers, but…

John Fritchie

Just saw your note regarding the instructor. Looks like you’re in the clear

Bill

Well done! A+!!

Hana

This is so good! I've always instinctively felt so much of this but developing a materialist understanding has been key to beating the mystification and having the wherewithall to confidently engage with *why* it's wrong and how it can be changed. And how rational the desire to overcome this shitty system is. I had a friend years back and one of the earliest indications of her rightward turn was a conversation about how the exploitation of the global south is no longer relevant to the developmental imbalances around the world. Last time I had anything to do with her she'd gone full reactionary, racist, Britain First-style ahistoricism and self-justification. The punchline is that shes a teacher of Religion, Philosophy and Ethics.

yesn't

I’m in a Human Geo class and Rostows Theory of development pissed me off so much lmao!!

HailZeus

I once wrote a paper in 2019 when Trump was looking to invade Venezuela with thst Guaido guy s support about how the "crisis" was overblown to support military action against a competing regional power and my global studies teacher wrote on my essay not to engage in this kind of writing. Now remember this was a super liberal young teacher she wasn't even 30 yet. The Uni Libbed to the core. And critiquing Imperialism gets you a stern "don't go down this road", but it's required to cite NYT or WaPo.

HailZeus

Please copy / paste more answers or feedback you get. When I attended higher Ed was the very early stages of my class consciousness I never would have wrote such a succinct and developed response.

LumpinLinecook

In a way I think all this warmongering about china & russia is misdirection, giving trumpz failed coup in Venezuela his first term and the more recent ramblings to renue the Monroe doctrine in 2024 under biden. I feel they might look to start conflicts in the central/south America's to use them for value added goods if BRICS can withstand this trade war.

Anonymous

Hi Breht, I was wondering if you could do an episode on the life/legacy/works of Jane McAlevey. I recently helped found a tenant power organization in my city, and we saw immediate benefits in the the building we’ve been organizing by implementing very basic lessons from the introduction to No Shorcuts. I think her legacy and lessons for new organizers are invaluable and should be spread as far and wide as possible.

Rev Left Radio

WE just dropped an episode on Tenant organzing and I saw this when I logged in to publish it! Yea, that sounds like a great episode. I see online that see recently passed... but I would love to help honor her legacy. Who did you have in mind for a guest? You interested?

Rev Left Radio

lmao absolutely!! Going through historical theories is wild !

Rev Left Radio

If there is a robust response and not a mere grade I will!! <3

Rev Left Radio

lol nope, its cleaner and more upright than I usually talk, but you can hear my voice and identify my rhetorical style. But I assume its a huge and growing problem in academia. Some teachers seem to be trying to address it and others dont. One professor I had made all grades based on in-class, handwritten essays and tests. This is the way to go IMO.

Rev Left Radio

lol, really flies in the face of the idea that universities are marxist re-education centers. But ofc, universities are thoroughly liberal and neoliberal, where moderate conservativism and libertarianism also flourish. Anything outside that spectrum is not generally embraced, let alone taught. Though, there are always exceptions from time to time.

Rev Left Radio

Identifying that earlier shift is insightful, and definitely teh first step toward reaction: denying the reality of imperialism and neo-colonialism. I had a friend years ago who's rightward turn I caught in its absolute INFANCY, based on subtle wording of positions that still mostly aligned with the left. I kept the suspicion to myself, only to see it evolve in a couple years to full on reaction. But overall, yes, a materialist/class analysis is essential in keeping a grounded, concrete, and revolutionary outlook as well as being able to demystify ideology and reveal actual social relations.

Anonymous

Thank you for responding! Definitely not me as our org is very nascent and I’m a baby organizer haha. If I understand correctly, McAlevey got the bulk of her labor organizing training from SEIU 1199NE, and it’s known as one of the most militant labor unions in the country, so maybe one of their members? Or maybe a red menace episode on No Shortcuts? Another option might be Hannah Srajer, the president of the Connecticut Tenants Union. She was a guest on The Dig recently. CTTU seems to be at the forefront of connecting labor and tenant organizing, as they have strong ties with 1199NE, and and they use a labor union-like organizational structure and constitution. She might not be able to speak much about McAlevy directly, but she might be able to give insight to McAlevey’s/1199NE’s organizing methods from a tenant union perspective

Rev Left Radio

Okay, great. Ill see if I can reach her and ill add No Shortcuts to the RM To-Do list! I appreciate the recommendation and the support of the show! WRT to organizing, keep going! We all start gotta start somewhere, but doing it at all is the important thing! <3

Anonymous

Absolutely! Rev Left, Guerilla History, and Red Menace have played a huge role in my political development and I probably wouldn’t be attempting without that influence, so thank you!

Sarah

It’s kind of hilarious the assumptions underpinning questions that just aren’t examined at all in high ed, I wouldn’t say this is limited to 101 classes either sadly. My entire psych bachelors and post grad classes relied upon so many flawed assumptions even in so called progressive and social psych papers, and it wasn’t until engaging with Marxism that these became obvious. I’m sure the rest of the class and the lecturer are either entertained or taken aback by such responses (or hopefully inspired to question their own assumptions)