Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Alyson and Breht explore Friedrich Engels’ Dialectics of Nature, a bold and underappreciated attempt to apply dialectical materialism to the natural sciences. Often dismissed or misunderstood, this unfinished work offers a sweeping view of reality - from physics and chemistry to evolution, human consciousness, and ecological breakdown - through the lens of Marxist philosophy. Together, they unpack Engels’ central claim that nature itself unfolds dialectically: through contradiction, motion, transformation, and interconnection.

They cover the three laws of dialectics, Engels’ materialist account of human evolution, his critique of mechanistic science, vulgar materialism, and metaphysical thinking, as well as his early warnings about capitalism’s ecological consequences. Along the way, they connect these insights to Marx’s concept of species-being, and reflect on what this revolutionary worldview offers in the age of climate crisis, hyper-alienation, and late capitalist decay. Finally, Alyson and Breht have a fascinating open-ended discussion about the existential and spiritual implications of dialectical materialism as a worldview.

Whether you're new to dialectical materialism or looking to deepen your understanding, this conversation reframes Engels’ work as a profound contribution not just to Marxism, but to the philosophy of science itself.

Here are the episodes recommended for further listening in the episode:

Files

Comments

Matthew

Awww yeah 🔥🔥🔥

Brad Northcote

Great breakdown of this text! Your laying out of Engels's critique of Darwin is both useful in itself and interesting as a supplement to reading Kropotkin's "Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution". In that text, Kropotkin lays out a naturalistic empirical critique that challenges the Malthusian view of Darwin, arguing by examples for cooperation as a function of species' survivability (insect hives as a notable case). But while that's a very dialectical approach, Kropotkin never explicitly frames it in dialectical terms. Maybe that speaks to the point about the potential "applying of dialectical materialism without realizing it" across the left more broadly.

Rev Left Radio

I think it absolutely speaks to the point of application without conscious awareness or articulation of it! Which really counts in favor of DiaMat because so many people who are not even aware of wtf that is, but who pursue truth in a given domain, can come to very diamat conclusions - this supports the idea that its how reality is already structured and even people outright hostile to Marxism come to such conclusions if they truly abide by objective truth seeking. But so glad you liked it, Brad, and I appreciate the feedback and support as always!!

CC

Stoked for this, thank you! I’ve been reading up a lot lately on complexity theory, and it’s crazy how well it lines up sometimes. Dude was ahead of his time.

Brad Northcote

Wanted to add my condolences to Alyson, as well. There's something hopefully comfortingly ego-transcendent in the sharing of grief.

PinkoScum

Big missed opportunity to coin the phrase “Engelian”

PinkoScum

Thank you for this extraordinarily enlightening episode, you guys never miss ❤️

Ben Padula

I was looking forward to this so much :)

nude tagne

Thank you so much Alyson and Breht for the wonderful work that you do.

Rev Left Radio

High praise!! We appreciate that so much. Glad you enjoyed it!

Rev Left Radio

Def. I love Engels so much. He needs to get more love in general!

Comrade Meow

This was a fantastic episode. Thank you for your hard work!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you! We appreciate you listening and your support!!

Eric Ripa

Wonderful episode. So dense with a lot of details. I will go back to this again for sure! I truly enjoyed the last section where you discussed atheism, which is something I have struggled with lately as someone who used to be a staunch atheist. Thank you both!

Joshua Bauman

History of human society isn't quite a straight line like that. The Dawn of Everything by David Graeber and David Wengrow goes into that.

Jihad

Beautifully well done by both of you. For me, this line of thought always leads back to (and complexifies) the question of free will as well. On the one hand I can see how this conception of reality would lead one to the conclusion that free will is an illusion and in a sense it’s deterministic all the way down. On the other hand, my visceral experience of the world tells me I am a radical free agent only limited by my constitution and the material environment in which I am embedded. I always land in the position that neither of those is really true, but any compatibilist integration of the two is never satisfying as well. In the end, I get the feeling that it may forever remain a mystery in the same sense that what came “before” the Big Bang may forever remain a mystery as well. I’ve heard bits of lectures where Chomsky also talks about the theoretical limits of our apprehension—in the context of his critique of Cartesian dualism. In any case, a great discussion that generates endless food for thought.

Rance Orrell

this might be my favorite episode you two have done together. my understanding of dialectics was strengthened more in the last 2.5 hours than in all the years i’ve spent learning about these topics combined. thanks for all the amazing work y’all do! and Breht - I’m looking forward to that book!

Tim Fitzgerald

Great episode, thanks. I would encourage you to consider moving away from the description of people embracing your (broadly, our) ideology and/or spiritual development as 'maturing'. My reasoning is two-fold. I think it frames you (broadly, us) as ideologically superior in a way that could easily be grating for people to whom you're trying to reach. Even moreso for older listeners - for example, my dad (a very kind, intelligent, open minded 70 year old man) has come around to a great degree to my politics. I'm fairly sure he'd find it somewhat obnoxious for people in their 30s to be explicitly describing themselves as more politically and spiritually 'mature' as a result of having embraced certain belief systems. More importantly, I know that this type of language from Marxists (particularly white Marxists) is grating to some amazing First Nations comrades. One of my First Nations comrades has mentioned a number of times that the material and spiritual understanding of his ancestors was very consistent with the type of society that we're trying to build, prior to the settler colonial genocide here in so-called Australia. To skip over this and briefly alude to attitudes of 'warring tribes' that need to be matured from is inappropriate and ahistorical, in my view. Thanks again and keep up the great work!

Matt Pierce

"No, brother, nature is in here, too!" LOL

Lhasa Apsos for Palestine

Absolutely love that you mentioned Alan Watts. I got super into his lectures as a teenager and I bet that dialectical way of thinking primed me to be a Rev Left listener.

Rohan Swinsburg

Hey Breht, I loved this episode! You and Alyson did a fantastic job at articulating some profound concepts.I appreciate you guys engaging with discussions of religion, the divine, imanence, in a nuanced and engaging way. I'd like to see more marxists taking this line of inquiry seriously. It's exciting to hear you are writing a book! I just wanted to suggest a potential thread you could look into if you are interested in synthesising dialectical materialism and "spirituality", and that is indigenous perspectives and the framework of animism as it is being currently understood. Animism in anthropology has moved beyond the colonial misconception of "everything has a soul". Now animism is being understood as emphasising relationality it with natural forces. I see Spinoza's Pantheism as being the broad, overarching, but abstract understanding of reality as divine, whereas animism relates to the complexity, dynamism, and felt experiences of people and cultures, in relation to land, climate, social context etc. Animism can be seen as a kind of spiritual materialism rooted in relationality, reciprocity, and respect. The part mythology plays, within animism, is as a tool of creating right relationship with land. A kind of relationship a future communism will have to foster. Below I'll link to an article on Cosmonaut Magazine, looking at animism from a Marxist perspective: https://cosmonautmag.com/2023/02/karl-marx-and-radical-indigenous-critiques-of-capitalism/

BammEs

Love this episode! Excellent, understandable discussion of difficult material. Especially appreciated the examples. I was already going to comment that you two are the only ones that could discuss dialectics of nature and end up talking spirituality haha My main criticism is that it's remained quite individualist in some sense, especially when you're talking about The Role Played By Labor. What's so important about labor is both that it's fundamentally social and that it has lasting effects that can be built on further. Labor changes the social dynamics, the practices, which then change the individuals, giving rise to language socially, which then changes the individual, and so on. So much that you should really look into, but there is one book specifically that pieces a lot of things together, it's Linguistic Bodies by Exequiel Di Paolo and colleagues. It's thoroughly dialectical, cutting edge scientific and philosophical, and it looks at the relations between biology, cognition, and the development of language. There's a few ways in which you're still stuck in old ways of thinking sometimes that this can really help undo!

Lesley Braver

High key one of my favorite episodes of any podcast ever

NostromoDreams

This is absolutely one of my most favorite episodes.

Larry

I wonder if with AI there's speed of light limitation, takes too much energy to artificially think. Whoa, artificial thinking.

Rev Left Radio

Wow! Thank you Lesley!!! WE appreciate that sooo much.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for the great feedback and the recommendation (ill peep it asap!) and for the support of the show!!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Rohan, and beautiful point about Animism and its relationship to dialectical spirituality and Spinoza, my friend! That is incredibly interesting and ill check that article out right now!!!

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely! Alan Watts was huge for me at a pivotal time as well. When I was like 18 I mentioned to an older coworker that I was interested in Buddhism and Taoism, and he burned me a bunch of CDs (yes, im old lol) of Watts lectures and it light my mind on fire!! I listened to those lectures over and over and over again...

Rev Left Radio

Totally fair criticism!!! Thank you for that, ill keep that in mind going forward when writing and discussing this topic. But by warring tribes, I wasnt specifying any specific culture, much less indigenous people in particular - I was trying to refer to a deeply human and completely universal aspect of human history. I mentioned it, if I remember correctly, in the context of modern nation states and our need to move toward a more planetary and ecologically holistic identity which is actually resonant with indigenous traditions moreso than modern capitalist societies. But thank you for the thoughtful listening and feedback! I really apprecaite it!

Rev Left Radio

That is the highest praise we could ever hope to recieve, my friend! Thank you so much for listening and for the kind words of support!

Rev Left Radio

Absolutlely. Would be fun to do a whole episode just exploring the nuances and caveats of historical materialism, because this is an important aspect of it - and of dialectical development in general. I tried to get at this with the progress vs. evolution point, but only indirectly. Nothing is ever linear in dialectial development. I should have emphasized that. IN the retelling of historical materialism, just by the nature of all that needs to be explained, it often is simplified into a narrative that implicitly feels straight and linear, but thats a function of narrative not a reflection of how historical development occurs IRL.

Rev Left Radio

SUPER thoughtful feedback, and it resonates with me a lot. Ive been trying to hold the dualism of determinism/free will at the same time. Is it possible that both are true in some sense? This would lead into some sort of compatibilism, but one that would demand the dialectical synthesis of opposites into a unified whole... Ill keep mulling this over alongside you! Thank you for listening and for your thoughts.

BammEs

Thanks for the response! I'm sure you won't be disappointed if you manage to plough your way through it. Hell, as a dialectical materialist it might be easier on you than it was on most of my colleagues But also: my own article on the role of labour in cognition just got published in the journal Mind & Society. I hope a bit more approachable and less dense than Linguistic Bodies, as well as a lot shorter, (and open access!) so give it a look if you're curious: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11299-025-00323-2

Bill

I thoroughly enjoyed listening to this episode. Much of it strongly resonated with me. Believing in a dialectical approach to analyzing social, political, and biological life easily falls in line with my Zen practice/belief in non-duality. Taking it a bit deeper I began to think about quantum physics, particularly the theories of superposition and entanglement, which seem dialectical to me- then expanding outward I began thinking about space, the universe, and how we are just a microscopic part of much broader unknown dialectic. On one hand this made me doubt the importance or relevance of our earthly struggle - while on the other hand, as small as we are, there is still something so powerful in believing that we are the sentient universe. Of course I am just speculating, but perhaps our struggle is a universal struggle- and perhaps it is played out across the universe in many other worlds. Though we may never know the truth or the denouement of these mysteries, I’d like to think that maybe our struggle in some small way impacts on a much larger evolutionary process. Thank you both for the generosity of sharing your intellect with us. It’s greatly appreciated. Looking so forward to your book!!

Lhasa Apsos for Palestine

Also listened to those on repeat! I was lucky that my mom was a fan of Watts and actually got some videotape of his lectures from Watts’ son Mark. Beautiful videos with Alan demonstrating Buddhist concepts through drawing and visual examples to enhance his lectures.

Joshua Bauman

I think my response was during a specific moment and not necessarily reflective of your whole presentation. This was a wonderful episode, I'm going to listen again. I shared this discussion with my good hearted lib father. He's a boomer and comes from a very dogmatic conservative Christian background but journeyed to atheism on his own. My own journey leftward was first influenced by him, against the norm of our church and private school community. Anyway all this to say, he listened to it and we are going to discuss it tonight when he takes me to the airport. He's been stubbornly resistant to my efforts at propaganda, but is a true believer in science. Dialectical Materialism is the worldview of the secular scientist, and I hope he can connect the dots.

xander

definitely my favorite episode ever. so good 💖

Joshua Bauman

Update: my lib dad was very impressed and your episode successfully broke through his American Boomer programming. He complimented the depth of knowledge and articulate presentation of a very complex topic. I've been trying for years to get him to read some Engels and hour episode has gotten through to him.

Mima

The episode that finally got me to sign up for Patreon. Thank you both so much for all the educating you do. I recently moved to LA and am curious to know if Alyson is involved with local organising groups here? There are so many and I’m struggling to piece them together/apart.

Cherie

At some point towards the end of this podcast I started crying, and I don't really know why exactly, but it was amazing. It took me several minutes to stop completely.

LeftoverComputer

thank you SO MUCH for this - so valuable and insightful, very helpful with understanding this text

alli

just incredible. i’ve come back to this episode again and again over the last couple of weeks. i think this is the most approachable, insightful, and expansive teaching of dialectics that i’ve ever had the joy of thinking through

T

Hey! listening to this made me think something you may find interesting to look into is Relational Quantum Mechanics, an interpretation in which the role of the observer can be played by any object and ultimately posits that the properties of objects exist only in the moment of their interactions and that all properties exist only relative to another object. I think there's fascinating (and challenging) implications for a dialectical world outlook. I'll leave a more technical overview below but a popular introduction can be found in Carlo Rovelli's book Helgoland. Interestingly he relates the debate between Lenin and Bogdanov exemplified in Lenin's "Materialism and Empiriocriticism" to the implications of this interpretation of QM however he ultimately comes down more on the side of Bogdanov and criticises Lenin's definition of "matter". Obviously this is something you likely won't get to anytime soon but I thought it's something you might have some interesting thoughts on! plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-relational/

Mason Herzing

Right when Brett said, “Look at your hands…” I was at my job as a mechanic using my hands to fix a truck, and that was a cool moment. Labor really is what makes us human.

Jona

Hey Breht, any chance you and Alyson would consider posting your script from this episode? I find myself coming back it over and over again and would love to be able to read through it to digest it even better and reference back/highlight certain quotes. Appreciate the depth of insights and analysis as always