Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

One of the most radical things you can do is live your life in direct opposition to the forces that control our society. Not just fighting for policies or organizing your community, although those are certainly important parts of it, but also living with values that oppose the values of our dominant society. And even more importantly, raising the next generation to embody those values—not in a coercive way, but through organic parenting and role modeling that make radicalism irresistible. This is how we raise revolutionaries: instilling community, love, egalitarianism, and a need for justice into children. And this is just what our guest in today's episode has devoted himself to doing.

Breht O’Shea is an activist, organizer, political educator, and host of the podcast Revolutionary Left Radio and co-host of the podcasts Red Menace and Shoeless in South Dakota. He is a father of three based out of Omaha Nebraska. 

In this conversation, Part 3 of our Post Capitalist Parenting series, Breht shares with us insights about parenting that he's learned over the years as a father of three and what Marxism teaches us about parenting. We discuss the classic text by Engels, The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State, which is a dialectical materialist analysis of patriarchy and the family, tracing the emergence of the patriarchal family and it took through various iterations of class society but also exploring what families have looked like under actually-existing socialism and also what it might look like under communism. We also explore the anti-natalist position which attempts to argue that having children is immoral, why this perspective is deeply flawed, what Buddhism can teach us about parenting, and much, much more.

Further Resources

Related Episodes:

Intermission music: "Cool 4 U" by Club Cafe

Upstream is a labor of love—we couldn't keep this project going without the generosity of our listeners and fans. Subscribe to our Patreon at patreon.com/upstreampodcast or please consider chipping in a one-time or recurring donation at www.upstreampodcast.org/support

If your organization wants to sponsor one of our upcoming documentaries, we have a number of sponsorship packages available. Find out more at  upstreampodcast.org/sponsorship

For more from Upstream, visit www.upstreampodcast.org and follow us on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, and Bluesky. You can also subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts.

Files

Post Capitalist Parenting Pt. 3: A Dialectical Perspective w/ Breht O'Shea

One of the most radical things you can do is live your life in direct opposition to the forces that control our society. Not just fighting for policies or organizing your community, although those are certainly important parts of it, but also living with values that oppose the values of our dominant society.

Comments

Cody

Hey Breht, I listened to this yesterday on upstream when it dropped. Just wanted to say I can really hear the love in your voice when you talk about your kids and as a father of two little girls, 3years old and 11 months I can truly relate to a lot of the the things you say. I agree with you on everything you said about parenting but in particular It’s so refreshing to hear people talk about kids as being their own little selves who are growing and trying to understand the world - much the same as adults. Anyways just wanted to leave a comment, happy belated Father’s Day!!!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Cody, I really appreciate that feedback from a fellow father. It means a lot. I send my love to you and your family. <3

Rev Left Radio

Happy Belated Fathers Day to you as well, my friend!!!

ebonii

I really appreciated this episode it reminded me a lot of my own childhood. My parents also had me at 19 and struggled financially, but my father did model a lot of the same things you talked about. He was very into Buddhism, we always had dinner together we talked about what was going on in the news, and he always seemed so interested in our hobbies and who we were as individuals. Importantly he valued our opinions and didn’t talk down to us as children, but pushed back lightly if we said something a little arrogant or without all the information. I’ve never really thought about how important that was for making me a critical thinker, so thank you for putting that in perspective for me. I also really appreciated the conversation in this about craft, hobbies, and creative expression as being important part of developing as a person. I recently took up a lot of new hobbies and it really does so much for your mental health, but also gets you out in the community. I started taking banjo lessons and the first thing my teacher told me was I needed to go a jam and listen to the music live. I took up knitting and not only has it greatly reduced my screen time (cant really knit and scroll at the same time ) but it also really made me rethink my relationship with my clothing, and the labor that goes into making clothes. I’m in a knitting group now, so just another way hobbies really got me out into my community. So I can’t advocate for taking time for hobby and self expression more, I think many people realized this during lockdown. Anyway great episode, reminded me to give my dad a call.

Rev Left Radio

What a beautiful response to the episode. Your father sounds wonderful, and im so glad this episode prompted some appreciation and even a phone call. That makes my heart swell. Your point about hobbies is so, so spot on, and connecting it with community, less screen time (something I struggle with when the news is like it is currently tbh), and mental health overall is crucial. So much distraction today literally robs people of their willingness or capacity to develop new skills, interests, hobbies, or even a sense of self. Many young people get enraptured by the algorithm and spend all day long staring into the squares, before ya know it years have gone by with nothing to show for it. Its genuinely an assault on our being, and we are all susceptible to its gravitational pull - im certainly not above it, and find myself struggling with it OFTEN. In any case, thank you so much for listening and for this feedback. It really moved me. <3

Brittany

I truly enjoyed the entirety of this episode, great work!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Brittany, I truly appreciate your support!

Jolene Bresney

Your story is incredible- hearing about your family dynamics is really inspiring. You are embodying liberation values and to see it in our closest relationships is pretty amazing.

Brandon

Hey Breht! First off thanks for all the work you do. You’ve helped me develop my Marxist worldview throughout the past couple years so immensely. I wanted to ask what other socialist / Marxist podcasts you’d recommend to folks who want to listen to more (or even non-podcast popular education!). I know and love Guerrilla History, Red Menace and Upstream. But any others you’d recommend?

Rev Left Radio

I am so happy to hear that you found the conversation useful and inspiring, Jolene! I am far from perfect, as we all are, and its constant work and struggle, but embodying our values especially in our closest, daily relationships is essential to seeing those values expressed on the level of social transformation that we as revolutionaries want to see! <3

Philippe

Hey Breht, thanks again for your, in part very personal insights ❤️ an argument I heard people bring up against having kids, is that it's against our objective class interests, because it’s hindering us to get organized. Especially as a women, since women are being pushed into the double labouring burden the most. Many activists drop their activism when they get children and have to start putting food on the table. In my opinion organizations have to be able to allow everyone to participate, even if they don’t have a lot of time, but I see how that can be very difficult. You mentioned, that your arguments are not addressed to people who decide against having kids for personal reasons (which in this case would be, to be able to do organizing work.) But this argument kind of touches more on a class struggle analysis type of thing, you know? I mean getting organized is not really a „personal choice“. People do it because they gained insight into the necessity of doing so, because of their class position. What would you say to that?

Monty O’Blivion

I cried so many times listening to this. So thankful for you my friend! I also became a dad at 19, and now my daughter just finished her freshman year of college. I know how hard it has been, and how at the darkest times you don’t think you can go on, but I wouldn’t change a goddamn thing. Your words resonate in me to my core. Thank you for all the work you do, my love to you and all the comrades in this community and the global one. Y’all make me proud to be a Marxist and a human being.

Jasper Foley

I drive a lot for work and this past week my coworker just chucked on a parenting podcast, and it's interesting to see how similarly what you're saying here tracks with the general parenting advice, hopefully there's a lot more kids raised like this in the future regardless of the political alignment of the parents. Also as an ecologist, I can't agree more with what you say towards about bringing your kids into nature, it's pretty rare to meet someone that truly loves nature that isn't cool as fuck.

Rev Left Radio

It means so much to me to hear this impacted you emotionally like this. And yes, as someone who started my own parenting journey as a teen, I totally relate to all the hardship and emotional intensity of seeing your little one grow into an adult. I too, would never change a thing. Thank you for your support of the show and your feedback, and I send my love to you, your daughter, and your family, my friend. <3

Rev Left Radio

Thats really cool to hear. I honestly do not ever consume parenting stuff for whatever reason, so its nice to hear there is some natural alignment there! I agree with you too! And the nature thing is ALWAYS a great litmus test haha

Mort Crim

Breht, I can’t thank you enough for this podcast. My wife and I spent the last five years having an exhistential crisis on whether or not we should bring a child into this world. One evening after having our young nephews over we discussed how much we loved them and how much fun they are. We decided right then and there to have a child. We were immediately elated, it was like a weight was lifted off our shoulders. Fast forward to today and in almost three weeks we should have a beautiful child. This podcast not only touched on many of my fears, and helped reassure me on our decision but it also lit a fucking Fire under me and somehow got me ever more excited. Thanks, again!

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely amazing timing, wow! That is the right choice, my friend. Truly. You will never know a love so unconditional as the one between you and your child, and it will bring you and your wife even closer in new ways as well. I send all my love to you and your growing family, and wish you all the absolute best. I have no doubt you will be amazing parents. <3

rayr

My wife is a child development, specifically infant development, expert (for lack of better terms) with a Master's degree, and the themes and messaging you've shared in this episode mirror so much of what I've learned vicariously through her. You're so very on point with the prioritization of the development of a relationship with your child. This is a critical foundational step. This is a really important episode and message. Keep it up, Breht.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you so much, and honestly that makes me feel really good to know that some of the stuff Ive learned through brute experience dovetails with the experts in the field! Thank you so much for the feedback and support, my friend.

Bill

As a grandparent I can attest to the struggles parents (and grandparents) face in raising children under capitalism. It wasn’t easy when my wife and I did it and I believe it’s even harder now. I totally understand why birth rates are dropping as young people are deciding that the struggle is insurmountable. I don’t blame them but what a crying shame it is that our economic system turns one of the most joyful and essential human experiences into such a burden. I raised my own children and will drill it into my grandchildren as well the belief (as you stated above) that one of the most radical things you can do is live your life in direct opposition to the forces that control our society. It wasn’t easy for the teenagers but now they see the light. Living small, living real, not buying shit- and not buying into capitalist indoctrination- provides a degree of freedom (and sanity) in an otherwise insane world.

Amy Erickson

Your relationship with your wife and your daughter’s mom (and their relationship) sounds exactly like my husband’s parents. They divorced when he was young. I only met him when he was 31, and I know things weren’t always easy, but I was instantly so impressed by their ability to be together for the holidays and what not. They walked down the aisle together (dad, step-mom, and bio mom) at our wedding. They go to concerts together, we’ve been on vacation together, and they share taking care of our daughter when we need them, etc. It’s so incredible, I am in awe of them. All of this to say keep fostering that relationship, it is such a beautiful and rare thing ♥️♥️