Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this patreon exclusive, Breht reflects on Zohran Mamdani's primary victory in the NYC mayoral race and how communists should think about and relate to it. Then he dives into the recent podcast between Joe Rogan and Bernie Sanders to clarify socialist positions, deepen anti-capitalist analysis, and equip listeners with arguments they can employ in naturally occurring conversations about politics with friends, family, and coworkers.

Here is the Link for Tomorrow's Community Zoom Call:
Topic: The Rev Left Situation Room
Time: Jun 26, 2025 12:00 PM Central Time (US and Canada)
Join Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81324720229?pwd=RwiIPtiXTUjC7TxMM2tYaRc83CZOnh.1

Files

Comments

Mackenzie parvin

Woah I thought that was the blunt rotation on the pod got me real exited

Mackenzie parvin

I’m hopeful he won’t turn out like AOC . He has much more concrete positions ,

Andrew Blake

Just as an aside it's hilarious comparing the cogency and incisiveness of sanders over the course of a 2 hour conversation to pudding- brain Biden stumbling his way through a single question at a presser... and remembering that Biden voters claimed Sanders was too old to be president

Beefdrip

Funny how you mentioned woodworking and Marxism since I do both outside of work. It's a field rife with reactionaries, since the barrier to entry is extremely high (a decent, safe tablesaw costs 3000 USD. A contractor saw will do, but it's a lot less safe). With regards to capitalist innovation, there are 30,000 tablesaw injuries every year in the states. There is a safety brake mechanism, but it is/was patented by a private company named SawStop back in the early 2000s. I think one of the key patents was donated to the public last year. Overall, the tablesaw safety situation is a complete mess and the consequence is that hundreds of thousands of injuries could've been prevented in the meantime.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

The absolute evisceration of Rogan and his lack of basic scientific understanding was WILD. 🤯 Side note: a LONG time ago you did an episode where you talked about Tim Heidecker’s parody of Joe Rogan and now whenever I hear Joe Rogan talk I think of that parody. 😂

Michael Xin

God listening to Rogan and Sanders talk is bad for my blood pressure. Great EP as always Breht and good luck on your Electrician/Education certification!

Ty

Can you share a good article regarding the topic of how the wealth gap was huge in the gilded age - the new deal was made as a concession to preserve the system - the system has clawed back those policies over time so we have a huge wealth gap again. I've heard you talk about this before at least a few times and I'd love a good summary to send people.

Andrew Blake

I skipped their convo for that very reason, just listened to Breht's response

Brad Northcote

Nice breakdown of (a large part of) that interview---don't blame you at all for finding it hard to restrain commentary! It's the perpetual challenge of this bullshit---you could spend two hours deconstructing two minutes of inane conspiracymongering.

curegore

I do kind of respect Joe's seeming openness and conversational approach, where he lets people say their piece, but alas he is a dumbass who can't push back against obvious bullshit.

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely. Within the first ten minutes I had a whole notebook page filled out with follow ups I wanted to make and knew I wasnt making it anywhere near the full interview lol

Rev Left Radio

hm im sure there are some out there! My analysis comes from a general knowledge of the history and not specifically from any particular resource. There has to be modern marxist or progressive thinkers/historians writing about it somewhere. Ill keep a look out for something!!

Gabriel Alvarado

Shots fired at Hasan Piker with the twitch streamer comment 😉😂

Rev Left Radio

Wow. super interesting and sadly unsurprising. I pulled that example out of my ass but love the woodwork-informed feedback. I think its cool and impressive that you are into it, despite the problems with the larger community.

Rev Left Radio

Without a doubt. When Rogan complimented Sanders on that he looked down and got all uncomfortable cuz Biden is his friend. But yea, Sanders - like Chomsky - has retained his cognitive sharpeness and its not only impressive - its something I really want to try and replicate as I age.

Rev Left Radio

yes, I am more hopeful for sure. I share your cautious optimism. We shall see....

Lefty In Training

Fingers crossed Zohran isn't just another sheep dog. Even though it has nothing to do with his job, I at least thought his rhetoric on Israel was as close to supporting a one state solution as any mainstream politician is going to have. I heard him respond one time that I Israel can exist as a state with equal rights for all people, basically denying its existence as an ethnostate without explicitly saying it. We'll see how that evolves if he actually wins. Am also looking forward to hiw hard the DNC will support Cuomo against him in the general. I'll never understand how the Democratic party is simultaneously anti-democratic to the extreme but also have 0 party discipline.

DD

1:09:00 the apparent "contradiction" between Liberalism and Zionism isn't a new one. Domenico Losurdo talks about it in "Liberalism, a counter-history": Liberalism constantly makes "exclusion clauses" for its declarations about "universal" rights and freedoms to prevent them from applying to entire groups of people. It's how the US founding fathers could keep a straight face writing the declaration with one hand while whipping slaves with the other, or how business tycoons could sincerely talk about "freedom of contract" while shooting striking workers.

Christian

Hell yeah Breht, glad to hear you’re considering the IBEW apprenticeship. I’m an apprentice out of local 68, Denver - if you ever need some advice or have questions on the apprenticeship program, please feel free to reach out and message me brother!

Jeremiah

How long did you have to wait to get the apprenticeship? I have a comrade in Seattle who's been waiting for months but idk if he's going through IBEW

curegore

Then again, maybe it's less being open-minded and patient, more "I have a goldfish brain and I barely internalize anything I hear except the most stupid reactionary stuff"

HotGirlsHateCapitalism

It can take months. Seems the past 3-5 months have had a surge of applicants here in Seattle.

EndlessToil

I'd love a patreon zoom call! I'd value to hear this communities perspective!

Brad James

I applied through the PSEJATC in Renton. I was ranked 124 on the list after all the testing and interviewing on August 8th, 2024. Since then, I've only moved higher. I was at 196 for a bit, and now I'm at 160

Brad James

I'm excited when you drop little updates about your experience applying for the electrician apprenticeship at the IBEW. I've been on the ranked list out here near Seattle since August of last year; hoping that I can make it up to the top at some point! I love working with my hands and it seems like a very good stable, dignified career, and then being able to work through the union lets you engage in political struggle as well. The perfect job!

jackson johnson

Breht, Wish I could have made the zoom call. You talking about Zohran and compromise with political realities kind of crystallized these thoughts I’ve had about how a lot of the orgs here in the Imperial Core are so worried about ideological purity they never actually engage in issues that materially benefit the working class. There are a few, of course, that do—tenant unions are doing fantastic work across the country, as you’ve said before—but by and large, the stereotype of book clubs and protest groups is the norm. So many caveats here: education is important, protests are important—but where are the groups building dual power? Where are the homeless shelters, food banks, home builders, disaster support, community centers, dentists, nurses, etc.? Especially under a strong, ideological Marxist org? Why, when Hurricane Helene destroyed whole towns here in NC, didn’t we have dump trucks painted red, first aid, and food relief out there? Two main reasons as I see it: 1. We commies are broke. 2. Most of the members of organizations I have had experience with have never held a hammer. Again, exceptions—but by and large, in my experience. Solution? I think we need some American Dengism. "Seek truth from facts." We need capital. We need capital to spread the word, and we need capital to do material things. Under strong Marxist leadership, ethical constraints can be adhered to—but we need businesses, trained professionals, programs. It’s happened before and been smacked down, à la Black Panthers—but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try. It has to start somewhere. And it has to become more common to be more aggressive in raising funds. I don’t care if local groups have to start selling Lenin-themed jams—but it has to become more widespread, or Marxists are just going to be shouted down in this crumbling system by rightists who have no compunctions about using their daddy’s contracting business to finance violence against us. Lastly, it builds goodwill and gets groups into their communities in a way that doesn’t seem antagonistic to their goals. I see BP Free Breakfast Programs and want to imitate that. It’s a lot easier to get people to hear you out when they’re eating a free sandwich. Anyway, just some thoughts I’ve had. I’m sure some people more experienced or knowledgeable than I am could have said it better or pointed out issues. Sorry for the treatise. If you’ve read all this, thank you. —J

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Hey Bret, I sent you a personal message on here. If you have time, would take a look at it and get back to me? Wanted to send you a comment on here because I don't know how often you check personal messages.

Ben

my man made the working class zoom call at noon on a weekday 😭😭😭 jokes aside: another poignant, insightful episode. people like rogan are bottom of the barrel- they obviously understand the logic of socialism and the lack thereof in capitalism but have no ideological commitment to it because it wouldn’t benefit them

BammEs

"15 minutes cities where you can't travel" 😭😭😭 A lot of bullshit but that one really is the funniest to me

SprocketMusic

As a New Yorker, I know people who ONLY turned out to vote for Zohran precisely BECAUSE the Democratic Party made it their mission to stop him. The Dems turned his campaign into a national issue. They used the corporate media to get him publicity that would have cost billions if paid for in traditional advertisements. Their message? That Zohran somehow posed an existential threat to anything and everything that the Democratic Party currently stands for. And the Democrats' own constituents said, "Fuck, yeah. I'm not passing this opportunity up."

atesah

love the passion, clarity and righteousness you bring to the Patreon eps that we don’t get as much of in the interviews. Love the interviews so much and I’m just so glad we get to have both types of episodes. Interviews are so inspiring and educational and this type of fiery commentary and agitation anchor me back to why I’m a resolute and committed communist. When my nerves are shot and heart is heavy from the struggles of community organising, it’s healing to be anchored back to the reason we are all doing this ♥️

Bill

Working in healthcare, the proposed cuts to Medicaid frighten me. Not just for myself and the inundation of even more stress I’ll have to bear in an already strained, dysfunctional system, but most of all for all the poor people out there hanging on by a thread- that’s about to get cut. It’s heartbreaking. There’s already so much sickness, so much suffering in American society.

Dave Miles

Hmmm… as soon as Sanders says “the system is broken!”, in my head I said, “Noooooo,…. the system is working EXACTLY as it was designed to.”

Rev Left Radio

Yes, and today the Senate just passed it. Grotesque, evil shit. If we had an opposition party, we could fight it, but of course we dont, we have Diet GOP: The Democratic Party

Rev Left Radio

Thank you so much for those kind words and for your support, my friend. It means a lot to us. <3

Rev Left Radio

lol yea, its really something to see! People fucking HATE the dems, and all they can do now is call you an anti-semite if you dont support their corrupt corporate ghoul candidates...

Rev Left Radio

lol yes, I know! I did that on purpose for the FIRST run only, just to gauge the amount of people who could make it on a bad time/date -- we only have 100 spots on teh zoom, so if that mark was reached on a thursday at noon we'd have to stragetize a solution, but about 50 or so people showed up, so the next one will be on a weekend! And yes, exactly right on Rogan. and more than that, even tho they can see the working class issues, it remains abstract for them, they dont feel it in their daily lives, so when push comes to shove, its not a material concern for them, its an abstraction.

Rev Left Radio

I think we have resolved this issue, correct? You have my email or phone now?

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely. Im waiting myself. I got good scores on the aptitude test and oral interview, so im hoping I get a call eventually. Hard to live in a constant state of wondering if and when Ill get that call out of nowhere, but im remaining patient and hopeful.

Ben

commented prematurely lol. makes sense, hope it went well!

Dylan

Hey Breht, I’m curious if you’ve ever listened to the band Deerhoof. They recently just took their music off Spotify in protest over the CEO’s involvement with AI-military technology. In addition to just being a great, hyper-creative band they’ve also been posting some really articulate critiques and commentary about US imperialism on Instagram, especially post-October 7. I’d bet their drummer Greg Saunier would be a great guest on Rev Left. I’ve always wanted to hear him speak in an overtly-political discussion about music’s role in revolutionary struggle. And I’d kinda like to hear more about the Spotify stuff. Anyway, it’s on my RevLeft wishlist if you ever get the time. Love the show!

Shane

Oh man, I used to really dig those guys back in the day but just fell out of listening to them. This makes me want to get back into their stuff. Friend Opportunity is such a badass album.

Sasha R. Jones

Hey Breht, would I be able to contact you over email? I am looking to start a series of in person educational sessions for my local community and would love a few pointers from your experiences with the socialist night school. I can't find your email address online, I assume for good reasons, but have learned a TON from your work over the years and would love to touch base!

Derek B Local Man

Is Breht alright? Been MIA for about three weeks now which is a bit unusual. Can't remember if he made any announcements.

HailZeus

Most of the dual power is held in religious institutions and in my personal experience MLs hate confronting that reality.