Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode of Red Menace, Breht and Alyson dive into Mao Zedong’s pivotal 1957 speech On the Correct Handling of Contradictions Among the People. This foundational text offers insight into Mao’s dialectical approach to politics, particularly in navigating the complex terrain of class struggle within socialist society.

Together they explore Mao’s crucial distinction between antagonistic and non-antagonistic contradictions, and how this distinction can guide revolutionary praxis. The discussion includes an analysis of the “unity–struggle–unity” dialectic, the historical context and lessons of the Hundred Flowers and Hundred Schools campaigns, and the subsequent Anti-Rightist backlash. They also examine Mao’s critique of Han chauvinism and draw parallels to white chauvinism in the contemporary U.S., as well as Mao's position on Tibet and the historical legacy of how that conflict played out, and how it is still weaponized today.

----------------------

Follow, Subscribe, & Learn more about Red Menace & Rev Left Radio: revleftradio.com

Files

Comments

Dog In Hot Car

The section on unity-struggle-unity and it's applications was so interesting. It is the way a working relationship has to work if the relationship is going to work.

Clinton Fraser

Interesting stuff, so much for the beatles singing :if you're carrying pictures of chairman Mao you ain't gonna make it with anyone anyhow " it's a blind spot of British trotskyism that orients itself towards the industrialised west and dismisses Mao and other anti imperialist struggles for socialism as somehow less important presuming only advanced workers in the west have the real potential for revolution perhaps a hangover of the pre 1917 rupture from orthodox Marxism, great podcast many thanks 😊

Rosanna Fields

In terms of antagonistic contradictions in what we call the "left" in the west, specifically the US, what are yalls thoughts on a really big problem of covering up serial abuse and misogyny that socialist parties here in the core have? Is that antagonistic in yalls eyes? Is thd kind of glossing over of the settler colonial nature we find in socialist parties antagonistic to yall? How do we resolve these contradictions in a non-antagonostic way when there are so many antagonisms with the parties structure and opportunist leadership?

Rev Left Radio

Glossing over settler colonialism is def an antagonistic contradiction which we do discuss in this episode I believe - at some depth! The whole analogy I made between Han Chauvinism = white chauvinism is exactly on that point! Serial abuse and misogyny is always a problem, and is present throughout society, and all institutions from large to small. I dont think its a particular or unique problem on the left - its a society-wide issue. It is of course always extremely antagonistic and must be dealt with incredibly severely when and where it arises. There are many, many great organizations - and ive been a part of many of them over the years - that do not have this problem or deal with it correctly if it ever arises. To your last point: you deal with antagonistic contradictions antagonistically, and non-antagonistic contradictions non-antagonistically. These are the dividing line between enemies and friends, within and without our organizations. Being clear on what kind of contradiction is present, and dealing with it appropriately, is the task of every organizer/organization.

Rev Left Radio

haha yea, thats a funny line from the Beatles and definitely an outgrowth of British Trotskyist arrogance and western chauvinism.

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely. Dialectics is present in all phenomena and relationships!

Rosanna Fields

Yes, i was really glad to hear that you touched on that point directly! I'm gonna get more specific with my thoughts. In terms of this white-settler cheuvinism, present in most (not all) of the "socialist parties", like psl, cpusa, etc. are tainted with this settler cheuvinism, of trying to preserve the settler state of the united states, and I find this to be extremely dogmatic in how they try to apply the "prison of nations" analysis that Lenin gave for russia, for the settler colony of the US. Now, this is extremely antagonistic in my view, to indegnous liberation, and liberation in general. Now that we've laid out the contradiction, a very antagonistic one, what are your thoughts on how we antagonistically fight this? My personal analysis, pairing this with the cases of sexual abuse, and covering it up as psl did, along with doxxing a survivor, i think that they have to be abandoned and isolated, and new organizations/parties havs to be supported, such as the red nation, and new organizations/parties formed. As they have obviously proven we can not change these parties, as has been tried, due to top-down abuses in the name of democratic centralist principles. But again, I would like your analysis of how we, as you said, antagonistically fight these very sharp antagonistic contradictions present within the US left.

Bill

Thank you both for providing us with your knowledge, experience, and insight, particularly in terms of understanding current relevance of past struggles. I think it’s super important to contemplate these struggles not only in terms of gaining knowledge but also for organizing wisely. There’s so much to consider as you pointed out. Disseminating this information cogently will be key- and both of you do that so well. Thank you for your leadership. We will need it more than ever in the times to come.

Rev Left Radio

thank yo Bill, I really appreciate that and your longstanding consistent support of our work.

Lefty In Training

Between your recent return to texts, SocialismForAll, ProlesPod, and I'm sure others I don't know about, it's a good time for those wanting socialist textual analysis. The oscillation between promoting a freer exploration of political ideas and a stricter discipline of ideas is interesting. Like you said, it may not be the case that one is inherently better or worse, but rather that the changing nature of the dialectic and material conditions can make one better or worse to promote at a certain place and time. As a possible example, I like a lot of the ideas and intentions behind the Cultural Revolution, but perhaps the people needed a bit more political education before being invited to let loose. On the other hand, maybe they needed to be let loose when they were to make the mistakes and successes they did to get where they are now.

Eli 🇵🇸

You know it’s gonna be a good episode when Comrade Mao is involved. Seriously, great analysis! Studying the thoughts of comrades past like this while both contextualizing them AND wisely applying them to the changing conditions of our time and place is not only of peak importance - it’s also exciting as hell. Thank you so much for your continued work on Rev Left Radio! Listening to your shows - even the heavier ones (especially the heavier ones) - have played a serious role in my development as an organizer, comrade, and human being, and they got me through a lot of long, shitty nights closing at Starbucks as a union salt. Love and solidarity! ❤️‍🔥