Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I am going to experiment with a new series on the main feed tentatively called Office Hours(?).

The idea is to take 2-3 questions from Patrons, give them several days of real concentrated thought, bolstered by a little research when needed, and put out a 20-40 minute public episode addressing said questions in detail. I think it could be a cool new offering from Rev Left, give me a chance to go deep on a few questions at a time, and offer something unique to our listeners.

With that in mind: Please ask questions below! Keep them as clear and concise as possible, with a broad audience in mind. Philosophical questions, questions of political strategy, questions relevant to our movements and era, etc. are all ideal! Thank you!! <3

Comments

Alexander

Why come pizza so good?

Rjl17afc

Am I not a true Marxist if I work in the corporate world, and want to advance my own personal career?

Snair

As a Marxist and in the light of Zohran win, is there room for social democracy to be the path toward raising class consciousness and organizing in America in the modern “conditions”

Mickey Marx

What’s a general breakdown of Neoliberalism in the economic context? And how does it apply to now? It’s such a complex concept to breakdown alone and understand, thank you!

Rev Left Radio

THIS is the sort of stuff im looking for. Thank you!!

Rev Left Radio

This is good, opens up a lot of ideas and avenues for advice, as many struggle with this stuff.

Noah

Are we transitioning from capitalism into a new mode of production, like neo-feudalism?

Quinn Keitel

what is the principled way to interact with retirement 401ks as Marxists who are privileged with the ability to save money but are under this capitalist speculative system?

Rev Left Radio

This one is essential, and thinking Alyson and I might tackle it on an upcoming red menace ep tbh!

Perro Wero

In your opinion, is the fall of the US Empire already well underway? With the apolitical multinational corporations that actually control our government slowly bailing out, and shifting their base of operations for their global project to the gulf region? And if so, what might we continue to see in the united states over the next decade or two, in terms of material conditions for the prolateriat, while this transition continues and/or eventually concludes?

Dylan F

How can revolutionary/radical thought be used by educators in public school systems? How can Walter Rodney’s groundings and thought in child education be used in contemporary schools?

AD

I teach first year writing at a community college and I’m always looking for recommendations for readings (short essays and/or books we could read over the course of a semester) that model historical materialism and dialectical thinking without necessarily being explicitly Marxist (I try to stay low key so as not to immediately trigger chuds/alienate normies). Texts that feel “contemporary” and that can compete with the short attention spans of 17-25 year olds are a plus.

Brandon

As Marxists living under capitalism, how should we approach retirement investing like Roth IRAs or 401(k)s? Even when we avoid funding war, fossil fuels, and prisons by choosing ESG options, our money still moves through systems of exploitation. At the same time, many of us have no confidence the capitalist state will care for us as we age, and we have no family wealth or safety net to rely on. If we’re investing modestly for retirement while also giving to mutual aid, local organizing, and global solidarity efforts, is that ethically defensible? Or should Marxists reject retirement investing entirely, even if we don’t yet see viable alternatives for elder care in our communities?

Brad James

What do you think explains the lack of a genuinely successful revolutionary movement taking hold in Amerikkka? Is the American Proletariat bought off by the spoils of imperialism? Are the contradictions simply not there yet? Is the power of COINTELPRO too strong? Perhaps because American had 'democracy' before industrializing a true worker's party wasn't able to take hold the same way as it has in other countries?

Benny Boy

What pragmatic steps can a movement wishing to create and maintain a more just socio-economic political order use to guard against those few individuals who will attempt to hijack such a movement for their own narcissist individualistic ambitions and desire to have power over others?

JS

even though it’s unlikely, if there were a successful socialist revolution in the US what do you think it would look like afterwards?

Pj

Do you think communists should be putting any/much effort into seriously having people elected to federal offices such as president, Congress, etc?

xander

i really appreciate praxis focus when we can. i think if you did some history and critique of contemporary political parties and their failures/successes, it could be interesting to see where IWW and DSA etc make progress and also fall short. i think often when I expose friends to shows like rev left or books that are theory focused, I often lack suggestions for how we put things into practice in real meaningful everyday approaches... like suggesting we support unions is great, but not all jobs can easily unionize, people still need to work often, etc - and not to say workplace organizing isn't real, it's just like the first thing anyone says re: Marxism or socialism in practice. anyway a little bit of a rant here but maybe you catch what I'm getting at - critique of some modern approaches, focusing on what they're doing right and where they could do better, and a focus on everyday pragmatic praxis? just an idea of course :) btw LOVED the dialectics of nature episode and also appreciated the recent mao essay one. great work breht, love what you (and Alyson) do!!! ❤️

Zachary Saile

What is the best revolutionary organization, in your opinion, that Marxists can join to advance the revolutionary cause? Considerations for me personally are that they make real progress towards goals, they have some momentum, and they show up in the community in a way that aligns with Marxist values. But I’m interested in y’all’s ideas more than my own.

Sionnach

What are the common threads that link different revolutionary movements and how can these be fostered and harnessed to create a broader struggle and support on a wider scale. I am thinking here of the solidarity between Ireland and Palestine as an example

JK

As a member of the Revolutionary Communist International, I'm so pumped to be part of a serious Bolshevik org and truly think we are building in a very exceptional way. It would be interesting to hear you take a look at our perspectives and get your opinion on our tactics/objectives. You can find two solid links here to get an idea of the work we are doing in the RCI/RCA https://marxist.com/revolutionary-communists-of-america-congress-building-a-bolshevik-training-ground.htm and https://communistusa.org/where-is-america-going/

Eli 🇵🇸

What ways have you found effective in motivating your liberal or “apolitical” friends into action beyond voting for dems and hoping for the best? What strategies can we use to educate, agitate, and organize the not-yet-communist people in our personal spheres without being perceived as preachy or doom and gloom? Thanks for all you’re doing, comrade! This is a great idea.

Eli 🇵🇸

-asked every American leftist. I agonize over this shit daily.

Autumn Williams

How does one navigate being a communist while working in the non-profit sector? For context, my dream was to have a career in counseling, mental health, domestic violence, etc. Got my degree and dedicated 5 years of my life to this work, only to see that this is all bullshit. Very difficult to actually help people when the people on top in non-profits have no idea what they're doing.

Don

Building off of @Noah's contribution: Every day, more and more of us are being thrown out of the economy by advances in robotics, AI, etc. This is absolutely wrecking capitalism. If we are being replaced by machines, how can we sell our labor to get what we need to survive? The ruling class knows they don’t need us any more, hence their ever-accelerating drive towards fascism. They need some way to protect their precious private property. Our solution must be to overthrow this system and replace it with a cooperative, communist society.

astrofool

I would love to know a bit more about your approach to self-education -- for example, how you approach reading theory, how you choose what to deeply dive into, how do you research for an episode (particularly on a topic with which you might be less familiar), etc. What recommendations do you have for folks in their own (political) education? More specifically, what do you think an "intermediate-level" political education looks like? And, what does self-education for a leftist look like *beyond* politics (referring to your episodes on topics like spirituality) as well? I ask this as an "adolescent" leftist -- in the sense that I've been in leftist circles for several years now (since the late-2010s), but I still feel pretty lost at times. I mean, I'm past the introductory "ABCs of Socialism" type of reading, but I don't know where to go next. My background is in the sciences, so I've been absolutely overwhelmed when I've tried to engage with theory and "just start reading." I get the feeling this applies to a lot of my peers as well -- people who moved very left over the past decade or so who fully buy into socialism but don't quite have the vocabulary to articulate their thoughts to others beyond the basic DSA Socialism 101 type of thinking. In other words, folks who want to get to an "intermediate" level of theoretical understanding but don't quite know the route. And with the Internet being what it is these days, I'm further overwhelmed by everyone's "takes" on theory. It seems so easy to get lost in the prevailing sentiment and never really get around to engaging with original writings. Rev Left and Red Menace have helped tremendously in my political education (I think precisely because of the balance between episodes focused on praxis and episodes that engage directly with original writings), but I still feel so, so lost sometimes. So, any advice you might have to this end would be great to hear. Thank you (and Alyson) for all your hard work!

J T

If humanity distances itself from capitalism, to address needs of climate and to address more sustainable use of resources in a fairly limited and restricted solar system, do we shift to socialism and then communism without the concern of devolving into dictatorships? Were a lot of the authoritarian regimes of recent memory a result of competition with capitalism, or were they just easily corrupted? Obviously capitalism is inherently vile and unsustainable, but outside of some socialist democracies emerging against capitalist entities, like for example Chile 1970-1973, what foothold do we all have to stand on that communism will succeed?

Danny Haiphong

Relationship between geopolitics and struggle between capitalism vs socialism. Also happy to collab with you if you’d like on this at some point been thinking about it a lot

Andrew Blake

I asked this for your AMA last year but you never got to it: what do you consider the best positioned North American organization to serve as a vanguard party? And what do you think would have to happen both externally and internally to bring that to fruition? Tangentially (or alternatively) , in a reality with no vanguard party even visible on the horizon, when, if ever, is adventurism justified? Yes Che was an adventurist to a fault, but then again so was John Brown and he is widely credited with jumpstarting the Civil War which materially improved the lives of hundreds of thousands of slaves. In our modern setting you have the adventurism of Luigi Mangione.

Clinton Fraser

Just wondering what your thoughts on captain Traore are? I find his speeches awesome and inspirational, but most importantly he is actually developing the country with popular support around the ideas of Thomas Sankara,anyhow thought it worth mentioning

Patrick malloy

A couple of thoughts (and the theme is well represented in the thread): 1. An analysis of 2-3 past revolutions/socialist movements and what needed to happen/didnt happen/was blocked from happening that would have made them fully functioning socialist/communist societies. 2. What are all the practical pieces that need to happen and need to be in place for a new society to take over. If x happens, y needs to be in place or the whole thing comes to a screeching halt.

Patrick malloy

Separately, I would also love a recommended reading list that could be small or large, could be biographies, histories, analyses, fiction, non-fiction, whatever. There is so much out there that Im often not sure where to start, especially since so many books are written with a western bias/sympathy that Id rather avoid or know about if possible. Thanks!

Mima

I’m enrolled in the ‘Summer School for Socialism’ by the People’s forum. Their first module was on ‘reform and revolution’. I’m generally very skeptical about [generally inherently liberal] reforms. The module had me considering how to analyse reforms to distinguish between reform that is liberal in nature (without a revolutionary path as the bigger picture) and reform that is compatible with the revolutionary path. Are reform and revolution inherently antithetical? Is ‘reform and revolution’ a necessary novel approach borne out of our current socio-techno-economic ‘end-stage’ context, or is it one that has been called for in previous revolutionary contexts too? Eg. The Cuban revolution was radical in that it didn’t involve really any reform but was entirely revolutionary in the sense that it completely removed the national system and replaced it with a different one. Obviously historical context is everything and we can’t just cut and paste revolutions, but we can learn from them. What may be different about our current context that we have to consider when concluding that reforms should be a higher or more necessary priority than in previous revolutionary moments? How do we find the balance? Will a focus on reform hold back/prevent progress? Related, how do we distinguish between controlled opposition and socialists who are interested in progressing down the revolutionary path with regard to figures such as Mamdani?

Adriaanus Stephanus

I’d like to hear about a Marxist analysis of social media? I imagine this would touch on “technofeudalism”. As a young person in 2025 I feel like society has quickly become all about, clicks, likes and influencers. Especially since the pandemic, the world feels like it has become so superficial, aggressive, materialistic and inauthentic (although this has always been the case, to some extent).

Chad Mayo

Union organizing✊🏽from a grass roots level. Take over your union. I encourage all of us to do as much as you can to build up worker power to fight the capitalist monster that is kiliing Heath care, Education and housing. Appreciate all the posts, glad to be a small part in this discussion.

DD

I have a spirituality/religion question for Breht. I've been getting more into my Buddhist spiritual practice, which has generally been good for me and injected a lot of extra meaning into my life. However, recenetly, it has been putting me into "dark night of the soul" territory, especilaly around the ideas of mortality and violence. While I find the practices of reflecing on impermanence and your own death profound and meaningful, it is reaching the point where it's becoming stressful and affecting my day-to-day life. I'm not really sure how I'd discuss this with my local Sangha, as they're a nice enough group of people, but I don't think they understand how a committment to radical politics and helping others can put you in constant danger of sudden violence and loss, even when you don't go around seeking it out or taking unnecessary risks. I also don't know how I would try to just opt out of doing these practices either, as while they're stressful, the thought of facing the current state of the world without them feels even more difficult and stressful. Any suggestions or input would be welcome, thanks <3

Luis Rosa

I was also going to ask this!

Quinn Keitel

For US workers who are privileged to save for retirement, most options are forcefully tied to the speculative stock market. What is a principled way to navigate and/or participate in this intrinsically capitalist system as committed communists?

Rev Left Radio

This is an important question, and I want to offer a bit of a response right away. First off, what you’re going through isn’t a sign that something’s gone wrong with your practice; it’s normal and a sign that you’re going deeper, this sort of stuff is inevitable. When the truths of impermanence and mortality stop being intellectual and start landing in your body and nervous system, it can shake you. Add to that a deep political commitment and awareness of real-world violence, && it makes sense that the practice is stirring up anxiety. But the purpose of these reflections is to cultivate clarity, courage, and love. Death practice, when done skillfully, helps us show up more fully, grounded in what matters most. And when things start to feel unbalanced in our practice like this, it’s often a sign that we need to reconnect with heart practices like metta, gratitude, or breath awareness -- tools that can help stabilize the mind and soften the intensity. Honor what is arising - even the anxiety and fear and discomfort - and be present with those uncomfortable feelings without running away, fueling them with obsessive rumination, or treating them like a problem that needs to be solved. They are merely arising... in order to grow and deepen in practice you HAVE to face all of your fears and anxieties eventually. If it gets overwhelming, you can always back off the practice and reconnect to nature, find ways of calming and grounding your attention in other activities, spend relaxing time with loved ones, stay off social media, and find balance again before re-entereing the practice fully. Even if your sangha or teacher doesn’t share your politics exactly, they can still support you in working through the spiritual and psychological challenges that arise in practice. You don’t need a politically perfect teacher to get real help with your suffering. The path forward is about learning to hold your ideals, fears, and sense of urgency with more wisdom and self-compassion, and to practice radical acceptance of what arises - even when its uncomfortable. The world is brutal, and your response is normal - but the clarity and ability to respond skillfully comes from within the practice itself, not from dwelling on the horror or shouldering it all alone. What’s needed is to turn toward what’s arising with honesty and care, and to let the dharma support you in becoming a more grounded, loving, and effective version of yourself. Ultimately, This Too Shall Pass. Everything - even fear and anxiety and dread - are impermeant and passing. Navigating such feelings with courage and acceptance and patience is what deepens you and your practice - there is no way to become more courageous without facing fear, there is no way of becoming more wise except through challenging experiences, there is no way of finding equinimity without going through the highs and lows of life with awareness and acceptance. If the path were easy, everyone would do it. Its not - it challenges you, it forces you to face those parts of you and teh world most people deny or distract from, and it requires you to be baptized by fire. But again, navigating this period will forge a deeper, wiser, and more compassionate you. I wish you the best of luck. Hmu if you need more help or someone to talk to: andersonbrett2011@gmail.com

Rev Left Radio

There are great resources for this stuff too - look into Adyashanti, Pema Chodron, Jack Kornfield on dark nights of the soul. Listening to these great teachers talk you through them - or just let you know your not alone and they all went through it too - can be reassuring.

JK

RCA is putting together a Vanguard party, part of the Revolutionary Communist International

Comrade Strauss

As someone from a very rural area in PA I find it difficult to find organizations to support locally. For example, using DSA as an example and because they are most prevelant in PA compared to PSL or other orgs, the two closest chapters are a 2 hour drive away and i find it unrealistic to make that commute. My question is, do i join an organization even if i cant reliably attend? If i dont, what would my alternatives be when it comes to organizing?

Jack Setters

Love this idea! Hi Breht! You often speak about your own Buddhist practice and how it has shaped/enhanced your Marxist thinking. You've also spoken about (I believe, correct me if I'm wrong) how the sublimation of the ego would be more or less necessary for moving towards true communism. I've observed how religion is a powerful tool for community building, and can be used to further class struggle. How do you think that Buddhist principles could be applied to movement building? In the present, but also in a party formation or a state building project of the future. Particularly, I've been wondering how this could prevent the revisionism/degeneration that has occurred in some state building projects historically. Take this question in whatever direction most sparks your interest, just curious to see what you think! Thanks :) PS: If you're in need of / interested in expanding your social media or YouTube presence I would love to help out with that, and I would be happy to work for free. Taking Upstream's Instagram page as an example, I think having clips from the show on socials would be really cool / relatively easy! Just something I thought of the other day. DM me here or on instagram @jack.setters if you want. Thank you for your hard work!

Bill

This is a hypothetical political strategic question which could be quite fun to answer. It’s 2035, America has been in a deep economic depression for several years. DSA and PSL merged into a 3rd party 5 years prior and in a landslide victory won the house, the senate, and the presidency. What policies do they enact in their first 100 days of power?

DD

Thanks man, genuinely really appreciate it <3

Jonathan Wood

I'm not really framing it as a question, but I would really love for you or you and Allyson to take a deep dive into the Degrowth vs Ecomodernism debate. I find myself sympathetic to arguments from both camps, although I probably lean more towards the ideas of degrowth as espoused by someone like Jason Hickel. It seems like both camps tend to do some combination of steel/straw-manning when critiquing their opponents' arguments...

Magnus Rui-Hu Lundgren

Overreach/depletion of military resources bringing death to the american empire. Sustaining Israel, Ukraine, Taiwan etc. while China, Alliance of Sahel States, Palestinian resistance, Yemen, Iran, Russia, parts of Latin America etc for all its flaws and contradictions step by step exhausts the empire till its collapse. Are we living through this atm? Or some other commentary on contemporary world politics connected to a broader systemic analysis. I know you do this once in a while, but those are among my favorites of yours (plus your spiritual content). And shit, new world events happens like every other day now.

Magnus Rui-Hu Lundgren

The mystic experience is not something we can grasp with words. What is the mystic experience according to Revleft? And how can regular working class people with families, obligations, material restraints etc make space for more mystic experiences in our lives?

DD

Also I don't know if you'll get time to view this response before you put out the video, but I think that trying to accept this period and sit with it has helped me to realise a couple of things. I know you said not to treat this like a problem to be solved, but this felt less like ways to try and "solve" my situation and more like things I could learn from it and take with me to the other side. 1. Living a richer and more fulfilling life, combined with the truth of impermanence necessarily means that the more I experience the joyful and meaningful things in my life, the more I am going to be aware that they're temporary and fleeting. 2. Just like how really loving a person means commiting yourself to them and staying with them even through their hardest moments, I guess I will have the comfort of knowing the things I'm able to do at this time are the things that are most important and meaningful to me, and that if I can manage to do them now, I can do them in the future no matter what. Hopefully once I get through this and get a bit more back to normal, I can put this new knowledge to good use.

Gideon Butler

I'd love to hear from various organizers about what first steps of "getting organized" looks like. As someone with social anxiety and ADHD, who doesn't know any socialists in real life, it can often be overwhelming to imagine what that means without any real specifics other than "talk to people." I'd love to have some idea of what I'm in for if I join the DSA or PSL, etc. Also, what other groups should I look for? Paired with this, I'd love to have an episode on operational security and maintaining digital privacy in the modern world. How do you safely organize without fear of the state or corporations listening in?

The Communist Larry David

I just met a woman from Belarus who thinks that Lukashenko is an oppressive dictator. I think that Belarus is an important member of the axis of resistance to prevent encirclement of Russia. Is Lukashenko an oppressive dictator or are the protests in Belarus just another color revolution of the CIA?

Hamish Bradley

How does the dialectical interpretation of reality allow for the non-dual universe to exist and continually change without anything outside of itself? Also, in buddhist and other spiritual paths there are teachings that say to completely let go of all desire and attachment. Do you think this includes letting go of our desire to help others? Our desire to alleviate the great suffering that we witness. Should we give up activism and organizing in order to truly let go of the ego? I have felt a draw to leave it all behind and go sit in the wilderness doing absolutely nothing until I return to dirt and escape the ego. Sometimes this feels correct, but other times this feels selfish. Would this be abandoning all others to find peace only for myself?

PeteR

Hey Breht. I wonder if you could comment on the issue of productivity, motivation and innovation in a future socialist society. How do we ensure everyone is contributing to the best of their ability and how do we ensure technological progress without financial reward as a motivational factor (important for our continued emancipation if not for outright defence against attacks from capitalist states)? Reference to problems in actually existing socialist societies would be useful as I think we need to tackle this issue head on rather than assume it will resolve itself naturally.

Adriaanus Stephanus

I thought of another one I had to put out into the universe: I would LOVE to hear a discussion about the commodification and exploitation of queer people and queer culture. There is not enough talk about all the ways queer people are used for profit, but corporations and governments make no effort to improve our lives in meaningful ways #rainbowcapitalism

oranjest1

i have a revolutionary psychology type question if youre interested in that but it relies on context from a post i read so if you might DM me i may be able to send the screenshots around it

Cat Ledue

I’ll post more context below, but here is my question: Beyond offering a vision of a world that is not so disabling, what concrete resources can the Left tangibly offer neurodivergent and disabled folks in the present? How can we be better at supporting members of our community (myself included) who want to help build a socialist future but have limited capacity to participate?

Cat Ledue

Context: I work with disabled/neurodivergent adults, particularly ADHD and autistic individuals, and I am constantly thinking about how this demographic is both at odds with and utterly imprisoned by capitalism. Not to over-generalize or over-romanticize… but ADHDers and autistics tend to have traits that put them in conflict with capitalism’s demands (unique relationships to time and a propensity for lateness; circadian rhythms that rarely pair well with a 9-5 schedule; behaviours sometimes labeled “demand avoidance” and a proclivity for questioning authority and social norms; highly sensitive nervous systems and a deep sense of empathy; being more socially motivated versus motivated by longterm personal goals; often drawn to pursue interests/creativity/curiosity versus productivity). Simultaneously, this demographic, often labeled “high-functioning” (a controversial term to say the least), are expected to comply with the demands of a capitalist, which leaves many neurodivergent people trapped in cycles of burnout, unemployment, and even incarceration. Considering 1/7 of U.S. adults are neurodivergent in some capacity—and as disability activists are constantly pointing out — disability justice is deeply pertinent to any revolutionary movement. I often think about how neurodiversity is already embodied within the Left (how many of us have intense special interests and a strong sense of justice???). Yet, I also think about the countless people who are stuck trying to survive capitalism’s rat race and have no more energy (I.e. executive functioning capacity) leftover for movement building - people who have a lot to offer the movement yet arguably need community support the most. Beyond offering a vision of a world that is not so disabling, what concrete resources can the Left tangibly offer neurodivergent and disabled folks in the present? How can we be better at supporting members of our community (myself included) who want to engage badly but have limited capacity to participate?

M

There is no ethical work under capitalism, but what jobs are "too" unethical? Almost everyone has agreed pigs. What about custodians for police precincts? What about soldiers? Factory workers for weapons manufacturers? Hedge fund managers? AI architects? Their personal assistants? Property managers? DEI sell outs? Why/why not? What are workers' personal obligations when it comes to choosing a job? How should we balance making enough money in this shit economy and not becoming the architects of our own oppression when so many well paying jobs are extremely unethical?