Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht updates listeners on the fundraiser for the family we are supporting in Gaza, updates listeners on his new job and talks about the challenges and rewards of joining a trade union, explores the economic developments in and around AI (the hype, the bubble, and the infrastructure build-out), and then discusses the US sending troops to Venezuela and the response from Latin America and China.

Here is the new link to the Gaza family fundraiser: https://www.spotfund.com/story/c600f234-0528-4498-809b-88b76a159c9d

Outro music 'Xtruhhturrestreeall' by Spinitch

find and support more of their work here:

https://spinitch.bandcamp.com/album/com-postables-4-dessert

Files

Comments

Luis Rosa

The bank where i work at organized some workshops on metalworking and soldering, you know just for fun/team building. Soldering two pieces of metal together felt much more rewarding than the actual job.

Lana

I gotta say, your solo eps are some of my favs so I’m 1000% here for more of them! Any time political shit pops off, my first thought is I hope Breht does an episode on this! 😂

James Litman

Glad to hear you found a trade. I'm a union mechanical insulator, chasing overtime most weeks. I hope you're as effective at swaying our union brothers and sisters from Trump propaganda as I think you will be.

Daughters of Delos

I am so excited for you, Breht!!! Been in construction for 27 years drilling water wells. Welcome to the party pal!!!

Max

Yes, AI is a mirror. But so is intelligence as a reflection. Ultimately, man is but a mirror in which Nature reflects itself. Large Language Models lack, among other things, intentionality and true subjectivity (the active side of intelligence), but they largely already possess its passive reflective side. I don’t agree with trying to diminish AI by pointing out it is “just” a predictive text generator. To convincingly predict text, you necessarily need to reflect human knowledge in a sensible order. By connecting terms and recognizing patterns you create a web of meaning that is in itself very useful to explore. Also, “predictive text generator” is a crude oversimplification that leaves out many aspects of state-of-the-art models which come close to reconstructing the finer parts of human intuition (representation learning, attention mechanisms etc.). We have had predictive text generators for decades, but nothing came close to what we have now. The parasocial pathologies are more a testament to the state of our society than the state of AI. As of now, AI models are still relatively unrestricted (i.e not yet lobotomized to only serve capital accumulation – like large parts of our education system), and will happily help you to reflect fringe standpoints as well (to a certain degree). On the other side, being a mirror also means these models are tied to their input. Firstly, the input they were trained on equips them with a mainstream Western academic bias towards most things (esp. politics). However, the data sets were broad enough, that you can get them to reflect almost any political stance if you dig enough. Secondly, any LLM tends to reflect the person that looks into it, changing personality and perspective according to what kind of knowledge they reflect (maybe somewhat similar to how our ego constantly invents a narrative). So you should not treat it is an all-knowing knowledge machine, but – as with any intelligence – as reflection from a materially concrete perspective. As a mirror all right. And a mirror can be a very useful tool. [But oh Lord please, cease the constant glazing.]

AL

When a new fundraiser goes up, please announce, my wallet is locked and loaded.

AL

Nevermind, I kept listening and found the link, thanks Breht

JJ

You’ve for sure proven yourself. Smart as hell and strong character

Max

The experience of “actually meaningful” work you describe is very interesting. I wonder if this has strategic implications for organizing. Certain communists have argued, the proximity to the definite threshold between society and nature has important ideological consequences, such as explaining stances within the “culture war”: “[They] charge us with reducing the question of class relations to the ‘culture war.’ They neglect the simple fact that, the reason the relation these segments of society bare to the culture war is such an effective proxy for their actual relations to production, is because they also serve as proxies for their relation to the production of material sociality itself, or the very genesis of the socius. The reason a construction worker, or a miner, is less likely to be a woke SJW than a barista, isn’t a fucking mystery. All it takes is common sense to understand that: The former understands the real, material conditions of social relations - the latter, taking them for granted, dwells within artificially and institutionally contrived social relations. The former understands what reality actually is, just in the form of their labor. The latter does not care what reality actually is, but aspires to determine what reality should be according to discourse, institutional change, etc. - the real worker knows with first-hand experience that actual, material reality is unaltered by this nonsense. It does not have anything to do with their proximity to ‘whiteness,’ ‘males,’ ‘heteronormativity,’ or ‘culture.’ It has everything to do with their proximity to the real conditions of actual material production, not only of material things, but also of social relations themselves. This is material not simply because of some eternal quality of nature – […]. It is material because these conditions of production are disposed of the least amount of liberty in terms of the determination of their form. There are a million different fucking cappuccinos you can make. But real, material production occurs at the site of necessity. […] In other words, the production of commodities, so far as they represent the valorization of capital, are commodities produced for the purposes of production itself, and therefore commodities which obey the necessities not of whim, aesthetic, taste, etc. - but ultimately of production for purposes of the accumulation of capital. This is in contrast to the ‘service’ economy, for which, production as such for purposes of capital accumulation is presupposed - what remains are decentralized interfaces for the planning of production, measured in the patterns of consumption of goods, i.e. not much Burger King vs. McDonalds by way of production, but drastic differences in profitability will be down to consumption patterns according to taste, aesthetic, form, etc. - and these patterns, in turn, will affect the determination of the material production underlying them (i.e. less horse-meat will be produced if the public chooses McDonalds, etc.).” This is obviously an exaggeration. Just throwing out the effects of heteronormativity, race etc. is unnecessarily edgy. But I find it to be an interesting perspective, nevertheless. Every class struggle is important, but should there be an emphasis on gaining traction within a core of the working class (producing the means of production)? And how do we relate to the “culture war”, if this core tends towards a certain stance within it?

ComradeCam

Im so happy for you! Been listening since 2022 and I look forward to these podcasts on my way to work and now school, my mornings and evenings home are filled with learning so much from your work and I just want to thank you for all the hard work you’ve put into this podcast as well as Guerrilla History and Red Menace! Congratulations again!!

Joshua Bauman

The inability to help everyone definitely weighs on folks. It hurts to give and know it's not enough.

chep

Breht!!! Congratulations on your new job. You are an inspiration to me as a comrade. My club out of Iowa city is trying to start a socialist night school because of the success that you have had. Perhaps there is a way we could speak with you or some of the socialist night school colleagues? I would also like to interview everyone in the group at large for a People's World article. This is important work you are doing, and it could be replicated in so many places.

chep

Did you use AI to write this?

Chase

Congrats on the new job! Bonus points bc it’s union! I do love these style episodes

Derek B Local Man

The solo episodes rock so don't feel bad about shifting to more of these bc of the new gig. Will keep supporting 👍

Daewoo

You mentioned the need for the bourgeois state to impose sanctions on Cyba and attempt to assassinate Castro and Che, because Cuba (and other socialist projects) offer real-world alternatives to capitalism-imperialism. I want to connect that to your discussion of Bernie 2020. There's a similar, yet inverted reason why Obama and the rest of the DNC and media HAD to defeat Bernie. Bernie, instead of showing what is possible under his version of democratic socialism, would've shown what is impossible under the American democratic system. Because he would've been a disaster as a president, let alone a "democratic socialist" president. His election would've proved the futility of electoralism. More and more folks would see that even if you abide by American "democracy" and get your guy into office, it still wouldn't make a difference. That was the true threat Bernie posed to the system. And the establishment Dems and media conglomerates couldn't have that.

Haazen

Im very happy and excited for you and your trade union job! Your solo episodes are incredible so dont mind getting more of these. I hope to hear an update on your books. Im sure this new schedule will impact but I'll be on the lookout! Wish you the best in your new endeavor.

LeftoverComputer

congratulations on your new job, it's really a shame you couldn't be a teacher- those students would've been so enriched and lucky to have you! personally i love solo episodes, of course the interviews are extremely interesting as well but you know, a lot of us are here for you and your insights. i love red menace and the going over texts style episodes. i know i can't speak for everyone when i say this, but i would love more and more philosophy heavy episodes, more on meditation, mysticism, etc- LOVE those. but really just wanna say im here for the ride, good luck with all of the changes!

Rev Left Radio

This is incredibly kind and means a lot, thank you for your feedback and your support, my friend. Truly.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, its had to fall to the wayside for the moment, during this hectic and intense transition, but its still coming! My preferred timeline got pushed back a couple months, but I definitely want to finish it this fall, so it can come out by spring! :)

Rev Left Radio

I think thats a very keen and dialectically rich observation. Bernie would have forced the system as a whole to come out and show its true face to stop even his tepid but widely desired social democratic policies, disillusioning millions of people in the process. With him losing, people can still have faith in teh system, the right candidate coming along, etc. Very insightful point!

Rev Left Radio

Yes! Let me figure out the best way to set up an email chain between us! Ill let ya know asap!

Rev Left Radio

This means the world to me and I appreciate it so so much. <3

Rev Left Radio

Okay, hit us up at omahanightschool@gmail.com! We can set up a zoom call or something :)

Jackson Duke

I prefer the solo episodes. Good luck with the new job.

Lhasa Apsos for Palestine

Breht, your solo episodes are my favorite and I find them so cathartic. Proud of you! Congrats on the job. And also, as someone in education, I’m so frustrated on your behalf that the teaching world didn’t absolutely fucking embrace you. I know my own students would love you. You could seriously change some people’s lives teaching humanities at a high school. I live in Cali and I feel like brand new teachers are getting jobs where I live! Do you think it was just lack of “experience” or do you think your politics may have played into it at all? (since you have a decent online presence). I myself am pretty sure I got rejected a while back from a teaching job—my application yanked—because of my open views on Palestine.

Lhasa Apsos for Palestine

Or maybe Omaha is just different conditions than Cali. Either way, just frustrated and astounded you weren’t given a chance.

H3wlett

Congratulations on the apprenticeship! I'm a hydro power operator with the IBEW and joining has been the best thing I could have done for my family and myself. You'll do great, please be safe. Don't assume anyone but yourself is looking out for your safety.

CJ

Love the solo eps, so glad you are stoked on the new job! Thanks for everything you do ❤️

Jo Vinova

Unfortunately gofundme been pulling shit like this for a hot minute. Donated and shared. Glad to hear you making moves in a union man! Education and labor in a critical industry are great places to invest one's time and energy. I'm hoping I get a call back from this EMT apprenticeship I just interviewed for. If this doesn't work out, I'll just dive into nursing as it seems it will be a great place to organize with how they predict the nursing shortage will only be getting worse in the coming years. And although you ran into some trouble within education, I gotta say I'm glad to have had Professor O'Shea be one of my educators over the years. You take us to class every episode man. Helping us understand history, theory, and current events with all your many colleagues has helped us be able to further our education and bring it to our communities. So here a teacher of the year award 🏆 You deserve it my guy 🙏🏽

Max

I did not.

Max

I think legitimate disdain of their conduct and some of their content is preventing a level-headed engagement with their theoretical contributions. I find myself more and more convinced, yet when I try to discuss this with my comrades they completely shut down any possible discussion, leaving me with no satisfying counter-argument to rescind my growing infatuation. I know this is not really the place for this, but I hoped to maybe get someone to argue with me, as I find myself increasingly lonely in this. I am sorry if this approach was dishonest.

Breakerofchains

The solo episodes are literally the best…. I live for the solo eps and the red hot takes and I’ve been thinking more news would actually be 🔥🔥🔥. Also very sorry to hear about the teaching process, as a teacher myself I can admit some of them are real assholes and I can confirm they DEFINITELY do interview people just to say they did it and humour the applicants and appeal to even hire up admins. They often have a person they want to hire in mind but they hold interviews just to make it seem more democratic. But either way if you are still interested in being teacher one day, for sure starting to substitute teach then student teach through your program (these two places are where they often get that person they want to hire in mind) then the full time teacher jobs might work out but either way good luck man I’m really happy for you!!!

Jocelyn Atkins

Congratulations, brother. I have been an IBEW inside wire(person) for 15 years in Portland Oregon. Been listening to your show since the beginning. We had a similar trajectory-I have a degree in Philosophy and now in the trades. I have many thoughts I would like to share with you…at the risk of sounding cynical, I think you will soon discover the ideal you report here is very much not reality. The International Office and the LU leadership, more often than not, works against rank and file. There is a burgeoning (somewhat underground) movement to challenge this dynamic. Rank and file building trades members are a microcosm of the larger population. Even in very liberal areas like Portland, we have large constituencies of Proud Boys and 3 percenters. There are also some details, I think, you should know about work and the likelihood that you will have to travel for work. Anyway, if you want discuss further you can send me a message on Facebook and I will give you my email address. Anyway, happy to have you amongst our ranks.

Jordan Defibaugh

Awesome news on the new job Breht! Your show has been a part of my life for years. I forget how I stumbled onto it, but damn - I'm glad I did. It can be isolating growing up as a leftist in America. Where do you look when you don't hear any voices that make sense of the cruelty and misery inflicted on all of us by those with power? Watching MSNBC or CNN can make you feel like you're losing your mind. So, thank you for the work you do. I also wanted to let you know my kids enjoy when I put on the show and have since they were pre-teens. I think today is the first time I've ever commented on a post, because I've always wanted you to feel free to take the show in whatever direction you believe is right. But these free-form solo episodes are my absolute favorites, so I'm excited for this new direction. You can especially feel your deep compassion and love for humanity - and it's infectious.

Matt

Congrats on the new gig, Breht! As a teacher myself I’m disappointed that you won’t be entering the profession, but material conditions are material conditions and this certainly seems like a worthy alternative. Personally, I enjoy episodes like this and feel that I get a lot out of them, particularly your analysis of marco, transcontinental current events. Congratulations also on your success in quitting marijuana. Very similarly to you, I am in my early-30s and since my late teens have been totally beholden on a daily basis to this addiction. Have tried to quit many times these past several years with many methods, cold turkey, tapering off, etc., to no avail—extremely discouraging. I remember you mentioning on an episode last year that you had been planning on quitting, and I had wondered ever since how that went. So happy to hear that you have found success! If you’re up to it, I think an episode detailing your experience more fully would be well received by your audience. In any case, send me your good vibes! Solidarity comrade.

CC

I second the request for a Cannabis Episode lol, I am *also* in my mid-thirties and frustratingly dependent on it. Because it’s not THAT bad, right? It does help. With some stuff. Sometimes. It’s cheap and legal where I am, and I get free shit through knowing people in the industry. In some ways quitting harder drugs was easier, because I was going to die if I didn’t. But I think the effects of cannabis addiction are quite insidious in their own right.

Andrew Blake

Such a cool episode and really excited to hear about your new career, best of luck! I've never been to Omaha but hearing about all the great work you do makes me wish I lived there so I could organize with you.

Andrew Blake

It helps until it doesn't, and one of its side effects is keeping you from identifying that tipping point for quite some time

Danny Boy

1:33 "Socialism or barbarism" is now "Socialism or extinction". Rosa didn't know about climate change.

Foko

I think that it’s worth thinking through that argument a little more for sure, because in just reading that quote my first reaction is that it comes across as scapegoating a significant part of the working class (both the culturally “woke” elements of the working class and the material service sector which is one of the largest sectors of the entire economy) for a failure of capitalism to provide meaningful work. But those people are not dictating the evolution of the economy nor will attacking them bring about the downfall of capitalism. Just looking up Haz took me to a page about MAGA Communism, which Alyson and Breht did an episode on a couple of years ago. If you haven’t listened to it yet maybe it will help clarify some of the reason why other comrades you have been speaking to have responded poorly to these sorts of arguments. https://www.patreon.com/posts/72562395?utm_campaign=postshare_fan

Foko

And I’ll also add that I would be happy to clarify any part of the general critique of haz and maga communism with you and would hope that others on this platform would be willing to do the same. I get if we were on twitter or something and I didn’t know who you were, it would be easy to write you off, but if you’re in this community and paying to support and be involved in it I think it’s the least we can do to have discussions with one another around topics that can easily lead people into different, perhaps more reactionary or revisionist sectors of the left - especially in an existing affinity group like this one, or a party like the DSA. In fact, Breht even made the argument in the DSA episode for agitating and doing political education to push the party to the left and correct revisionism within that party. I think that’s something we can all really take to heart and put front and center in our political work, even outside of it, just in our interactions with people more generally. So, Max, please let me know if you have any questions after you listen to that episode Breht and Alyson did, and I would be happy to discuss that or any other topic with you!

Max

Hello Foko, thank you for your kind offer. Of course, I don’t think me paying a negligible amount each month should lead me to expect anyone has the obligation to take their time to dispute my bullshit. But I am glad nonetheless, if someone does. Thank you for highlighting that episode, I think it can provide good starting ground. However, it suffers from a severe underestimation of the theoretical core that is present within this movement. In it, Breht says he tags his reputation to the prediction that in five years everyone of the ‘MAGA communists’ will be republican, and there are only two years left for it to come true. I can understand their sentiment though, because I had the same reaction and arguments towards it when I came across the first ‘Patriotic Socialists’. I still think Caleb Maupin is a muppet, but with Haz and the ACP this has acquired a new quality to it. Of course, its practical substance is still very thin and immature, but the theoretical groundwork is what had me sit up and take notice and which has thoroughly influenced me as well as infused me with new vigour and enthusiasm for our cause. When I first came across Haz on Twitter, I was repelled by all the posturing and terminally online mannerisms. I then started to read his essay “Why Marxism is not woke” and expected to be amused, but instead I had to cede that this was some very high level philosophical work, that succeeded to capture aspects of Marxism, that are very dear to me, and managed to enrich them with thinkers that I would have never ever considered to take in to account. What I would have preclassified as eclecticism as well, turned out to be like the last brick finally falling into place. As someone predominantly engaged with philosophy, this is the core for me, and that which has me looking over some of the immaturities (and sometimes worse discharges) that are present within this movement/party. I am convinced the way he integrates Heidegger is ground-breaking and is not often given a fair consideration (albeit for obvious reasons). Now, there is lots to say about this philosophical core and the controversial nature of Heidegger and his thinking. But since this can be very abstract and I don’t know if this is an interest of yours, I will instead try to start with the more general aspects, which are also discussed in the aforementioned episode on MAGA communism. Precisely, the effort to tie to the ‘right-wing-shift’ of the working class, that can be witnessed all over the Western world, in one way or another. I think there are fundamental problems with the established left-right spectrum. Alysson and Breht accuse the ‘MAGA communists’ of basing themselves on a cultural divide rather than a class divide. Conversely, I think this is precisely what they try to overcome and what the established left has succumbed to. Because the left-right spectrum, as it is generally understood and coded, is primarily a cultural one (liberal – conservative) and it does confuse our intuition of proximity. I would like to question if the LeftCom university student really is always closer to us than a worker with a MAGA hat. The issue regarding the service workers, is also one of how we naturally tend to contain ourselves to our milieu (urban baristas or whatever) instead of leaving our comfort zone and going to the ‘countryside’ (not necessarily rural in a literal sense) where the base of the proletariat may reside. In our highly moralized political environment, we tend to work with the implicit assumption that everyone on the right has revealed themselves as a chauvinist, opportunist and overall repulsive human being by taking this side. This is what I would like to contend. There are legitimate, even honourable reasons that drive people to the right, because the left is (at present) unable to fill this role entangled in the shadow of liberalism. Of course, there are plenty unsavoury and outright disgusting people on the right. Not just within the leadership, but there are certainly many opportunistic people who are deeply egoistic but too weak for individualism and therefore hide within a narrow-minded tribalism. People for which all the prejudices we have about the right are definitely true and which we rightly conceive as our enemies. But, there are also people, and I think the left severely underestimates this, who are trying to preserve collective values. Trying to hold communities together, safeguard traditions and searching for an identity beyond liberal hedonistic nihilism. And these are not just “white settler colonialist wannabe slavers”. I have met conservative muslims in whose uprightness and reliability I would put more faith in than in colleagues who are seemingly more “to the left”, but who have individualistic and cynical outlooks. Western leftists talk a lot about the working class, but are very quick to dismiss large parts of them as backwards and chauvinistic. Of course, in our present state of society and of class consciousness, strains of chauvinisms and prejudice will certainly always be present. I am not saying there is a clear and obvious distinction between the “pure” upright conservative workers and the bad opportunistic types. The borders are flowing and permeated by many contradictions. But whenever there is such a persistent and prevailing sentiment within the masses, we sometimes should try to listen. This does not mean automatic surrender to every whim that gets popular traction, but this one has a substance to it. And Haz (especially) is putting good efforts forward to try to theorize this. To maybe illustrate this with a personal example: I have an aunt [who is not a worker and not our target audience - she manages the kitchen/supply of several retirement homes], but who is one of the kindest and most altruistic human beings I know. She will help you to the point of self-denial, has a strong sense of duty as well as a deep appreciation for nature. She is also the one in our family, who has had the hardest turn to the right. Now, she will sometimes say truly awful things about people, that she would never do if she would meet them in person and get to know them. It all started with a legitimate deep fear of the dissolution of society and a disdain for anti-social behaviour, which was poisoned by the Right and has now festered into conspiracy theories and many utterances that are themselves deeply anti-social. The point I am trying to make is not that we can get everyone back or that we should even prioritize them. Because some are just too far gone down the rabbit hole. But many are not (yet). The amount of working class people at least leaning to the right is not negligible. And the way to include them is not (just) to critique and deconstruct their positions, but to take up the collective, social and devout impulses present within a conservative stance. Caring for the nation can contain the desire for a collective identity, preserving traditions can be an attempt to weave a social fabric and belief in God can lead you to set aside your ego in order to serve a higher purpose. Not only can communism take up these impulses, and did so within existing socialist states (still does), but I would even go so far to say only communism can provide the outlook to fulfill these desires realistically. Communism is the only ideology that can shine a path to overcoming modernity, not by trying to undo it, but by going right trough it. Exemplary, the trajectory of National Socialism shows how the reactionary anti-modernism defeats its own purpose. None of the romantic hopes invested into it came to fruition. Instead, fascism revealed itself as an infinitely heightened modernist excess: the industrialized annihilation of human beings, a technological-technocratic war machine, the wholesale destruction of entire regions and traditionally rooted communities in the service of capital, culminating in the gassing of millions—predominantly artisans and small peasants. This proves that the anti-modern, romantic stance is not realizable in itself and, when driven by fear into submission to capital, necessarily collapses into its very opposite. All the petty-bourgeois fantasies that still circulate today in the right-wing meme-sphere (“Reject Modernity, Embrace Tradition”) have thus been resoundingly refuted and delegitimized. Yet this does not mean that their underlying impulse cannot be preserved in a higher form. They are not just romantic idealizations of the past, but the identification of a present problem that beckons to be solved. And we could. I strongly disagree that this approach is Utopianism. Instead, it is doing exactly what Scientific Socialism calls for, it tries to locate the seeds of revolution, that are already there. And it does so by trying to engage and tie to what is actually present within the working class. Of course, as was rightly pointed out, not the entire working class is MAGA or “conservatively” aligned. What might appeal to a hard-cap industrial worker (if it even does), might not to the bigger section of service industry workers. I get that. The problem is, I don’t think we will be able to a priori form a definite picture of the mental and ideological state of the working class in its entirety. We all have many presuppositions about what the people think, why they are thinking it and how they might be won over or need to be written off. In the end, this is something that can only be decided practically. It is not clear what will be the decisive current (more likely currents) of the next revolution. This corresponds to the manifold of little groups which try out their own approaches. Let’s remember, the successful Bolshevik revolution grew out of many different strains (from social-democratic trade-unionism to the peasant focus first formulated by the Narodniki). A matured communist party will be measured by its ability to integrate many different strains. But for now, where each little group tries to define itself in differentiation, there will be a testing of limits, people taking things too far, making mistakes or opening themselves up for humiliation. It is easy to make fun of Internet warriors trying to convince MAGA people of communism, but I bet everyone’s attempts to reach out to the working class outside of your milieu or comfort zone will start out very awkwardly. If we are serious about our convictions, then communism is our shared destiny. We (from both sides) should try not to burn all the bridges and keep some sort of communication alive, so that we can learn from each other’s mistakes and maybe sharpen our own standpoints by being challenged theoretically once in while. Should they actually manage to establish themselves to some degree, then they deserve at least a passing thought.

ATX Joe

Hey Brent I just started this episode but congrats on the new gig I will hear about in a bit. One thing I wanted to ask you about for some time is what timeframe or which episodes in the archives have you talking about your time as an anarchist and you transition to communism. I, while still new to revolutionary thinking, feel most aligned with anarcho-syndicalism. I want to understand your transition to help me reaffirm or potentially consider things I haven’t previously considered.

Jack Sauer

I feel like people don't understand how big of a deal the fall of the Western Roman Empire was. The end of the WRE is generally considered to be the middle of the 5th century. Living standards in Western Europe did not recover to the same level as the WRE until the mid-19th century. Even that relatively localized collapse took 1,500 years to recover from.

Tristan You

As members of the revolutionary left how do we handle the question of the right of Taiwanese citizens to sovereignty and self determination? Love the show! You’ve been integral in my road to radicalization and I’m deeply grateful for that. I myself am an arborist and I’m excited for you to start doing labor and enjoy the reward of doing a good hard day of work

Beach

Can you offer any books or podcasts to understand Taiwan and the future proxy war between the us and china?

SprocketMusic

Congratulations on your apprenticeship!

Kevin

Congrats man, I’ve been moving away from the desk job and working towards becoming a firefighter. I feel you

Clint Blakely

Big fan of the solo eps. No problem with more of them. I’m getting better at viewing current events and through a dialectical/anti-imperialist lens, but I’m so conditioned to the insanity of our system that it’s hard not to buy into propaganda on some level. Basically, your analysis helps me understand the world better, and that’s invaluable

Seany G

Sorry I missed the previous call-out for your fundraiser. I donated at the new site. Keep up letting us know about worthwhile campaigns.

Serjie Clemons

Loved this and all solo episodes! Can't wait to hear more comradely perspectives from within a Union.

Serjie Clemons

Also, trying to radicalize a dear friend who is strongly anti Zionist but fails to accept Pal resistance as justified and righteous. I'm hoping to track down a good episode to share with him. I recall something, likely a Red Hot solo ep, where Breht outlines the moral basis of support for Pal resistance. Any recommendations for guiding this friend?

J O E & R U E

Longtime listener, finally pulled the patreon trigger BECAUSE you are continuing to do this show and be a worker and be a father and be an organizer. I’m all those things too and I look up to you brother. Also I kinda prefer the solo eps 😎

Wes Rich

Fuck yeah you’ve earned the right to come on this show and give your analysis! That’s why we’re all here lol. Really glad things have been going so well and wishing you the best as you move into your new trade. Im currently in an apprenticeship role as well working towards being a full union member so yeah can confirm it’s hard work.

Guydude

Breht saying he enjoyed line cooking is crazy behaviour.

Dave Miles

Congratulations on making your career move. I spent the first 30 years of my working life as a concretor and steelfixer (“rod buster” in your language 😁). I still drive over bridges I helped build and past hospitals, schools and apartment buildings I worked on - and say to myself “I did that”. Keep doing what you’re doing and I’m pretty sure we’ll keep backing you up. As for unions - I’m a delegate in the Transport Worker’s Union in Australia. And yeah,… far from perfect. But we have to build from somewhere. Solidarity, brother.

COL

Congrats! Your solo eps are some of my favorite ones! Often very cathartic

Andrea Bolt

You’re making me want to do more for my union. It’s a shell of its former self to be sure…. we have a “no strike clause” which is outright ridiculous. If we had more solidarity, that clause would hold no power.

Lefty In Training

Totally feel you on teaching not working out. I was a teacher for a hot minute, but had to transition to IT because I sucked at it and was making myself miserable. Unfortunately, even though I am good at IT work and like dealing with data, staring at a computer for 8 hours a day is infinitely less fulfilling than raising the next generation. Hopefully if we can get this socialism thing going, IT work for the collective good will be at least a bit more fulfilling.

Hamish Bradley

Congrats on the union job! Brett becoming a proper swolletariat now. And I've always loved your solo episodes, you're really good at getting super deep into topics that way:)

Hammer & Pistol

Just listened to this. As a 2nd gen Venezuelan and a union sparky, this episode was super relatable. Happy to answer questions about the trades, or about the state of organizing within the unions, where there's currently some movement in rebuilding a militant rank and file to fight back against business unionism.

Comrade Hesher

It's great to see so many IBEW comrades in the comment section. Listening to this episode was cathartic for me. I've been a wireman for almost 2 decades and I've spent countless hours listening to rev left on the job to learn and pass the time as I worked. I took many of the lessons I learned and applied them to my work in the union and eventually became an officer and now a BA. Congratulations on your apprenticeship and I hope you love and cherish your time in the trades as much as I do. Solidarity brother.

Comrade Hesher

Are you familiar with the rank and file caucus within the IBEW?

Comrade Hesher

Are you familiar with the rank and file caucus within the IBEW? I'm an 18 year member. Glad to see other sparkys here

Brandon Richey

Congrats on the trade position! The union trades are one of the few places where you get out what you put in. Trade work is very rewarding, so I think you'll take to it pretty well!

Ben

“when i hit send does it just delete it?” lmao thank you for speaking to the extremely depressing nature of the cover letter application

M

Do what you gotta do to make the money and have the time you need to live. I'm grateful that you'll be continuing the podcast. That being said, while I enjoy your solo episodes and the ones with Alyson, one of the reasons Rev Left has been my go to podcast since 2020 is because of all the diverse perspectives your interviews provide. Getting takes from Maoists, Anarchists, Socdems, historians, philosophers, women, people of color, etc encourages critical thinking and prevents your audience from blindly following your word, as well as gives marginalized people access to a large audience they might not have access to otherwise.

flippy

when you said: for all I know, my application was deleted when I hit "send" I laughed out loud xD it really feels like that ffs