Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Alyson and Breht critically engage with the concept of "technofeudalism" from a Marxist (and thus historical materialist) perspective, analyzing its origin and recent popularity, critiquing its depoloyment and the implication that it represents a "new mode of production", explaining related concepts like rent-seeking, discussing the role of private equity in the modern American economy, the politics of Yanis Varoufakis, and much, much more. 

Private Equity Explainer HERE

Learn more at https://revleftradio.com/

Files

Comments

CJ

I think you can also look at “Technofuedalism” as Marx’s M-C-M’ in the digital realm. Where C is the labor power and raw materials but also the Data generated by Alexa or a digital platform used for “free”. That data is a commodity that is either sold directly, for ads, or to generate more data. Sometimes it is sold for M’. Sometimes M’ < M but that C still remains in the form of data. Regardless, I think the implications Alyson brought up are important. Struggling through tenants unions is a great idea! And I wonder if something like data strikes could be an effective tool for asserting demands in these spaces.

Jose Alvarez

Were the thumbnail and outro music prompted into existence? That’d be really creative for this episode lol

Rev Left Radio

haha no, I didnt want to use AI stuff tbh -- but it would be a funny exclamation mark on the ep

Rev Left Radio

Something like a data strike is a really compelling idea. New ways of struggling and resisting on the digital terrain. But as always, the main goal, which I know you know, is to organize and capture political power!

surkesh

Especially appreciate Alyson’s points near the end regarding being cognizant of quantitative and qualitative shifts. I have also been thinking about how the internet, social media, AI have all represented an ongoing attempt at capitalist enclosure/“primitive accumulation” of the mind/human thought. As an adjunct/supplement to the discussion on economic rent, I have appreciated the following long-durée perspective on economic rent, Feudalism, and economic theory by Michael Hudson and Richard Wolff. In particular Michael Hudson’s summation of Marx’s “Theories of Surplus Value” and Capital Vol 2/3 with respect to classical political economy and rent (he has also research looking at an even longer view of premodern society with the David Graeber institute). My interpretation is that imperialism and monopoly capital, financialization, etc all represent growing vestigial elements of feudal structures that were never fully eradicated and have grown/developed again in the 20th century. These are transcripts of the discussion and are framed with relation to modern geopolitics/BRICS and is somewhat repetitive between the 2 links, but especially in the 1st link is a good summary of this theory: https://michael-hudson.com/2025/06/the-value-war/ https://michael-hudson.com/2025/05/sanctions-and-shell-games/ “And by the time that World War I ended, there was no more classical economics really being taught. Everything was restructured to say there’s no such thing as economic rent. And that was because England, America, Germany — the industrial nations — had used their classical economic policies to achieve such a head start that they didn’t need protection anymore. They were able to, all of a sudden, pull up the ladder to prevent other countries from developing in their same way and becoming rivals. And they themselves became the rentier economies. And it was as if they were rolling the clock slowly back towards feudalism and its rentier classes, very much so.” This is a transcript of a speech regarding pre-modern debt and property relations. I am yet to find a published book/set of articles with respect to this (although I have not had a chance to look very deeply): https://michael-hudson.com/2022/07/from-junk-economics-to-a-false-view-of-history-where-western-civilization-took-a-wrong-turn/ I’m half asleep so hope this makes sense and welcome any feedback/discussion to further my understanding!

Chris Brinlee Jr

I just bought six all-time favorite albums for the CD-changer in my old new-to-me car.

Jördrider

I was waiting for Alyson's critique at the end and agree. I think that Yanis is allowed to pedal his techno-feudalism grift because the solution would be a French style, "eat the rich" type of revolution. Yet another way to channel revolutionary potential toward something that ultimately leads back to capitalism.

Lefty In Training

Echoes a lot of the questions I've had about techno-feudalism. A big point Alyson confirmed for me was an overemphasis on the consumer extraction part of the phenomenon techno-feudalism is describing. These companies absolutely do utilize productive labor beyond just the passive collection and value extraction of consumer data, so I think labeling it as a new mode of production is premature.

Mackenzie parvin

We’ve had different modes of production and ownership coexisting before . Slavery and Capitalism in the American south . Feudalism and capitalism in Russia . This is definitely unique from the type of capitalism that existed before the internet

Chase

I love the dynamic and analysis you and Alyson provide. Great insight and gives us a lot to chew on when it comes to the evolution of late capitalism. Also! Just got my hoodie and I love it. Looks great and super soft! Gonna order a shirt as well.

Liv

What y’all are saying about the consequential backlash of technofeudalism is something I’ve been seeing a lot in my own circles of ages 18-35, for me personally, I just wanted to reclaim a relationship with music and media without the constant monetization and extractive schemes through ads and upsells, or how Spotify only plays the same fifteen songs on every ‘curated’ playlist. The quality of media content we’ve been fed over the past 5+ years has also significantly declined, and that has led a lot of people to say what you’re saying ‘why am i paying $13/mo of music rent when there are free/much more accessible ways to listen?” These streaming services are becoming more obsolete, selling us almost exclusively liberal garbage and copaganda

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely. A counter cultural movement is brewing already as you say, and will expand in the years to come.

Rev Left Radio

So glad to hear it! We are in talks about a new design and release too! Be careful washing the hoodie, it can shrink fyi!!! <3

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for these links, and I do like and listen to Hudson often. Almost had him on the pod once, cant remember why it never happened. Some schedule conflict or missed email. In any case, he is definitely someone to learn from!

Gabriele Pumo

To be honest I find the claim that Varoufakis points to a return to capitalism as a way out of technofeudalism completely unsubstantiated either by his writing or by his political organising.

Mackenzie parvin

I don’t get the Leninist argument for 21st century America. We can’t have the military or police on our side. That’s ideologically and tactically impossible

Bill

Thank you for this great episode! I am in agreement with you about Alyson- brilliant! The most salient point (for me) was the idea of whether or not capitalism has “transformed so substantially that the qualitative realities of life under capitalism are no longer the same system that Karl Marx outlined”. Are we late capitalism or are we already post capitalism? Regardless, understanding the technology, its algorithms, and the dangers it poses are perhaps more necessary than debating its underpinnings. While you can argue that this new order of rent seeking “cloud capital” is parasitic, creating no productive value, we can also appreciate to a certain extent how it has made our lives easier and fuller-no more trips to a life sucking mall, greater exposure to new ideas (Rev Left!). This is the allure. This is how it captures us. So for me, the challenge is to find balance in my own life and not necessarily to escape from it altogether. Part of finding this balance is figuring out how to fight for the ownership of this new means of production- to develop a new technosocialism . How would that look? How can we fight for this? These are questions I’d like to explore. In terms of semantics I must add that this current trend of monopoly capitalism will soon lean more toward a techno totalitarianism than a feudalism- if we allow it. In fact, we may already be there. Marx may not have captured the future of capitalism in terms of technology but he did teach us how to critique economics regardless of how it manifests. So thank you both for using Marxism in this vein- it’s the right way. It’s pointing us in the right direction, the right kind of action. Solidarity.

JK

When so many "leftist" podcasters have strayed from Marxism these last few years, this episode is a brilliant example of how theory has helped keep Brett and Alyson on the right path, and why I keep listening. When I heard Upstream host Varoufakis as they nodded along silently to his claims that technofeudalism had replaced capitalism, I made a reply begging them to address these statements critically. A claim that we have somehow moved past commodity production into a new epoch is bold and should be met with harsh skepticism. I totally agree, that this kind of rhetoric is easily co-oped into a reactionary role, hinting that we need to "go back to plain old capitalism" and away from "this bastardized, feudal form". While I can appreciate new ideas and attempts to update theory, this "techno feudalism" fad does feel very much like a market ploy to sell books and offers little/nothing in providing solutions. All it takes is looking at the top 10 corporations in the world to show that even though tech billionaires dominate much of the United States, the dominant capitalists remain the fossil fuel companies, banks, Walmart, ect. Although capitalism and rent seeking has certainly created peculiar forms of profit extraction, mostly here in the United States, we should never let this misdirect our ire towards just the tech capitalists instead of the capitalist class as a whole. Brett and Alyson, keep up the good work. Your adherence to the principles of Marxism has yet again proven to grant you the benefit of foresight over astonishment when it comes to analyzing the world around us. Today I'll have to give More Perfect Unions episode on Private Equity a listen because Brett's brief interjection about it was absolutely fascinating. Well done comrades, looking forward to next episode already. Would absolutely love to hear you all have a discussion with a cadre from the Revolutionary Communist International sometime on world perspectives and building a vanguard party. <3

SD

Joined the LA tenant union after listening. Thanks Alyson!

Rev Left Radio

This is incredibly high praise and so deeply, profoundly appreciated. Your insight is also palpable in its own right, and I appreciate your analysis and feedback. I love upstream and I too have been criticized in the past for not holding my guests feet to the fire, so I sympathize with both sides of that particular critique. Sometimes letting a guest speak takes precedent over trying to correct them, especially with guests who are overwhelmingly friendly and "on our side". Still, I hear you 100%, and I wouuld bet that Robbie and the crew over at upstream would accept and even agree with your constructive criticism there. In any case, we appreciate having you as a listener and supporter. Love and Solidarity!! (im down to have RCI on anytime! :) )

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for this feedback and I agree with you totally, my friend! All technology inherently has positive and negative impacts, but the mode of production under which it emerges will be decisive in this regards, and under capitalism, despite various benefits, will overwhelmingly be leveraged for profit extraction, surveillence, etc. So your idea of techno-socialism is great and needed. Id like to explore that idea and vision more in depth soon tbh, its a great little concept, akin to eco-socialism. An emphasis on an aspect of socialism that already exists, but is particularly relevant.

JK

You both deserve every ounce of praise. As I may have mentioned before in the past on here, I will be forever grateful for you both helping pry me from doomerism and introducing me to Marxism and revolutionary optimism. It would bring me alot of joy if you had an episode with one of our RCI cadres. Almost like a full circle moment; the podcasters who helped radicalize me meets the revolutionary party I've since become heavily organized with. Off the top of my head you might want to reach out to Joe Attard, Fred Weston, Jorge Martín, or Hamid Alizadeh who host our shows such as The Spectre of Communism Podcast and Against the Stream. Or perhaps I can message you the email of one of the cadres who works at our National Center for the RCA (Revolutionary Communists of America). Let me know, I'd like to help in any way I can.

Wes Rich

Really great episode, with just so much to chew on. As usual incredibly disciplined analysis rooted in theory that is able to cut through the BS and get at the heart of a pretty important conversation. I just feel lucky that I got to be a fly on the wall for it.

Jördrider

I never said that he advocates for a return to capitalism. Correct me if I'm wrong, but he advocates for reformation within the capitalist system. Which is still capitalism.

Jördrider

So many people who join the military, do so out of desperation. I think the use of a revolutionary vanguard, comprised of veterans could organize within the military. Look at people like Mike Pryzner. I think you're right about a lot of police officers though. They're extremely reactionary for the most part. Historically speaking, you don't need everyone on your side. I think it's something like 20 percent.

Rev Left Radio

That is very high praise and we appreciate it so so much .