Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht is joined by Nick from MEANS TV and JT from Second Thought and The Deprogram, to have an unstructured conversation about fatherhood, parenting, role modeling, masculinity, marriage, children, and much more!

Files

Comments

Kolibri

One could even say that many people are having Second Thoughts about having kids

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Really good episode. Any chance this will be made public? I’d like to share it with someone but totally understand if you have no plans to make it public.

Gaige

Great episode. You guys hit on a point that I’m worried about as a new father to a 10 month old and that is the importance of extended family. Through some fucked up stroke of misfortune, my poor little guy has no extended family that he will be able to see even moderately regularly. He has his uncle near but he’s not overly reliable or from an older generation. I worry about that. But at least he has the world’s best mom so maybe it cancels out 🤷

Irene

Omg dream team😎 excited to listen

Pablo

As a soon to be father, I really appreciated your insights on this episode. You talked a fair about about modelling masculinity for a son, but I'd be very interested in hearing your thoughts on how you do so for your daughter as well

Danny Boy

I LOVE this. One point that came up about "normalizing" late-teens kids' problems - my brain never processed that enough to find any relief. It might be good to take it a step further, and say that everybody is going through it, your parents went through it, and it's not likely to ruin their futures.

Jack Maslo

You guys touched on it, and I was just talking to my wife about it the other day: There are days where I feel like I do not get to exist for myself. I go to work and I'm subservient to the conditions of my job, I come home and I'm subservient to a toddler. I put him to bed every night, I wake up with him every morning. I have to remind myself that in the end it will be worth it. There are just days where it feels never-ending though. I feel guilty for wanting time to myself but I know its healthier for everyone if I find that time.

Panayotis League

What a great episode. It was so helpful to hear y’all talk through all this. I’m a divorced dad of two teenage girls who split their time between me and their mother, an abusive, manipulative narcissist who models really awful behavior, so I have a whole set of added challenges on top of all the other stuff. It’s incredibly hard and very lonely, mostly because I don’t have many male friends who can relate and commiserate with me, so I really appreciate just listening to y’all talk through your own struggles. Big love!

AL

Seriously make this free so I can share it with my straight dad comrades.

Jolene Bresney

i wish all the men in my life could hear this honest, vulnerable exchange. as a mother to a son- i can say i tried to break cycles. i succeeded and failed up against these systems. talking about it all connects us in our frail humanity. thank you for this.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for listening and for those kind words. I succeed and fail every single day, but keep trying to do better. Our frail humanity indeed. <3

Rev Left Radio

I am sorry to hear that, that is definitely a huge challenge. I got lucky with my daughters mom, as we get along very very well these days. But I applaud you for doing your best, and send my love to you and your girls!

Rev Left Radio

I could not relate to that any more, my friend. And guarentee my wife would say the same. When you are in the trenches of raising young children, you literally do not have time for yourself. Maybe you can get a sitter for a few hours a week at most, but its a 24/7 grind. Waking up at 5am, working all day, coming home to the kids making demandds and my stressed out wife whose been home with them all day haha plus classes and podcasts on the weekends. Oh man, its hard. So I resonate with what your saying, its totally normal, calmer times will come, try and be grateful for the things you have and remember when your kid grows up, youll look back nostalgically on their youth! <3

Rev Left Radio

I never got to talking about that, but intended too. My 18 year old niece and my daughter recently told me that what they admire about me is that I am a "manly man" (their words) who provides for and protects his family, but one who does not ever exhibit "toxic masculinity". They both said they use me as a template for partners as they continue to grow up. Brought a tear to my eye and made me smile... But thats the short of: show them that being a man means to be loving and gentle and to not have an ego. The men who are insecure about their masculinity always have to over-perform machismo as compensation. Real men use whatever strengths and talents they have to love, care for, serve, provide for, and protect others.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, loving parents go a LOOONG way, if you guys have friends, they can become extended family. All my best friends are "uncles" to my kids. So when life doesnt provide an in-built extended family, you can always make one :)

Panayotis League

What Breht said, 100%. It’s so important to make time for yourself, even if it’s 20 mins a day and a weekly date with your wife/yourself. It’s vital for your own health, will enable you to be a better parent, and will teach your kid about the value of self-care and self-love and independence and resilience. And I relate so much to the guilt that you feel… but you got this.

Pablo

Thank you Breht!

Danny Boy

If you're interested in making a mini-series on this, I would love to hear more about parental climate dread, political education/inoculating against the political programming of our education system, pro-feminist parenting, religious discussions, etc.

she's all rat

I loved this episode, we're severely lacking in hearing men talk about these things as openly and thoughtfully as this. On the issue of to have or not have kids, I think there's an additional aspect that shouldn't be disregarded. It's true that "less than ideal" circumstances have always existed, but a major difference is that it's only very recently in our history that women have been able to make the decision to not have kids. I mean, we STILL face blocks to our autonomy on the cultural and physical fronts of reproduction, but ppl 45 and younger have options childbearing people have never ever had before. Which is all to say, and Federici has said it, that people in the past also worried about having kids in bad times, and often tried not to, but it was next to impossible for most. Talking to older generations of women has made me a lot more sensitive to the people who don't want to bring kids into their conditions, even if they do want kids. It just makes me sad for how much capitalism robs us. The full potential we have to be thoughtful and enriched partners, friends, children, parents, all truncated and drained by this system. It hurts man! From a hismat perspective, I think if women had historically had more say in whether or not to reproduce the working class, birth rates would've declined and forced a change in circumstances one way or another. Either way, the thoughtful haves or have nots are motivated by caring about people, and any life devoted to that is well spent.

Rakish Tilt 🎩

This was a very relatable and affirming episode - my wife and I have a 10 y/o and a 2 y/o and it's been so fkn hard. Thanks for reminding me that, while being a mental health therapist who serves medicaid/medicare clients who are multiply-marginalized, my wife's job at home with the kids is much worse.

Mort Crim

Haven’t even listened to this yet but I’m hyped. Loved the parenting under capitalism episode. As a new dad I’m thrilled for any leftist parenting content. I feel like there isn’t really enough content like this.

B8ttyH

I don’t have children myself (probably never will) but I really appreciate your insight on parenting and breaking harmful cycles

Monty O’Blivion

Really enjoyed listening to this, y’all. Means TV, Second Thought, and RevLeft is a dream team. Like Breht, I was a young dad at 19, and never really knew any other dads I could talk to, my own father is not in my life, so it really means a lot to me to hear your experiences, feels like I have some community somewhere, I appreciate you dudes so much!

Bill

The only father figure I had was my step father who was a reactionary, racist, conservative, abusive alcoholic. So maybe dialectics were at play lol as I turned out diametrically way different. Interesting as well, as a parent I had a lot of anxiety, was super OCD, and very hyper driven because of my childhood precarity. My own kids: cool as cucumbers, not an anxious bone in their bodies, and zero desire to play the capitalistic bullshit game we’re all expected to conform to. So in my experience parenting is so ridiculously amusing and so ridiculously difficult to control. Advice: Just love your kids for who they are and for gods sake let them stay kids as long as possible.

Irene

Dang I think you did the thing they call breaking generational trauma!!!!

Kyle

1st child is due in February and this was both helpful and reassuring!

Rev Left Radio

Best of luck, my friend! Im sure youll do great. Its the most challenging and most rewarding thing ive ever done.

Rev Left Radio

100% Let them flower and blossom in their own natural way, give them love and autonomy, support them no matter what, listen to their thoughts and ideas, teach them to think critically not just agree with you, and more times than not, they will turn into good hearted, competent adults! Theres so much in life that we cannot control, relinquishing the need for impossible control, and letting life unfold while doing our best is the move. Salute to you Bill!

Rev Left Radio

Love hearing that Monty! Appreciate the support, and solidarity my friend. Being a young parent is difficult, but helps you grow up and mature and take on responsibility in a really unique way.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for listening and for your support of the show!!

Rev Left Radio

I agree! Im consciously trying to help create some useful stuff on that front!

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely. My boys are 10 and 3, and the past 2 years have been the hardest parenting years ive ever experienced. But things do get easier, the older one begins to mature and calm down a bit, and the toddle comes into their own. Youll look back on these chaotic days with gratitude and nostaliga one day. In the meantime, trying to be as kind and loving and compassionate to our partners is ESSENTIAL.

Rev Left Radio

Great and important point, absolutely! Appreciate you adding that into the discussion, and I agree with you wholeheartedly.

Monty O’Blivion

Thanks brother! Solidarity right back atcha! ☭

Rakish Tilt 🎩

Learning to be compassionate to each other with basically absent grandparents and barely any other help has been a big challenge, but I think we've finally got there. It's hard not to get adversarial when there's no one coming to help. Our older child has mental health and behavioral issues that have been brutal on us. We've almost broke up so many times. Luckily our son has been so chill and I finally understand how people have multiple children. Like you said though, two kids is like 4x as hard and I believe you when you say three is 10x. We're all neurodivergent too, and both my wife and I are survivors of family trauma, and we feel successful in at least breaking the cycle. We have given and will continue to give so much of ourselves to our daughter (unfortunately, the resources you imagine are there for child mental health issues have been very disappointing) but we understand now that parents can "do everything right" and your child can still suffer profoundly. Accepting that is hard as fuck and I guess, as we Buddhists say, that suffering is my greatest teacher. You hope to never hear your child voice suicidal ideation, but hearing it starting at age 5 is brutal.

MirrorOooMirror

Thanks fellas! Breht, I can relate as a dad of a 3 year old boy and 2 year old girl, breaking down in front of them while trying to read Cat Man of Allepo at bedtime. Still unsure how to navigate that stuff, or anything really. Some nights I can barely sleep full of anxiety and dread over my kids future. Especially as an older parent (didn’t have my 1rst till I was 39) and regularly worry they will be left to navigate a future hellscape without their dad. On the bright side some days are pretty good.

Chris Brinlee Jr

Have him try ice (figure) skating. It's artistic and expressive, but also physical.

Rev Left Radio

I resonate with that and have dealt with anxiety and dread over their futures as well. But life is unpredictable and uncontrollable, and the price we pay for this marvelous and miraculous existence is precisely that lack of control, predictability, stability, or assurance. Our suffering too is part of the price we pay, and all humans must pay it. Still, I doubt very many of us would go back and choose to never be born at all. Id rather live and suffer, than never live at all.

MirrorOooMirror

Thanks, I agree. Though going down that psychological rabbit hole of what was before “me” is a real mind bender. Is there/was there ever such a thing/time? Anyway, thanks Breht you’re an inspiration, truly.

B Grimez

sorry if this is the wrong place for this, but seeking any MCs that want to work on real relevant shit, @bgrimez on youtube I got some joints on there but that's just the tip of the iceberg, got a lot more I'm going to be putting up since I'm currently furloughed, I MC too sometimes and have some projects I'm working on, stay tuned, if anyway wants to just support a comrade, please subscribe, and Brett if this is the wrong place for this, I apologize in advance and let me and I'll delete

Rev Left Radio

Naw man, its cool. Do your thing! I wish you the best and appreciate the support!

B Grimez

good looks, keep doing your thing man, it's needed more than ever at moment. Salute!!! ✊️

flippy

would be nice to make the last question a bit more central to the episode, how to deal with the thought of becoming a parent in such a messed up world. Especially for activists it seems that we need more of us as times get worse and parenting is a potential loss of comerades as family becomes priority. would also be interesting to hear a perspective on white people deciding to have kids of their own (i.e. white kids) as opposed to adopting or building a community for co-parenting. on that note, would be cool to expand on the idea of being a parent from the nuclear standard to the "it takes a village" theory. why do we think that two people who are attracted to each other will also be the right people to teach a child everything to survive. what are systems of community parenting that can work? what needs to happen to enable such systems of collective responsibility.

flippy

nice to hear @revleft I'd be a bit careful about using words like "real men do this and that.." as I feel it reinforces the idea of strict gender roles

flippy

samsara is a rly nice track :)) I could try record some raps over it

surkesh

I know the Upstream podcast has done some other episodes on parenting that have touched on this a little bit. I am not an expert by any means, but the early USSR tried to work out some of these problems - especially Alexandra Kollontai and her contributions as the People's Commissar for Social Welfare and the Zhenotdel. I would be curious to learn more about what other socialist countries like China, Vietnam, Cuba etc have done since then with respect to your third paragraph

Rev Left Radio

Yea upstream has a whole parenting series, and I am the guest on one of them! You might find much of interest there. IN my episode, I explicitly and in detail address the first part of your question! Not sure I totally understand your second question, but if you elaborate on that, id give my two cents fwiw.

flippy

thanks for the hint surkesh <3 Kollontai leaves some radical footsteps I wouldnt call china or vietnam socialist but am sure there's valuable lessons on parenting in socialism to be drawn from their recent history

flippy

nice to hear you being involved with them breht <3 and thx for taking the time to answer personally. Regarding the first point, while i liked the episode I felt that deciding whether or not to have kids as a person on the left came a bit short compared to the discussion on how to be a father once the decision has been made. It would be nice to hear more on how you all dealt with those doubts, and whether the thought of deciding not to, as a sacrifice for the cause ever came about, as weird as that may sound. Regarding the second, I was referring to the thought of not having offspring as a white person and instead adopting a child of BIPOC or lower class origin. It comes from a cynical perspective of "the last thing the world needs is another middle-class white kid" and the fact that there are a lot of kids aready alive who need some loving parents :)