Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

I almost didnt post this... I wanted to get a more specific recording of Fuentes to react to and critique in FULL. But since I recorded this a few days back, the civil war on the right has exploded, and so perhaps this can still be useful for some basic orientation to whats going on - even if it is not perfect or complete. Consider this the beginning of an analysis, NOT a full analysis! Ill cover all of this in more depth and more critically as it continues to evolve. I have many more critiques of Fuentes that I want to articulate and focus in on.

-----------------------

Breht explores major rifts on the American Right, the ascension of America First, the Israel issue, the politics of Nick Fuentes and Tucker Carlson, and much more.

Files

Comments

Peter McEntee

I’ve been similarly following this ascendant right wing movement that is increasingly open to rupture with the GOP. I’ve long agreed with your idea of trump being the “Obama of the Right”, and I think it’s incumbent on ALL of us to try and understand exactly what this means for us as the (non) organized left because although it’s frightening to see the decay from awful to even worse on the right, there’s power to gain from the degradation of an enemy

Saya Clarke

HOLY SHIT Breht I almost messaged you about watching this/doing an episode. Buckwild interview and extremely interesting!

B Grimez

I need to listen to this, just hope it don't trigger me lol hey sorry for coming in hot the other day.. been having issues with my meds and a lot of shit going on in my life.... lately and I was suffering from mild serotonin toxicity, so it got me mad hype, I'm ok, getting help, and sorry if I made.anyone uncomfortable... but I wanted to share a prayer I wrote a few months ago, it's kinda dark I guess but idk it helps me, maybe it.could help someone else: From the void, we all emerge to the void we all return day breaks as night recedes good thoughts good words good deeds in the flux where all is new I ask the reins to steer me thru and if today I fail and fall the void will take me where it takes us all I guess the void to me is the possibility of anything and everything which in many religions would be God, even Christian musicians, like the book of unknowing and other privy counsels, the unknowing I guess is the "void" man

B Grimez

sorry if this sounds intense, my body is still in shock, idk

Pj

I've had a pretty shallow understanding of Fuentes, really like you said just from having seen clips from years ago. Listening to what you shared was honestly kind of shocking because it IS so close to being a similar analysis on something like Israel before he gets into the "nuance". And that's kind of terrifying to me. Ive seen so much of the mainstream narrative surrounding the Palantir Pals and most of the folks on the right that I know are older, that I just never expected there to be this big a rift on the right.

Bill

Looking forward to this episode. I wasn’t familiar with Nick Fuentes and his Groypers until I read an opinion piece in the NY Times this morning about him. It was written by Michelle Goldberg. The take away is that Fuentes is ascendant and conservatives are divided on censoring his extreme views. So I was thrilled to see your timely episode posted this morning and am looking forward to hearing your perspective. Thank you!

Bill

Remember that there is strength in solidarity. Hang in there!

B Grimez

thanks man, that means a lot, I'm doing a little better today

Andrew Blake

Breht-Fuentes debate incoming? The person you described who could dismantle him in a debate is basically you

Peter McEntee

Coming back after the full listen here. I watch almost every video Tucker puts on YouTube(minus some of the most insanely boring interviews he does with people), and watch a decent amount of nick’s AF openers on a weekly basis. Tucker to me represents the “left” wing of this far right America First deviation of the MAGA right, and I feel like his general framing of America first as a question of civic nationalism (which also absolutely has racist rooting in understanding who “is” and “can be” American) is a point of deviation from Fuentes who is pretty openly a White Identitarian and Nationalist (he said this explicitly in his interview with the Return to the Land project leader Eric Orwoll). Tucker to me almost represents the “big tent” of America First nationalism ranging from blunt civic nationalism to explicit white nationalism, whereas Fuentes is much more the latter and is even hostile towards civic nationalists for their lack of criticism on Jewish identity itself as the progenitor of all evil. When you’re that steeped in idealism and have the ego that many “thought leaders” on the right tend to have, I feel like you’re bound to at some point rupture and isolate yourself and practice similar sectarianism to what see on the (broadly conceived) left. All this to say, I think there is an inherent contradiction that will turn antagonist even amongst the Israel critical right (to use Fuentes’ own terms here) , and as these big egos clash and divide their bases it gives us what is probably one of our last real opportunities to offer substantive left wing solutions to the masses. I agree also 100% that SocDem/DemSoc beliefs are the mainstream consciousness of the American Left at large, which is why I really think (speaking as a member of Liberation Caucus in DSA) it is ESSENTIAL to be organizing where this energy is most greatly consolidated. Even though the true left wing of DSA is still a minority, its got a tangible presence and I think can serve as the basis to building some sort of anti imperialist, economically populist mass organization/United Front. Which while ofc not the end goal, is essential in the struggle against imperialism/capitalism (and is thus my elevator pitch to anyone reading this to join DSA lmao)

surkesh

I don't have the time to view much American Right Wing media, so this was a good foray for me, thanks! Here are my rambling thoughts. One theme I heard in your analysis and some of the clips is another attempt (in the long line of historical attempts) to define American National Identity by the Right, especially centering a certain privileged race/caste of people. Goes to show how fragile the concept of "American" is in that it constantly needs to be re-shored and is an ongoing terrain of struggle. This contradiction of being a settler-colonial, racist, capitalist project on the one hand and the construct of "American Exceptionalism" on the other (as we hear espoused by politicians seeking election) will continue to play out in this country for a long time without an accurate and open accounting of American history both domestically and internationally. On a similar note, I notice a lot of tendencies that espouse a domestic policy focused agenda such as "America First" or MAGA have minimal historic analysis of how the US got to where it is (perhaps somewhat on purpose but I think in their arrogance they have large blind spots) - especially with respect to the international conditions and exploitation that have led to the current moment. As you pointed out Breht the "America First" ideology is still on board with imperial geopolitical moves as long as there isn't the "appearance" of foreign interference; I see a similar parallel to the liberal hysteria around Russiagate from the first Trump term.

Rakish Tilt 🎩

I found this very helpful, and as much as I abhor Fuentes, it behooves us to understand how he makes his arguments and how to counter them.

Rev Left Radio

Pretty much. Hes praised him many times in the past with a thin facade of irony. Says hes christian and doesnt actually wanna hurt anyone. In any case, he is certainly a fascist.

Rev Left Radio

Great points all around. i dont think the reactionary nationalists are at all interested in an accurate and open accounting of American history, their romantic nostalgia would be displaced... Plus, anything about American history we would consider a moral outrage or a negative they will laugh at or outright embrace. Nick's embrace of Empire is a bit of a divergent from someone like Tucker, who would argue for a general non-interventionism and say that you cant have an empire and be a functioning republic at the same time. In any case, when push comes to shove, none of these people truly stand up and oppose the empire in any meaningful way, and would disparage and attack the actual critics or protesters of empire on the left.

Mackenzie parvin

Yea I get what you’re saying but they’re just racist idiots , just like the nazi party the American Right is a big tent . The Nazis had Lutherans , Pagans , Atheists , millionaires and workers in the same group . They all just fought underneath hitler . Same thing seems to be happening here . IMO you probably know more about the current state of these guys .

Rev Left Radio

Superb analysis, and I agree - both with your point about where Tucker stands on the AF spectrum AND your point about the egos/contradictions emerging and clashing. Also agree on your point about where the energy is, and its our job to engage with it and help shape it!

Rev Left Radio

haha I am too small a figure for him to debate now that hes a household name. But of course, id love to. What a convo taht would be!

Rev Left Radio

He is leading the charge against the neocon zionist right, while also having deeply reactionary and outright fascist views himself for sure!! appreciate your support as always, bill!

Rev Left Radio

No need to apologize my friend. I send you my love and support!

Rev Left Radio

Yea, the moment i saw it pop up on my feed I hit play and got a crazy dopamine rush lmao, cuz I knew what it represented on the Right and what it would mean. The fall out from it is still shaking the foundations of the american right, and will for a while. it is after all a deep rift only temporarily covered up by Trump, but after him, this HAD to erupt, and erupting it is...

B Grimez

thanks man, doing a lot better, I guess I really know how to make an entrance lol, hey man, thanks for real, and I plan on contributing more in the future, just getting my head right, thanks again everyone and talk to you soon ✊️

Andrew Blake

To answer your other questions, I don't listen to this stuff so I appreciate you doing so, and I agree it's important to be familiar with the arguments. Your overalll analysis seems pretty correct too. I do think in terms of debating these guys there's a sizable risk of inherently conceding too much ground just by arguing on their terms, so one must be very cautious when entering that realm. E.g. it'd be important to come armed with a list of his most hateful comments to confront him with when he tries to soft pedal his Nazism, then ask if he disavows them. At that point you get him either admitting he's a Nazi or admitting he doesn't actually have any principles. When you ask "how much does it help us" to spend time grappling with these guys, imo it's "not that much, unless you're going to debate them publicly." While it's good to have passing familiarity with their arguments I'd say it's only "useful" inasmuch as it helps you dismantle them when you encounter them in your own organizing work. And I'm not sure how often that would actually be. In cost-benefit terms, time spent actually organizing is far more important than time spent doing oppo research, and the latter should only be pursued as far as it abets the former... unless of course you're a type of masochist and genuinely enjoy spending your leisure time that way 😉 Finally I was glad you got around to the main point at the end, which is that the zionist project IS the U.S. project, and any analysis that concludes one controls the other is flat out wrong, with the America First version inexorably leading towards antisemitism.

nickw

I’m wondering if more thought needs to be applied structurally to the Christian right and Project 25 fuelling the republican policies?

Peter McEntee

Appreciate the response man, and all your content as always. You and Alyson I think are some of the most passionate, articulate, and intelligent voices on the left today. Thanks for all you’ve done as always!!

EdLam

Great breakdown. Glad someone is watching chud slop so i don’t have to. I’m not totally convinced about the establishment media being totally irrelevant. Fox news is still a titan in every reactionary boomer household and CNN is still the go to slop for most centrists and libs. Although these newer currents are taking shape I don’t know how far they have penetrated mainstream media and policy. Obviously for us real leftists and for right chuds of the newer generation establishment media is out. These two dorks aren’t exactly the GOP in its current form. Loved the breakdown and love your show.

BammEs

How he talks about Israeli blood and soil politics like it's a good thing is wild, but I can 100% see the appeal. He's well spoken, knows his facts, is level-headed about Israel right now. He feels more in touch with reality than the news anchor types. But I'm not in the US, I'm unsure how much of a hold this has on regular people outside of the online spheres. 5 million is a lot of views of course, but even then the mainstream media attention probably brought in a lot of curious people, rather than only sympathizers

Lefty In Training

First time listening to Fuentes (I'm not online that much). He certainly has practiced a delivery that is confident without being grating (unlike a Tim Pool). And he can certainly present a more coherent analysis than anything you'd hear on Fox, MSNBC, or Newsmax. Going towards one of ypur last points, whether his followers are dumb like he says they are (at least in character), they are doing one thing that humans are good at: reading between the lines. Even when he says he's not antisemitic, his followers can read between the lines to understand both what his real views are and what the implications of those views are, even when they contradict what he says. Atleastin their minds, and likely true in reality, talks like these are him hiding his true power level to be presentable to "the normies," not unlike what some people say of Richard Wolfe types. I'm sure those in the know that watch all of his streams have seen the more hateful, less presentable side of him come out, which they (probably correctly) interpret as his true positions.

Keira Foster

As someone who's similarly aged to Fuentes and same timing of radicalization (just be it in the opposite direction), I also think its important to keep tabs on this shit. If anyone else wants to go further into that pool of thought. Knowledge Fight (podcast chronicling the many lies of Alex Jones) has been covering more and more Fuentes and Jones' career is on the decline due to people such as Fuentes

The Communist Larry David

When you were talking about the Democratic Party running a democratic socialist I was waiting for you to give some names of potential candidates like you were giving right wing names like Tucker. But you gave no names. I was waiting for you to say AOC but you probably couldn't get yourself to say her name. I can barely look at AOC when I see her, but I will probably hold my nose and vote for her if it's her against JD Vance or Tucker. I've been voting Green lately but it's time to stop "wasting" my vote. The Republicans are so bad that they've driven me to this horrible conclusion.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I think what you sense is precisely that: I am not sure the figures on the left that represent those ideals in a genuine and deep way exist on the national stage yet. It feels to me that figures that AOC, even if they are totally sincere (and I actually think they are), represent liberalism in the final analysis, not genuine socialism. More than that, they seem to represent a kind of careerism and individualism that I sense at a visceral level. Bernie Sanders was more legitimate, but ultimately capitulated to the Democratic Party Apparatus and Zionism. Real socialist candidates will have to come out of the working class and on a wave of mass, organized support from the grassroots, representing their constituency and class, NOT themselves. I think we will know it when we see it, and we havent quite seen it yet... But yea, doesnt mean I personally hate them or wish them ill - just that they are not the sort of leaders we need imo.

Rev Left Radio

Interesting, ill check that pod out cuz im interested in both figures. They are actually good friends and Jones often has Fuentes on his show - they just did last week actually.

Rev Left Radio

Spot on. IN fact, if you watch the end of his shows wherein he takes superchats from listeners, they are often vulgarly racist and anti-Semitic in non-ironic ways, so yes, they read between the lines and many of them do take it seriously. And to your point about "hiding power levels" he of course says that every show and recommends his listeners do the same: conceal their true views and try to infiltrate the institutions and upper echelons of society.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, he does have increasingly mass appeal. He says in the last few months he gets recognized and lauded everytime he goes out in public where for years before this he was much more niche. He has absolutely launched into the mainstream, his tweets regularly get triple what JD Vance, Ben Shapiro, Ted Cruz, etc. get. Among Gen Z in particular he is as well known as Tucker Carlson is to Fox News boomers.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for your support and your feedback! I agree they arent totally irrelelvant, but as their relevance gets confined to the Boomers exclusively, they lose overall impact in society and public discourse. Still, you are right to point out they still have massive impact that is not to be underestimated.

Jacob Bucci

Funny how you just need a radio voice and concise oration to rebrand ol fashioned racism into something more palatable for the elites. I listen to broke ass podcasters because it guarantees a degree of separation from this dark magic practiced by modern media apparatchiks. Their “beliefs” simply define their addressable market of people looking for answers, into which they dump a bunch of chum to see what advances their career. This informs how their “beliefs” “evolve” and the cycle of desperation and manipulation repeats until everyone involved loses their mind and embraces the death drive. Thanks for saving me from that!

BammEs

Damn, really? Not that it's any news, but these are proper signs of the big crisis (upon crisis upon crisis) that we're in.

JK

As always, really good analysis Brett and I think you did an excellent job of parsing through Nicks Rhetoric and exposing the veiled racism and ideology behind his words. Not sure if you caught it, but Kirk and Tucker had an interview a few months back with a really interesting segment on the financial frustrations of younger generations and I believe Kirk even goes so far as to say if not addressed, this kind of shit will lead to revolution. I hate to feed you any more right wing media, but you may enjoy hearing the right wingers talk about such things. Hell they even name drop Marx! Link with start time 23:06: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-4tNK6dfD4&t=1386s

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I listened to that entire Tucker interview with Kirk while cleaning my truck when it first came out and found it fascinating, but frustrating. While they are able to see the economic problems clearly, they oppose any real material class politic that would fight for and secure the obvious solutions to those problems. But yea, they sounded like Democratic Socialists for chunks of that convo, only to turn around and support a political party and an economic system that creates and perpetuates those exact problems.

Rev Left Radio

Incredibly well said, Jacob. I appreciate the support, god knows im working class through and through and struggling month to month like all working families in this godforsaken country. Support like yours make this whole show possible and helps me put food on my families plates, so thank you.

Jackson Duke

Good analysis Bret. Something to keep a close eye on is the beginning of a feud between Nick and smaller, further right streamers like Devon Stack. This has emerged due to Nick moderating his rhetoric like you mentioned here. I personally believe Nick views this as a real threat to his influence since he personally knows the effectiveness of attacking larger less right-wing media and more establishment media personalities from the right.

redlove

Thanks for the analysis Breht. I agree it’s useful both to know what’s going on with the right and to anticipate what arguments somewhat undecided/apolitical young people are being exposed to rather than dismissing them with the fascist label (however accurate it is). I’ve been a little thrown off when you’ve mentioned Fuentes before as I’m not sure he’s helping the pro-Palestine cause so much as usurping the genuine anti-Zionist popular sentiment towards the right and antisemitism. It would be so outlandish for outrage against Israel to lead to more trust in the antisemitic far right rather than the anti-imperialist anti-colonialist left but this trend in the right is definitely threatening to make it so. I listened to the full interview after this episode and man I really hope you come back to talk about the misogyny segment. I don’t know how Fuentes et al expect women to want a lifetime of submission and servitude in marriage rather than “marrying their best friend.” Obviously can only achieve that by legally restricting all our other options, but he also complained that supposedly “women don’t want to work.”

redlove

I’d softly push back on the idea that we won’t encounter Fuentes’ ideas in organizing spaces… hopefully not with people who consider themselves on the left of course, but for a large number of working class but largely apolitical people, their first encounter with actually articulated antiestablishment ideas are going to come from the right and not the left.

redlove

Antiestablishment mainly meaning against the two establishment political parties, for clarity

Ben

Excellent analysis - grateful for it. One point worth naming that I don’t think I heard in the podcast. in critiquing the link Fuentes makes between “organized Jewry” and Zionism: most Zionists in America are right wing Christians.

Jolene Bresney

this was such a great post, i’m glad you decided to share it. nick sounds cultivated and informed so i can see why his followers get lulled in to his worldview. it really does take critical analysis like this to understand what’s happening. his opportunism is shining and tucker is a hypocrite on his israeli stance given his father’s ties. fuentes’s america first sounds almost reasonable comparative to his extremist bedfellows. had i not heard his comments on women (SA and DA) i would have considered him reasonable and decent, but i know better thanks to others who share clips. i cannot listen to most of these alt right fascist figures most of the time so it surprised me how measured he seems. they sound almost like thought leaders, but i know better. this is what makes him dangerous. more on this please. excellent work!

Anonymous

A little late but I listened to the whole Tucker interview. There’s a part when Nick says he’s a huge fan of Stalin. What’s up with that?