Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

This one goes deep, with Breht listening to and reflecting upon a lecture by the late Professor Michael Sugrue on the philosophy of Martin Heidegger. In the course of the episode, Breht and Professor Sugrue dive deep into existentialist themes around life, death, being, time, and the meaning of it all; in the process, Breht opines on the anti-human ideology of Silicon Valley techno-dystopians, the desperate importance of cultivating an ability to reside in the present moment, the evolution of human consciousness, the dark intricacies of the shared human condition, and much, much more.

Find the full lecture here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MaobMHescwg

Files

Comments

Guilherme Carvalho

For everyone to laugh a bit, my distracted brain read it as “being on time” first (which is a topic my being is also interested in), so mid episode I started to be confused about that and checked that it was not in fact about mentioned topic. Thanks for the knowledge as always!!

Rev Left Radio

haha ill do a whole 5 hour episode on being ON time just for you! XD

Lana

Bless all philosophy majors, ya'll have so much mental stamina and I'm jealous of that lol. I didn't know much about Heidegger other than his political views so I'm grateful to have a chance to learn a bit more. On the "feeling like something isn't right" thing, and trying to solve the problem of our own lives. Very relatable, and difficult to put into words. I wonder if it is a side effect of living so long in class society and capitalism. Did our pre-class society communal hunter-gatherer ancestors experience these feelings? Did they never feel satisfied? Were they always chasing more in an effort to fill the void? If only time travel were possible. Do modern tribal communities experience this? Idk, but I feel like probably not? Sigh, just another way we are effed by this disgusting system, and I grieve for the real, genuine wholeness and authentic fulfillment that we will probably never experience in our lifetimes.

Rev Left Radio

Great point - "Did our pre-class society communal hunter-gatherer ancestors experience these feelings?' I would bet my life that the answer to that is NO, they did not. The alienation from Nature that is part and parcel of class society, and certainly capitalism, comes with an alienation from ourselves. The modern person is defined by this feeling, and the causes are almost certainly very complex and obscure, but definitely are related directly to alienation in the Marxist sense.

Jihad

Always enjoy listening to you expand on these lectures. Somehow it sounds like Heidegger is trying to construct a “grounded” metaphysics, which sounds like an oxymoron. But I guess when you’re trying to bite your own teeth like Sugrue says there’s no way to really get at this with language alone. A lot to think about thanks for sharing.

Max

Great episode and lecture! I love what you say about respect towards religion. I had to shed the smug atheism of my early twenties as well, and I’m very glad I did. The question on the intellectual difference between the three “Great Nations” of Europe is also intriguing. Much of it lies in their diverging development out of Feudalism. After the final defeat of Spain, England climbed to the top of European development erecting the mightiest Empire and being the first country in which capitalism fully developed. In a sense, the English were doing the next step of social development before being able to articulate it theoretically. That’s why this development happened alongside or dressed in medieval vestiges (until today England has feudal remnants such as the monarchy, the House of Lords, some weird boroughs and medieval stipulations etc.). The English intellectual landscape therefore tends to be very pragmatic (America took up their torch later and is somewhat similar). As you alluded to, many of the great classical economists are English, but this practical primate also includes the arts, especially poetry and literature, which are also realms of ideas not fully ripened to articulation. English philosophy however, which always had a strong emphasis on (practical) Moral philosophy (and later analytic philosophy) is absolutely terrible and on the verge of uselessness. The French came second. They could draw on the English experiences and did their practical and theoretical development in parallel. With the French Revolution they made a clear cut between Feudalism and capitalism, thus privileging the conscious political sphere. French philosophy tends to have a strong political dimension and even today the country is notorious for its culture of political activism and its many protests. Germany came last and has always been the most backwards of the Great Nations. It’s unification as a nation state came very late, when the other nations had already divided up the world (similar to Italy - the other birthplace of fascism). Prior to that, the German Reich was a carpet of various little feudal fiefdoms, religious turmoil and great regional differences (even today there is no one great city like Paris or London, but many local centres of gravity). While the English and French performed modernity, the Germans were contemplating it. The New Age came to us in the form of ideas and it was digested as such before it was actually realized. Marx often criticised the very heady approach of German thinkers to every problem – the German ideology. These differences have been engrained deeply into the cultures of the respective peoples and while having weakened, still influence the countries today- according to Zizek even in the shape of their toilets (which is actually somewhat true, lol). First and foremost however, it shaped how their language developed, because in these post-medieval times, much of the grammar and linguistic rules where formalised out of the many disparate dialects and ways of speaking. English as a language is also extremely pragmatic. It has abandoned most of its grammar and has been very flexible in taking up many foreign words, giving it an enormous vocabulary – though little internal consistency. French has a more streamlined feeling, which all romanic languages tend to have. Their grammar and how they form words is relatively regular and less organic than for example German. The French especially have a thing for linguistic purity (e.g. trying to avoid foreign words). French is a very conscious and rational language, certainly the most “constructed” out of the three. Finally, German is the language with the most complex grammar and many irregularities. It has grown to its current state as much as it was constructed, and is somewhat unwieldy, but also allows for very subtle expression of meaning. And while to say you can only do philosophy in German is obviously an exaggeration, I very much prefer to write and think about philosophy in German. It has some very powerful conceptual metaphors and also grammatical ways of expression that I miss dearly when having to resort to English. Heidegger, especially, is a master of using German to its full philosophical potential (what Sugrue says at the end about his use of language and word plays is very fitting). That being said, I do love writing in English. It is very fun, because it has such a large and colourful vocabulary that you can play around with. It also has a sort of nice and pleasing flow. English literature is really wonderful, and while I do love and cherish our own literates, there is nothing German that could come close to a Shakespeare.

Max

Funny that you word it that way. In "Was ist Metaphysik?" he uses the metaphor of a tree of knowledge. In it, metaphysics are the roots of the tree, and the Being he tries to uncover is the ground in which the roots are embedded. However, he tends to use "metaphysics" in a negative way, ascribing to the rise of metaphysics the (very early) downfall of Western civilisation.

Max

Regarding Heideggers involvement with fascism, I think it is impossible to separate it from his work. There is no possible “selective” reading that leaves out the “bad parts”. However, maybe controversially, I don’t think this means his philosophy is to be discarded as a whole. Rather, it indicates that we cannot separate ourselves so cleanly from fascism as we might wish. I used to think, in order to avoid regressive ideology, we have to sterilise us from “irrational” ways of thinking. But I ended up finding them missing towards the organicity truth requires. I now think it is a conceit of the mind to think the realm of ideas has primacy over this matter and a sanitised version of human thought will absolve us. Instead, it seems to be a matter of character that decides if we seek out the right enemies, if we devote ourselves to a just cause, and discipline the correct deviations. As much as it may displease us intellectuals, what great narrative humanity will fulfil will never be fully thought out beforehand. Heidegger (as well as Nietzsche or Schopenhauer) was unquestionably a genius of great depth, but he was also a petty man: vengeful, opportunistic and antisocial. This coloured his account of what he uncovered but it does not spoil that we can see through his eyes on something truthful and profound. Of course, that does not mean every intellectual product has the same value of meaning. There are reactionary excrements, which are nothing more than purely demagogic and repulsively shallow, and of which there is nothing to gain from. Heidegger (for the most part) does not belong in this category, though.

Jihad

Interesting metaphor, never heard of this work so thanks for the info

Arthur Bray-Simons

I listened to the little free audio sample from this episode and immediately went and got the subscription :)

Louie

Awesome episode. Got my hands on the Denial of Death. Thanks for the enlightenment on that front. Hope you’re doing all right. Your bit at the end comparing your show to “shittier shows” concerning paywall behavior sounds like a man who’s currently not confident in his output. I think I speak for many who sub to this Patreon that we’re here because we like being here. We’ll leave when that changes and you don’t need to try and convince us to stay. Hope this helps. I got a feeling at the end. Wanted to say something. Not always easy to find the right words.

Rev Left Radio

Wow, I really sincerely appreciate that so much!!! Thank you!

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate that feedback! The part at the end only came sincerely from my experiences as a podcast listener and subscriber to podcasts patreons who, its clear to me, use their patreon to put their less-good episodes, and I find that mildly disrespectful to the audience (me in this case), though also understandable on some level. Thats all! Still, I appreciate the constructive criticism, your kind words, the face that you got denial of death (awesome!), and your support of the show!!! <#

Mexican Stalin

I can see why reactionaries are anti-modernist and hate Marxism. They are the ultimate hypocrites, abusing technology for profit and creating sick societies—from the polluted factory shanty towns of the late 1800s through the 1940s and 50s, to today’s morbidly obese car-dominated hellscapes. Reactionaries are like children who can't stop eating cookies. They can't stop abusing technology in a futile attempt to bring back the "good old days," so now they lean on it to create what amounts to a "techno-Roman monarchy." Marxism, by contrast, represents societal discipline. It is like a healthy diet and exercise for the body of humanity—modernizing in a sustainable way that serves humanity rather than exploiting it. Reactionary capitalism is society binging on technology, becoming sick and unhealthy in the process. (I used ai to fix my grammar)

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely! Well said. The right simultaneously wants to defend capitalism AND traditional ways of life; Marx and Engels showed very clearly - and stated poetically in the Manifesto - that capitalism itself is constantly turning and overturning stability "all that is solid melts into air". In the face of that contradiction, and the impossibility of their politics, they inflict cruelty and violence on others and are miserable inwardly. Truly poisonous mindset.

Rev Left Radio

I think youve hit on something very unsettling but ultimately correct. I really do agree with you overall here!

Rev Left Radio

Wow, man this is soooo fucking interesting, and once again, you add a lot of depth to this discussion and are teaching me many things in only a few paragraphs! Fascinating stuff Max!

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

There’s never been a bad episode from your philosophy series. Going back to your comments about linguistics, you should bring on a linguist. I don’t recall you having done that yet. If you need help finding a guest, my brother has his PhD in romance linguistics. I think his undergrad is in Classics so he has a philosophy background too. Just a thought.

Panayotis League

Breht, I really appreciate these philosophy lecture episodes. And I particularly love your perspective as a meditator (being a long-time and very inconsistent practitioner of Vipassana myself). Also, yeah, that anti-humanist techno-nihilism is utterly foul.

Brad Northcote

Fascinating episode! I'm only about 200 pages into "Heidegger in Ruins" since that episode, thanks to a detour into Luke's "History and Class Consciousness" which offers an interesting foil (proletarians as the 'subject-object' rather than free-floating subject of history). Critical but fair engagements with "irrationalism" and perspectives like Freudian psychoanalysis are a great help in avoiding the reductive "vulgar Marxism" that says we can wait for the system's own internal contradictions to play out and bring us into socialism. As long as we remember not to essentialize the subject. I might be babbling here but had the urge to bring some cursory thoughts while the episode is still new in the feed!

Brad Northcote

One other burning thought, re our human perspective of time: I've also been struggling with OCD, and there are times when the anxiety is so all-consuming that executive dysfunction leaves little to do but remember "this too shall pass". Absolutely can relate to the sense of guilt when our windows of time is so limited and it's difficult not to crave the fleeting "moments of clarity". Haven't made the Sanghas due to family obligations, but I'm inspired, if not to meditate, then to at least do something "meditative".

anon corgi

These style of episodes are my favorite. I love hearing the connections you make and the insight your specific experiences bring to the table. As a patron, these are a real treat and I look forward to them always

Dave Miles

These episodes are great and thoroughly worthwhile. Love ya work, mate. Also, not sure if the line came from this ep or not, but… “Hope fools us while we dance into the arms of Death” absolutely sat me on my arse😹

Aiden Cain 🇵🇸 🇨🇺

"The mystery of life isn't a problem to be solved, but a reality to experience; a process that cannot be understood by stopping it. We must move with the flow of the process, we must join it, we must flow with it." - Frank Herbert

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Dave! Appreciate your support so much, and yes, thats a quote from Schopenhauer! :)

Rev Left Radio

Thank you so much, that genuinely means a lot to me!

Rev Left Radio

Amen to that! And thats awesome. Inconsistency plagues all of us meditators lol, just keeping at it over the longterm is the important thing! Insofar as I have worthwhile emotional and mental insights, I credit to my meditation practice mostly!

Rev Left Radio

Check out OCD Recovery on YT, their main thing is unconditional life acceptance as the ultimate solution to OCD. So much out there is effective treatment, but practicing and adopting radical acceptance really is the way to uproot the problem at its source - at least in my experience! I send my love and solidarity to you though, cuz i know that shit is HELL. It will absolutely pass, it always does. Take care of yourself in the meantime, my friend.

Rev Left Radio

Great points, and honestly History and Class Consciousness is one of those books ive never read but KNOW I need to. I hope to do an episode on it sometime in 2026 ;)

Rev Left Radio

Id love to! Im so curious about the subject, but know very little. Have you or your brother send me an email (andersonbrett2011@gmail.com) and ill make it happen!!! Thank you!!

BammEs

If you're writing a philosophy book on this, I BEG of you to please read The Embodied Mind by Varela, Thompson and Rosh, it weaves together theoretical/dialectical biology, phenomenology and Buddhist thought (get the second edition from 2017, the extra preface has a helpful self-criticism) and after that please read Linguistic Bodies by Di Paolo, Cuffari and De Jaeger, which makes a proper marxist turn and gets more into the specifics of language I swear to god you (and Alyson (sorry if I'm spelling her name wrong) will love that Edit: it also grapples with the interiority/subjectivity problem through dialectics

kbtdj

Dang that guy was literally a Nazi