Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, we’re joined by author and poet Too Black to unpack his essay “Nonviolence is violence, too: Somebody’s gotta die,” and to challenge the comforting myths that often surround “nonviolent” struggle. We dig into what he means by the claim that nonviolence is never actually bloodless, why he prefers the term “sacrificial violence,” and how nonviolent movements frequently gain leverage precisely because an opponent supplies the repression that shocks the public, shifts legitimacy, and forces concessions. Along the way, we talk through the research Too Black draws on including Erica Chenoweth’s work on lethal repression, and we explore his core metaphors and case examples, from confronting power like “poking a bear over honey” to the method-independent brutality of settler colonialism in Palestine.

At the heart of our conversation is a deep dialectic between Martin Luther King Jr. and Frantz Fanon, and how both frameworks, in different ways, move through violence as an unavoidable terrain of liberation. For King, suffering becomes the redemptive path, a willingness to absorb brutality to expose evil and transform the political and spiritual situation. For Fanon, revolutionary violence itself is the redemptive force, the route through which the colonized reclaim dignity, agency, and self-respect. We close by asking what this reframing means for organizers today: if rights require enforcement and “dramatizing evil” often demands real sacrifice, how should movements talk about nonviolence honestly and strategically in the world as it actually is?

Subscribe to Black Myths Podcast

Files

Comments

Finn 415

😆 this title 😆

Rev Left Radio

It hits HARD, but also genuinely points to a core argument of the essay, its not just a punchy title :)

AL

I will say, relating to the comments about abolishing the police, that the majority of folks in South Minneapolis/Floyd immediate areas are still heavily anti-police. The majority of people taking the bait, and acting as if MPD is better than the Confederates occupying our city, appear to be establishment Dems. The problem is also that our boy Mayor won't actually do anything, which is also making more and more neighbors hate the police. Just yesterday, the MPD was out with vans of troops and assault rifles on full display in my neighborhood. They are the reason that the armed Feds are getting away with this. Anyways, ACAB.

BammEs

Nonviolence or violence is a difference in tactics and should be applied in different circumstances. It's democratic socialists or "violent revolution or nothing" folks who mistake the tactic for a strategy. The system is violent, there will be, already is, violence, the question is about when you should or shouldn't answer likewise and it depends on your own organisation and the circumstances you're in

ComradeCam

Every time you two are on together I know the episode is gonna hit!

Lefty In Training

The sacrificial violence angle is so good. Like everything MLK, the capitalist order has so de-fanged non-violence. Liberals think non-violence is just peaceful protests, yet even some of those will put limits on that like not blocking the road. We are so backwards that we are not even having the arguments non-violent types were having with more aggressive types 60 years ago. The system has set both sides of the argument most are having, and neither are militant.

Andrew Blake

I think this argument is correct, I'm just not convinced it's very pertinent to praxis... feels a little boutique I think a much more compelling argument to take on nonviolence stans is that even the most famous practitioners made exceptions (i.e. Losurdo's).

Anonymous

Depends on the circumstances. Clearly participating in ICE watch has the capability of turning into sacrificial violence very quickly and should not be framed as “non-violence.” If you’re a tenant union organizer, yeah, not very relevant as of now.

Andrew Blake

I guess what I'm trying to say is that you're still just talking about labels. Whether or not someone understands ICE watch to be "nonviolent" or "sacrificial violence" is very unlikely to move the needle on them deciding to do it or not. It's a fairly interesting philosophical argument and that's about it.

Michael Xin

When you're young you think the world is nuanced and "true evil" is a childish thing that only exists in cartoons. However it turns out our world is full of human-shaped demons who believe capital is more important than all the living beings on Earth. Marx said capitalists are capital "personified", and I cannot think of a better description. Why do these rich sickos feel they have the right to murder and molest as they please? Because they see everything, including other human beings, as potential sources of profit to exploit. In their eyes we are bipedal cattle. If our labour power cannot be profitably employed, then our bodies should be extracted of all other sources of value: we are perambulating organs yet to be harvested, wombs open for surrogacy, orifices to be used for their sexual gratification. Finally, when we get wise and threaten their honey in any way, we become vermin to be exterminated. When the time comes, we will make no excuses.

SaSeigneurie

Great discussion. The bear's honey analogy can be expanded to the concept of violence itself, which is defined by the side that has the power to impose its definition of violence, namely the elite. In that sense, any act of sovereignty by the masses represents an act of violence against their control by the elites (capitalists). It reminds me of how Pr G Horne qualified the freeing of slaves in the USoA South as a violent act of economic appropriation. Closer to home, I never understood why people are OK with the idea that a random dude with a badge has the right to arrest you, often violently, out of some "suspicion" and you resisting it is considered illegal. In many (more civilised) countries, citizen are not arrest at the rate they are but are summoned to the police station.

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely, and totally in line with the guests argument!

BammEs

Definitely! Really enjoyed this conversation!

Rev Left Radio

The point of his essay imo is to complicate that normal argument and reveal it not to be the binary its often thought to be, and to show that nonviolence strategy does depend on violence (the violence of the state, oppressor, etc.) and should be clear sighted about that. But both are ultimately strategies in the tool box that should be employed in different contexts, its not an argument for one or the other. I think it behooves all of us to think deeply about the issue, especially as things continue to get worse and worse and expanded tactics of rebellion will increasingly have to be contemplated in the face of more and more belligerent oppression and fascism.

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely perfectly said, Michael. As dark as the truth you state is...

Carin Vetta

I’m not sure. I’m in my 50s, and am finding that as I continue to age and my Buddhist practice deepens, I’m seeing the world as even more nuanced that it seemed when I was very young, and in fact there’s very little to be sure of. I see hubris, othering, and black-and-white thinking as the main things that got us into this collective mess. What seems to be lacking on all sides is curiosity.

Jonathan Wood

Great episode. Question for @Bret : Off topic and I know you're super busy so I'll keep it short and sweet. The American Communist Party (ACP) looks like an unserious outfit to put it mildly. I vaguely remember you briefly talking about them. They might be that Patriotic Socialism, MAGA Communism dumb-dumbs but I can't remember? I know that unhinged clown, Haz, is involved. Hoping to nicely suggest to some comrades who are curious about the organization that it seems like a great way to get your name on a list with no upside. What do you think?

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

I'm a little behind on the podcast, but I'm looking forward to this episode. Too Black has been a guest on a number of shows I follow, and I know him as an insightful analyst, commentator, and educator. I know this will make for a rich discussion. At the same time, "groundbreaking" deconstructions of the "violence vs nonviolence" discourse are as common as grass in the radical milieu. Every few years another one comes out, sharing many of the same talking points as their predecessors. Also, the conclusions they reach generally strike me as not wildly divergent from what the average person in the street probably believes anyway ("yes, nonviolence has its place, but some foes are so evil/dangerous that the only practical defense is deadly force"). To be clear, they still often provide excellent analysis and reasoning, as I'm sure Too Black does here. One common limitation I frequently find in these takedowns of nonviolence is that they tend to assume the conclusion as their starting premise, which isn't the most helpful. A bit like debating the merits of communism by asserting in your opening statement: "of course, we all know private property and billionaire entrepreneurship have been the greatest drivers of human success and flourishing and general well-being the world has ever seen." A second is that they brilliantly eviscerate the liberal or state-apologist model of "nonviolence vis-a-vis violence," spotlighting all their disgusting hypocrisies and justifications for various forms of status quo oppression and brutality, such as those phenomena sometimes referred to as "structural violence." However, having done so, they then proceed forward with that - deservedly debunked - model. This approach implicitly invalidates all other definitions and models for nonviolence, such as those put forward by fellow revolutionaries. In my experience, leftist critics of nonviolence raise a substantial number of great points that demand deep consideration, some of which are very difficult for pacifists, including radical pacifists, to answer. ALSO in my experience, revolutionary pacifists/advocates of revolutionary nonviolence raise many great philosophical and practical points about effective work for liberation that deserve deep consideration, a lot of which get insufficient attention in most radical circles I'm aware of. You'll notice I'm not coming down definitively on either side: my contention is that our general discourse is impoverished by the way folks from both perspectives largely speak past each other, rather than engaging dialogue. I'm a podcast junky, and RevLeft Radio is in my favorite top 20. And one of the things I most admire is your commitment to a big tent approach, and to platforming guests you have substantial philosophical disagreements with. Because we have so much to learn from one another, and because it's important to affirm what unites us, as well as debating the issues where we diverge. In this spirit, I would love to see you interview a revolutionary pacifist/revolutionary nonviolence advocate, to add another layer of depth and richness to the conversation. This comment is already monstrously long (for which, my apologies), but I can furnish a list of promising candidates, if you have the interest. I look forward to listening to this episode, I'm certain there's a great deal of valuable analysis and commentary. And in addition, I know there's also a great deal of valuable analysis and commentary to be gleaned from talking to revolutionaries who take a very different perspective on the topics covered here. I hope sometime fairly soon there will be space in this podcast to explore their position as well, even if it ultimately does not change any minds about the central points of disagreement.

Matthew Pinkham

Don’t know where else to mention this. Just an idea for an interview. Are you familiar with Tad Stoermer? Author, teacher, and interesting guy! Resistance history

Carin Vetta

I would love to hear an interview with a revolutionary pacifist as well, or maybe a solo episode where Breht talks about how his Buddhist practice, especially the first precept (nonkilling), and right speech, fits in with his views on violence.

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

Have now finished the episode. As expected, this was a very thoughtful and reflective discussion. I come to RevLeft Radio for highly sophisticated political analysis, and the show does not disappoint. However, also as I expected, there were a number of limitations. First, a minor point, Erica Chenoweth is non-binary and uses they/them pronouns. Second, I appreciate Brett acknowledging towards the end of the episode that he finds Fanon's model of cleansing violence more viscerally appealing than MLK's rejection. I often see critics accuse pacifists of being motivated by personal aversion to hurting and killing others - which may be true, so I think it's important to recognize we all have biases which color our interpretations, and make us instinctively more sympathetic to some models than others, regardless of whether they actually hold up better or not. We have to name and own our biases in order to weigh the questions effectively. There's also a bit of double consciousness, where at one point nonviolent resistance is characterized as provoking violence, where a little later, there's an acknowledgment that MLK explicitly named the fact that his movement was a response to the already horrifically violent Jim Crow status quo. Whether it's armed or unarmed, resistance is always a RESPONSE to the violence that already suffused society. The question revolves around the most effective ways to resist an inherently violent system, and, moreover, to replace it with a society of justice and total liberation, where everyone is guaranteed protection from persecution, no exceptions. (The problem there is that, for the principle to be upheld, no exceptions must mean no exceptions.) Some proponents of nonviolence as philosophy believe in redeeming oppressors through their suffering - but not all. The real root of nonviolence as philosophy is that justice and liberation stem from the praxis that eschews dehumanizing, persecuting, maiming, and killing opponents, else the new society you build will be predicated on dehumanizing, persecuting, maiming, and killing, which is anathema to liberation. To paraphrase MLK, the means don't justify the ends, because they're intrinsically unified. You don't have to agree with this philosophy, but I think it's at least worth sober consideration. Nonviolence philosophy states that while it's acceptable to make the decision to risk suffering and death for oneself, it is unethical and ultimately counter-productive to make that choice for others, whatever they've done. (And, incidentally, there are modes of nonviolent resistance that seek to minimize risk to participants, as seen in, for example, Otpor! in Serbia, or certain resistance movements in Scandanavia and parts of France that saved thousands and thousands of Jews from the Nazis. Unsurprisingly, examples such as these are cited by anti-pacifists as evidence of pacifists' cowardly unserious nature, and refusal to acknowledge the suffering necessary to resist oppression when one gets too close to the honey, to use your metaphor.) Proponents of revolutionary nonviolence contend that evil in the world stems from systems, not people - a premise that, by itself, should be uncontroversial to any leftist. (No, the folks in the Epstein files don't need to abuse others as a necessity for maintaining their status. That doesn't preclude them doing so because they have unhealed trauma and live in circumstances of wealth and influence that amplify rather than curbing the catastrophic coping mechanisms they've developed. As prison abolitionist Mariame Kaba observed: "No one enters violence for the first time as a perpetrator." If I am being truly honest, I cannot say with certainty that if I were born into their circumstances and lived a life similar to theirs, that I would definitely be more moral than they are. In which case, moral condemnation on my part would be the height of hypocrisy. I can still condemn their actions, and advocate for an end to their abuses and accountability for their actions, without setting myself as intrinsically superior.) As a side point, whenever I'm tempted to say: "I am one of/on the side of the oppressed, so I inherently hold the moral high ground, and anything I do to fight oppression is morally justified"; when I say, "my enemies commit atrocities because they are evil; I commit atrocities because it's necessary - nay, virtuous - to vanquish evil"; that's me empowering the fascist in my head. Fascism, capitalism, the state - they all thrive on self-evident moral superiority, on punishing evildoers with overwhelming righteousness. The fact that the specific reasons I give and the people I condemn are very different does nothing to erase the fact that I'm using the exact same biased outlook and motivated reasoning as those I despise, or just those I strongly disagree with, for that matter. And even if I could somehow account for my personal biases and motivated reasoning, even if I had incontrovertible, objective truth that I possess the moral high ground, then so what? Just because my opponents are worse, I'm justified in doing whatever? I'd argue the USA had the moral high ground vis-a-vis Japan in World War II - that still doesn't justify Hiroshima and Nagasaki, or the firebombing of Tokyo. If, and it's a big if, I do indeed posses the moral high ground, then it's MORE incumbent on me to assure my actions are truly ethical, not less. I say this is a side point, because it's not inherently a case for nonviolent resistance specifically. One can recognize one's intrinsic moral equality with, and be filled with compassion for, the men pressured or duped or deluded into serving in the Gestapo or Wehrmacht, and ALSO believe in the necessity of armed resistance to protect one's community from their violence. But getting up on my moral high horse in respect to them is playing with fire in the worst possible way. It's for these reasons I reiterate my suggestion that your show would benefit immensely from interviewing some proponents of revolutionary nonviolence. And not liberals like Chenoweth or the coauthor Maria Stephan, but actual leftist revolutionary pacifists. Not because I think you'll be persuaded to their way of thinking, but to enrich and broaden the discussion in the ways this podcast does so well whenever you bring on a guest you hold serious philosophical/political disagreements with. I would be happy to furnish a list of promising candidates, if this is an area of inquiry you're opening to exploring further.