Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht went on Deep Into History w Arjun to discuss current events in Iran (RECORDED 3-8-26)

"Breht and I join forces to in wide-ranging discussion on the War between the USA, Israel, and Iran. We focus on the underlying causes, the mainstream media, online disinformation, and the geopolitical implications. Along the way we talk about the causes, Epstein, the politics, the conspiracies, the human and environmental costs, along with the global response form Europe, NATO, Russia, China, India, the Gulf States and the International community in general.

We bring you up to date on the events of the War right up to the moment we stopped recording. We try to help one another through the insanity of trying to make sense of the sheer amount of misinformation, outright lies, and AI slop everywhere. The conversation naturally takes many interesting and worthwhile detours along the way with tangents ranging from Operation Millennium Challenge 2002, the response of the left & right, YouTube misinformation, and exploring historical parallels."

Files

Comments

Lana

Sorry this is gonna be a long one lol! Arjun mentioned that it’s hard to believe that anything is real and I truly feel that too. It feels like we are in a post-truth era. I feel so lost and like I'm existing in a place where I feel like either nothing is real or everything is real and I can't figure out how to tease the two apart. Like, how do we analyze the validity of conspiracy after the Ep. files coming to light? Weird ass conspiracies like “the government controls the weather” and “COVID was manufactured to control the population” suddenly seem, dare I say, plausible?? Ugh. How do we differentiate crazy conspiracy theories from actual conspiracies? Breht mentioned staying grounded in material reality and hard evidence, but how do you do that when you don’t even know whether the evidence is actually real? And speaking of materialist analysis, I hope someone can help me understand something. I follow a lot of ML’s on social media and lately in regards to Iran, I’m seeing a lot of responses about using dialectical materialism to understand what’s happening. I admittedly struggle with connecting the dots between dialectical materialism and geopolitics/ history. The suggestion is always to use dialectical and historical materialism but I never see examples of what that looks like lol. So, can anyone help me understand what that means exactly? To me…analyzing something historically or something that is happening geopolitically means looking at events and historical context that occurred prior to said event, not acting like the event just happened in a vacuum all on it’s own. I mean, I have always viewed history in this way. Is it too simplistic to say that’s dialectical materialism?

Rev Left Radio

Great stuff, let me take a shot. First, conspiracy theories. I feel you haha. Its weird when the Epstein files come out, we see the depth of deception by Israel historically, the fact that JFK pushed back on Israel developing a Nuke right before he was shot... It does make you rethink things. Hell, the idea that Lyme disease was a result of a bio-engineered CIA project seems reasonable to me. But ultimately, while its okay to entertain some things, and even to investigate them, if it is clear that there is just no way to know for sure, its best to remain agnostic and set your gaze on things you can understand and reach conclusions about. I think the trap of conspiracy theories is that they ultimately lead you into an infinite rabbit hole with no conclusions to reach; at that point it becomes faith. So for me, I keep a truly open mind, but when its clear something cannot be resolved, I remain agnostic and move on. When new evidence arises, I can revisit it. Now, for the big question, how to apply dialectical and historical materialism in, say, the context of Iran. For me, the materialism part comes in a few forms: first the political economy of interests involved and the fact that imperialism IS monopoly capitalism means that our analysis of "why is this happening?!" starts with an exploration of the economic interests involved. For israel, that interest is about land and hegemony, for the US its about Israel as well as control over strategic resources, for Iran its about self-determination and resistance to economic and military domination. The dialectics comes into with a recognition that all these relationships, as well as all the relationships throughout the region and the world that are relevant here, are in constant motion and that big events are caused by contraditions. The contradiction between Israel's aspiration to regional hegemony and its desire to take over palestine and extend its borders and Irans axis of resistance that prevents exactly that means conflict is inevitable. The Contradiction between Israel's NEED of US support and the dwindling support among americans after the genocide FORCES Israel to act on a tighter time-window and force the ultimate showdown before another admin comes in and is increasingly more resistant to it and its demands/desires, etc. The contradiction between China's rise and its Belt and Road initiative and the US empire in decline trying to prevent it helps us understand a broader geopolitical reason that the US might be interested in destablizing or toppling the pro-china government in Iran, etc... I could go on all day, but by analyzing contradictions between the relevant forces - politically, economically, religiously, etc. - we can hone in on the ACTUAL CAUSES of the conflict, as well as the likely trajectories from here. Historical aspect is slightly less relevant, as its concerned with the evolution of human societies over time, but still we can analyze the history between the relevant countries and see that history as deeply embedded in and informing the present state of affairs to make further sense of it. For example, if you do not know about the Maidan Coup in 2014, you will not understand the current Ukraine and Russia war. If you do not understand the history of the communist party in china, you will not understand their rise to global super power status. If you do not understand the 1953 coup in Iran or the 1979 revolution, or the history of Israel, etc. etc. you simply will not be able to make sense of whats happening, why Iran hates the US and Israel (and vice versa), etc. All of this puts us in a much better position to understand and analyze than liberals or fascists or even the imperialist leaders like Trump and Hegseth leading the charge on the war itself! I am in class and have to go now, but please lmk if you have any follow up questions. Or things youd like me to clarify!!! I have more to say about dialectics and how to use it in analysis. I really should do a whole patreon using the Iran conflict to explain all of this in depth.

Ryan

Just wanted to say thanks for all you do & that it gives me hope. Lost my job today as a hospital physician for alleged social media comments critical of a certain country & haven’t been able to find other jobs, likely because of this. My malpractice record is clean & I’ve only done this type of work for 15+ years, but none of that seems to matter… Thinking of where else I could find work is incredibly stressful, hearing about your pivot to trade school gives me hope.

Mexican Stalin

The right wing has a monopoly on military analysis so unfortunately we still have to listen to them to get some counter information. If you listen to "mainstream" leftists like hasan they exclusively get there information from western sources. Like if we went on western sources we would think Russia has been destroyed China is gonna collapse Iran/Hezbollah is done for. Even the epstein files hasan contra points and many other leftists down played them. The "Left" is to attached to liberalism in the west what i like to call "Occam's razor liberalism"

Lars

Best of luck to you. Not to be one of those guys, but If you're in the US, I'd recommend reaching out to your state's ACLU. You don't need to reveal further details here. Just consider it.

Lars

Great episode & discussion, yall.

Eli 🇵🇸

Off topic - but I’ve been discovering Zen Buddhism for myself. You and Alyson are people whose words I trust, and it’s thanks to you that I’ve opened myself up to this wonderful practice with clear eyes and an emphasis on ENGAGEMENT with the world, not trying to escape it for my own comfort. I found a local Sangha, and my brother and I will be attending soon.

BammEs

Great discussion, it's cute to hear how excited he is to talk to Breht! I do disagree on two points: 1) reality isn't grey, it's black and white but in a yin/yang kind of way; 2) the left isn't supposed to bring calm but direction to the chaos. This may seem nitpicky, but when you get down to it these are fundamental differences between a liberal, metaphysical perspective and a revolutionary dialectic imo.

Andrea Bolt

@A_ham96 on Twitter is posting leaked videos coming out of Isnotreal. I think they’re sneaking thru the censors because they’re posting in Hebrew and the profile pic is of what appears to be a settler. Pretty ingenious if you ask me. Not sure how long it will last, but check it out before they’re discovered.

Perro Wero

Great response and YES an entire episode on exploring the Iran conflict from a dialectical materialist lense would be 🔥🔥🔥!

Lana

See I KNEW you’d give me a banger response. 🔥 I felt shy about asking my questions at first but I figured what the hell, just do it lol. I’m SO glad I did. Appreciate you and your teaching so much, you have no idea. An entire episode would be so great, but this response is a perfect foundation too. Thanks for adding examples in your response. I think part of why I struggle to connect the dots is because no one has given me concrete examples in modern times like you just did. I had notions of what dialectical materialism means like in definition and theory but no understanding of applying it, if that makes sense.

Eli 🇵🇸

This hits so hard. Can you recommend any reliable information sources? I fully got off of social media for every reason under the sun, but I feel like guerilla Instagram accounts and shit like that are the only way to get a glimpse of what’s actually happening.

Andrea Bolt

The Grayzone and Drop Site News on YouTube are both excellent sources on geopolitics… they are both doing heavy reporting on Iran. I especially love Grayzone because they focus on communist/sovereign states in particular. I’ve learned a lot from them, especially on the Ukraine/Russia conflict. Very eye opening.

Andrea Bolt

My introduction to dialectic materialism (even though I didn’t know what it was called and that it had a name at the time) was my first deep dive into Palestine. I spent a lot of time on that subject and once I got a pretty good grasp on it, I started seeing patterns of colonialism in other conflicts past and present. Once you get comfortable with the concept, you start to see red flags in developing conflicts all over the world. And believe me, the West has inflicted so much pain on the Global Majority past and present that it’ll make your head spin! Since you’re here, stick with Iran, there is an abundance of information at your fingertips on the subject. I suggest following RevLeft’s guests that resonate with you and take in all the rich information you can handle.

Rev Left Radio

Mondeweiss is good too. I actually watch Breaking Points on YT most days as a good daily coverage of news from a dissident perspective - but i do so critically, as I have disagreements with all the hosts, espeically the right wing ones Emily and Saagar. But still, when engaged with critically, its a good news round up outlet that doesnt take corporate money, is critical of Israel, economic populists, and anti-war - even anti-imperialist at times.

Rev Left Radio

haha, yea hes a really sweet guy. And yes, I agree with your points too. totally.

Rev Left Radio

Wow... I love that. And honestly its one of the best feedback comments I could get: that we helped inspire someone to jump seriously into Buddhist meditation. Keep it up, make it a part of your life, and it will open you up in beautiful ways, as awakening unfolds gradually over time. <3

Rev Left Radio

Totally agree. I listen to Scott Horton, Douglas Mcgregor, Scott Ritter. Also Jefferey Sachs, John Mearschimer, etc. I take whats useful and discard whats not. But get genuinely insightful information from them. I am no military expert, so such perspectives are helpful. I dont really listen to any left wing / popular rad lib types cuz my analysis has already outpaced them (just being honest), and I get more from other sources that I can absorb into my already existing marxist analysis. Two areas Id like to get much more knowledgable on: - Military strategy/insight/internation relations - Macroeconomics/Finance I think my analysis overall could be very helpfully informed by deeper knowledges of these things, and you wont get any of it from left liberal types, or even hard left types.

Rev Left Radio

That is so disgusting and I am sorry to hear that my friend. What utter bullshit. Its disgusting the grip they have on us, and many many people have had the same thing happen to them. The Trades are def an option. Im 37 and a first year apprentice haha. Its never too late. But as a physician there is need and demand for you, and im sure its just a matter of time before you find something. I send you my love and solidarity. I have had to start over many times myself, just keep going.

Rev Left Radio

Lana, never feel shy. You are a pillar of this community, been here a long time, and I appreciate your support so much. I promise your question is a common one. I reached out to alyson, she also had people ask her similar type questions so we are going to do a full episode early april turning this question and thread into a full episode and going deeper! So your question is directly turning into a full episode that we are excited about and will hopefully be useful and helpful for many many more people!!!

Rev Left Radio

IN FACT, my good friend who is also a Neuroscientist had similar questions. Hes the smartest guy I personally know haha. Explaining it helps me deepen my understanding too. THATS dialectics haha. But yea stay tuned for full RM episode on exactly this!

Lana

Awesome!! So hyped for that episode!

rhubarb

thanks again for another great episode! it would be really cool if you could get overzealots on the pod. he’s done a lot of really good work recently debunking israeli myth-making amongst other things, and i think you two would have good chemistry and it would be great to listen to! much love from australia 🖤💛❤️

Jack Sauer

I listen to Andrew Napolitano's podcast pretty regularly, as my snapshot of what the America-First Right is saying, and I do genuinely glean some good insights into the US military (and specifically its limitations) from the multitude of former War on Terror officers he has as regularly guests. He's an annoying libertarian, but I think he's probably the most worthwhile voice to listen to on the US right without having to suffer through the likes of Fuentes. Plus I always get a good laugh whenever Scott Ritter or Doug MacGregor says the most off-the-wall stuff about communism and the USSR that you've ever heard in your life.

Haazen

I have to dosagree with some of the premises discussed in this episode around the War with Iran. Every US president has in one way or another contributed to this climax. Presidents are the face of an entire foreign policy formula tailored by the ruling class. See Brookings institute which path to Persia. See how Syria was worn down through years of war, sanctions and rebel group funding. Direct bombing runs are possible because Syrian air defenses were destroyed in the process of installing Al Shara/jolani. The whole Arab spring movement led to anti iran leadership much like the coups in Europe against Russia. Iraq and Afghanistan invaded, both surrounding iran. The US ruling class understands the role iran plays on the geopolitical scale and its fall would isolate russia and china with a serious blow to multipolariam. Trump is an idiot and would never be able to conceive this. It would have happened under any president, just like the path to today was a multipresident process.

Haazen

Israel is an imperial project. They have interests that directly align with the US's. Nothing Israel does can be done without US support. The framing of Israel being the on driver seat is also something I disagree with. There is a dialectical relationship between the two but the US benefits from using them as the meatshield in this effort to secure hegemony. It helps the US on the media as well, it distracts from the primary contradiction of US imperialism. The zios are nothing but an instrument that has interests fully aligned with the US.

Ben

drop site did an incredibly hegemonic interview with robert malley where they allowed him to parrot narratives about slaughtering of protestors and the idea that iranians wanted an invasion. they were brilliant on Gaza but would take what they say with a grain of salt now. would highly recommend Danny Haiphong’s show on YouTube. independent, brings on a wide variety of credible hosts coming from a variety of anti-imperialist backgrounds. not a lot of marxist analysis but good for updates on the war

Ben

you summed up all that needed to be said on the topic lol i don’t get why Arjun is so insistent on vilifying these analysts

Rev Left Radio

I think your criticisms are very well thought out and totally valid. I agree the relationship is more dialectical and mutually beneficial as you say, but I still think this war at this time is clearly more beneficial to Israel than to the US, certainly to Trumps presidency. I think Trump is a dunce and was manipulated into it by neocons and zionists who played his ego like a fiddle and leveraged his ignorance against him. I truly do not think he thought it would be this bad or difficult. I also would argue that Netanyahu has tried to convince basicially every president since Clinton to go to war in Iran, and it was only Trump that finally gave the green light for the reasons mentioned above. I think the US deep state, CIA, Mossad, and the Israeli state are so intertwined that its reductionist to say Israel "tricked" the US into the war, but zionists did manipulate trump into this disaster, if I had to guess. Either way, your overall points and arguments are spot on and I agree with you.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, same! I agree with you. I also listen to Scott Horton who is very similiar. I do appreciate Napolitano's humanizing of Palestinians, - Hortons too. Lots of right wing anti-israel folks dont do that (Nick Fuentes for example doesnt). Ritter and MacGregor are compelling listens, but yea, they are def anti-communist lol and its hard to get a bead on just how true their analysis is. Though I often want to believe cuz they make it seem like Iran is spanking tf outta US-Israel. Mearsheimer is another good voice in this realm.

Rev Left Radio

yes, I am a fan of overzealots work on YT! Great stuff. Id love to have him on. Not sure how to contact him. But ill look into it. If you are in his community, drop the idea of a collab in there too ;)

Rev Left Radio

Yes, everything must be engaged with CRITICALLY. There is no perfect source of info. It must be searched out, collated, synthesized into our existing analytical framework, etc. No straightforward easy single source for sure. Drop Site did have that issue and were called out hard on it, overall though, they still do some valuable journalism imo.

rhubarb

yay!! i’ll definitely see what i can do :)

Haazen

You bring up a very good point. Netanyahu has indeed been pushing for this for so long and trump is very easy to influence. Im sure the epstein ties had a play on this one way or another. With this in mind I now think the contradictions all played out to this point. US interests, the zionist entity interests, and Trump's (idiotic) presidency all culminated in this disastrous war. May the world see better days as a result.