Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, we’re joined by professor Joel Wainwright (co-author of Climate Leviathan) to discuss his newest book, The End: Marx, Darwin, and the Natural History of the Climate Crisis. Together, Breht and Joel explore the intellectual impact Charles Darwin had on Karl Marx, and why it matters for the ecological crisis of our time. Wainwright argues that Marx’s study of Darwin helped him develop a distinctly Marxian concept of natural history, reshaping how he understood history, nature, and capitalism itself. Reading Capital through this lens, they unpack how Marx’s critique becomes an ecological critique: capitalism as a social formation that reorganizes the human–Earth relation, producing crisis, “surplus” populations, and new forms of domination - and have some fun disagreements along the way. They close by asking what this natural-historical Marx can contribute to building an eco-socialist alternative beyond capitalist growth and climate catastrophe.

Check out Breht and Alyson's previous episode on Climate Leviathan HERE

Files

Comments

StinkLord

I don’t think I understood dialectical materialism until it was pointed out that it was just Darwin’s theory of evolution applied to human history

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

Breht, I have endless admiration for your patience and ability to engage in meaningful discussions with people whose beliefs differ from your own. I think I struggled a little with this conversation because it didn’t feel like your guest reciprocated the same open mindedness that you showed throughout the conversation, perhaps because of his academic expertise on the subjects he spoke about. There was a matter-of-factness that he spoke with that made some of his points feel more like a lecture than a discussion. But the way you engaged with his expertise and opinions made this an excellent episode, as always! Thank you for the important work you do. 🙂

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

I think some of my difficulty with this conversation stems from a larger critique that I have of academics. By nature of their research and expertise, they approach conversations as an opportunity to share what they have learned and deduced. But being well educated on a subject doesn’t mean you don’t have more to learn or shouldn’t consider others’ perspectives! Anyways, apologies for the ramble, I truly appreciate the way you navigate conversations like this one so respectfully. ❤️

John

I'm reading "Communism: The Highest Stage of Ecology," and among many great adpects of it I find the pushback on degrowth refreshing. Its an Iskra book translated with your boy Hakamaki, and I'm wondering if you intend to cover it! Love love love the ecological content. Really appreciate it. I'm a native plant gardener by trade, and it's an endlessly mindblowing and insightful world, building ecosystems, fulfilling my own ecological niche as a good land steward.

Derek B Local Man

Should've asked him what punk and hip hop acts he's into!

Nick

This is the best episode yall have done in a long time (they’re all amazing but this one sticks out)- really rich and respectful push back and exploring these dialectics

Brad Northcote

There are so many fascinating threads to comment on in this conversation (didn't expect the Dune reference!), so just a couple that come to mind. One of the most instructive texts for coupling socialism and Darwinism is, strangely enough, the anarchist Kropotkin's work "Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution". There's something in its analysis that speaks to a directional tendency of nature without being teleological. On the second thread, I get the sense that your guest could describe himself as Althusserian. His approaches to different threads of the conversatoon evoke both an epistemological break with Hegel and "aleatory materialism". Neither of which, though, seem to strictly necessitate abandonment of the project of building a vanguard. What they do is problematize the optimistic fatalism that would have us await the socialist rapture.

Sean Sullivan

I was beyond thrilled when I saw this episode drop this morning and it did not disappoint!!! China and vanguardism are two things I really needed shored up. These topics can be hard for me to explain to people who don’t get into politics. Hearing you two exchange thoughts and critiques helped me massively. What I appreciate most about Joel is his precision and thoroughness. I know this can be challenging but you managed this discussion incredibly well, Breht! Thank you so much for the episode.

JK

This was a fantastic conversation. I can appreciate the concerns and arguments he raises about Darwin and dialectics. What I’m really going to have to chew on though, and what I hope to hear more about, was his aversion from the Vanguard Party. It’s especially relevant to me personally as that type of organization is what I see directly as my purpose at the moment. It begs the question, if it worked for the Bolsheviks, why wouldn’t it work as a tactic for us today? What has fundamentally changed besides the proletariat growing even larger with more leverage than ever before? If it’s not the right tactic for the moment, what could possibly replace it? Perhaps he just associates the Stalinist degeneration of the USSR as a direct result of Bolshevism. A lot to parse through but hes certainly an intellectual powerhouse and I deeply enjoyed your conversation. Keep up the good work comrade

Deven Toast

I agree. Very smart guy but I did feel he was a bit condescending. Breht also does literally say "dialectical" in his explanation of evolution at 1:29. The arguments on China are definitely solid ones to grapple with. I find the general dislike of every country with a Communist Party leadership to be suspicious. Especially from Western leftists. It seems idealist and chauvinist to have such strong negative opinions on countries that are actually doing something different, because it doesn't fit their image of communism. Especially baffling that he thinks children should be taught political economy BEFORE understanding the general framework their country uses to make decisions.

SaSeigneurie

Listening to this I was reminded of the text "Left-Wing" Communism: An Infantile Disorder". Joel Wainwright is the typical scientist that appears to have a fetishism for "big men" such as Darwin & Marx, something as a scientist I see a lot in the scientific community. In that sense, he appears to essentialise concepts, looking into "purity of thought" that is almost anti-materialist. His take on China is just ridiculous, typical of westoid leftists, and Brent should have been more thorough in countering his confused arguments. People like Radika Desai, Michel Hudson, Carlos Martinez among many others (all westoids as well since many in the west only listen to westoids) would have trashed him within seconds. Finally, regarding what happened in Minneapolis (MN), as someone living in Minneapolis in one of the neighbourhood where ICE was highly active, I can say that the social networks built in response to those thugs have almost completely disappeared, a pattern similar to what happened after George Floyd's murder, while the liberal fascists (the Democrats) have been once again trying to hijack more radical demands. In fact, those recurrent uprisings in Minneapolis that die done within months show why a vanguard party is actually necessary to direct and build upon social rage. Brent, please bring more non-westoids guests on. There is no point trying to talk to aristocratic proletariat or even worse, aristocratic scholars like Joel, since the end goal of the latter group is, after all, to secure their position within society by maintaining social situations that allow them to continue to publish & get paid. I know that because I am a scientist evolving within this system.

chep

Can you recommend anything to read on China regarding this topic? Or a podcast, doc etc. Up for anything to learn more! Thanks comrade

SaSeigneurie

The 'Tricontinental Institute for Social Research' has several "dossiers" on China. 'The International Manifesto Group' has several presentations with many scholars. Recently, 'The Deprogram' had 2 China shows. You can also look up 'Proles of the Round Table' who had some on it. As for books, a short one to start with is "The East is Still Red" by Carlos Martinez.

Hoàng Nguyễn

I completely agree with your take regarding the China issues. Many leftists in the Western Hemisphere are so caught up in their little bubble of academia, just thinking of all socialist projects as being pure, having no contradictions to be solved, is an absolute anti-materialist approach. I find it funny that he was criticizing China for its top-down approach and for still operating under the capitalist influence of the dominant West, without taking into account the broader context of why China needs to develop in that specific way.

Brad Northcote

Addendum re China: I would offer a complication in that there was a time when "hardline Marxist-Leninists" explicitly criticized marketizing & geopolitical maneuvers as revisionist vacillations in their party line (and were attacked as "dogmato-revisionist"). But as always, I appreciate and echo your principled position of anti-imperialist solidarity.

Hawkeye Bufkin Plank

Phenomenal episode, looking forward to your next interview with Joel. Love from Reno NV

JK

The deprogram episode on China was an absolute joke. Those kiddies are only interested in vibes and youtube/twitch viewers now. Or in Hakims case, pitching me an ad for headphones during his video on socialism. They are not serious Marxists. "Socialism 4 All" did a really good job listening through that deprogram episode and pointing out all the contradictions the deprogram guys make. They never seriously try to answer the actual concerns about China's mode of production and just handwave away all criticisms. Granted, S4A is a jerk off, whom I don't like. He isn't exactly a people person (which is probably why he only does videos alone). But, he was spot on for his china analysis, would recommend checking it out

Brad Northcote

Thank you! I will say they've each done some great work at times and I try to approach good faith with comradely critique. That said, I listened through that episode and it was a slog. Alternative reading list: -Battle for China's Past by Mobo Gao -From Commune to Capitalism by Zhun Xu -Afterlife of Chinese Communism (various authors). State-managed capitalism allows for some genuinely rational, constructive projects with genuinely positive outcomes...but when decollectivization or privatization of steel mills is pushed for by the state and hindered by mass popular movement, the hope for socialist revival is in the workers.

Clinton Fraser

I think of survival and how it influences our consciousness. In today's global complexity real survival is going to need a great leap forward in realising how we are all interconnected internationally and our common unity of class struggle transcends those divisions.

Liv

Breht, have you heard of the book Programmed to Kill by Dave McGowan? It would be such an interesting topic to cover on Rev Left, especially nowadays since it ties into systematic abuse from the Epstein class and the rabid anti-humanness in the US Empire.

Anthony Bifulco

Thank you for this episode. A robust debate on the Marxist left is an imperative, just as it was for the for Castro, Che, and the Cuban revolutionaries efforts to build communism in the 1960s. Dogmatism is the source of ruin, so this kind of debate is the antidote. Debate robustly, but never forget to ultimately close ranks. We are in this together.

Brigitte Debord

The Deprogram is mainly a podcast about dick jokes 😂

Landis Brown

I don’t know. I had a hard time listening to him after his dismissal of Engels.

anon corgi

Your discussion of Dialectics of Nature helped me clarify and deepen my understanding of both dialectics and evolution

louis stephens

You did a really good job with this interview Breht! Joel doesn’t seem like the easiest person in the world to interview, but I think you showed a lot of compassion and grace as the interviewer. Job well done!

Lesley Braver

It’s truly hard to listen to a smart guy about many things be so deluded by western “Marxist” propaganda about China.

Rev Left Radio

Haha, yea, but I mean its also fair to say that he is a super smart dude and instead of being brainwashed by propaganda, may genuinely come to different conclusions than us! He said hes visited china and its his honest assessment. I think hes a critical thinking and good faith guy who just genuinely disagrees with us. I have some great comrades who are Maoists and have deep criticism of China too. But I get the frustration

Rev Left Radio

Its a live debate in Marxism tbf, but yes, I am an Engels Partisan lol

Rev Left Radio

I totally agree! Would love to host more straight up debates between honest and good faith left wing interlocutors. Hard to find people for it tbh.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, in fact I bought a copy few months back. Havent dived into it yet, but its intriguing!!!

Rev Left Radio

Totally agree. Along with techno-material evolution comes an evolution of consciousness; they basically co-occur in real time. A global, dialectical, and interconnected consciousness - along with its expanded sphere of moral concern - is already emerging through us. The catastrophes we are living through accelerate the spread of this consciousness out of material necessity.

Rev Left Radio

We have an episode coming up on China leading the charge on green new energy and infrastructure, and I just had an episode with Torkil Lausen arguing that China is in fact developing a new mode of production. Ive probably had dozens of pro-china episodes with Eastern and Western scholars and organizers alike. One episode with a dissenting view should be acceptable in the context of our broader slate of work and interviews. I didnt expect the china stuff to come up, as it was a digression from his book, but did push back - albeit politely - in real time. Rev Left has always allowed guests who do not fully align with ML positions on the show to discuss their work, and there is no difference. I still think there is plenty we can gain from Joel and his work, both this book and Climate Leviathan. We did an episode on the latter and were critical as well!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you JK. Yes, I absolutely agree with you and am def an advocate of the Vanguard model, hands down. We did an old Red Menace episode on "What is to Be Done" by Lenin where we go into DEEP detail about this issue specifically, if you havent listened to that one yet! Thank you again for your support of the show!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Sean, glad you found it useful my friend, and I appreciate your kind words and your support!!

Rev Left Radio

Great feedback and insightful input AS ALWAYS Brad, thank you! Yes, wrt China, someone described themselves as "Marxist-Leninist anti-revisionist with a soft spot for contemporary China" and I think that gets as close to possible as my "line" personally. You and I have discussed this before though of course, so I know you know! :)

Rev Left Radio

I almost did. I grew up on Minneapolis underground hip hop and was bout to pull the trigger on the question, but got sidetracked and never got around to it!!

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate your kind words, and I am def sympathetic with your arguments overall, my friend. I like Joel and lot and apprecaite his work and his willingness to come on and talk with me. He is the one asked to come on and talk about his book, so he deserves the leeway imo. As a host, my job is to help highlight his ideas, ask interesting questions, and provide meaningful and interesting feedback, analysis, etc. in real time. I enjoyed the debate / back and forth with him and would love him to come back on to hash those disagreements out even more! In any case, your support is deeply appreciated!!

Rev Left Radio

I really am happy to hear that. I too think its sooo helpful. Im teaching a class on dialectical materialism for socialist night school and use it in that curriculum too! I understand Joel disagrees, but I am not budged from my position on that one haha

Lesley Braver

I appreciate that deeply as well as your attempts to push back! W this question I kinda feel like the coming years are going to make it more and more obvious that china’s path is not only divergent from, but completely opposed to, the mess that is global capitalism

Zentigeist

Really great episode. Marxism as a natural history is so fascinating, especially as a biologist/stem head myself. I'm going through a period now of deeping my ecology knowledge too so this episode came at the best time. Not sure if I'm entirely convinced either way but I do LOVE engaging with the topic. Each time I learn something new or get a new angle on it, great stuff. Love the convo and love your emphasis that disagreement is an invitation to learn and consolidate your own knowledge. Likely why Rev Left has always been my top show haha.

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

Great point about the distinction of your role as host and his role as guest + subject matter expert, thank you for providing this framing! I would definitely be interested to read his work and listen to a part 2 of this discussion. Always appreciate you reading and responding thoughtfully to your Patreon episode comments!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you, my friend. That compliment at the end means so much to me!! I appreciate your support so much, and salute to you for your career in biology and STEM!

Lefty In Training

Exactly. To me, that reality confused me when listening to that portion of the interview. Breht's point was Dawin clarified Marx, which seemed to be a large part of Joel's thesis.

Lefty In Training

Overall enjoyed the episode. Found some of his critiques either dogmatic or missing essential lines of analysis, but overall I do enjoy an ecological expansion of Marxism. Just to comment on something different, I enjoy that you don't curate your guests so tightly as to push a 100% cohesive line. That's the job of a vanguard, which you and your program are most certainly not. As a DSA member, I wouldn't expect a 100% consistent political line because that isn't their function. I'm hoping listeners arent listening to you (or anyone else really) to be handed a political line. What I do take from episodes like this is how different ideas can be pitted against each other to refine one or both instead of simply one defeating the other. At the end of the day, we will engage with people like Joel who will have different ideas than ours, and we will need to discuss our and their ideas in nuanced but still confident way.

Lefty In Training

Probably my one critique of his presentation that I will bring up is his inconsistency on some Marxists having a so-called hope in China making a socialist turn vs his hope for more spontaneous, less vanguardist means systemically breaking from imperialism. While I do share your agnosticism on China, their and many other Global South anti-imperialist revolutions were explicitly Marxist-Leninist adapted to their conditions. I don't know of such a revolution at the scale of a nation state using Joel's ideology. Just as I would be glad if China does make the socialist turn, I'll be happy if Joel's approach produces a revolution on the scale of a USSR, China, Vietnam, or Burkina Fauso.

JK

I'm sure I've must have listened to it at some point, as I immediately crush all your content. But I will go give it another listen to refresh myself!

M Workman

As someone who was on the ground in MN during the general strikes, I can say for sure that well organized formations including aspiring vanguard parties were actually quite instrumental in the organization and reach of those events. While spontaneity was the trigger, it was the organized forces on the ground that turned it into what it was, giving direction to mass outrage. Appreciate your discussion here and the discipline in your responses, although I disagree with much of his conclusions.

Zentigeist

Ahhh I appreciate the reply! Thank you! :)

Gabriele Pumo

Who else is using this episode to apply the lessons from “who paid the pipers of western marxim” on leftist intellectual production within empire??? This is like a perfect case study. Lenin bad boycotts gooooooood!

Liv

I will warn you that the first part is really dark, but McGowan does a great job of sticking to the research and facts of the situation, no glorification of trauma which I appreciate. It seems to be one of those books that exposed so much, yet didn't receive any attention due to the suppression efforts he mentions in the book. Gah!! I haven't been able to put it down, MK-Ultra has always interested me, but man, the connections made in the book really bring to light how much further this network goes and the real grand conspiracy of the global ruling class.

Beach

First thing that came to my mind as well. Straight to chompsky lol

Gabriele Pumo

Rest assured that’s never gonna happen. Revolutions don’t happen through spontaneity and boycotts. The only apparently spontaneous revolutions that do work are color revolutions, precisely because they are not spontaneous at all and need the complicity of western intelligence assets and the media arm of empire, and local comprador burgeoisies and fascists. It’s not a concidence that the intellectuals that peddle such nonsense are those that get uplift within academia and publish well with verso.

JW

Great conversation Breht, thank you. You handled it well. I agree with the other commenter who brought up Rockhill's work; this was a good case study. A limitation of Wainwright's thinking seemed to be his inability (unwillingness?) to apply historical materialism to the question of the vanguard party and revolution. He seemed to suggest the "failure" of communism in the USSR and China was because of theory, rather than assessing the specific material conditions that surrounded each revolution. For example, if the German revolution had been successful, things would have turned out very differently: "Regarded from the world-historical point of view, there would doubtlessly be no hope of the ultimate victory of our revolution if it were to remain alone, if there were no revolutionary movements in other countries. When the Bolshevik Party tackled the job alone, it did so in the firm conviction that the revolution was maturing in all countries and that in the end – but not at the very beginning – no matter what difficulties we experienced, no matter what defeats were in store for us, the world socialist revolution would come – because it is coming; would mature – because it is maturing and will reach full maturity. I repeat, our salvation from all these difficulties is an all-European revolution. […] But history has taught us a lesson. It is a lesson, because it is the absolute truth that without a German revolution we are doomed […] At all events, under all conceivable circumstances, if the German revolution does not come, we are doomed." - Lenin, Extraordinary Seventh Congress of the RCP(B), ‘Political Report of the CC’, 7 March 1918, LCW, Vol. 27, pp. 92-8. (Loved the Red Menace ep on the German Revolution btw!) On a more general note, thank you so much for all the work you do Breht and for your principled analysis. I got my formerly liberal/non-political mum on to Red Menace a couple of years ago and she's now listened to every episode. She loves you and Alyson. We can now have great conversations about politics, history, philosophy, etc. Sometimes you don't need therapy, you just need political education!

Max

I thought it was quite revealing when he said the introduction of Hegelian philosophy should be forgone because it introduces a power imbalance, which is an odd thing to lament in the context of a school where you expect to learn from each other, and only makes sense if you tend to treat every theoretical exchange as a test of your intellectual prowess.

Max

I would like to give more consideration to the question of the teleology of evolution. Because the insistence on its non-teleology is precisely what makes evolutionary biology not just “science” as Wainwright posits. ‘Bourgeois science’ is a bit too broad though, rather I would say it is a cornerstone of a liberal world view. I remember an argument I had with one of my philosophy professors, who argued from a distinctly liberal perspective. And the non-teleology of evolution was very important to him, as a pillar in fending of ‘grand narratives’ he would fear to impose a totalisation on society. I also had the opportunity to take two courses on evolution in the biology department, and the professor there too was very adamant against any notion of teleology. I think they’re wrong though. Darwinian evolution had to force its way into thought against the theological image of a created and fixed order, and to this day it remains under attack from creationism. So for many biologists, every form of teleology appears in the vestments of Creationism. Their rejection of it therefore often mirrors the shallowness of what they are rejecting. It tends to collapse into a merely negative argument: evolution cannot be teleological because there is no single gravitational concept: It cannot be complexity, because there are organisms that ‘devolve’ and gain evolutionary fitness by shedding complexity. It cannot be humanity, because humanity is just one out of countless species, none of which display any inner drive to converge. And yet, for all its efforts to disentangle itself form any grand cosmic schema, evolutionary theory cannot quite rid itself of the atmosphere of telos. Its own narrative is too immense for that: the totality of terrestrial life unfolding immanently from single-celled organisms into ever more differentiated, mediated, and internally articulated forms is just too perfect not to attach meaning to. It’s the thing about creationism, I have never understood. The awesome process of evolution does lend much more credence to the notion of intelligent design than a god who just arbitrarily imposes a fixed natural state. Similar to Leibniz’ analogy to the maker of a clock: would we ascribe mastery to the watchmaker who constantly has to intervene to keep his clock running to plan, or to the watchmaker who creates a perfect mechanism that runs on its own forever once it is set into motion? In any way, it is very hard to look at the evolutionary process from single cell organisms to present day nature with humanity as it’s apex and not imagine a trajectory. I’ll leave as an addendum my interpretation of the telos of evolution, should anyone be interested in that. Just one final observation on the episode, that I cannot supress: To criticise the People’s Republic of China from the standpoint of an end it is supposedly failing to realise, while at the same time advocating a non-teleological Marxism, seemed to me a contradiction waiting to be addressed. I think fatalism also implicates a teleological order – albeit a negative one. Well, it was a very interesting episode, once again. --------- If there were a world, this would be God In contemporary natural philosophy, the distinction between living and non-living systems is most plausibly located in their relation to boundaries. A stone possesses an edge, but this edge is accidental to its being; it neither maintains nor regulates it. A living system, by contrast, exists only through the continuous production, stabilization, and modulation of its boundary conditions. Detached from its systemic whole, it ceases to be what it is. Life can therefore be described as a process of regulated exchange with an environment. The organism incorporates external matter and energy, transforms them internally, and expels what can no longer be integrated. This cycle is not static but dynamic, driven by adaptive feedback. The boundary is not merely a limit but a functional interface through which the system constitutes itself. Adaption thus becomes the driving force of life. Through adaption an organism starts to mirror its surroundings. From an evolutionary perspective, organisms increasingly internalize the structure of their environment. Natural selection favors configurations in which external regularities are mirrored in internal organization. Photosynthesis is the biochemical inscription of solar radiation; flight is the aerodynamic inscription of atmospheric dynamics; neural networks are the inscription of environmental complexity into excitable matter. In this sense, organisms are material records of the conditions under which they persist. As ecological complexity increases, organisms do not merely reflect abiotic factors but also the behaviour of other organisms. Life becomes relational in a stronger sense: adaptation responds to adaptation. This produces higher-order regularities that cannot be reduced to isolated interactions. The world begins to fold back upon itself. With the emergence of mobility, memory, and increasingly centralized nervous systems, reflection detaches from immediate stimulus. Representation appears. The organism no longer reacts solely to what is present, but to what is anticipated. This capacity constitutes intelligence. From a strictly evolutionary standpoint, intelligence is not an anomaly but a highly efficient adaptive strategy, allowing indirect, mediated engagement with reality. The human being represents the most advanced instance of this process known to us. Human cognition does not merely track local environments but constructs abstract models of extended systems: ecosystems, societies, histories, and ultimately the universe as a whole. The world becomes an object of representation in its totality. At this point, a reflexive inversion occurs. The world, having produced a system capable of representing it as a whole, appears within that system as meaningful totality. Religion arises at this threshold. It is not the arbitrary projection of fantasy, but the symbolic articulation of the world’s reflexive structure. What appears as God is the idealized unity of the processes that produced reflective consciousness. Humanity understands itself as created. From this perspective, humanity is an image of the world, while God is the imagined inverse image (Urbild) of humanity. The former is materially instantiated; the latter is symbolically condensed. This does not render religion false, but situates it within the logic of emergence. Whether religion ossifies into illusion or unfolds into insight depends on how this reflexivity is understood. If the symbol is taken as a literal entity opposed to nature, it collapses into superstition. If it is understood as the world’s self-representation within consciousness, it remains open to correction, development, and truth. Under this interpretation, God is neither external to the world nor identical with any particular state of it. The concept names the process by which the world, through life and intelligence, becomes capable of understanding itself.

Danny Boy

Love seeing the interaction and response here. Love the episode, especially your good-faith attempt to give your guest a fair hearing. I just wanna suggest you try to get Saito Kohei, who was name-dropped several times, on the pod.

Lars

I listen to & support many leftist podcasts, but RevLeft is the most consistent in challenging my beliefs, teaching me new ideas, and having guests on that scramble all of that up & introduce different ideas & pathways. Breht is a great interviewer & always produces great, expansive discussions. I sound like an ad, haha. But I really appreciate the hours upon hours of brain fuel. Like Breht, I work a blue collar job (auto manufacturing) and hopefully unlike Breht, I commute a very long way to and from work. I survive it because of pods like this. 🫡

Lars

I've got that on order + his other book "Weird Scenes Inside the Canyon: Laurel Canyon, Covert Ops & the Dark Heart of the Hippie Dream" I'm excited to read both.

Liv

Yes! My partner is reading that one now! The Phoenix Program by Douglass Valentine also pairs well with these two !!

Ryan V.

long time/first time. great episode, ty for keeping it generative. doing line struggle over philosophy is new to me. I think you described it as dm as ontology vs. dm as method? and I think you might have said it dates back to sartre? I’m wondering if you or someone could elaborate, name the debate, etc. as “dm as guiding philosophy” has always been fundamental to my understanding of marxism. would love to learn more about this particular deviation.

Sarah

Listened to this 6 days ago, came back to leave a comment and found many of my thoughts have already been addressed more eloquently by other commenters - thank you for building such an engaged and knowledgeable community! Also would just like to say, as many have, that you navigated the conversation incredibly with good faith engagement and clearly reasoned push backs as well. As much has already been said, I’ll just leave my own little take on the social biology and genetic aspect which is that it’s neoliberal capitalist impact on our health systems is deeply rooted and in my humble opinion requires a very strong re-engagement with dialects to undo. My research area is in mental health, and it doesn’t take long before you find biological determinism deeply rooted in every aspect of our diagnostic and care system, despite VERY limited or non-existent evidence. In areas where this has been challenged, it’s been replaced by a shallow psychosocial explanation of someone have gene someone experience socioeconomic hardship someone then have gene triggered bad mental health. This completely ignores that we do not have a genetic basis for any of the mental health conditions we’re diagnosing anyway! They are majorly based on our current socio-political system and hence norms. I don’t see a way through these contradictions and towards better systems of care without serious engagement in Marxist theory and dialectics, and to say that’s simply a historical moment seems incredibly reductionist and blind.

Rev Left Radio

Hey Ryan, yea so the basic debate is whether or not dialectical materialism can or should be applied outside human driven historical processes. Engels thought it could in his Dialectics of Nature - attempting to show how dialectical materialism is embedded in nature and thus the hard sciences itself. The Dialectical Biologist - the book we discussed in this ep - applies it to Biology as I apply it to Evolution via natural selection. Sartre, Lukacs, and the guest in this episode basically disagree that its a useful thing to try to do, and that it should really only be used in a more narrow way: to analyze the evolution of human society through history. I admittedly havent plunged into those thinkers work on this particular topic, have only engaged with it through secondary sources. I, along with Lenin and Mao and probably Marx, side with Engels, whereas the others do not obviously.

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate both of you very much! I never want to narrow my show to one line, as I genuinely enjoy friendly disagreements, highlighting differences on important topics, and trusting my audience to engage critically, think and reflect on what they disagree with and why, etc. For me, its unthinkable to not have that level of discourse. Maybe its my philosophy background, but engaging with ideas that diverge from my own in substantive ways is literally fun to me haha. Glad to see it resonates with you comrades too!!

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely! Thank you for that insight, and the support!

Rev Left Radio

Thats amazing to hear about your mum, my friend. Very cool to hear!! Send her Alyson and I's love! :)

Rev Left Radio

Very well said, and insightful points about the dialectical approach to mental health against the determinism and reductionism of the field more broadly (which clearly plays a superstructural role, ofc!). If you ever want to come on and discuss your research area and the dialectics of mental health, id love to have you on! shoot me an email if you are interested: andersonbrett2011@gmail.com

Rev Left Radio

This is excellent, Max!! Your right that liberal anti-teleology often presents itself as "pure science" while actually expressing an ideological fear or avoidance of totality, development, and historical direction. There’s def a Hegelian impulse here (which I align with totally) in the sense that evolution is being read as an imminant process moving toward greater complexity and reflexivity culminating in the world becoming conscious of itself through humanity - or rather through all sentient life to varying degrees imo. Your account of God as the symbolic form of the world’s self-consciousness is a genuinely rich idea that I am sympathetic with and of course dovetails with prominent strands within german Idealism broadly (though I know you are maintaining marxist materialism here ofc)

Zane Suhadolnik

I haven't even listened to the episode all the way through yet, but when it was mentioned that Verso books was the publisher and after when the discussion was underway I was thinking of Rockwell's work. I see that many others had done the same. Great episode nonetheless, you handled it way better than anyone else could Breht, no interruptions, you let the guest speak and then you gave your point of view. if only every such discussion could be done the same way, fantastic example.

BammEs

I would also be pessimistic if I was waiting for a spontaneous world revolution, my god! But really SO MUCH to say here! As a philosopher who's worked on diamat and cutting edge science in biology/cognitive science, this was a difficult conversation to sit through! Besides the ideological difference, I really dislike the whole "that was Engels's idea, Marx never thought of that" trend. I'm reasonably sure he also makes an (incredibly brief) mention of nature being dialectical in Capital, but he's certainly done so in correspondence about how he and Engels have a division of labour of sorts. I think he's incredibly wrong that dialectics doesn't help. It's not about metaphysics, it's about understanding the movements of society, about the ebbs and flows, about the constant change, about tensions antagonistic and non-, about part-whole relations, about democracy/centralism (which is crucial even if you're not demcent), the principal contradiction, and so on and so forth... (Also, incredibly unimportant but I'm 99,9% sure he mispronounces Saito in a weirdly pretentious way)

Sarah

Thank you so much Breht! I would love to come on the show (despite hefty amounts of imposter syndrome), and would greatly value the opportunity to discuss my research with you (and also to see the broader Rev Left community respond to a dialectical analysis of mental health). I have sent an email your way, from sarah.kate.morrison@icloud.com

BammEs

Btw, I haven't read the book but based on the conversation I'm not sure you're correct about his criticisms 🤔 I think he's more against dialectics than you think, based on him saying he thinks Marx went from Hegel to Darwin. He also disencouraged you from getting into "Hegelian metaphysics" at all in your course, right? He also doesn't call his work Marxist but "Marxian". It feels like he's part of a tradition that disavows dialectics more broadly, thinks they're just stuffy "metaphysics", where that doesn't mean (as it does in Hegel) "anti-dialectical", but instead more towards "ontological", the study of the foundation of reality, something which for a long time in analytical philosophy has been deemed a silly, unscientific project.

StinkLord

What’s the deal with Verso books? I’m out of the loop

Squiggle

You teased an upcoming episode on China and Eco-socialism. I'll hoping you got started via the Deprogram's ep "China Glaze!" I'm so excited to learn more.

Zane Suhadolnik

Listen to the episode with Gabriel Rockhill.

Steven Phillips

I just want to add that recent spontaneous movements haven’t resulted in any long term changes. They are either highjacked or just fade into the ether. That’s why leaving any movement to chance will never work. This has even less of a chance of being successful than economism or syndicalism

Liz Mooney

Vincent Bevin’s recent book, If We Burn essentially argues that spontaneous movements without a vanguard (he doesn’t really use these terms, though) actually have counter productive effects because they tend to create either a power vacuum or at least room for a well-organized counter-revolution force to step into the upheaval that the spontaneous movement creates, leading to worse and opposing circumstances than what led to the movement in the first place. Interesting, cautionary point to consider.

Michael Borchard

hey breht, just want to join the community here in saying this kind of back and forth is really beneficial. i found myself analyzing my own modes of thinking to see where there might be holes, which i know is part of what you want listeners to get from your show. it’s refreshing to have a guest on who challenges you! i personally felt more analytical than some other episodes. thank you for your relentless effort in developing this community of truly critical comrades

David Munkvold

Great episode! One thing id like to point out regarding January '26 Minneapolis- I think it's inaccurate to say that the strikes were spontaneous. To some extent, the mutual aid and rapid response groups emerged spontaneously. But much of the mutual aid and the "strikes" were the result of vanguard or vanguard-like parties who organized like hell, amplified and channelled the energy of the masses towards economic action. This is a marked difference from the more spontaneous events of 2020. In 2020, peoples economic action was not withholding of labor but appropriation of commodities. Time will tell, but I believe that the "strike" campaigns of 2026 have advanced revolutionary consciousness amongst the people moreso than the commodity appropriation campaigns of 2020. And this is bc of the actions of vanguard(-like) groups. To say that this "formula" is bad without offering an alternative is low-key backwards. A "formula" that I have seen work: vanguard(-like) parties coordinating a massive withholding of labor. To romanticize spontaneity + unknown alternatives is not helpful. We don't got much time to experiment here

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

As a mid-level student of revolutionary theory and history, I agree with Breht's critique about the limitations of spontaneous uprisings. As a non-Marxist Leninist leftist, I agree with Joel's critique about the limitations of vanguard parties and vanguardism. While I'm skeptical of spontaneity, I do agree with Joel that full communism/total liberation will most probably be achieved through an innovative process with no direct antecedents in previous models of social change. We can certainly learn from previous examples - Marxist-Lennist and non-Marxist-Leninist alike - but not treat them as a blueprint for the future. I also agree that it will have to be a global process, not a matter of shifting individual countries 1-by-1. As someone coming to the topic from this perspective, (and as someone who does not have a knee-jerk aversion to pacifism and philosophical nonviolence), I'm highly influenced by George Lakey's model laid out in his book "Strategy for a Living Revolution." Lakey's model is the best theory of revolutionary theory I've encountered that reconciles my criticisms of the existing proposals for revolutionary change discussed above. I was also a little perplexed to hear Breht share, near the end of the episode, his conviction that the Chinese Communist Party leadership believe they're building socialism. Not having made a particular study of current Chinese politics, I can imagine this observation is accurate, but if that is their mental state, then so what? I always thought that judging a person or group based on "what's in their heart" was bourgeois moral analysis, as Breht discusses in one of the episodes that came out a little after this one. From a materialist perspective, I thought it was commonly accepted that people frequently act in ways that are directly contrary to their professed and perhaps truly heartfelt values and intentions, based on the constraints and incentives of the structural positions they occupy. Surely a materialist reading would not start with the Chinese Communist Party leadership's beliefs about what they're doing, but on the material impact their policies have on peasants, proletarians, ethnic and religious minorities, and other deeply marginalized and traditionally disenfranchised strata in the Chinese government's administration? From this perspective, they deserve enormous credit for lifting so large a number of people in Chinese territory out of extreme poverty. This is an unambiguously good thing, deserving of our admiration and praise. While emancipating populations from extreme poverty is a laudable project, it is not necessarily the same thing as instituting communism, so a further question must be asked: has the Chinese Communist Party instituted a wholesale transfer of power over the means of production from a small elite into the hands of the proletariat and the population in general? The answer to that question is clearly "no," so the obvious immediate followup question must be: is there strongly compelling material evidence that the policies of the Chinese Communist Party are aligned with making that transfer of power over the means of production into the hands of the proletariat and the population in general over time? As I said, I've not made much study of current Chinese politics, so I'll have to leave that answer to persons who are more informed on the subject. But I would think for materialists, this is the appropriate line of inquiry to judge the Chinese leadership's communist credentials, rather than whatever they believe about their policies?

Jonathan

I'm a little late to this party! I'm a somewhat new listener and am playing a bit of catch up on older episodes. Just listened to it and really enjoyed this particular episode. Joel mentions Kohei Saito multiple times, and I think that he would be a great guest to have if he's not already been on the show before. His "Slow Down" book was a very interesting read.