Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Breht is joined by writer, intellectual, and poet Too Black to discuss his essay “Nonviolence is Violence, Too (Part 2)—We’re All in the Gunk.” Together, they critically examine the liberal mythology of “nonviolence” as a pure moral alternative to violence, arguing instead that all movements operate within conditions already structured by state, colonial, racial, and imperial violence.

Drawing from the Black freedom struggle, Ghana’s independence movement, Kwame Nkrumah, Martin Luther King Jr., Malcolm X, the Black Panther Party, Gandhi, Indian independence, riots, armed resistance, and the “positive radical flank,” Too Black shows how so-called nonviolent movements have often depended on the threat, presence, displacement, or redirection of violence in order to win concessions.

Rather than offering a simplistic celebration of violence, this conversation asks us to think more honestly about power, confrontation, sacrifice, propaganda, state repression, and the real historical conditions under which oppressed people struggle to breathe beneath the boot. At its core, this is a discussion about what movements actually do, how victories are actually won, and why peace is not the absence of conflict, but something that must be fought for.

Listen to our previous discussion on Part 1 of Too Black's essay here: https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/nonviolence-is-violence-too-somebodys-gotta-die

Subscribe to Black Myths Podcast

----------------------------------------------------

Support Rev Left and get access to bonus episodes: www.patreon.com/revleftradio

Make a one-time donation to Rev Left at BuyMeACoffee.com/revleftradio

Follow, Subscribe, & Learn more about Rev Left Radio https://revleftradio.com/

Files

Comments

Monty O’Blivion

This right here is why police kill over 1000 people per year. This is why ICE is so fucking brutal. They know they have a monopoly on violence, they know the American people are unwilling to use violence against them (yet they’re almost eager to use it against their neighbors on behalf of empire), and it completely enables them to use boundless unchecked violence against us. It will only get worse, until we prove that we can and will return fire. That requires organization and training. This discussion along with part one articulate that point so well. I love it anytime Too Black comes on the show.

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

I love the conversations you have with Too Black, the way he describes his ideas through analogies and transparent language is easy to digest. Will definitely read both essays and will definitely be listening to the Black Myths Podcast to hear more from him!

SaSeigneurie

I agree with Too Black when it comes to be more straightforward regarding the challenge to alleged “allies” of our movements. Living in & being married into a typical USoA midwestern family, I totally see the hesitations of Brent when it comes to criticising people’s faults. Such hesitations symbolised by the famous “Minnesota nice” behaviour are misguided because effectively they lead to the total absence of constructive criticism. I always compare political discussions I have in the USoA with those I had back in France: in France, it is not uncommon to see people yell at each other over political differences but then shake hands & got for a beer afterwards. Even within couples I have seen extremely diverse political views & stances. This I nearly never observed in the USoA. While these could seem like circumstantial evidence, I ask all amurikans to truly ponder how many right-winger friends they actually have or interact with. More generally, the idea that one should never make others feel uncomfortable as a driving current within the USoA culture has led to effectively never challenge people’s ideologies, and we all see the result now: support for a live genocide, political disengagement & apathy, doomerism & couch revolutionary behaviour.

StinkLord

I live in an extremely liberal area and what I’ve noticed is that when I have tried to talk about politics, the response from liberals is to disengage entirely once they are uncomfortable. they don’t really understand what their beliefs are, don’t want to question them, and definitely don’t want to talk about it with someone they are now perceiving as MAGA (can’t forget they still live in a duopoly that they haven’t questioned, so me calling Obama or Biden war criminals automatically makes me a Trump supporter in their eyes). So the conversation gets shut down and i get written off as MAGA without a single word ever being said. The silence is the worst part . But you’re right, and Mao talked about this too https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-2/mswv2_03.htm

StinkLord

There’s a quote in the video game Disco Elysium (the creators explicitly thanked Marx/Engels when accepting awards for it…they have since been ousted by the studio and lost IP rights to create their sequel!) where a character says “The mask of humanity falls from capital. It has to take it off to kill everyone - everything you love; all the hope and tenderness in the world. It has to take it off, for just one second. To do the deed. And then you see it. As it strangles and beats your friends to death…the sweetest, most courageous people in the world. You see the fear and power in its eyes; then you *know*…. That the bourgeois are not human.”