Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • May AMA.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

Files

Comments

Nancy Kogel

Thanks so much for this podcast. A small language note: would you consider avoiding speciesist expressions such as "kill two birds with one stone"? PETA has suggested alternatives like "feed two birds with one scone," which convey the same idea without normalizing harm to animals. For those of us who see animal liberation as part of a broader commitment to justice, compassion, and respect for vulnerable beings, these shifts in language matter. Thank you for considering it, and thank you again for the thoughtful discussion.

Nancy Kogel

Thank you both for this rich discussion. One point especially stayed with me: the idea that we need not only a new society, but a new human being. Che spoke of creating a new consciousness, and you both spoke beautifully about meditation helping loosen the grip of ego, increasing patience, compassion, and self-awareness. That left me wondering about a question I rarely hear discussed on the left. If we are committed to overcoming domination, exploitation, and the normalization of violence, where does our relationship with other animals fit into that project? Breht has acknowledged before that veganism makes ethical sense, which I appreciate. To me, that makes the question even more interesting. If meditation helps us become less attached to old habits and more aligned with our values, what might it mean to extend that circle of concern to other sentient beings? Animal agritorture is built upon the routine domination of the vulnerable by the powerful. It consumes enormous amounts of land, water, grain, and energy, contributes significantly to ecological destruction, and conditions us to see some lives as existing primarily for the use of others. For me, the issue is not simply diet. It is whether the "new human being" we seek to cultivate can be grounded in a deeper ethic of ahimsa, compassion, and solidarity with all who can suffer. As someone influenced by both dialectical thinking and contemplative practice, I find myself wondering whether animal liberation is not separate from the struggle for human liberation, but one of its logical next steps. Thank you again for a thought-provoking conversation.

Monty Fuch

Breht I have a question about the Marxist theory of value. Can an example be given in which “the worker generates far more in value than he ever earns from his labour in the form of wages” can be demonstrably quantified? Is it, for example, as simple as stating (figures pulled out of thin air) ‘In 2009/10 Apple reported profits of $3.5bn after annual turnover’ Yet also, ‘In 2009/10, Apple paid all of its employees globally $11.5m’ And the differential between the two represents ‘value’?

Lawrie Coombs

Look up The Red Brigades: NSW Australia, militant union organisation etc

Lawrie Coombs

Re. Music, aesthetics and our still multiple influences in society. This links hip hop, dance music and popular culture with communism. The aptly named Leftfield. This is almost 30 years old, still one of my favourite records/music videos. https://youtu.be/cJGg_vdSPaI?si=bM038gH1lZG40NtK

Mort Crim

Would love to know what East LA punk bands Alyson was referring to!

Daughters of Delos

When is there going to be another Socialist Night School? Would love to be at the next one. Comrade Across the River

Cody

Hey Breht just wanted to ask if you knew the YouTube channel “wisecrack”? It’s ended now but one of the main dudes from it named Micheal burns has his own YouTube channel that I think you would have big time interest in and he would be a great guest on rev left as well. He Does a lot of work connecting communism with religion. Anyways just thought I would throw it out there. Thanks for everything you do. Solidarity

Jessica

I love Q&A episodes, thank you for publicly sharing this! You guys have a lot of wisdom and even where I have differences (I'm an animist anarchist that believes in dialectical idealism, thanks to my direct experiences with the non-physical world through shamanism and 5-meo-dmt), I very much appreciate the thoughtful discussion!

Jessica

This is honestly why I'm not a materialist, as I believe there's an invisible field (consciousness, energy, mathematics, etc) behind material reality and have experienced that directly thanks to psychedelics. My shamanic practices and animistic beliefs also are based in interconnection and relationship - with all living beings as well as forces of nature and the cosmos. And I'm not a vegan, because I believe veganism demonizes death and tries to resolve the disconnection of modern society by disconnecting completely from our place in nature and our engagement with the forces of nature such as killing and death. And yet I'm sympathetic to the motivations behind veganism because I feel the same deep desire to come back into right relationship with the web of life and other living beings. I deeply love animals and interact with them as often as people, but I also know myself to be a predator and don't reject my role as that in the web. It's absolutely possible to eat meat in an ethical way (in theory if not currently in modern society) and pushing society towards that is something we can (and should) all work together on.

StinkLord

Wouldn’t it make more sense to see this as a dialectic rather than rejecting materialism outright? The system we exist under shapes our minds, so the revolution must also happen in our minds in order to change our material conditions

Monty Fuch

I was gonna say “there’s bigger fish to fry” but that probably won’t go down well either!

Rev Left Radio

yes, I am familiar! In fact, when wisecrack was blown up, I reached out on IG to ask him to come on and discuss what happened and promote his new channel, and he left me on read! haha, since then though hes DM'd approvingly on a story or two that I have posted, so I assume he just didnt actually see it, forgot to respond, wasnt in a place at that moment to accept, maybe he wasnt aware of RLR at the time, etc. Idk, but my default is to grant him the benefit of the doubt. All that is to say I agree with you, our projects intersect and we could def have a great convo, and I have tried!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Jessica, I appreciate that, and I appreciate even more than you dont agree with us on everything - or even many things - but still find value in what we have to say. I take that as a deep compliment and appreciate your support so much.

Rev Left Radio

Not Sure, but weve ran it once each spring for the last two years, so perhaps we will run it again next spring!!!

Nancy Kogel

Jessica, thank you for this thoughtful response. I found myself resonating with much of what you wrote about interconnectedness, animism, relationship, and the living intelligence that permeates the natural world. While I come at these questions from a somewhat different path, I share your sense that reality is deeper and more mysterious than a purely mechanistic view allows. One place where we may differ is in our understanding of veganism. For me, veganism is not about demonizing death. Death is part of life. Every living being eventually dies, and all life participates in cycles of transformation. Rather, veganism is about asking whether we should cause suffering and death when it is not necessary for us to do so. I also see a distinction between what occurs in nature and what we choose to create as moral agents. Predation exists in nature. So do infanticide, territorial violence, and many other behaviors. The question is not what exists in nature, but what kind of relationships we wish to cultivate. If compassion, solidarity, and opposition to domination are values we seek to embody in human society, I wonder what happens when we extend those principles beyond our own species. I appreciate that you describe yourself as loving animals. In many ways, I think most people do. The question that continues to fascinate me is whether our love deepens when it is no longer mixed with ownership, use, or consumption. From my perspective, the challenge is not to separate ourselves from the web of life, but to participate in it with the least harm possible and the greatest respect possible. That is why I increasingly see animal liberation not as separate from human liberation, ecological healing, or spiritual awakening, but as deeply intertwined with all three. Thank you again for engaging so openly and thoughtfully.

Nancy Kogel

I appreciated the discussion about self-care and the question from the listener dealing with foot pain. One place where my perspective differs somewhat from the response offered is that I tend to begin with the body's remarkable capacity for self-healing. Of course, there are situations where professional medical care is necessary and even life-saving. But I think many of us have been conditioned to look first toward medical intervention rather than first asking what conditions the body needs in order to heal. If an injury is involved, one question is whether the area is being continually reinjured through overuse, repetitive motion, poor footwear, posture, or walking patterns. Sometimes healing requires not only treatment but removing the cause of the injury. I would also look closely at factors that either support or interfere with healing: nutrition, sleep, stress, movement, fresh air, relationships, and overall lifestyle. My own experience has led me to place enormous importance on whole plant foods, ideally organic when possible, and to avoid processed foods and animal products. I see health not as the absence of symptoms but as the result of creating conditions in which the body can thrive. For me, self-care also includes exercise, time outdoors, meaningful relationships, meditation, adequate rest, service to others, and living in alignment with a purpose larger than oneself. One reason I raise these points is that I sometimes feel the broader left critiques economic systems and corporate power without applying the same scrutiny to the modern health-care and pharmaceutical industries. Questions of profit, prevention, nutrition, and lifestyle often receive far less attention than questions of diagnosis and treatment. I would love to see more conversations that integrate social justice, personal responsibility, nutrition, prevention, and holistic well-being. If we're talking about building a healthier society, perhaps part of that project is also rediscovering how much healing capacity already exists within us when we provide the conditions for it to flourish.

Nancy Kogel

I appreciate the discussion of historical and dialectical materialism and the emphasis on class. At the same time, I find myself asking a question that I rarely hear explored on the left: If we are truly historical materialists, shouldn't we also ask where class itself originated? How did human beings first come to divide the world into owners and owned, rulers and ruled, subjects and objects? One possibility worth examining is the transition from foraging societies to herding societies. For hundreds of thousands of years, our ancestors lived primarily as gatherers and foragers. Then, at some point, certain groups began capturing, breeding, controlling, and claiming ownership over other sentient beings. Animals became property. Wealth could now be accumulated, inherited, defended, stolen, and expanded. Land became valuable not simply as habitat, but as territory to support privately owned herds. Conflicts over resources intensified. The concepts of ownership, domination, hierarchy, and accumulation took on entirely new forms. From this perspective, the domestication of animals may represent more than an agricultural development. It may be one of the earliest material foundations for class society itself. If this is even partly true, then animal liberation is not separate from historical materialism. It becomes relevant to understanding the origins of property, wealth, hierarchy, and exploitation. I am not suggesting that all social problems can be reduced to this single factor. History is more complex than that. But if historical materialism seeks to understand the material roots of social relations, it seems worth asking whether the first widespread ownership of living beings helped create the psychological, economic, and social framework that later expanded into ownership of land, resources, and eventually other human beings. In that sense, perhaps the animal question is not peripheral to the left project. Perhaps it belongs much closer to its center.

Nancy Kogel

One additional thought. Sometimes I wonder whether many of our political conversations remain confined within too narrow a frame. We analyze class, labor, ownership, production, and distribution, all of which are essential. But what if some of our deepest contradictions and greatest opportunities for transformation lie beyond the exclusively human sphere? What happens when we widen the lens to include our relationship with nature, other animals, and the living systems upon which all economies ultimately depend? From my perspective, this doesn't replace class analysis. It enriches it. The struggle between labor and capital remains important. But so does the relationship between humanity and the rest of life. A dialectical understanding invites us to see connections, interdependence, and reciprocal influence. Human beings shape nature, but nature also shapes human beings. Our treatment of animals affects not only them but our psychology, culture, economy, health, environment, and social institutions. When these dimensions are left out, our analysis can become flatter than reality itself. When they are included, new possibilities emerge. Perhaps the path toward liberation is not only horizontal, between human groups and classes, but also outward, toward a more conscious relationship with the larger web of life. If so, then animal liberation, ecological healing, and human liberation are not competing struggles. They may be different expressions of the same movement toward a less violent and more sane, and compassionate world.

StinkLord

Lmfao and in French they say “I have other cats to whip” (“j’ai d’autres chats à fouetter”) it’s just bad universally

Nancy Kogel

One connection that came to mind while listening to the fascinating discussion about Buddhism, meditation, love, compassion, and spiritual practice: A principle found throughout Buddhism and many other wisdom traditions is non-harming, the commitment to reduce suffering wherever we can. Breht, you’ve mentioned before that you find meditation deeply grounding and that veganism makes ethical sense, even if you haven't yet fully embraced it in practice. I appreciate that honesty. What interests me is the connection between these two paths. If we are seeking to cultivate compassion, loosen the grip of ego, become more conscious of our actions, and live in greater alignment with our values, what does that mean for our relationship with other sentient beings? For me, veganism is not primarily about diet. It is an attempt to bring my daily actions into closer alignment with the principle of nonviolence. Speaking only from my own experience, after more than fifty years of practicing yoga and meditation and nearly fifty years of veganism, I have found these paths deeply complementary. Each has strengthened and deepened the other. The more I cultivated mindfulness and compassion through spiritual practice, the more natural veganism became. And the more I sought to reduce the harm I caused, the more coherent and peaceful my inner life felt. Of course, veganism does not magically solve all of our problems. We remain human, with all our contradictions and struggles. But I do think there is something profound about extending the principles of mindfulness, compassion, and non-harming beyond our relationships with other people and into our relationships with other animals. None of us can live without affecting other forms of life. But we can ask whether the suffering we cause is necessary and whether it can be reduced. That question seems deeply relevant not only to Buddhism, but to any path grounded in love, compassion, and liberation. I often wonder whether animal liberation is one of the most overlooked applications of these teachings in the modern world. Thank you again for this show and for a rich and thought-provoking discussion.

Nancy Kogel

I enjoyed the discussion of quantum physics and the questions it raises about consciousness, interconnection, and the nature of reality. If you're looking for a guest recommendation, I would suggest Rupert Sheldrake. Sheldrake is a biologist and one of the most interesting critics of conventional scientific assumptions. Beyond his scientific work, he has spent decades examining the philosophy of science itself: what science is, how paradigms form, and which assumptions are treated as unquestionable. What I find especially compelling is his intellectual openness. Trained within a conventional scientific framework, he became willing to question assumptions that many scientists simply take for granted. His years in India also helped broaden his perspective and deepened his interest in consciousness, spirituality, and the relationship between mind and matter. Whether one agrees with all of his conclusions or not, he asks fascinating questions and challenges people to think more deeply about memory, perception, consciousness, interconnectedness, and the nature of reality itself. Given the show's interest in dialectics, consciousness, Buddhism, materialism, and quantum questions, I think a conversation with him could be extraordinarily interesting. One thing I especially appreciate is that he models something all good scientists should practice: the willingness to follow evidence, experience, and inquiry wherever they lead, even when that means questioning one's own prior assumptions. Thanks again for another thought-provoking discussion.

Max

Well... First off, the example you give is a useful one as it illustrates clearly the core concept Marxist value theory revolves around: that the workers do not own what they produce and that the gap between the value they create and what they are compensated for can be quite large. This is immediately plausible to most people and morally raises the question of the share between labour and capital regarding the realised gain. Trying to attach an empircal number to the Marxist conception of value, is a treacherous endeavour though. Marxists, in order to fortify their position, were not content with leaving the unequal share as a moral question and tried to give it a “scientific”, almost law-of-nature-like objective quality through their theory of value. This entangles “value” in a quest to look for the "true value", opening up its inner contradictions and ultimately leaving it too fragile to be outright attached to empirical values, such as the concrete profit margin you have conjured. So, your example works, but it is not terminologically correct. To begin with, value as such is too underdetermined. In the Marxist conception, “value” can refer to at least three different expressions: use value, exchange value or surplus value. Use value is the qualitative side of value, meaning the concrete use an iphone has for someone that leads him to buy one. Exchange value is what a good is worth (usually in money) as a commodity compared to other commodities. This is adjacent but not equivalent to its empirical price. Rather value is the prices’ gravitational centre, its “true” value that prices will normalise towards, if supply and demand balance out and they are no other distorting factors. Then there is surplus value, which denotes the difference between exchange value and the costs of production. This is what you identified with value. Again, it is adjacent but not equivalent to empirical profit. [The better approximation would be net value added, as a lot of factors not necessarily tied to production can influence profit]. So far so good. The main complication here arises from the Marxist claim that only labour actually creates value. While this is backed up well philosophically, it stands in tension with its presentation as an empirical, mathematical figure. Point blank, this would mean any production with a higher relation of wage costs to capital stock (organic composition) would create more profit. This is obviously wrong (or at least not visible) as capital would flow from less labour-intensive branches to more labour-intensives branches quickly soaking up the difference. To keep up the theory’s main tenet, “value” therefore needs to retreat behind several layers of mediation as the metaphysical “ought to” under the surface of concrete empirical prices and profits. This gets further complicated: Not only is the true value of Apple’s production obfuscated by the volatility of prices or the organic composition of production costs, the profit might also be inflated due to monopoly power, neocolonial exploitation or manipulative marketing. In short: Apple’s workers might not get the full the share of the profit, but should the profit even be that high? With all these considerations the “true value” of commodities becomes inevitably mixed up with normative aspects. The “normal” conditions under which prices settle around their value, become conditions of an idealised state without capitalist distortions, even though the concrete value form is tethered inherently to capitalism. This is why you cannot point at the Apple profit margin and call this the “value”. Rather, you could say the value form (and its inherent exploitation of workers) shines through the massive profit margins of big corporations. Ironically, it is not possible to put “value” as a concrete value. At least not under the Marxist terminological assumptions. It is much more salient to try to conceptualise and convey the “movements” of the value form, than to become caught up in pseudo-scientific value equations with impossible to solve recursive calculations (such as the transformation problem).

Scott

Loved the AMA! Curious if you all would consider doing an analysis of a lesser known socialist org in the US, Liberation Road. They're a group that split from FRSO in the 90s I believe. I have some friends in the organization and have considered becoming a member. Here's their strategic orientation if you have a little bit to take a look: https://roadtoliberation.org/our-2025-28-strategic-orientation/ I have a sense you would consider them revisionist but would love to hear from you directly about them. Thanks! Also, if there's a better place to post questions in the Patreon, please do let me know.