Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Breht is joined by organizer, educator, and Marxist feminist scholar Comrade Gabi for a discussion on patriarchy, misogyny, and power within contemporary socialist and organizing spaces. Together they explore the relationship between capitalism and patriarchy, the contributions of Marxist feminism, the persistence of sexist attitudes and behaviors among those committed to liberation, the politics of the sex trade, and the challenges of building healthy cultures of accountability. Grounded in both theory and lived organizing experience, this conversation examines what it would take to cultivate a genuinely anti-patriarchal socialist movement capable of embodying the liberatory values it seeks to bring into the world.

Check out more of Gabi's work here: https://medium.com/@comrade_gabi

Files

Comments

Clinton Fraser

Back in 2012 I was a member of the British SWP when an horrific rape accusation literally ripped out the heart of the organisation which had always prided itself on women's rights. The party leaders totally mishandled the situation and to this day the SWP has never recovered. The infighting and toxicity was something I'll never forget. The rapist was high up in the central committee and he was eventually expelled . I left the party not long after demoralised and confused especially when other leftists would attack us rank n file members as the "rapist party"

Clinton Fraser

Anyhow hearing this podcast is important for all left wing men to listen and understand so many thanks again Breht

Hamish Bradley

Really fucking awesome episode, thank you Gabi and Breht! It’s absolutely insane how widespread misogyny and abuse is in organizing and other leftist spaces. In animal rights organizing, every single organization that I have worked with has had the founding man have multiple people come out about abuse. And yes I mean literally every single one and all of them were THE leading/founding man and all of them had multiple women coming out. Some orgs kicked out those men, others didn’t. Even the ones that kicked them out have all been shown to have kept close ties with those men and promote their other work after being at least ceremonially kicked out. So often they will downplay what happened, smear the victims, or at the very least just say that the leaders activism and accomplishments are too important to truly kick them out. I have never seen any of the men admit to any wrongdoing. And I know this is the case in every movement and I find it really hard to even know what to do about it. I’ve heard some of the men talk about how they feel trapped because of what you were saying about healthy dating in movements. Like yeah people who are passionate about animal rights want to date people who share that passion. And where do you meet those people other than animal rights organizing? Of course this is no kind of excise but shows the mindset of these men and that they view themselves as being unfairly subjected to policing “just because they happened to be leaders”. Of course most of these situations were bad for more reasons than “just” the power dynamics. As a man who has dated and hooked up quite a bit within organizing I feel that I have found a system that works well to not make people uncomfortable or put people in weird positions. I just do not ever make any moves at all. I approach everyone with only the intention of organizing well and possible friendship. Even when I do have crushes I don’t flirt or do anything about it. I know that women and other genders always have to deal with man after man giving them that kind of attention. Of course if done respectfully and upfront like you talk about here it’s totally fine. But I find that even that annoys a lot of people because they just want to not be always seen as a crush and to be seen as a comrade instead. My women/other friends complain about that even if it is done correctly so I prefer just to avoid making any kind of move.

Hamish Bradley

Yeah this is like crazy fucking prevalent. Definitely super important to hear and think about. And prepare for so things aren’t handled by winging it cause that never works at all

Nigel Thomas

I was in Militant tendency in early 80s and one of the men had the brilliant idea of raising funds though a porn film night, I past his idea onto the female members 🤣 they were not impressed

Andrea Bolt

Sheesh! That would be the 80’s for ya 😂😂😂

Paddy League

I LOVED this episode! Gabi, as a Marxist academic and musician in Florida Bo less, I *completely* get what you’re saying (and I’m also reading Rockhill’s latest book and screaming OH MY GOD YES ALL OF THIS). Also, our local chapters of FRSO and PSD have basically imploded recently because of sexual harassment and assault shit. Infuriating beyond belief…

Paraseltzer

I'm glad you had Gabi on to discuss this. It's a really frustrating problem. Personally, I feel like it's super important to maintain certain boundaries within organizing contexts. I think we would all benefit from learning to keep these worlds separate and not make solidarity conditional based on interpersonal connections. Friendships and other relationships are maybe inevitable to some degree, but I consider it about as risky as getting personally involved with coworkers. Meaning it's usually a bad idea

Mike Andahl

This episode covered a lot of important ground. Dean Spade's Love in a Fucked Up World offers some good practical advice about when relationships seep into organizing spaces. It's also important to acknowledge we're all human and these situations will absolutely happen if you organize long enough.

Danny Boy

Breht, when people buy the merch, they do so because they want to support you. Our desire for sick Marxist threads is secondary. I understand if you don't feel like you deserve or should take a portion of the proceeds, but I would suggest that you are family might feel differently. Including your family here. As ridiculous as it is, one of the big indicators of success in our world right now is financial success. That's part of the reason that so many people pay attention to Hasan Piker. His success is not only a reflection on himself, but also on his listeners. It shows that there are so many of them that even a small donation can lift him up above the toiling masses. I sincerely love that you incredibly well read, well respected, and frequently recommended on the left. I seriously think you are more highly recommended in leftist circles than Hasan. In that way, your lack of obvious financial success could be strategic - a mirror of Chinas strategy, flying under the radar. I love your work, and I want to see you become more popular, more respected, and more successful. If that's not the strategy, then I am incredibly moved by the sacrifice and commitment you show to us, but a GoFundMe to pay for your kids' college etc would be well-received. I'm plastered and blubbering, but I just want you to know - you are loved and respected by people across the world, and you have my vote for premier when the US balkanizes. Solidarity forever.

Anton Pannekoek

After similar experiences with sexualized violence or at least highly dubious heterosexist conduct in an organisation I was member of (I'm cis male) I absolutely second the idea that any self-respecting marxist-feminist organization must have a written down and collectively supported document on how to handle these situations- because, comrade Gabi is fully correct, they will always happen. If you don`t have such a thing you are flying blind and often paralyzed when it matters most to act quickly. This can destroy or split longstanding orgs just because some (usually cis male) "friends" of a guy just cant accept that they hung around a sexist asshole for years. And the victims are often left behind and send towards state institutions because the radical left milieu has no resources to help. Its ugly and a viscious cycle because patriarchy still dominates, even in the radical left. One thing that resonated with me strangely - is crowdsurfing at a punk concert really a good example of the (undoubted and undenied!) forms of sexualized violence and heterosexist domination that occur in leftist places and orgs? I personally havent crowdserved as a 2 meter, 300 pound guy, but this seems a bit strange to me because as far as I observed, it always includes being manhandled by an intoxicated mob. I`m not trying to victim blame here, I just find it puzzling how to differentiate in such a situation between correct and sexist/groping behavior. Being held aloft by the muscle power of the uncoordinated crowd alone in a usually dark place makes this an example that I find at least unhelpful.

Comrade Gabi

Hi there! The scenario I was describing was as follows (a trigger warning for SA): I was crowdsurfing and a 40-50 year old man pulled my pants down and shoved his fingers in my vagina. He laughed in my face the entire time. Was pretty clearly not a matter of “accidental groping” or whatever. Didn’t really want to divulge all the details of the assault on a podcast but I guess there’s always someone (usually a man) who questions the validity of these experiences. Hope that clears it up for you!

Comrade Gabi

Solidarity with you, comrade!

Anton Pannekoek

Thank you for replying and for teaching me a well deserved lesson.

Wes Rich

Really great episode. I learned a ton. I was also a huge huge Anti Flag fan and felt so incredibly deceived and heartbroken when the truth about Sane’s behavior came out. The punk scene played a major part in my political journey but it also was a constant reminder that a lot of people get into different movements for the wrong reasons. They may say the right things but it’s all in an attempt to obfuscate who they really are.

HotGirlsHateCapitalism

Where do you guys think touch and human connection fit into the commoditization of sex via sex work and the abolition of the trade. I follow a stripper on instagram @stripperwriter who has a lot of interesting takes on the needs for sex work outside of chuds at the strip club. Where do you think disabled people or even socially disabled people fit into this ability to purchase touch and human connection? I suppose in a socialist world they could receive human connection through many available avenues but I’m not so sure about sensuality and touch.

jackson johnson

Breht, this comes from the perspective of someone who is a spouse of a sex worker. I think the reason a lot of people, and even a lot of women, have such strong reactions to the discussion of the abolition of the sex trade is that it is such a lifeline career for a lot of people, especially marginalized people. From personal experience, online sex work in particular is a field that someone who has disabilities that prevent them from working in traditional fields can do. I think there is a fear that "oh, Marxists want to take away my livelihood." There is a real, material element to the work that is often ignored in favor of the social or philosophical elements of the trade. As an ML. my spouse and I understand that is not the case, that instead a socialist society should remove the pressures, social and material, that force people into sex work. That said, in reality, Marxist movements are not anywhere close to achieving those goals. So to have other people, who often are not involved in the trade, make it such a point to abolish and oppose it, so early into the development of a revolutionary movement, feels targeted, scary, and in line with the growing right-wing violence towards women and sex workers. Furthermore, to touch on the social elements a bit more, a lot of sex workers view the work itself as something not much different from other service providers, such as providing a massage, haircut, or live entertainment. Why is sex in particular considered so demeaning to the worker who provides it? I think this still stems from puritan and sexist values that see promiscuity as something that "taints" women, and makes them not suitable for marriage, or polite society. We can talk about the social harm of sex work, but this often falls into sexist discussions of the harm to men, or young men, or to values etc. We don't condemn bartenders for providing drinks. Why is a man not being able to regulate his vices a woman's fault? Why does it once again fall to Women to change their behavior for the good of men? A lot of Marxists talk "hate the work, not the worker," but the real-life, material result is increased shaming and violence towards sex workers. I know this isn't the intent, but it is often the result. I think too often we look towards the ideal future of established socialism, and not enough at the very messy conditions we are living in currently. Most sex workers are in a very good position to be radicalized. I guarantee you they have a close-hand understanding of the exploitation within our system. But we are losing a lot of them because of this insistence on having a conversation about abolition that, in my view, is way too early to be having. I have a lot more views on this, from someone "inside" the industry, so to speak. I am not the performer, but I do a lot of the work associated with it, editing videos, fielding weirdos, filming, etc. I don't know if you have talked to many communists who are in the industry and have that first-hand perspective, and discuss it in a respectful way. So if you have any questions, discussion, or pushback you are more than free to DM or email me. Both my wife and I would love to answer any questions or have a back-and-forth. Love and solidarity from a long time listener.

The Sickle and the Hammer: A Socialist History of the Soviet Union

The first revolutionary org I ever joined was a Trot org (I swear I didn’t know at the time, or what the difference was, I was very green to revolutionary spaces lol). I was a member for about a year. I learned years after I left that the entire national org collapsed when it came out that someone who had recently been elected to national leadership had had a credible accusation of rape made against him, and the local club had basically mishandled the investigation and covered it up cause everyone loved him. The thing was, I knew the guy. It was the club I was a part of, and I had been at the party where the alleged assault had taken place. And the woman making the accusation had been a friend of a friend, both of whom I had invited. And they had later come to me to bring it up in the club (I was a member, they weren’t). So I did, immediately, and then I left the org altogether a few months later, partly because of how all these individuals - men and women - had been talking amongst themselves and with me of how they didn’t want anything to happen to the guy, and they didn’t know that they actually believed the accuser. I don’t know to this day what actually happened after the party. I know my friend and her friend were extremely upset, I know alcohol was involved, and I know I was very taken aback by all these folks I had considered comrades for a year suddenly circling the wagons around who was essentially their friend and leader. And I know I was surprised and not surprised a few years later when I learned all of it came to light and the rest of the national membership was so upset either how it was handled that they voted to dissolve the entire organization. I’m sure that last part had to do with other things, as well, including that it was a Trot organization. But it was definitely a first-hand lesson that just cause someone calls themselves a socialist or revolutionary or feminist doesn’t mean they aren’t capable of, at the very least, extremely questionable behavior, if not morally repugnant. And just because an org calls itself revolutionary and socialist and feminist doesn’t mean it can automatically be trusted to handle such a crucial situation appropriately.

BkhFlx

Great discussion. I especially appreciate that Gabi brought up how continuing to criminalize pimps and johns can continue exposing prostituted people to police violence. I hadn’t realized that this podcast had featured Esperanza Fonseca. That reminded me of her writing, so I reread the first essay on her Medium account, and it’s far more thorough and well-argued than I remember. The essay doesn’t fully address the harm law enforcement does when criminalizing buyers and sellers, or issues like harmful exit program requirements (though I’m looking forward to reading more of what Fonseca’s written to see if she discusses any of this elsewhere). Obviously these are not easy problems to fix, but I’m glad Gabi is still talking about how important they are to address.

BkhFlx

Thanks for raising all these great points. I’d be very interested in whatever you or your wife has to share.

Sarah

As someone who has been in, and still has many loved ones in, the industry, couldn’t have put this better

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

I was in London as a student in 2012 when that controversy broke, though I was fortunate to be in a sufficiently different sphere of leftist organizing that neither I nor anyone in my my close association were directly affected or compelled to make tough choices. For me, that whole business with the SWP's mishandling of sexual assault accusations serves as a cautionary tale about institutional failure in leftist organizing and the necessity for having appropriate mechanisms in place if and when highly placed/regarded persons may be guilty of serious offenses. It's something I still think about, all these years later.

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

Thank you so much for sharing this message. I don't have the direct experience with sex work that you and your wife have, and I'm not super close with anyone I know to be engaged in sex work. So my perspective is primarily second- and third-hand, but it follows the reasoning you lay out here very closely. In the circles I frequent, supporting people engaged in sex work often centers fighting legislation that purports to be helping or even "rescuing" people in sex work, but has the actual effect of making their lives even more difficult, precarious, and hazardous. I get the impression a lot of discourse that frames itself as "sex work abolitionist" gets conflated with the above tendencies in a lot of peoples' minds, even if that isn't the direction the speaker intends to go. Also, a talking point I hear not infrequently from sex work abolitionists is that leftists, and particularly leftist men, who disagree with them/take positions that they would call "pro-sex work" do so primarily for selfish personal reasons and uninterrogated patriarchal tendencies. While I've no doubt that's true for some persons in that camp, I think the same can be said for some of those seeking to eliminate sex work. I think in both cases, it's unhelpfully reductive and actively harmful to health dialogue to reduce the opposition its most patriarchal and reactionary elements. (Really, whenever I see someone put forward an argument that boils down to "the main reason for disagreeing with my position is that those who do so are bad people/acting from malicious motives" is a big red flag for me. I suppose maybe it's true, in some circumstances, but I also think that's a conclusion we humans are prone to adopting way too readily, often to our own detriment and to the detriment of our causes.)

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

I was reminded listening to the episode of some advice by some of my comrades in grad school not to date one of my classmates I'd developed a crush on, because of how messy that can be. As Breht and Gabi affirm, it's not an ironclad rule, and sometimes it can work out for the best, but it's a pretty good as a general guideline for organizing, education, career, anyplace that entails close collaboration with others on an ongoing basis. (In that specific case, I learned with further contact the fellow student in question isn't even attracted to my gender, so it was always a moot point, and we remained platonic friends. I don't think I'll ever understand the contempt for Just Friends as a concept. I understand romantic disappointment and frustration - indeed, they're the only things I've ever known in that sphere of life - but strong friendships are valuable in their own way, perhaps even more than good romantic connections, though I admittedly have no personal data to compare the two. They're life-enriching, even life-saving. But now I'm straying very far off-topic.)

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

It sounds like you have a lot of experience with romantic and sexual connections in organizing spaces (and perhaps out of, as well). I think it's extremely valuable that you share in some detail what behaviors you specifically avoid, engaging with women/non-men, so as not to intimidate or alienate them. We all have some amount of patriarchal programming we pick up from being born into and raised within a patriarchal culture, and it can be so helpful to lay out "these are types of behavior that, whatever you think you're trying to do, have the effect of perpetuating patriarchal dynamics, and here's how to avoid doing so." I think it would also be valuable to share in some detail what strategies HAVE worked for you and don't play into patriarchal dynamics, for the benefits of folks who are either just starting out, or have been engaged for a while and have not shared your good fortune when it comes to finding romantic and/or sexual partners.

Paraseltzer

Platonic relationships/friendships (specifically with the opposite sex, as I am straight) are some of my most cherished connections with people. And while I'm happy to say I've been able to maintain friendships with most of my exes, I don't take that for granted or assume it can always be the case. Sometimes it's for the best if we just don't look at others through the lens of romantic or sexual pursuits as if that is the height of connectivity. Romantic and sexual entanglements are often extremely corrosive to friendship and solidarity, not just between the two parties involved but everyone in the vicinity who has to navigate all the weirdness when it goes badly...

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

Thank you Gabi and Breht for the great discussion. I think, along with advice for men/masc leftists for how to avoid behaviors that make women and non-men feel uncomfortable/unsafe, it would also be immensely helpful to have a fairly comprehensive guide of recommended behaviors and strategies for men/masc leftists who want to date in ways that support their women/non-men comrades. I think there are a lot of men/masc folks out there who could really benefit from in-depth positive advice, along with explanations of what not to do. Anecdotally, I know went to a school that generated the foundational text of campus sexual assault policies more than a decade before I arrived, and it was an incredibly sex-positive policy that was primarily concerned with giving people positive tools for successfully initiating mutually enjoyable sexual encounters, with the list of verboten activities supporting that goal. Can't say it's helped me find a romantic partner, but as a cishet male with low self-esteem and undiagnosed neurodivergence, immersing myself in that milieu at that young and impressionable age was invaluable in helping me develop a more healthy relationship with my sexuality and conceptualize viable ways of expressing it that were compatible with feminist and person-respecting values. (Similarly in-depth dating advice for women and non-men, and perhaps specifically for men dating other men, may be comparably important to generate. However, the angle of approach for these would be different in some respects due to disparities in social dynamics, which I'm less qualified to speak to.) Other topics I think deserve comprehensive guides for men and masc folks (and potentially non-men also, but again, different social dynamics) include: how to call out/push back against sexist comments and attitudes among co-workers or teammates or the like, especially in male-dominated spaces; how to respond when a friend or mentor or leader figure is accused of sexual assault or other abusive behavior (as discussed in some of the other comments to this episode); and how to intervene when witnessing instances of sexual/gendered harassment, with pointers on overcoming the bystander effect and on avoiding compounding the harassment in one's attempts to defuse it (I actually have some personal lived experience relevant to this third point).

Sarah

Thank you both for an excellent conversation! And kia ora to you Gabbi from Aotearoa (New Zealand), if you’re visiting here I’d love to catch up with you and discuss your ideas further! I’m studying at Massey Uni here, but connected to Marxist reading groups with UoA and UC too and would love to connect you in for a convo there if you have the time! If you’re down south there’s a co-op (anarchist but lots of ML members too) cafe in Ōtepoti Dunedin, with many SWer members too who may be interested in having a chat and are connected with NZPC too! Really resonate with your insights into how even abolitionists should support decrim, and further thoughts on the matter around supporting workers rather than the industry. As someone who has been in the industry and has many friends still in the industry I’ve struggled to find a clear position between lived experience and a Marxist abolitionist stance, understanding and wanting to support vulnerable workers whilst also having very clear insight (even from my position of relative privilege) of how deeply harmful this industry is. Great to hear another conversation on it. Just a note thought that it shouldn’t be so surprising that there is such a strong reaction to these conversations, given the context of patriarchy discussed throughout the episode but also the psychological impact of the sex trade itself. From liberal women trying to convince themselves it’s empowerment to those who partake in this work because they feel like they don’t have any other choice, I believe there is a huge amount of cognitive dissonance and protective mechanisms that goes into being able to hold onto an illusion of choice or agency in any of it, so to have someone who hasn’t experienced come in an say that the industry should be abolished, I think strong emotional reactions are to be expected even if they don’t make sense. Empathetic and sensitive conversations are needed to unravel complicated beliefs, and self beliefs, where sexuality, work, agency, and material conditions are messily entangled - appreciate this conversation doing some of that untangling!

Sarah

Also really appreciate you clearly pointing out Breht that no self respecting Marxist should partake as a consumer in the sex trade 👏👏👏

Sarah

I think that the point around disabled people is often weaponised in support of the sex trade, when the vast majority of people consuming those services are not disabled. In the current context basically all SW whether it’s in a strip club with a ‘chud’ or with a (seemingly) well intentioned buyer is coercive, and therefore cant be consented. Im sure that there are people who genuinely enjoy giving touch / sensuality to those who may not easily find it elsewhere, that does not need to be work or be done with the complete power imbalance that the sex trade upholds

Quinn Keitel

Proud to say my DSA chapter's poli-ed group has read Kollontai and spent all June of this year reading from trans feminist Marxist texts like Transgender Marxism and Whipping Girl. As a cishet white guy it was so valuable to engage with these topics and writers in a group setting. We also regularly share Rev Left and Red Menace episodes in the group. Thanks for this conversation!

David Duba

I just read something about radical feminists point out how society values traditionally masculine ideas like control, individuality, dominance, hierarchy, violence, power, owning, etc. over traditionally feminine values like love, kindness, communality, belonging, sharing, etc. and it got me thinking about how Marxist-Leninists often (seem to) also lean into those former values over the latter. How do you all think organizing and even revolution might be different if it emphasized traditionally feminine values?