Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

(Recorded on July 4th) Alyson and Breht reflect on recent Democratic Socialist electoral victories, the ongoing contradiction between the progressive left and the corporate center within the Democratic Party, the principled and strategic approach to this development that Marxists should take, the implications for the near future of american politics, what it all means for the broader socialist left in this country, proletarian internationalism, the anti-imperialist red line, and much more. 

Learn more and support the show at https://revleftradio.com/

Check out Unlearning Capitalism for more political educational resources

Files

Comments

spinitch

dropping banger after banger after banger (can’t wait to listen lol) 🙌💥

spinitch

💚💚💚

Mexican Stalin

The problem with American communism, especially in the 21st century, is that communists have not been able to fulfill the role of serving the people. It's logistically impossible—how do you help tens of thousands of people in local communities with their modern problems, like paying their bills, treating their illnesses, or fixing their cars before work? Communists before could come to a village with college students and sacks of rice, teach villagers how to read and write, and feed them. Now, the only way to do that is to use the state—become the mayor, lower rent, tax corporations, and create infrastructure to reduce electrical bills. But how do you connect this to a broader struggle, especially since communists are legally not allowed to participate in government? Already, the social democrats have crossed the red line with Graham Platner and their alliance with liberal Zionism. Zohran Mamdani has crossed the red lines many times. I think we do need to embed ourselves in the DSA and other electoral struggles, maybe advocate for a split from the Democratic Party, and make it clear—even if it's unpopular—our opposition to figures like Graham Platner. I agree that we should organize in and out of the DSA. I hate electoralism with a passion but as much as I wish we could organize outside of it and create "revolutionary people's" mechanic shops, hospitals, daycares, law firms, or farms—we just don't have the numbers, the will, or the imagination among socialists to do it right now.

Mexican Stalin

The funny thing is, I realized I don't hate electoralism or entryism—I hate the Democratic Party, lol. I respect Chávez and Evo, probably the height of what electoral politics can achieve, compared to Lula or any of the other milquetoast Pink Wave leaders in Latin America. Unfortunately, electoralism is still too connected with the Democratic Party in America. Like I dont hate electoralism out of some purity* politics angle its just the democratic party makes me sick 😅

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

Incredible conversation as always, I learn so much from you both. I’m a DSA member in the Bay Area (East Bay) who joined at the start of this year after months of deliberating on which organization to join. Breht’s conversation with folks from the Springs of Revolution last summer was actually a huge influence on my decision, as I had no idea of the organization’s ideological diversity before listening to that episode. The work I do with DSA is twofold: fighting for divestment from apartheid (Israel) in support of Palestinian liberation through BDS work with cities, counties, retirement funds, and our utility monopoly; and advocating for better working conditions for transit operators (most of whom are Black in the city I live in) and more reliable & realistic transit schedules, which requires uniting the interests of transit drivers and riders. The critiques pitted against the DSA are very valid: the bureaucracy and frequent focus on resolutions to resolve disagreements can be daunting and frustrating; the solutions to resolve societal issues often rely on existing institutions through policy changes; the organization, particularly its leaders and most active members, are often white and white collar, and rarely recognize that privilege when organizing; and the strong emphasis on electoralism is frustrating for members like me who do not believe that electing progressive candidates will lead to lasting material improvements for the masses. In spite of all of these shortcomings, I am proud to be a DSA member because of the organizing skills it’s helped me to develop in just over 6 months, the amazing comrades I’ve built relationships with, and the vast array of campaigns and committees available to get involved with. As I continue to develop and sharpen my own political ideology and gain more organizing experience, I would like to join a DSA caucus (Red Star and Communist caucus are the ones I currently align most closely with that have active members in my local chapter), and I hope to push my comrades further to left through advocating for and participating in anti-imperialist work. I’m also grateful to have had organizing experience prior to joining DSA, most consistently through weekly ICE patrols that have started to evolve into opportunities for resource sharing within my community. Thanks again for the insightful conversation! I’m so grateful for the myriad of ways this show educates me politically and spiritually. Love and solidarity to all fellow Rev Left Radio comrades. ✊❤️

Eli 🇵🇸

Love and solidarity from your comrade in Northern Colorado DSA! I identify with so damn much of what you said above.

Eli 🇵🇸

10 minutes in and you're already right on the fucking money. As always. Breht and Alyson for Commissar 2028!

Eli 🇵🇸

Jesus. Thank you for working through EXACTLY what has agonizingly been on my mind as a communist organizing in DSA.

Foko

I think your first comment is spot on, and something I've been thinking about for a long time. How do we meet the immediate needs of people when daily life has become so unaffordable & exhausting, while still doing community education and not remaining totally focused on mutual aid? I would love to learn about the actual reality of implementing rural literacy programs or the Free Breakfast Program, and what it actually took to implement and standardize it nationwide. I do think that Paulo Freire lays some foundation for standardizing community education in Pedagogy of the Oppressed, but when it comes to meeting people's material needs there is a shocking dearth of practical information on how it's been done in the past. I am studying acupuncture currently, largely because of how inspired I have been reading the history of the BPP and Young Lords' occupation of Lincoln Hospital in the Bronx, and establishment of Lincoln Detox, which only offered ear acupuncture and community education to its participants -- no methadone, no wasteful and patronizing government programs -- and yet is perhaps still today the most successful detox center in US history. (The documentary Dope is Death is an amazing intro to this history, as is Johanna Fernandez's book The Young Lords: A Radical History. She came on Rev Left years ago to talk about the book with Breht!) As the cracks in our healthcare, food distribution, and education systems all intensify, strategic openings for organized left groups to insert themselves and help communities will only expand. But it's crucial that we learn from the experience of our predecessors and do it right.

Nico

hehehahaha go awffffff Breht 😆

.

You should contact Hasan honestly if you are ready for that kind of platform. Further left and trying to give a communist platform. I know it’s not the end all be all but it might push people further left even if they vote for these DSA candidates. Obviously we still have to do stuff on the ground but I’d love to hear this on a massive left program like Hasan’s We aren’t punk or 90s skate culture. We want our ideas to go “mainstream” for a different type of politics. I’m excited about all these DSA wins. I want the Overton window for communist politics being on the national stage in relation to socdems. If Hasan rejects this invitation you know where we stand tbh.

EndlessToil

I get a hit of pure dopamine everytime Alyson says wrestle with.

Tom Servo

Is hasan further left than rev left? I've never been able to get into the twitch style streamer shit. If its worth a watch, maybe I'll take off work for 3 days and catch one of his streams.

Jesse Seastrand

I’m part of the Bernie phenomenon you mentioned. I was in my 20’s and coming of my political age and then inspired by Bernie. Slowly but surely I found Jacobin, and then wanted more and found your show and others where I continue to learn and grow. Thanks for your show and helping me move into the fold.

Brad Northcote

Awesome! This will be food for thought as the third-party NDP in Canada shifts explicitly toward a 'democratic socialist' direction, while the Liberal PM who rode a wave of voters assuming he'd "stand up to Trump" find him disgustingly echoing imperialist rhetoric on Iran while promoting public service cuts. Different dynamics, but some transferable lessons for organizing, I'm sure!

Finn 415

I'm so glad you're bringing up the problem of YIMBYism Alyson. I've found only people really attentive to housing politics know they are problematic. In SF, (perhaps where they originate?) we've been battling them and their tricky ways for what feels like forever. In particular, I see them fool tons of ppl into signing their petitions to "solve the housing crisis." I make a point now to always ask what orgs they work with anything I hear someone purporting to solve the housing crisis. If it's not one of the tenant rights groups that actually helps tenants with their struggles with their land lords than I'm a hard pass.

Sarah

Excellent episode thank you! Although not in US, I think much of this analysis can be extended to electoral politics in other contexts - in Aotearoa NZ, & I believe Australia & UK are most similiar with MMP systems, we’ve seen a surge of more ‘socialist-esque’ policies and figures primarily in the Green parties, who have been outspoken in support for Palestine as well as domestic issues. There is a lack of clear ideological anti-imperialist international lines, as there’s a call for no imperial wars and yet a condemnation of Iranian media black out etc. but on the most part further left than any alternative in the electoral domain

.

Sorry I worded that weirdly. Revleft is further left. Only reason I commented about Hasan is because Breht said he was contacted by AOC’s people to do an interview years ago. Might be beneficial to reach out to some like Hasan at this particular moment. Not a twitch person either. But a lot of young leftists I know look to him. Massive platform that obviously played a huge part in DSA candidates winning primaries unseating establishment democrats.

Ben

i’m so grateful for the Palestinian resistance and for you two for being so instrumental in my personal political development. it’s probably silly but it’s meaningful to me that instead of reacting with mystified MSM-generated horror, i felt a sense of gleeful awe and hope and pride when i saw those heroes had broken through the gates.

Finn 415

Ahhh! i kept listening and you explain the phenomenon beautifully! Yes, this exact same dynamic is happing in the Bay Area. I had no idea they were gaining traction among DSA's base, but that makes sense given what you said.

Jessica

Great episode, and it's really good to hear such a clear explanation of why leftists need to not be ideological purists and alienate themselves from the wider, far more liberal overall, left-wing movement. At the same though this analysis doesn't go far enough, as it contradicts the very idea that Marxists need to act as a far-left block ready to criticize and even declare as an enemy any candidate who crosses the invisible (to all but Marxists) red line. Here's why I say that. The simple fact is that given the current conditions of education, propaganda, delusional thinking, etc among the population, the majority of people aren't going to be convinced of Marxist ideas by trying to educate them on those ideas. That strategy had decisively failed even before the era of social media and bot farms. Rather, the only way people are going to be convinced to move further left is if the left take power and enact REAL CHANGE that directly impacts their lives. And necessarily this process starts with electing progressives and social democrats. It seems the hosts understand this last part, but don't take that to the logical conclusion that agitating for those candidates to move further left ISN'T the path forward, but rather pushing for those people to enact policy that affects change in people's material conditions. And those two things are not the same, because in the current conditions successfully enacting such policy REQUIRES working within the system, and strategically at times working with those who Marxists would consider enemies (the Democratic establishment). Further down the road as the Overton window moves far enough left those establishment candidates can simply be opposed on all fronts, because we will have enough political power and will have changed the system enough for it to be a successful strategy. That time is not now. In other words, the very concept of a Marxist red line and those on the other side of it being our complete enemies is simply incompatible with eventually actually getting what we want. We can (and should) be ideological hard liners when it comes to the vision we are working towards, but we cannot be that when it comes to the PROCESS of getting there. Ideology and strategy are not the same, and what our principles look like in our ultimate vision is not going to be what they look like in practice - at least not for a long time. This is where I think Marxist education gets in the way of organizing - when people superimpose either the movements of the past or the ideas in their heads onto current reality, rather than adapting to current reality as it is. This is why the influence of Marxists has for decades been more problematic than helpful in actually moving society leftward. Where I think Marxist education truly does the movement good is in the clarity of vision of what we want, and what it ultimately (eventually, not right now!) will take to get there.

Jessica

Unfortunately though we're simply going to have to get over our disgust at them if we ever want to move society to the left, because the only way that's realistically going to happen is if openly left-leaning candidates get into office and enact policies that affect real material improvements in people's lives. And the only way those candidates can ever win in our current two-party system (as the failures of third party organizing and the success of the DSA working within the Democratic party have proven) is if they utilize the Democratic party. The goal is obviously for this to change, and if the DSA succeeds in electing candidates and those candidates succeed in enacting real change to material conditions, it will. But we can't jump past this stage just because we don't like it 😛

Luis Rosa

I’m not from the usa but was following how that guy that went 5 times to Iraq and then joined blackwater was being pushed as a progressive leftist, that was insane. Anyway great episode!

Michael Murray

In short: don't back down, double down if asked to condemn Hamas or communism. DSA sounds a lot like Sinn Feinn in Ireland

Grond

You're way too charitable with AOC. Her moves and stances are completely motivated by ambition.

Grond

Please take this critique charitably: you have made consistent mention of the power/potential of tenant organizing but have never really fleshed out any analysis as to why. It goes without saying that any gains made for working class people are to be applauded and repeated when possible; but why is it that tenant organizing should take precedent over workplace organizing at this point in the struggle? Rent strikes cannot disrupt the flow or production of capital anywhere near the extent that workplace organizing can. https://substack.com/@multinationalcommunistparty/note/p-203397673?r=6xckr7

Jess W

I see your point that we can’t be too rigid with our ideology and thus write off people who don’t check all of our boxes. I agree with that. I think the point being made by the co-hosts is that we also can’t just become complacent while leaders who can affect change pander to the center/right and let slide ideology/ignorance that leads to inaction or harmful practice forward - which we see time after time in the Democratic Party.

shane bennett

Im not even sure if hasan is socialist. He's not really advocating much more than universal Medicare. He has decent geopolitical analysis but its obvious he tones down his opinions in order to keep his personal position secure

shane bennett

Yea I hear alot of content creators in that DSA lane shitting on NIMBYs but was kinda unaware of why. It just seemed odd to me til I heard this

Peter McEntee

I don’t have the link, but the reasoning behind the importance of tenant organizing is better fleshed out in the episode on their critique of Technofeudalism by Varoufakis. I’ll take a stab at why I think it’s so important: in the context of the imperial core, it’s an issue that is easier to mobilize around because a) so many jobs are gigged/lumpenized/de-unionized that it’s difficult to find a “working class” ready to organize and b) it is an example of how imperialism has domestic ramifications (ie many landlords hyper exploit immigrants/take advantage of language barriers), thus being an opportunity for us as communists to link domestic struggle that most people face to the racialized violence of empire in a way that also shows those in the core that they have more in common with oppressed people around the world than they do with the ownership class. TLDR, I think tenant organizing is a way to “find” the proletarian in the imperial core, and to link the struggle to imperialist violence that is wrecking the world around us (and obviously destabilizing us here domestically)

rhubarb

i’m completely disgusted by hasan after his response the platner situation, and i would honestly be very disappointed if they had him on without challenging his role in the platner left and a myriad of his other transgressions that i think highlight his very poor character.

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate that feedback and insight, and you make many good points. My only counter argument would be around the red line: I think drawing a red line at murdering, harming, or impovershing people in the global south is a reasonable, principled line to draw in the sand and to be actively hostile to those who aid and ebet such harm is totally in line with proletarian internationalism and a communist ethic. I dont think thats too puritanical or sectarian, nor do I think pushing that line would weaken or alienate us. Id also argue that such a red line is not an idealist superimposition on concrete reality, but a principled response to a reality where life in the imperial core is upheld and maintained via brutal and neverending violence and immiseration of people in the global south. Perhaps I misunderstand your point, in that case please lmk, but that is my defense of the red line argument I made in this episode fwiw!

Rev Left Radio

Amazing to hear that, my friend. Thank you so much for listening and for your support!

Rev Left Radio

Yes, such behavior, especially that late in life (perhaps a teenager can be forgiven), violate the red line of proletarian internationalism!

Rev Left Radio

haha, I agree. Though I dont think i was nice to her in this episode. I specifically called her out as someone who is clearly spineless, careerist, and ambitious in a way that undermines core values of the socialist left.

Rev Left Radio

yes, work place organizing is and always will be essential, but as Peter said, given the dynamics of the economy, the conservative and self-serving nature of the big unions, gig work, etc. organizing in workplaces isnt as straightforward as it was the past when you had big factories where hundreds of workers were forced together day in and day out. Doesnt mean we shouldnt do it, but rather that in addition to those efforts, organizing tenants should have a particular focus cuz housing in increasingly an essential site of struggle, the housing crisis is something people immediately recognize as a threat to them adn their families, people who are renters are almost always also working class, and big apartments buildings are a place where working people and their families are concentrated. So its really not an either/or thing, its a both/and. For many people though, organizing tenants has a much lower barrier to entry than organizing shop floors, and thus its more efficient to recommend people looking for something to organize around to focus on tenant organizing. Im sure Alyson could add more here, but thats the basic logic.

Jessica

I get that but the problem is that that critique isn't just being used against establishment Dems, but against social democrats and progressive who simply aren't toeing some ideological line. In other words, pandering to the center/right is bad when it leads to actual center/right policies. But when the policies are basically great steps in the right direction, who cares if some words are said in order to make those policies able to happen? Who cares if those policies don't go far enough, or are limited? As long as they are steps in the right direction, we are actively making actual progress towards our principles and values. Rejecting anything other than the pure expression of those principles will only succeed in preventing their ultimate realization. Just as pushing candidates towards a more ideal expression of our politics will make it harder to actually ever achieve them, in these current conditions. We have to adapt to conditions and work with what is if we want to be effective at getting what we ultimately want. Demanding what we want regardless of current conditions will only ensure we never get it.

Jessica

No, I think you're understanding me! My counter argument would be that such a red line as you state it absolutely is an idealist superimposition on reality, because it's too abstract (as stated) to be clear what it means in practice. Because where do we draw the line at harming and improverishing people in the global South when literally our entire modern life does that? We steal every resource we use in our lives from there, from water to food to land to minerals to oil to human labor. The entire human world we've collectively created harms them, so what does it mean to draw a red line against harming them? Is it not advocating for certain populations in the South strongly enough? Is it not supporting policies that do that directly, given that countless policies do that indirectly? What does that actually mean, in practice? And if it's a dialectical question that must be answered on a case by case basis, then is it really a red line? And if satisfying it requires completely rejecting modern life as it currently exists (which I would argue it logically does, as stated), then how is such a stance not just another ideological purity test that gets in the way of us actually gaining power? I would argue that because it's a dialectical question, that abstract hard line only has value when it comes to the goal we are moving TOWARDS. In practice (and in hindsight), Harris getting elected in 2024 would have done far, far more to reduce harm to the global south than it would have caused harm, even given all we know about the harm her politics and policies cause have and would have caused them. This is why "lesser evilism" is actually a better answer to that dialectical question of harm in our current conditions: because if we are to apply that principle to reality dialectically (as that would require), the line shouldn't be "no harm" but rather "reducing harm", given that current conditions are already so massively harmful.

zahcary

Do you have any reading/listening recs on the German revolution or what went wrong with the SPD in the years leading up to it? Besides your episode, which is great. I'm in the middle of What is to be Done and Lenin is saying how great that party is so it's crazy how much they fell off in a decade or so.

World War II on the Air and in Print (old time radio, movies, and news)

If communism is so great, how come there is not a gigantic influx of immigrants to communist countries? My family fled communism for the United States. I worked hard as a laborer from age 19 to 55 (I'm not a Boomer) when I was able to retire by taking advantage of the ability to make wise investments in the capitalist system. If I were living in a communist nation, I would be a laborer with no chance of becoming anything else but a laborer unless the state tells me otherwise. I would be stuck living in a laborer's apartment complex provided by the state instead of the house and land that I was able to buy because of capitalism. I worked very hard, usually 50-60 hours a week and outside no matter the weather (Midwest US). I've worked 12 hours in 110-degree heat and 13 hours in -30-degree air temperature. I self-taught myself by buying college textbooks and reading on my own. Capitalism gave me a good life whereby if I had done the exact same job under communism, I would be miserable because I'd know there would be no way to better my situation, The only ones that win under communism are the chosen elites, one of which I had in my family (KGB). He made today's ICE agents seem like nursery schoolteachers.