Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Breht explores how Frantz Fanon transformed and expanded Marxism by bringing Hegel’s master-slave dialectic into the concrete world of colonialism, racial domination, and revolutionary struggle by placing Marxist analysis into conversation with psychoanalysis, phenomenology, and psychiatry.

Moving from Black Skin, White Masks to The Wretched of the Earth, Breht examines how colonialism organizes not only land, labor, class, and political power, but also language, desire, bodily experience, recognition, and unconscious life. Along the way, he discusses Fanon’s concepts of sociogeny and racialized embodiment, his critique of European psychoanalysis, his analysis of the peasantry and national bourgeoisie, and his controversial account of violence, disalienation, and revolutionary subject formation.

At the center of Fanon’s work is a profound insight: colonialism is a total social relation that enters into the people who inhabit it. Decolonization and socialist revolution must therefore transform not only governments and property relations, but culture, consciousness, institutions, and human beings themselves.

Check out our related episode on Hegel, Marx and Althusser HERE

Check out our classic three-part episode on Fanon's Wretched of the Earth:

Check out our new Summer Design Merch HERE

Files

Comments

Foko

Dang Breht you are on fire lately! Seriously feel like i'm learning sooo much from your work lately. Thank you so much for your contributions to left theory & philosophy, it's invaluable.

Foko

Also the new merch is sick!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you so much, it truly means alot to hear that, my friend! < 3

Brad Northcote

As always, I appreciate your openness to an Althusserian/structural Marxist perspective, as well as suggesting of its limits. This and your prior essay are definitely going to be ones to revisit and mull over. Generative as ever!

Aiden Cain 🇵🇸 🇨🇺

This came out at the perfect time to celebrate Franz Fanon's birthday and honor the revolutionary legacy of Black August. I'm currently reading The Wretched of the Earth for the first time (I've listened to the audiobook twice). Also just finished re-reading Blood In My Eye by George Jackson and I'm reading Revolutionary Suicide by Huey P. Newton for the first time.

Ellis Maxwell

Loved this episode, and the last one on Hegel through Althusser — learning so much. At the end, as you are summing up the argument, you mentioned alienation, which made me question whether the very concept of alienation includes an idea of humanity that Althusser rejects? Alienation seems to point to the prospect of disalienation, as your argument based on Fanon’s work demonstrates. Does that imply the idea of humanity as main character in a story with a plot that Althusser rejects? I am much more in line with the humanist Marxist position than the anti-humanist. Just sharing curiosity. Thanks as always for the amazing work!

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

I appreciate the timing of this essay, I’ve been reading Wretched of the Earth for the first time and this essay summarized some of what I’ve taken away from the text while also uncovering a lot of new insights from Fanon that I haven’t considered. I intend to listen to your episodes on Wretched of the Earth once I’ve finished reading the book. Thank you as always for your incredible work, Breht!

Roving Canine

"A body can become tense under meanings the conscious mind rejects, because those meanings shape what other people are likely to do" As a non-traditionally passing or presenting transfem person this hits like a wrecking ball because when I'm in non-queer spaces my physical body is clocked and catalogued before I get any chance to dictate my own narrative or perspective and I've had even well meaning people slip up with pronouns or jokes or forms of adress, (no need to get started on strangers or actively hostile folk). You are gendered and put into a box whether you like it nor and have to behave accordingly for your own safety and survival to either placate, evade or defend yourself in certain social situations. I still benefit from being an able bodied white person but my visible transgression of gender norms is noted and stereotypes are imprinted on me whether I like it or no.

Rev Left Radio

Amazing! We do have that three part series on wretched which might make for a good companion after ya finish reading it! Thank you for your support Aiden!!

Rev Left Radio

Yes! Alienation was part of what Althusser would call Marx's early, less scientific, humanist strain that he rejects for the later scientific Marx of Das Kapital. One can agree or disagree with that division itself of course, and many do. But Fanon is a humanist, but his humanism is more advanced and, i think, is a humanist response that takes in and deals with the Althusserian critique, which I tried to make somewhat clear in this episode! Though, again, Fanon lived and wrote before Althusser, so his work wasnt a response to Althusser, he just anticipated and arguably deals with a sort of althusserian critique automatically in the process of his work. At the end of the script i talk about Fanons New Humanism, and tried to weave in the fact that he does accept a certain amount of structural determinism ala Althusser, but also moves beyond it by arguing not that we can reclaim some lost or alienated humanity, but rather that we can forge a new consciousness, a new humanity, through struggle. But yes, you are absolutely right, it is still definitely humanism!

Aiden Cain 🇵🇸 🇨🇺

Of course! This podcast has been indispensable in my political education and I share a lot of your episodes whenever I can. I'll have to check out the Fanon series. Thanks comrade

Rev Left Radio

I love hearing that, my friend. Glad your finding the episode helpful alongside your reading of Wretched. I hope listening to our series on wretched after or during your reading helps illuminate the text even more! :)

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely. So glad you saw how deeply and profoundly Fanon's work on race translates to the trans experience specifically. Fanon of course wasnt thinking of that, but it applies 10000%. I send you my genuine love and solidarity, my friend. I know it cannot be easy, especially with such a reactionary, hateful American superstructure that we have to live in - not to mention the despicable way in which reactionaries, and the most powerful men in the country, use trans people as a scapegoat and ratchet up bigotry toward them.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Brad! It is always high praise coming for you, and I appreciate it!

Brad James

Hey Breht, I've been a listener and supporter for years and I absolutely love everything you do, whether that's this podcast, Red Menace, Shoeless in South Dakota, or anything else. I think that you genuinely have a gift and I feel so fortunate to have discovered your work. I just wanted to flag for you that in this episode and the other one about Spinoza, Hegel, and Marx, some segments, particularly the biographical ones, struck me as AI-generated text. Your interjections are just as articulate, but then when you would switch back to the text this very different writing would be present that--in my opinion at least--displayed a lot of hallmarks of AI text. I could be wrong, and if so I sincerely apologize.

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate your skepticism on that front, and these days its increasingly hard to tell, as AI writing is plagarized and regurgitated human writing after all. As someone who writes and wants to be a better writer, its increasingly important to me that my writing stays unique, develops its own voice, cadence and tone, and in my book, my RM scripts, and my public speeches they remain 100% ME. Having said that, when I wrote the last script and this one, I used claude only to CHECK the philosophical substance of the arguments itself and to fill out the background biographical info, to ensure that I am being precise when employing a thinkers nuanced use of terms or arguments, and when something is flagged as off-base, confused, highly contested, or otherwise written in a way that is misleading, i let claude fix the language so that it maximized for philosophical precision, even at the expense of my voice. Admittedly, I feel conflicted about that, but figured that as political education goes, and since im engaging with multiple philosophers, some who I have not read their entire oeuvre, that I could value precision over personalization. I have only ever done it on the last two philosophy episodes - again to maximize for philosophical fidelity given I was bringing in lots of thinkers and their intersections which are often hotly contested and can be ambiguous in my own mind -- (when im teaching a specific text or one thinker whom I have a deep grasp on, its never needed obviously). Its also true that me speaking extemporaneously and me writing something complex and precise will and always have had different tones, cadences, flows, etc., as the two forms of communication are genuinely different. In any case, for a multitude of reasons, I ultimately dont think its worth it, and I will refrain from using it as an editor going forward. If I am uncertain about the complexity of intersecting works, the specific use of jargon, etc. ill simply not write it at all unless I have the time and energy to work it all out myself. It was an experiment in maximizing philosophical precision, but I agree that it sacrifices too much, and Ill cease experimenting with it for that reason. You have my sincere word on that. But to be clear, the idea of the essays, the core arguments, the things I covered, the things I emphasized, the points and connections I made, and the base writing itself were my own; it was only then reviewed and edited by claude. In the process of editing for precision, my voice was lost in sections. Despite that, I genuinely spent over 8 hours writing these two essays and am proud of them, and hope they still functioned as useful pieces of philosophical and political education, which was the ultimate goal ofc. I appreciate your feedback, constructive criticism, and support, my friend.

Steven Phillips

Breht! Once again, you always come thru. Thanks for the shoutout and thanks even more for another brilliant episode. We love you

Jess W

Also sending you love and solidarity sister!

Jess W

Loved the part about how individual therapy cannot wholly solve the problem of alienation because that is put on the individual by our society. On a personal note, a couple years ago I tried doing a Masters in Counseling and quit because I started associating with true leftists and it really hit me that I could do the most important parts of therapy: listening and helping problem solve with an added bonus of direct action - without all the whitewashed bureaucracy of a credentialed professional.

Rev Left Radio

The love is mutual my friend! Thank you so much for yoru support!

Rev Left Radio

I salute you for using your skills and talents for community work and organizing, my friend! Thank you for your support!!

mike clemow

Wow these History of Ideas episodes are so, so good. Thank you so much!

Brad James

They definitely did function as useful pieces of philosophical and political education nonetheless! Thank you for your really thorough and thoughtful response. There's a lot for us all to navigate in regards to AI use in our work, and hard to decide where we should each draw our boundaries. I just wanted to flag this for you so you would know how it was potentially coming across to your listeners. Love + Solidarity always.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you, Mike. I appreciate that and your support so much.

Rev Left Radio

I sincerely appreciate you doing so, and it helps me to navigate these issues when someone like you gives me constructive feedback like that. Love and solidarity!!

Jonathan McGovern

These two essays are stunning! One created in the back seat of a van! What? Thank you!