Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • Hagel again.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

Breht sits down with philosopher Colin Bodayle for a wide-ranging exploration of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit, one of the most influential and notoriously difficult works in modern philosophy. Together they unpack Hegel’s account of consciousness, contradiction, freedom, recognition, history, and the dialectical movement through which human beings come to understand themselves and the world. Along the way, the conversation traces Hegel’s immense influence on Marx and considers why his philosophy remains so important for anyone trying to think seriously about liberation, social transformation, and the development of human consciousness.

----------------------------------------------------------

Check out our Summer RLR Merch HERE

Learn more about Rev Left HERE

Files

Comments

Brad Northcote

Terrific episode! Really challenged the Althusserian on my shoulder. Also helped improve my understanding of Kantian ethics beyond a crude 101 version. I'll have to once again recommend Lukać's "History and Class Consciousness" because it (especially the concept of proletariat as "identical subject-object of history") meshes so incredibly well with your comments on maintaining a sort of concurrent emergent consciousness in dialectical relationship with evolving material conditions in which it's embedded. Even though Lukać himself would later self-criticize that subjectivism. Anyone else have to temper down their ego's reaction at the mention of a need to work with liberals?

BammEs

Lukács's History and Class Consciousness is amazing, but his "new" preface/self-criticism from in the 60s or so is probably the most important part of it imo

Sarah

Excellent episode! Have been listening on my commutes for the last two mornings and found myself replaying sections and grappling with new ideas - thank you!

Rev Left Radio

Thats wonderful to hear Sarah! Its def challenging in spots, but wrestling with it and other resources on Hegel should steadily increase comprehension. Here is a really good (if long) youtube video on Hegel with great visual production to go along with it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w85nGQ_KUgE

Alec Gutteridge

This is so useful, linking and making clear the implications of a lot of Hegels Ideas which I have been trying to apply in my work but have been feeling a bit uneasy about. I would be interested in either your or Colins take on the new Titus Stahl essay - What is Imannent Critique? Or the book he published afterwards. Loved the dig at french philosophers and their dodgy translation, the power of the lingua franca

Steven Phillips

Brilliant episode. Starting the second listen

Max

The Phenomenology examines the journey of consciousness on its way of acquiring knowledge about the world. At its core, it reveals this fascinating contradiction: The further you get along this path - the more concrete knowledge you acquire - the more abstract your objects become. It starts with the sense object in its most concrete form, where nothing has been stripped away from by abstraction, yet precisely because the lack of abstraction the consciousness is unable to form any judgement about it but the most primitive insight: that it >>is<<. You might notice on a forest stroll a clamorous entity, and your investigation leads you to the more abstract category of bird, going from there to form a concept about its environment and maybe one day about life itself. The abstract the consciousness starts with is poor and formless - mere existence-, yet the abstract it develops is enriched by all the concrete determinations and relations. The consciousness throws itself at its outside, trying to gain knowledge of it and is promptly rebounded from the external world back into itself (self-consciousness). But in order to understand the self, it again needs to delve back into the world: the community of the spirit, the mystery of religion and ultimately grasping at the Absolute. The Phenomenology is a masterwork of a text that drives itself onwards through its own contradictions. I would not recommend to start with it -though it may seem to lay near to do so as I once thought myself- because it’s one of the more difficult of his texts that will leave you completely stranded without a prior insight into Hegel’s thinking. The funny thing is, I have started this book now six or seven times, and I do consider myself somewhat knowledgeable about Hegel, but I have so far never finished it. The farthest I came, was to the gates of Religion. I have dealt a lot with religion in the past couple of years, so maybe I will now be able to finally venture through that last bit. The master-slave dialectic is certainly the most famous and probably the most salient chapter of this book. Though what confers it this salience, is also its weakness. It is perfectly reasonable to use this dialectic for reflections on society and class struggle etc., but the suggestiveness of the terminology kind of overshadows its systematic purpose. That’s why I like that you emphasised to look at it in a more general way, Breht. It grasps at something fundamental to the establishment of the self (the recognition in the other), not just at a specific socio-economic relation. And as Bodayle rightly points out, Herr und Knecht does not really translates to master and slave. The medieval household on a farm extended beyond the immediate family and encompassed domestic servants, maids or labourers. Those are “Knechte” in opposition to the household patriarch. It has its etymological roots in a word for “boy” or “follower” and it is btw related to the English “knight”, although the knights of yonder seem to have had more honourable fates. In the context of the Phenomenology, “Herr“ and “Knecht” are signifiers of a more general relation of authority and subordination. Bodayle certainly has a prominently liberal interpretation of Hegel. This tends to soften some of his edges towards a left audience and project some discourse into him, that threatens to skews his system a bit. Generally, reducing Hegel to Left-Hegelianism is somewhat of an impoverishment. For example, I find it odd to frame his polemic against phrenology as a kind of ethical teaching. Deeds matter here– epistemologically as the realisation of inner sphere in the outside, but not as proof of someone’s virtue. This is not an ethical critique of race science. We are still dealing with the formation of knowledge and he scolds phrenology not for being unethical but for being bad science. In the chapter, in which we encounter those osteophiles, spirit has reached a kind of empirical attitude of the world. It now knows itself as reason and tries to find itself in its environment. However, this observing gets into trouble once it has to pierce the surface and derive laws for the inner workings of its organic objects. And as it transfers a mode of thinking that worked more or less when counting plants and animals to more immaterial or rather relational objects of study (e.g. psychology), it starts to go insane. What he ridicules here, is a crude or vulgar materialism that tries to reduce psychological phenomena such as the character of a person to a physical part of matter (“spirit as a bone”). In Hegel’s time the phrenologists might be the most apparent example of this physicism, today it may be a modern charlatan like Paul Cockshott implying all philosophy could be replaced by neuroscience. What Bodayle makes out of this sounds more like Sartre than Hegel. Another thing, that bothers me, is saying that Hegel offers a “critique” of the French Revolution. In the sense of: It was generally a good thing, but it would be better with less left infighting and a more concretely defined concept of freedom. That is an approach which is either ignorant or tries to actively bury the conservative (or right) aspects of Hegel’s thinking. It is true, that Hegel was an admirer of the French Revolution and particular its results (“a glorious sunrise for all thinking beings”), but he is not idealising the act of the revolution itself. Though he sees the terror as necessary, he describes its utopian abstract universalism not just as unstable but as inherently violent. Absolute freedom is >>horror<<. He shows how from its inner contradictions the fight for freedom and liberation turns into its opposite. This may not be as crude as Animal farm, but many a leftist glosses too quickly over this passage, thereby missing a valuable lesson targeted at them. Let’s not forget: He was a supporter of Napoleon after all, who is not exactly who the left narrative of the French Revolution favours. But these little critiques aside, this episode was once again very invigorating and I thoroughly enjoyed it and the follow-up. Be well!

Left Hand Notes

“moving on to our last question” *52 minutes left in the episode this was a great listen - very helpful especially with my understanding of the master/slave dialectic. Hearing about Marx’s reference to commodities in relation to this dialectic was so interesting.