Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht and Alyson explore Simone de Beauvoir’s The Ethics of Ambiguity, a foundational work of existentialist ethics that asks a deceptively difficult question: if there is no God, no predetermined human purpose, and no absolute moral order written into the universe, why shouldn’t anything be permitted?

They examine Beauvoir’s understanding of ambiguity—the strange condition of being finite, situated creatures who are nevertheless free, desiring, future-oriented, and responsible for what we make of ourselves. From childhood and bad faith to the sub-man, serious man, nihilist, adventurer, and passionate man, they explore the different ways people flee from or embrace the anxiety of freedom.

Finally, they turn to Beauvoir’s challenge to revolutionary politics: how can we struggle seriously against oppression without turning History, the Party, or the Revolution into new absolutes? What responsibilities remain when liberation requires coercion, sacrifice, or violence? And what would it mean to build a revolutionary ethics capable of pursuing collective freedom without losing sight of the dignity and freedom of the people liberation is supposedly for?

----------------------------------------------------

Make a one-time donation to Rev Left at BuyMeACoffee.com/revleftradio

Follow, Subscribe, & Learn more about Rev Left Radio https://revleftradio.com/

Check out Unlearning Capitalism for more political educational resources

Files

Comments

Josh Ruston

So happy to see this one, can’t wait to listen. De Beauvoir, as much as she is appreciated, is so underrated.

Brad Northcote

Awesome! Can't wait to give this a listen. Read it probably in my early 20s and am now 35, so this will be a great refresher/chance for a fresh perspective at a different stage of life. I think of de Beauvoir's ambiguity as a great contrast to Camus's idea of the absurd. Much as Camus can be therapeutic, de Beauvoir's answer to the existential questions is more politically constructive.

Carli Leppard

I’m so sat for this ohmygoodness. Also — I’m wondering if you guys have any thoughts on .. the impending climate doom? It’s been terrifying me to my absolute core and I keep wondering what you guys might be thinking!

Hunterchuck

Since i listen to this podcast while working i cannot remember where to timestamp this. I wanted to address the anti-natalist point that was brought up. I've noticed a few times, even in my own conversation on this topic, that there is a kind of defensive posture when confronted with the anti-natalist position and critique. In the same way vegans are correct, so are anti-natalist because it is morally wrong to bring children into a world like this just because we want to have children. The point is that it's not about us but the one's we then subject this society onto. The point is that we need to seriously fix our society before even thinking about having children of our own. And if we don't manage it then the point still stands that it's morally wrong to bring another into this terrible situation. It's easy to reject it in the same way we reject Veganism because we still love to eat our meats. Ultimately eating meat isn't wrong, especially if the creature was already dead. But that's obviously not the point.

Rev Left Radio

10000%, our next episode is a deep dive critique of Camus (as much as I myself have found him useful, interesting, or enjoyable)

Rev Left Radio

Hopefully you enjoy it! and yes, ive certainly done a lot of coverage and dives into the climate crisis over the years. Its frustrating how it fades from popular consciousness so often, including now. Almost no politician in the midterms focused on climate change or discussed it much at all. I do not think it will be doom (i.e. extinction or civilizational collapse), but of course its going to upend everything in one way or another and be the defining issue of the 21st century. Ive had many episodes of depression/OCD doom loops over it myself. All the more reason to fight for socialism as the only viable political and economic system that can address and respond to the intensifying crisis. Revolution is genuinely the only true solution to it.

Rev Left Radio

I wasnt able to articulate my full position on the topic, as it was a passing comment - though I have addressed it in much more depth in other places. Still, I must ultimately disagree that having children in any context is immoral. There are pregnant women as we speak in Palestine, in the Congo, in Cuba, etc. Despite facing much much worse conditions than those of us in the imperial core, and still they love and have babies and raise families. I simply cannot bring myself to say they are immoral for doing so. Things are fucked, things have always been fucked, life is suffering - its the price we pay to experience consciousness. All of us feel pain, grow old, get sick, and die - and thats true in a PERFECT society; suffering and pain are built into the experience of being alive. Moreover, there is almost no period in history where it was better or safer to have children imo. Human beings have an inborn right to reproduce the species. For the vast majority of our species history we lived in a brutal state of nature where most children and many women died just in the act of attempting to be pregnant or give birth. For most of civlizational history there wasnt even germ theory. People were born into slavery and serfdom. Still, we love and create and build families and have children. Its a beautiful thing, and as long as new people are being born, change is inevitable and hope for the future still persists.

Edward Blum

Breht, has your knowledge of Beauvoir influence yiur child raising strstegy

Mexican Stalin

Its funny the final archetype of the critic is mostly leftist a modern example are people who criticize Hamas Iran Ansarullah. In the past it was Cuba Soviet union. Like there is plenty to criticize but it gets to the point of destruction of the movements

Carli Leppard

Thank you for your reply!! I’m a relatively new listener so I’m still making my way through the back logs and excited to listen to the previous episodes around climate as well! Revolution is the only solution certainly.

Sarah

Amazing episode thanks Breht & Alyson! I definitely need to read more Beauvoir! I found the analysis of failed responses incredibly interesting, particularly considering what different external and internal influences may be on how people reach those particular responses, and also on how they may then move through those responses. I’m not sure if I’ve fully understood this correctly, but it would sound like Brehts experience of the teenager facing existential despair at the apparent state of the world (a similiar experience to my own) would be a nihilist response, and then whether that be through a greater understanding or personal support or both there is a way to move past that to further developed stances? Curious as to what would develop someone further from the positioning of the adventurer / passionate man then and so forth. Also really useful in critiquing accelerationism etc!

Khaver

I have a question. I stumbled across this pod recenty via the Deprogram collab episode about Buddhism. I come from a country where pro-Stalinist/'anti-Revisionist MLs' don't exist whereas Trotskyism seems practically nonexistent in the US (ignoring the macro sense in which we're all virtually nonexistent). I'm just curious for anyone interested in the topic of that show (e.g. the importance of both structural and subjective conditions, particularly concern with spirituality, existentialism, buddhism) — do you see that as something entirely consistent with an ML viewpoint or pretty novel? I hope this doesn't come across as bait. I think my local strain of trotskyism shares with most ML traditions a kind of nostalgia for socialist aesthetics and a suspicion towards spirituality, poetry, etc. Like the guys I talk to will ask me what I'm reading to be polite, and then look abashed and aay "I don't know anything about poetry" and rapidly change the subject. The word "prefigurative" is used here exclusively in the pejorative to describe anything deemed ultraleft/anarchist/off-message. It's like code for "maybe our grandkids get to talk about that, but stop wasting party time." There are some practicing muslim trotskyists but in general you wouldn't be caught dead talking about faith or a spiritual practice beyond mindfulness and therapy. But all the MLs I've personally met are even more intensely hostile, what with the "immortal science" stuff. So is this a controversial subject in the states or not really? Appreciate your perspectives.

Adunni

Very great conversation. There are several valuable things that I took away from it. I was wondering if you could go into more detail as to how you feel patriarchy and white supremacy plays into all of this. Alyson briefly mentioned that oppressed people have a tendency to infantilise ourselves in this world, which I feel has a lot of truth to it. Could this be a product of the fact that, the world of men in the eyes of women, and the world of white people in the eyes of non white people is largely deemed as being ‘the serious world’. Thusly every activity and ideology white people/ men are engaged is deemed as inherently serious by society. Regardless of its use value to the total well being of humanity and the planet. Which might also be misleading if you are part of the dominant social group because your peers are looking to you for what is or isn’t serious when you are no more or no less serious than they are, in reality. And how do we go about reorienting the thinking of the masses with regard to this phenomena. Sorry it was long, thank you again

Rev Left Radio

Yes, and we will get into how Camus was this sort of leftist in the next ep! haha

MKUItramega0K

I can't stress enough how important this book was to me about 12 years ago. I was stuck in a nihilistic rut, drinking heavily and working my ass off just to blow my money on more booze etc. I literally quit drinking and even became a vegetarian after reading this book and I'm just a dumbass welder lol

Lefty In Training

Other than what Breht said, another issue is that the mass act of not having children until society is "fixed" (whatever that means) would lead to extinction. Advocating extinction, whether implicitly or explicitly, is immoral. Even implementing anti-natalism in a small, but meaningful amount would likely degrade the very society you're trying to fix through demographic issues. For morality to mean anything, we should not engage in immoral acts, either in certain contexts or all contexts. Yet if waiting to reproduce until society is fixed would lead to extinction or a degraded society, then calling reproducing in a society of suffering immoral is illogical. This strikes me as illogical as Kant's categorical imperative forcing us to not lie to Nazi's that there are Jews in our attic because lying in all contexts is immoral. Any rational person is obviously not going to follow that, which makes calling lying in this case meaningless. Even if I'm overstating the causal nature of moral evaluations, it still begs the question what practically one should do with the notion that reproducing in a society of suffering is immoral. If it's to not have children, thats illogical and anti-historical. If it's to fight for a better society where reproducing isnt immoral, that would be the best case in my mind, but theres also so many better justifications for doing so that i find the anti-naralist position unnecessary. If it has no impact on my actions, then it's just navel gazing.

Lefty In Training

After my thankfully short flirtation with Ayn Rand's nonsense, I did think she had a good point that acting out of moral obligations would ultimately lead to dissatisfaction, either from burnout of having to subjugate one's will to an obligation imposed on us or a moral crisis when one sees moral obligations as having no ultimate substance. Sounds like Beauvoir had a much better analysis of that situation. Which isnt hard, cause Rand sucked.

Hunterchuck

I probably made a mistake mentioning the word "moral" in reference to the position of anti-natalist since that obviously confuses the point. I realized that after Breht responded and left it at that. At the end of the day, people will change their lifestyles, like how vegans do already. I'm not a vegan or anti-natalist but i acknowledge that there is a very valid point behind it, and i respect the ones who are serious enough about it to change their life to stand by it. I don't think it's something that anyone needs to 'push' others to become. Rather that it needs to encourage us to be more serious about fixing the core issue. Because the truth is that the world has not done jack squat about it. The critique applies more to the people as a whole rather than anyone in this community that is already on the right track.