Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everyone, here is the thread through which you can ask any question you want to for our End-of-June Q and A episode.

Remember, you can ask anything: organizing advice, personal stuff about me, questions about the show, and even difficult theoretical questions or issues that you are wrestling with.

I will answer as many as I can, and for the more difficult questions, I will do the research necessary to bring the best answer I can.

Ask away!

(Try not to use this to make recommendations for future episodes, please. I would really appreciate it!)

Comments

william christopher

Can you talk a bit about writing to political prisoners? ...ways to discover who's been incarcerated, ideas about what to say/not say, anything you think would be relevant to know... Is this something someone who is relatively new to leftist theory and movements should even attempt?

Dexter Theodore

I was hoping to hear more about immigration and how it affects the working class? ( I have very reactionary relatives who say it’s bad for the working class because we’ll get taxed a shitload). Thanks for your podcast, I can’t begin to explain how useful and helpful this is! Thanks Brett and Dave!

S Abbas

How best should workers in the West fight against imperialism and their labour aristocracy? And how best can revolutionary groups in the imperial core support revolutionary movements in the Third World?

Jack Yates

Hey! I just wondered what your favourite episode you’ve ever put out is and why? Thanks, Jack!

Matthew Petrone

On both Rev Left & The Guillotine, you've talked about armed self-defense and training, which I agree is needed, but I know nothing about guns. I live in the South, so all the gun shops and ranges are filled with extreme reactionaries (Confederate shit everywhere!). So my problem is two-fold: 1) I don't want to interact with these people and rely on them to educate me, and 2) I don't want to give them my money. What resources do you recommend for learning? And what kind of places should I look toward when I'm ready to buy - like are pawn shops or online better options?

Ạ̵̌ C̶ I̴ D̴͈̏

If you have any advice on finding local leftists and what the earliest stages of organizing entails, that’d be much appreciated. Also, if you know of any great international humanitarian organizations that are reliable and focused on really helping. Was thinking of the peace corps, though I’m hesitant

Alan Scott

This is a theoretical question, and you've encouraged cross-tendency questions, so here it is. My question has to do with how contemporary Maoists view cultural struggle. I figure I'd ask since Maoists are well represented in recent episodes. Obviously one wants to avoid economism (focusing all attention on point-of-production struggle)(ignoring intersectionality, for example) because economism admittedly will be insufficient to liberate society and create socialism. That said, isn't there a real danger in trying to speculate about (let alone enforce) what constitutes "socialist" or "working-class" culture (literature, film, music, etc.)? We've seen that doing so can lead to dangers, such as Stalinist-style enforced artistic expressions (e.g. socialist realism), censorship of supposedly non-socialist art, as well as Maoist-style call-outs of art which is claimed to be reactionary (non-working-class/non-socialist)(such things as: "Reading novels is a petite bourgeois affectation," "Drinking wine isn't working-class. Beer is working-class!" "Dying your hair is individualistic," etc.). And there can also be the condemning of cultural products from (in my opinion) a very superficial, non-dialectical surface reading of a work's supposed politics. There is a slippery slope here. Where is the line between reactionary and non-reactionary art? Reading memoirs of Maoist in the 60s/70s, one hears stories of Maoists who condemned a comrade as being individualistic because they liked something like acid rock, and then they'd get pulled into a criticism/self-criticism struggle session where they'd end up having to condemn themselves, everyone falling all over themselves to to appear "more working-class," more militant, more committed to shorning everything that might ever be perceived to be petite bourgeois individualist. There's a prefigurative element to cultural struggle, isn't there? Namely, needing to push superstructural elements along in a socialist direction because those elements are stubborn, are infused with ideology, and are infiltrated by reactionary individuals. The idea being that just working at the base (forces of production/relations of production) is slow and perhaps ineffective in shifting the superstructure. But this also means that you are imposing "socialism" on those structures without allowing them to take a more natural, gradualist growth/development resulting from real, concrete changes at the base. Trotsky warned (in "Literature and Revolution," as well as in "Manifesto: Towards a Free Revolutionary Art") against trying to create a "proletariat culture" from within capitalism (but also within socialism) because our ultimate goal is to eliminate the proletariat as a class, not reify what we imagine to be its culture (as counterposed to supposed "bourgeoisie culture"). It is idealist, not materialist, trying to change the base by first changing the superstructure, imposing ideas that came from ideas as opposed to reflecting material conditions, he would argue. He makes the point that bourgeois culture took hundreds of years to form, so how can we know or even speculate about what socialist culture will be, let alone valorize socialist culture as superior to bourgeois culture when we're still deeply embedded in the heart of late capitalism. Another critique that might get made about about valorizing socialist culture above all other forms of culture is that a lot can be learned (and enjoyed) from bourgeois culture, even reactionary culture, when decoded using a Marxist analysis. Also, dialectical analysis (say, Fredric Jameson) posits that ALL art contains both utopian and reactionary elements, but never is it purely one or the other, nor, likely, can it ever be. I know there must have been and continue to be a lot of internal debate on these subjects, so I'm curious what contemporary Maoists think about cultural struggle. Are they critical of how it went down during the Cultural Revolution, and how US Maoists practiced cultural struggle in the 60s and 70s? Do they continue to do it now as a current practice? Have they hit upon strategies/tactics that takes some of these issues into account but still does the work of cultural struggle? NOTE: I know that cultural struggle isn't just confined to artistic production, but includes all elements of the superstructure, but for the sake of making the questions manageable, I'd be totally fine if you confined your responses to those areas.

Daniel and Phoenix

Would you consider Che a Maoist? I know Maoism would have not have been a concrete ideology at the time but given his support of Mao in the Sino-Soviet split and his ideas of Guerilla warfare it seems like he could have been an early Maoist.

Daniel M.

I'm going to bump Communization Theory. I'm super excited to hear your thoughts not only on the Endnotes side of the spectrum but the Tiqqun / The Invisible Committee side as well

Ammon Faerber

What is the difference between Bourgeois individualism and egoism?

Mitchell Jones

What is Luxemburgism and is it really its own tendency? Does it fall into the Leftist communism tendency? Or did she pre date it?

Rev Left Radio

This is one I will have to research a bit, but definitely Ill answer it. There was one like this last month that I didn't get to. So I need to address it for sure!

Rev Left Radio

THESE QUESTIONS ARE AMAZING! Thank you all. I cant wait for this one!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you! I will definitely answer this one on the ep!

Rev Left Radio

Fascinating question! I look forward to trying to tackle this one!!!

Rev Left Radio

In fact, I might have to break it down to a part one and part two, release one halfway through the month, and the second part at the end! let me know if you all would like this approach? So many good questions, and I wanna be able to get to them all. ALSO, I was thinking about bringing on a personal friend or comrade of mine during these Q and As to get their thoughts on these questions too. A new friend every month sort of thing. Obviously they would be organizers and thinkers, not just random dudes I went to highschool with lol. Let me know what you all think of these ideas! I want to keep expanding this and make this a real treat for you all. Something you sincerely look forward to and feel that your donation is well spent!

Alan Scott

More episodes (breaking them into parts) means richer depths of responses. My vote always goes with do more with less. NOTE: The best college English class I ever took focused on ONE text (Milton's Paradise Lost) the entire semester (as opposed to survey courses which blazed superficially through one fact novel per week). I always think about this. Sometimes less is more. Also, great idea to bring in backup, and switching it up for continued diversity of perspectives.

Alan Scott

Thanks. I'm sincerely curious. I didn't write the question the first time around because I wasn't sure how to phrase it without coming across as sectarian/divisive. Still not sure if I managed that. NOTE: I keep revising/tweaking the question to try to make it better/clearer. I'll try to stop doing that soon, but I can't guarantee anything ;-)

Daniel M.

I definitely support this idea!

Andrew Garland

Where is the divide between Mao and MLM theory?

Jacinto De La Cruz

Brett! Thank you for the amazing work you do. I have never missed a new episode since i started listening. I particularly appreciate the depth of theory that you usually cover. I have a theoretical question that has been deeply concerning to me for many years. Before being absorbed into leftist politics and theory, I also had a severe new-atheist phase. I adored Dawkins and Krauss and all those guys. Obviously, I was very much falling into scientism at that point and thought science was the only "true" form of knowledge. Because of this I later became very interested in the philosophy of science, and the philosopher that shaped most of my worldview was Karl Popper. Thus, one of the things that kept me away from Marxism was Popper's zealous critique of Marxism and the Dialectic. I don't think I have fully come to terms with this critique. I would love to hear your thoughts on this critique, if you've heard of it before, and how you would address it. I've now come to think that his view of science is actually quite narrow and it doesn't allow room for lots of work that has much value. However, one of the reasons I haven't laid this critique to rest is because I don't think I understand what the dialectic is very well either. I've never read Hegel and most of my experience with Marxism is through secondary sources. As a maoist, is this critique relevant to your outlook? Sorry for the long question. I hope it's not too much to ask. Btw, the critiques i refer to can mostly be found in his essays Science: Conjectures and Refutations, What is Dialectic?, and his book The poverty of Historicism. Thank you!

BDeF

I live in a pretty remote area and have had trouble making connections with fellow Leftists. I have found some members of the IMT (International Marxist Tendency). Anyone on this thread worked with them/are a member? Full disclosure, I skew maybe a bit differently than what I understand most IMT folk would align ideologically. How up-front should I be without burning the only bridge I’ve found outside of online friends and comrades. I’m good to just hear from folks on this thread if time does not fit for the Q and A ep. Solidarity, everyone!

Jon Watson

What are your opinions on venture communism, Ian Wright an marxist economist is doing some great work and references venture communism as a useful tool...<br><br> Im interested in starting these organizations as a way to de-commodify inputs to labor, that can later be the basis of freeing labor form the yoke of capital.<br><br> Also, what do you think of the idea of justified hierarchy, i.e. hierarchy that undermines its own power and whether or not stored labor/capital over variable capital/current labor can be justified if put under a dissipative force (i.e. concentration of capital is counteracted by either a nationalized capital market like that described in Jacobins "The Red and the Black" or something like that described by in "After Capitalism")...<br><br> Great show, thanks for what you do!

Brock Barber

We have a handful of them here, I have worked with one of them and they are a great comrade. I don't know what that has to say about the organization as a whole. I would be honest with them about your politics and be open to their ideas as well. It will likely lead to interesting discussions. If you burn a bridge based on ideological differences then they likely aren't the kind of people you want to call comrade.

Brock Barber

I am going to jump in with my own suggestions since I was in your shoes a few years ago. There are a lot of comrades out there to talk to and learn from. Depending on where you are, there may be comrades closer than you think. There are a lot of resources online that keep politics out of it or are leftist. For buying, you will need to find and FFL dealer locally that will do transfers if you buy online unless you build your own guns(which is legal). They may charge between 30-90 bucks for the transfer. You can buy guns from Walmart, so that is an option if you want to avoid gun stores. I've never bought a gun from a pawnshop. The hardest part when it comes to staying away from gun culture is a range, although I have never really had anyone talk to me when I go to the range. If you have land you can shoot at, that can be a lot more relaxing. I spent a year looking into things and reading before I bought my first gun.

Brock Barber

Do what you have to do to make a good episode and what your schedule allows for. Personally I would enjoy hearing more people on the Q&A.

Bratan Rooster

Any tips on how to combat the ‘very online’ nature of lots of Leftists’ views, ie people using Leftist language for cultural capital? An example might be the incessant Trotsky-bashing, or the stan-ing for Assad, claiming that to support the Lion of Syria is to also somehow be a good ML. Don’t get me wrong, I’d much rather have these types of arguments with Leftists than bashing my head into a liberal wall with no chance of discourse, but a lot of what I see online seems to be performative, ‘I belong to this tribe’ behaviour. Conversely, most of my dealings with different groups face-to-face have been much more stripped down: hammer and sickle carriers are friends, if you see them at protests, we’re all here to support one another.

Dexter Theodore

Hey idk if it’s too late to ask another but I’ll ask anyway. So a lot of people when they hear about anarchism they ask what does that society do about crimes like rape, murder, etc. could you talk about that? People think we need the police to keep “order”. So just wanted to know your thoughts on that and if prisons and jails were abolished, what would that look like or be like in an “anarchist” society or from a MLM perspective?

Connor Ilyich

How would one go about encouraging their union to take a more radical position? I'm a school teacher in liberal MA combating charter expansion and corporate integration of public schools and our union (AFT) seems either hesistant or disinterested to combat. I have been in touch with my local IWW chapter about the possibility of joining as a dual card carrier, but I was curious if there was something more I could be doing. Love your podcast and everything you guys bring to it. In solidarity, Phil

Edward Kehoe

Hey thanks for awnsering my question last time. Sense then I think I have listened to every episode. I have been living the music you play at the end of every episode and would love a RLR mixtaoe. I got two questions for you. Q1: Top 5 favorite rappers Q2: One my biggest pushes way from egoism/ self-sufficiency as a means of separating from the state (at least from my understanding) is how badly I worry for those that are not able bodied. Growing your own food and making your own clothes for an entire community are huge tasks but compared to open heart surgery or processing medicines with ingredients from other countries seems like a breeze by comparison. My question being in order to achieve a true communist community it feels like we need to make some sacrifices in our way of life. but have we hit a point in globalization where a communist community will still have to participate in global capitalism?

Rev Left Radio

Hey, thank you for listening, and I am glad I could get more people into the artists we feature because I genuinely love them all! Im just getting offline now, but I will come back and answer those questions as best as I can tomorrow when I have some free time!