Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Comrades!

Dr. Bones, the infamous insurrectionary anarcho-journalist and my co-host on The Guillotine, is coming into town this month to meet me IRL. We will be doing lots of cool stuff while he is here, including a VIDEO episode of The Guillotine.

Therefore, our Q and A episode this month will be with Bones and I. We will even try to do a video version for ya if possible.

So, please use this thread to ask any questions you have for Bones and I. This episode will be a patrons-only episode, like all of our Q and A exclusives. We wont be able to answer them all, but we will answer as many as we can!

Thanks for all your support! We are constantly trying to think up new ways to give back to those who support the show with their hard-earned money. So stay tuned for those ideas!

Your support means the world to us and allows this show to continue.

Solidarity,

- Brett and Dave, RLR 

Comments

Daniel M.

Hey guys! What's your take on Communization Theory?

max

With Ocasio-Cortez's primary victory and the subsequent media attention surrounding her and the DSA, I'm curious to hear what each of you think about both Ocasio-Cortez as well as the DSA as a whole.

Jacob lee

Can we get a confirmation from bones that brett's kids don't actually eat leaves? Also, which tattoo is your favorite?

LaszloKovacs59

What are your thoughts on squatting and rent strikes as tactics to fight gentrification? What other tactics would you recommend to fight gentrification in major cities like NYC? Thanks y’all!

Cristina Berti

Heyy comrades! How do you think leftists outside of the USA (such as in Europe) should tackle arming themselves and the masses and training with guns? How should that be dealt with when violence and self-arming becomes necessary especially when possessing a gun is illegal (they're harder to get and would run into obstacles with the government)? Can those places use these means to defend themselves from fascists and/or the authorities, or do they have to find alternative ones? And what would those be? Solidarity! (Am very excited for all of this!)

Sel

Intersectional leftist spaces often still aren't that good or educated on issues of neurodiversity and mental health. Are any of you aware of any leftist theory relating to that, and the inclusion of for instance autistic people in political activism; or on that note how to effectively incorporate digital communication (which a lot of people with various issues heavily rely on) within political parties and local organizations ?

Jin-ah Lee

Can you speak on the politics of engaging in the U.S. political system via voting? Should leftists vote? Voting participates in and perpetuates governmental systems of oppression, but politicians also have power over our material conditions, especially in the case of local politics and small government bodies, which control many resources in community. Keeping in mind an ultimately radical goal that isn't mere reform, should we engage with the electoral system at all?

Bratan Rooster

As you guys say on the show, you both come from differing backgrounds, tendencies, and (I assume, like an ass) ideologies or frames of mind when it comes to approaching organising and direct actions. In your experiences, what are the similarities to how folks within your respective tendencies approach organising and activism, and where do you differ? More importantly, how do you reconcile those differences?

Josh Johnson

Brett and one of his comrades from NLC talked about rent strikes and tenant organizing in the episode "Community Organizing: Advice & Ideas w/ The Nebraska Left Coalition" I'll link at the bottom to look pretty. From what I recall they were largely in favor along with suggesting other ideas to bug landlords, stuffing their mailboxes, public shaming, and more in the episode. Worth a (re)listen. <a href="https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/community-organizing-advice-ideas-w-the-nebraska-left-coalition" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/community-organizing-advice-ideas-w-the-nebraska-left-coalition</a>

LaszloKovacs59

Thanks. I’d like to get Bones’ opinion as well.

Rev Left Radio

Asking if Breht’s kids eat leaves is like asking Bones to remove his bandana...somethings are best left to the imagination.

Grant

Hey, I've really enjoyed your Maoist turn lately as you seem to be mirroring my own political development from an anarchist. Your shows have been especially supportive recently, so thanks! My question is about the universalizability of Maoism. This Finnish guy on YouTube has a video (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swYUaIzXOXk)" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swYUaIzXOXk)</a> where he argues that while Mao was an excellent Marxist-Leninist, and his strategies worked well in China, Maoism is nonetheless just an application of Marxism-Leninism rather than an objective development of it. He goes through Maoist ideas (Peoples War, New Democracy, Mass Line, Cultural Revolution) and argues that they all either aren't universalizable, or they're already apparent within Marxism-Leninism. His argument seems compelling to me and I'm curious to hear your thoughts on the topic. tl;dr: is Maoism truly a universalizable, objective development of Marxism-Leninism, or just an application of it? How should Americans, with such different material conditions, understand and apply Mao's lessons?

R

I posted this on the Guillotine page, but then realized it probably belongs here instead. I just stumbled across the Socialist Rifle Association. Curious to know your thoughts, if any, on the organization. Love the shows, keep up the great work.

Rev Left Radio

All great questions! Keep em coming! We will try to get to them all if possible.

Rev Left Radio

Okay, I watched the video, and a few things I wanna address before I forget lol: 1) I agreed with him on the parts about sectarianism at the end, and how its totally absurd to create factional splits over names, images, and smaller tactical differences. I see no reason whatsoever that MLs and MLMs cant work together, especially here in the US. 2) I disagree on some things, but perhaps the best way to express that disagreement is to pose a question to those who are sympathetic to the arguments in that video: Was the Chinese Revolution at least as big and "World Historical" as the Russian revolution, and if so, did new material and theoretical developments arise in the crucible of that revolution? I would argue yes on both fronts. And while I am not overly concerned with attacking MLs over our differences, the fact is that Mao and our Chinese comrades did learn from the failures and mistakes of the Russian revolution and attempted to address those shortcomings in the actual process of revolution. The Cultural Revolution was NOT just the basic idea that the superstructure needs to be changed as well as the base, but was more about *unleashing the people that the party was supposed to represent on the party itself*. This strikes me as a move that Stalin would never, ever have made, and it strikes me as a real dialectical answer to the problem of a party ossifying over time, separating its interests from the people, and giving rise to an impenetrable bureaucracy. Mao tried to figure out a way to not only keep the party accountable to the proletariat it was representing, but to give the masses agency in the ongoing process of revolution. This, imo, imbues the people on the ground with a real sense of power and that sort of bottom up power is essential to win, maintain, defend, and perpetuate any revolution. So while I can agree on some of the points about New Democracy and even PPW, I still think Maoism represents an advancement of the science of Marxism big enough to justify that addition of Maoism on the end of Marxism-Leninism. Having said that, I don't ever get super sectarian and I'm definitely not a dogmatist. Ill work with any principled comrade of any stripe around shared goals and be extremely friendly and loving and loyal in the process. And I think *principled* MLs and MLMs are as close to one another as *principled* An-Coms and An-Syns are, they both share a tradition, both overlap very heavily, both can absolutely work together around virtually any goal, etc. Lastly, I will argue that what makes the difference between MLs and MLMs most distinct in the 21st century, imo, is their conception of what constitutes socialism. MLs and MLMs disagree heavily over whether, say, China is a socialist country or not, the former saying yes, and the latter saying no. If Maoism is just an expression of Marxist-Leninism then why do they differ on such a fundamental question, ya know? That should give the Finnish Bolshevik pause, and I'm disappointed he didn't address that. Anyways, Ill try to answer this on the podcast as well! :)

ho

What are both your takes on academia in this society? Does pursuing a college degree have its uses or is self education the best route in your opinion?

Rev Left Radio

We answered this in our Q and A episode if you didn't already know! Great question! :)