Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello,

Please use this thread to post any and all questions for our upcoming AMA episode!

We will answer as many as we can. 

Comments

Shane

What are some of the myths or misunderstandings surrounding Maoist thought, and how can we better understand Mao's ideas?

DD

Two-parter question: 1. You've said before that you think left-wing groups should unite and work together where they can but they also shouldn't sacrifice their principles to ally with groups they fundamentally disagree with. What do you think are the general guidelines that leftist organisers should bear in mind when deciding whether or not to organise or ally with another group? 2. You've said before that you think that when leftist groups aren't united and working together, they can experiment with their different approaches and learn what works. What kind of situations do you think are better takcled by this kind of approach (a sort of "left plurality") and which are better handled by working together/left unity?

Rev Left Radio

YES! haha, but I will elaborate on this in the episode for sure! :)

Edward Kehoe

I'm not sure if you heard about the core civic HQ shutdown, but I was one of the protesters. We got a lot of criticism for going to jail protesting a prison company, and there being a lot of confusion around other options other then prison and what the right way to protest is. I also am attending a laborers conference. I live in the south and have a hard time radicalizing people due to race and religion. You can tell there passion and anger is there they just need that push. Any advice to get them to take the next step? I was also hoping for an episode of fudalism and the transition to capitalism.

Mike A

Do you know of any organizations practicing a mass-line approach in the US? If not, what are your thoughts on the best methods to getting something like that established?

max

I'm living in a secluded, semi-rural area where there are not many leftist groups working on the ground. I've joined the only explicitly anti-capitalist group around, and while we are doing good work to meet the material needs of our community, the org's goal is only to establish a Solidarity Economy locally. Not sure how familiar you are with the Solidarity Economy framework, but it's basically anti-capitalist network of worker co-ops, housing and tenant co-ops, local agricultural self-sufficiency, etc. Definitely not bad, but it's also definitely not what I believe we should be working towards, which is building socialism in a global context in order to move towards communism. So my question is sort of two-pronged: What, if you have any, are your critiques of the Solidarity Economy framework, and how would you advise me to push my organization further to the left from within? And thank you for all the hard work you put into this podcast! We appreciate all the hours you pour into raising class-consciousness. Solidarity from Humboldt County!

Jacob lee

What processes do ML's typically prescribe to wither away the state when material conditions allow for it?

Jacinto De La Cruz

What are your thoughts on Market Socialism? I just read a quite convincing argument of why China has a market socialist economy and how it has benefited from it (granted this is from a 1998 book). What i liked about it is that it offered a very nuanced take recognizing China’s accomplishments in improving productivity and the material conditions for large parts of its population without ignoring its terrible working conditions in some areas and other humanitarian failures. It seems to offer an interesting lense to look through in analyzing market reforms in previously planning-heavy economies such as Cuba. What do you think about this, and does it come into serious conflict with your Maoist philosophy?

Ammon Faerber

How can we combat “meme communism” and get people to take us seriously? I’m talking about the people who laugh and treat leftism like a costume or a funny joke for people who are too serious.

Dexter Theodore

How can people reconcile the ideas of anarchism and communism? Also what is identity politics?

Google Hushabye Vally

If you could change the history of a leftist movement/revolution/society which one would you chose, how it would it change, and how would it lead to a brighter future? This is more or less an alternative history question.

Jesse Hoffner

What would you recommend for a leftist that is very UN-social(not really anti-social), works 40+ hrs. a week, and has trouble making themselves get out and meet people. Is there anything I can do from home or something that doesn't require a lot of IRL interaction that I can do to contribute? I have serious social anxiety. Thanks, comrades.

nope.jpg

What do you say to your critics, that the Guillotine is the Infowars of the Left? In that you (I assume breht will be answering this) and bones are perceived as gunnuts who are "obsessed" with the end of the world.

nope.jpg

(please don't take this as an insult - I see the writing on the walls too and it's hard to explain my thinking to my liberal friends that don't see how bad it's getting out here)

Rev Left Radio

I actually talked about that exact criticism on our episode last night which should be released today. Its Going Down, our friends, said in a complimentary fashion that The Guillotine is the Leftist ANSWER to Inforwars (as opposed, crucially, to the leftist VERSION). I think that's fair, but certainly we do not traffic in any sort of conspiracy theories or false reporting. But if the analogy is not meant to be one of content but rather form, in that we are visceral and passionate and highly emotive, I cant deny it. We definitely are. We are NOT everyone's cup of tea, and we are fine with that. We are merely ONE door through which people can enter into Leftist spheres, not the only door. Some people connect with our emotive approach, others prefer different approaches. But to say we are gunnuts who are obsessed with the end of the world is unfair. On the show last night, I said we are canaries in the coalmine, seeing patterns that we believe are going in certain directions and trying to warn our comrades about those directions, and hopefully prepare them intellectually and physically for the plethora of bad possible futures we have in front of us as a country and as a species. But sure, I will tackle this in depth on the Q and A! I think about it a lot.

Rev Left Radio

And I definitely do NOT take it as an insult, my friend! Not at all!

Rev Left Radio

Probably Dr. Bones. Behind that bandana lies the face of a Greek god.

Infinite+Distortion (ID)

I hope you bear with me since this is my first time posting and I'm somewhat nervous. I've seen first hand how data analytics can be used to codify and structurally gloss over/codify the structural vectors of oppression in our society, through my work as a mathematician and data scientist. My question to you would be: what role, if any, do you see the information sciences playing in the construction of a radical society? I suppose I also have a follow up question: how might we best tackle the challenge of demystifying "big data" and the information sciences in the public sphere? I find that people have many misconceptions about algorithms and how they operate and categorize us; the fact that we're drowning in abstractions don't help nothing. Additionally, Cambridge Analytica / Amazon chicanery are often brought up as examples of the excesses of the tech industry, but I find that it sometimes misses the insidious assumptions that often lurk behind these algorithms in a general sense (the big one being that humans are too stupid to run a society, and so require the algorithms developed by some privileged assholes with coding competency to run it for them). I think there's something of a fascistic character present in these disciplines and within the way these algorithms are constructed; I am not sure how to convey that most clearly and would love advice on how I might best help articulate that. It would be one way to put these damned skills to use. Sorry for being a bit long winded. I love your shows and you've really helped inspire a continued growth and transformation in me. Much love.

Rev Left Radio

Funny you ask that, we already did our Q and A for this month before you asked this question, BUT I really want to dedicate an entire month (maybe October?) to the Vietnam war, having a handful of different episodes addressing it from different angles, and an entire Ho Chi Minh episode is a part of that. At the moment I am just trying to find good guests to come on and discuss this stuff. LMK if you have any recommendatinos!

Rev Left Radio

Hey, great points and insight there. Unfortunately we already recorded and released our Q and A episode BUT I am super interested in these ideas. I don't think I personally have the answers to the first question based on my ignorance of the relevant science, but I do think I could tackle, at least in part, the second question about what role they play in the political and social sphere and how technocratic neoliberalism does have some fascistic impulses within it. Either way, lets both try and remember to get this question onto the next Q and A. Id love to hear more of your thoughts on this too, as I am still learning. Thank you for the kind words about the show. I really appreciate all the support and encouragement, it means a lot. I do this show for comrades like you, and it always feels great to hear that its had a meaningful impact.

Rev Left Radio

Also, Ill be making a big announcement soon about this patreon page; adding a bunch of new levels of support with new forms of extra content, including a Rev Left Radio reading group. So if you have the time and are interested in such a thing, stay tuned! Id love to have you involved.

Pierce Delahunt

I am very grateful for the podcast. It has helped me understand a lot of things that seemed nebulous or confusing to me for a long time. I wonder about practical/concrete Leftist practices: What do the different Leftist ideologies have to say about someone trying to invest in another's business, for example? Is that made illegal? How is it enforced? Is it permissible if it is on the level on individual relationships, rather than hedge fund managers buying Wall Street stock from strangers and betting against the economy? That is just one example I have been wondering about, but I am interested in a broad range of how Leftism plays out on an everyday, political/economic level.