Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Seth (@CornCobMaoist on Twitter) joins Brett to explain and discuss Maoism and answer your questions.

(Let us know if you have trouble accessing it. You may need to sign up for dropbox, but after that it should work fine!)


Questions we answered: 

- What are some of the myths or misunderstandings surrounding Maoist thought, and how can we better understand Mao's ideas? - Shane Neal

 

- Do you think vanguardism is a valuable concept for contemporary organizing in the United States? What is the relationship between vanguardism and mass line? - Alyson Escalante

 

- Two-parter question: 1. You've said before that you think left-wing groups should unite and work together where they can but they also shouldn't sacrifice their principles to ally with groups they fundamentally disagree with. What do you think are the general guidelines that leftist organisers should bear in mind when deciding whether or not to organise or ally with another group? 2. You've said before that you think that when leftist groups aren't united and working together, they can experiment with their different approaches and learn what works. What kind of situations do you think are better takcled by this kind of approach (a sort of "left plurality") and which are better handled by working together/left unity? -F Fred

 

- Do you know of any organizations practicing a mass-line approach in the US? If not, what are your thoughts on the best methods to getting something like that established? - Mike Anderson

 

So my question is sort of two-pronged: What, if you have any, are your critiques of the Solidarity Economy framework, and how would you advise me to push my organization further to the left from within? - Max

 

- How can people reconcile the ideas of anarchism and communism? Also what is identity politics? - DavDavid Allison

 

Files

(No title)

Comments

Mike

It opens up in HTML after saving it, is it supposed to be a link?

Rev Left Radio

Patreon limits the file size we can upload so we have to use an external platform.

Rev Left Radio

You may have to sign up for drop box if you haven't already, but after that it should work.

Brock Barber

Excellent discussion on Maoism, thank you Seth and Brett!

Rev Left Radio

thank you for listening and supporting the show, my friend! :)

Shane

Dude! Thanks for the amazing Maoism discussion!

Rev Left Radio

Yeah, I think $1 is the minimum that Patreon allows. You should be able to open/access it if you have Dropbox.

Rev Left Radio

If not message us and I can email you the audio file.

Rev Left Radio

You are welcome! Thank you for supporting the show!!!

Josh Johnson

Loved the episode and always appreciate getting to learn more about Maoism. However you both saying Maoists wouldn't consider the DPRK socialist did surprise me. For a while I was interested in trying to find the distinctions and critiques between Juche and Maoist ideologies and found this article by the CPN (Maoist) where they said many things like, " they have held ideology strongly and concretized it into formula that ‘Man is the master of everything and can decide everything.’ It strongly grasps the conception and spirit of Marxism-Leninism-Maoism that ‘only the people are the creators of history’." and calling the DPRK socialist throughout the article. Here's the link if you'd like to read or respond to anything here. <a href="https://marxistleninist.wordpress.com/2008/11/30/cpn-maoist-on-juche-in-dprk/" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://marxistleninist.wordpress.com/2008/11/30/cpn-maoist-on-juche-in-dprk/</a>

Rev Left Radio

I will check it out for sure! Thank you. As far as I know, the only tendency that consistently argues that the DPRK has socialist productive and social relations are MLs. MLMs have a higher adn more precise standard regarding what actually constitutes socialism, imo. The DPRK, even though we should absolutely uphold it on anti-imperialist and self-determination grounds, are not building socialism. Socialism is, as we say in the show, not a checklist or a static thing, but a process, a transitionary period moving in a certain direction. Juche is simply not a Marxist or materialist ideology. It might have some interesting or even laudable aspects to it, and it certainly has bumped against and been influenced by Marxist-Leninist and anti-imperialist history, but its not socialism. But that's just my two cents, I am still always learning and willing to learn more of course. :) Thanks for the link, ill read it now! I do see that its from the Nepalese Maoists, which says a lot. I don't think the Maoist movement in Nepal is seen very favorably by MLMs around the world currently. But again, I'm still learning.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for listening and for supporting the show, btw!

Josh Johnson

It was my understanding that Juche accepted dialectical materialism as it's basic premise for the development of history. But for social transformation it centers man, or the working masses, as the ones responsible for the transformation and domination of the world. I got this from the essay "The Juche philosophy is an original revolutionary philosophy" written by Kim Jong Il. If you had some reading material that demonstrated why Juche isn't materialist I'd be happy to read it and expand my knowledge as well. Thanks for taking the time to respond and keep up the amazing content.

Jamie Sims

I commented on this but it seems to have been deleted or at least I can't see it anymore. Has my comment been deleted? It was intended as a sympathetic and good faith correction on the structure of the national-democratic movement in the Philippines. Really enjoyed this episode anyway :)

Rev Left Radio

Hey, absolutley not! We have never and will never delete a comment from a supporter on here (unless of course it uses slurs or something over the top). Idk why the comment isnt appearing, but I am interested in hearing your thoughts! You can message me directly on here if you want and Ill definitely be sure to read it and get back to you! Sorry for the confusion!

Jamie Sims

Hi :) Thanks for the clarification - knowing the culture of Rev Left Radio I was pretty sure it wouldn't have been deleted but was struggling to work out why else it could have disappeared. I'll just reiterate my point from the original comment. I think at some point Seth mentioned or alluded to the National Democratic Front of the Philippines (NDFP) and suggested they were a broad united front org that even ran electoral candidates. This isn't quite right. The NDFP is an illegal, underground organisation; it doesn't operate as a legal political org or run candidates. They do have a broader united front character than the Communist Party of the Philippines (CPP), but they are under the hegemony of the CPP and I think its fair to say their non-Communist base has narrowed somewhat since they were forced underground during the Marcos regime. Nowadays they are very associated with the CPP, for instance representing them in peace talks. I would imagine what Seth means is the aboveground national-democratic forces in the Philippines - these do have more of a united front approach and operate legally. Under this category you have the Partylists (a particular kind of electoral party in the Philippines' electoral system), and lots of mass organisations which federate into BAYAN. BAYAN's mass organisations are organised 'sectorally' which means basically along the lines of particular social or demographic sectors - so there are peasants', workers', indigenous peoples', urban poor, women's, youth, etc orgs which represent their sectors. I bring this up not to be pedantic, but because it is important in public discourse to maintain the lines of demarcation between legal and illegal organisations in the Philippines. Blurring these lines is a major tool of repression - trade unionists, indigenous leadership, land and environmental defenders, even Congressmen get "red-tagged", i.e. accused of being communists leaving them open to imprisonment, assassination, and harassment.

N.R. Safi

Also get the 404 error but would love to listen in to this if there is any chance of it being re-uploaded!