Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everyone, please use this thread to ask ANYTHING of me and my special guest for this months bonus Q and A episode.

The topic for the primer will be a secret (cuz why not! Thats kinda fun lol), but we will use this thread to pull questions from for the second half of that episode!

AMA! 

Comments

Lev

What is your take on the integration of classically oppressed people's into right wing movements like PB?

Doug Woos

What role do labor unions play in a dual power strategy?

Victoria Aelia Magna

Does the current failure of working class consciousness require a new or updated theory of class for the current postindustrial iteration of capitalism, or can we explain and address the lack of class consciousness thru a caste lens that incorporates an intersectional analysis of race, patriarchy, etc. which are outside the frame of vulgar economic theories?

The Left Page

Can there be revolutionary, or maybe not even that, but at the very least transformative potential in student movements and organizations? And how to position oneself towards them in either case, when there seem to be so many of them with tiny imperceptible diferences between them?

dominic

What’s something you’re ashamed you haven’t read yet? For me, it’s probably Caliban and The Witch

DD

Follow-up from last week: which texts by Mao do you recommend?

Benjamin Blackwell

Do you think the Soviet Union would've been better off if they kept with the NEP for longer? Was the at times deadly rapid industrialization and collectivization necessary/justified under Stalin?

Infinite+Distortion (ID)

What role, if any, do you see technology playing in strategies for both organizing and base building? How have y'all tackled the challenges of working with technologies that, to me as a data an algorithms scientist, has an unmistakeably fascistic impulse? I guess, to kind of wrap up my question, I'm most curious about if there are ways we can imagine using some of the technologies that are developing today without being swallowed by the models they can generate, as I feel has happened in general with algorithms and society.

Daniel M.

What's your take on Communization? Or is there an upcoming communization episode?

Dan

What do you think are the chances of a unified Worker's Party coming together out of the US Left? I really enjoyed the recent episode on the work of the Marxist Center, but I still worry that the Left in the US is too fractured and without a Party to unite behind, forming a coherent platform to agitate the working class and raise class consciousness is going to be a nigh impossible task.

Josh Johnson

Whenever I talk about Cuba, the DPRK, USSR, Venezuela etc. the topic always comes up on how the country is a dictatorship, undemocratic, entire population is brainwashed, lies we've all heard a million times. How do you go about responding to these historical and even modern day inaccuracies/blatant propaganda claims?

John-Paul Collins

I had to really spend time to think about my question. Have you considered doing an episode about the role of the Social Democrats during Bismarck’s time serving the Kaiser(s) and how he used the welfare state as a means of keeping people from joining the various socialist movements of the time? I think it’s a great opportunity to show the forces of reaction have always been willing to make concessions to workers to pacify them, a point that you yourself make often. I’m a history nerd so this would be an epic episode.

Glenn 5yearplanzig

I would really like to hear about the ml’s and mlm’s forming a government in nepal and how that relates to the naxalite movement in india and the current nepalese relationship with china. Im woefully uninformed on this subject. Any perspective on this would be appreciated

Glenn 5yearplanzig

Also, if you’re comfortable sharing (I completely understand if not) parenting as a radical. Teaching radical perspective to your kids. Also, an episode on “pedagogy of the oppressed” would be awesome.

Professor Ryan

I’m a fellow Commie Dad, my daughter’s 2, so I’m still pretty new at parenting and the resultant philosophical wrestling matches I’ve gotten into with myself over how to apply my politics to my role as papa. It’s especially tough when I imagine scenarios of violence, the police, military apparatus, etc. I’d be really stoked to hear more about your perspective and experience raising your kids and how being a parent has changed you, both as a person and political actor. Much love, Breht, and thanks for all you’re doing. ❤️

October Road

Why doesn't the left use more Modern Monetary Theory talking points? I'm not saying to drop your tendency for it but it's something that can be used along side it. It's an easy way to refute misinformation on taxes and spending and it's end goal is to realize the ubiquity of modern money. I think it's the next step on the way to a moneyless society, by making money available to everyone and undoing its social construction and contrivance.

Anton Pannekoek

Since you changed your tendency from Libertarian Marxist to MLM, you've had a lot of episodes about Maoism and China (Jun 18, 2018/ Jun 4, 2018/ May 8, 2018/ Mar 29, 2018/ Mar 18, 2018) on the podcast, not to speak of all the times it came up in other episodes, "The Guillotine" or when you were guest-star somewhere else. That's fair enough, it's your podcast and your position after all. But wouldn't it be in the spirit of self-criticism that Maoists are said to uphold if you invited someone on the show - maybe only for one half - who presented a libertarian marxist/left communist critique of MZT and MLM? I'm always in awe of how you manage to get guests of many different tendencies on and allow them room to present their views on many different topics - but that generosity hasn't extended to your own current views up to now. What do you think about it? As for whom you could invite, how about Donald Parkinson from Swamp Side Chats (<a href="https://soundcloud.com/swampsidechats/67-on-practice-and-contradiction)" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://soundcloud.com/swampsidechats/67-on-practice-and-contradiction)</a> who wrote a critique of the GPCR sometime back <a href="https://libcom.org/history/mythology-great-proletarian-cultural-revolution-chinese-ultra-left-donald-parkinson" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://libcom.org/history/mythology-great-proletarian-cultural-revolution-chinese-ultra-left-donald-parkinson</a>

Jim's Corner

What is your take on the Israel-Palestine conflict? As I understand it, where there may have perhaps only been two parties involved in the conflict in the past, it appears that within at least the last decade, there has emerged three relevant parties to the regional conflict - Israel, the PLO, and Hamas. I find myself often conflicted on how to think about the entire situation, given the historical implications of antisemitism, the various civil wars and border movements, the continuous profit-driven take-over of historically Palestinian settlements, and some of the questionable and fundamentalist tendencies of Hamas (well, both Hamas and Israel, really...). It’s a very confusing and important situation and I’d love your insight on the matter, Breht! Thanks!

TheWorkersWorld

Do you think we can appropriate American rhetoric about freedom, liberty, justice, etc. and frame it in a Socialist/Communist context? Specifically I’m talking about the common phrases Americans like to use (e.g. with liberty and justice for all, give me liberty or give me death, etc.)

John Redcorn

What's the best beer to go with while getting stoned and listening to leftist podcasts? Are you more of a mixed drink kinda guy? You strike me as a gin and tonic drinker.

Bratan Rooster

Yesterday I was at a meeting with revolutionaries from Turkey, and they were discussing ‘the Red Line’ — their policy is that people involved in their movement need to be sober, as contemporary drug culture is in no small part bound up in capitalism and is a means of governmental repression and oppression. They spoke about some of their initiatives in cities, where they’ve set up clinics and ‘healed’ people of addiction, or at the very least got them off of hard drugs. What are your views on the role (?) of drugs within the Left? Is it something that needs to be talked about, or is it besides the point?

Enrique Pérez

I understand you have no patience for bad faith criticisms of Rojava and the PYD, I'm not a fan of those either and share your basic position of critical support, but I'm wondering if you've listened to or are familiar with criticisms from non-Kurdish minorities in Northern Syria? Season of the Bitch had an episode that was really critical of Rojava with a few Assyrian women, one of whom is now a permanent host of the podcast. I'm not asking you to change your position but I wonder if you have an answer to these critiques?

Guys_Frenchy’s_Official

I love partyhats’ question about drugs and leftism and am currently researching an article to write on this topic (more or less). Marx’s line is that drugs are connected to alienation, and insobriety is a product of capitalism. However other Marxist thinkers such as Benjamin and Marcuse have been much more open to them; and thinkers like Foucault have suggested that drugs can reveal to subjects the limits of ideology. Very interesting topic!

Rosie

I would love to know how you parent as a leftist. (Pretty envious, personally)

Bratan Rooster

I’d also be interested in here that. The city/group in which I’m active is fairly critical of the YPG due to their alliance with the American military, which has now led to 25 military bases in northern Syria/Kurdistan. The fear, of course, is that what may be a tactical move for the Kurds now may be what facilitates more imperial aggression against the Middle Eastern nations.

Rev Left Radio

All great questions! Its hard to pick between them! Keep em coming if you still have some to offer!

Brock Barber

What are your views on the tension between the producers of leftist cultural products(media/art/clothing/etc) need to make a living from their labor and the consequences of 'selling revolution as a commodity' might be? What does it mean to have a leftist media outlet me a million dollar a year business mean? What's the alternative?

Petty Bourgeois Individualist

I would have posted this to a discussion on the recent Stalin episode, but I don't see it on this site. Your guests make the claim that the Makhnovists took part in antisemitic pogroms. I have found no evidence of this, except from soviet propaganda. Do you know of any resources that I can look at to prove this?

Rev Left Radio

haha, damn good guess! Yes, Im a gin boi. I drank whiskey and rum WAY too much in my younger years and the hangovers became brutal and all of that shit is also pretty fattening lol. So I made the switch to Gin a few years ago and its my go-to liquor. But I am primarily a craft beer guy, tbh. Thats what I drink for pleasure. Although i love red wine too

Rev Left Radio

Hey, If I havent gotten to that topic its simply because I have too many topics on my plate that I want to tackle! But yes, I am completely open to having on criticisms of MLM and would love to have Donald from Swamp Side on. I wouldnt want to do a debate, because I dont think debates are useful learning mechanisms and actually work against learning. But a broader conversation that includes critiques would be great! Is donald a left communist? I could do a tendency episode with him on that and embed criticisms of ML and MLM into that convo!

Rev Left Radio

I am working on a Pedagogy of the oppressed episode! I have good friends who are theater people and communists who are really into it.

Rev Left Radio

Ive been trying for a long time, ive reached out to multiple possible guests but to no avail! Any recs?

John Redcorn

A man after my own heart. Us gin drinkers think alike.

trash collector

It's possible you've addressed this elsewhere and I haven't seen it, but what are your opinions on the Frankfurt School? Do they build upon our understanding of capitalism's sophisticated ability to entrap subjects within its logic or do they deviate too far from a praxis focused, materialist line for you to consider them true Marxists?

Anton Pannekoek

I'm not totally sure how Donald (or SCS as a whole) would "sort" him/themself regarding tendencies, but I think that "leftcom" might be a fair description. I wrote to them about the idea of you interacting, but as of now, I've got no reply. I'll keep my sights on this and will get back to you as soon as I know more.

Rev Left Radio

Please do because I would love to do a show on that exact thing!

Rev Left Radio

I would honestly suggest reaching out to THEM and asking. They would know more on this front than I do. I am still learning a lot on this topic myself. Its not my area of specialty.

Rev Left Radio

I am working on an episode on this topic as well! So both of your questions will get answered in teh form of full rev left episodes in the next month or two! :)