Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The work we will all be reading for this installment of Communist Book Club can be found for free here: https://www.revolutionaryabolition.org/political-framework/ 


This thread will act as the masterthread for this book club reading. Patrons will be selected to come on the show to cover this work with me based on the engagement levels in this thread! So if you want to come on the show, please make sure to be active commenting and replying here.

This is also open to the $5 tier as a way to say thank you for all the support. So if you are in that $5 tier and want a chance to come on and talk about this work, definitely be mindful of the fact that commenting on this thread is the sole means by which you can be selected for that.

Thank you all for your support, and I look forward to reading and working through this together with you all. <3

Comments

Cassidy

Perfect!! I actually just started reading it a couple weeks ago. Got it at a ABCF event for like $5.

Rev Left Radio

Its loose; I dont want to be overly deterministic about it. But generally you have a month from when the master thread is posted

Rev Left Radio

Yea, idk. It may simply be a formatting issue? Is all same content in both?

Rocco

To start off this discussion with an overview of Burn Down the American Plantation, I found the work of the RAM in the book to be really empowering while maintaining a huge amount of tactical importance. It reads a lot like a manifesto, and I immediately started to draw stylistic comparisons with The Communist Manifesto. In 1848, Marx and Engels wrote the manifesto for a specific movement and a specific course of action in a specific context, but used the work to investigate history, the present moment, and how to move forward. The RAM does something really similar here. They show us the historical trajectory of slavery and abolitionist struggles to diagnose the problem, look at various solutions in the present day, and chart a political program and multiple courses of action for the future. I want to add that I think this comparison shouldnt be taken too far. In many ways, I feel like the RAM really improved on Marx’s version of the manifesto format by giving specific examples and focusing on what the right thing to do is—rather than focusing on what the people who are wrong are saying (ie: in The Communist Manifesto, Marx looks at other revolutionaries at the time negatively, analyzing the issues with idealist currents of socialism and the like, but pushing mainly for a cohesive scientific socialist movement. This is because of his context, but the RAM due to our current context is really able to get past this and focus on material steps forward in a more positive way in my view). The RAM give us a lot of really important tools to work with rooted both in their deep(but brief and accessible) historical and current analysis of resistance. The first section is really important for laying the groundwork of their overall argument and making the reader really feel the rooted historicity of this struggle. From the horrifying stories of US genocide to the appalling cases of white supremacist police brutality today, the RAM really makes you want to fucking do something, and makes a great case for seeing the struggle for black liberation not as separate instances of different struggles, but as the 150+ year long continuing of the abolitionist struggle itself. This brings me to something else I found as super important in the work, which was the concrete analysis of the methods used by abolitionist struggles in the 1800’s. I’d read about and looked up to the Underground Railroad for a long time, but I saw it as something back in history, and subconciously I mentally detached those methods used from our own struggle. The RAM really demonstrate with their analysis that we need to take the lessons from these struggles, modify them, and then actually use them for today. This is evident in their ideas of safe-houses and creating a modern day underground railroad, which I find to be a fascinating and very necessary course of action to combat slavery today. Just because the pre-civil war abolitionist struggle occurred over a century ago doesn't mean that its methods are stuck in that time. Just because a particular struggle has happened closer to us in time, doesn't mean that its methods are automatically better suited for our current context. This is such an important lesson, and this work totally teaches that. Makes me want to go back and read about the Seminole revolts in the 1600’s and the Mapuche resistance against Spanish colonizers starting in the 1500’s from a totally new, more practical lens. That oversight--not seeing the modern applications of methods from history--could be fatal, and I am making that change in the way I read and understand history to-fucking-day. Speaking of in-depth analysis, another badass part of the RAM is the way they look at present day examples. When looking at Rojava or the Zapatistas, often we get an idealized or simplistic understanding of the basics of libertarian socialist-type politics. The RAM really analyzes how specific institutions operate on the ground to make that society function and how they can be used to further revolutionary dual power in our own society. This in-depth analysis of specific institutional frameworks is fucking essential, and is super awesome to see in a work this short but powerful. Thanks for the suggestion comrade Explosive Soapbox! I had never heard of the RAM or this work and its a very powerful and important read. It makes you want to get shit started right now, and we all need that feeling over and over again to keep us going long term.

Jason McDonald

I just bought this book from RAM (You can purchase as a donation, I encourage you all to do the same if you can afford to) and have been diving in so I can participate in this book club event. Gimme a day or two to catch up and I'll be back!

Enrique Pérez

I'm finally reading this, and while I do appreciate many things about it, there's so many problems. It gets the need for historicization completely right and still manages to completely erase actual communist history (emphasizing the EZLN taking from Spanish anarchists rather than Maoism, Cuba, Che, anti-coloniality, liberation theology, FSLN, FMLN; absolutely no mention of the BPP's admiration for Mao and Kim; doing this weird anarchist thing where Rojava is the one important attempt at socialism that has existed; mentions of decolonial revolutions but never contextualized along ideological lines). I'm also extremely not into nebulous calls for action against "the state" that don't explain their necessity or relation to capital. No idea where this "scientific socialist" strand that manages to ignore all Marxist-Leninist or generally non-anarchist developments comes from but I don't like it. Not to say they're bad comrades or anything but there really is something missing, and it's precisely that historicity that they say is necessary at the start.

Enrique Pérez

(I'm writing this as literally my first impression, I'm not even halfway through and they could seriously engage Marxism in that time, but I still encounter this kinda stuff often enough that I recognize it).

Enrique Pérez

For all this talk of self-defense and self-reliance, a study of Juche (up to and including its limitations and failures) would actually have a lot to offer. Maroons are also a great example to take from, though, I'll give them that.

Rocco

I think thats a really fair criticism. I liked the work a lot overall, but that is one of the biggest issues. I dont know if they did it for optics or for ideological purity, but I did think that the logical conclusion of their plan of action (ie: “building dual power”, creating safehouses and safe communities like the underground railroad)is the mass line and protracted peoples war. Since, (at least in this work), they completely ignored protracted peoples war and the mass line (at least didnt mention them by name), I think it falls on us to learn from what we can from the RAM’s work, but do take those logical conclusions and dont cut ourselves off from the lessons of those who **successfully** implemented some very similar shit in other contexts (definitely thinking of Mao’s China, collectivos in Venezuela, Soviet power in early USSR, and “ungovernable zones” in the Naxal controlled red corridor in India)

Petty Bourgeois Individualist

I understand the criticism, but it is obvious that RAM are ultra-left/anarchist influenced. You can't expect that tendency to cite ML/Maoist movements as inspiration. How many MLs do you know include anarchist thinkers as inspiration? Probably far fewer than the anarchists include Marxists.

Petty Bourgeois Individualist

I actually really enjoyed how this book constructed a historical materialist conception that seemed to be somewhat original. It shows that Marxist tools can be used even by those who don't identify as Marxists themselves. While there are obviously other examples that they could use regarding self-sufficiency, I like that they focused on an example that is happening right now as we speak (Rojava). I feel that it makes the text come alive a bit more. Also, there commentary on the BLA is in line with their politics. A few members, such as Kuwasi Balagoon, turned to anarchism while in prison. I am including a link to a pdf of "Anarchist Panther." There's an interesting essay called "Black Anarchism" by Ashanti Alston, a former BLA member. Might help historicize this piece more.

Rocco

Thanks for the input comrade, I agree. Although I think the lessons of other contemporary movements, such as the Naxals, are also important, I do agree that we can't expect that from anarchist texts (just like we cant expect maoist texts to cite anarchist movements). I stand by what I stated that it's our job to read widely and take the insights from the RAM and apply them to our own overall framework (rather than getting completely stuck in our sectarianism). Thank you for the link! I can't wait to dive into this material as well.

Rev Left Radio

Great discussion and great points!!! This will be a really fun episode.

John Redcorn

This was honestly pretty mind blowing. Despite not being an anarchist, I found this text incredibly helpful and easy to read through, and really liked how it gives the reader a framework to build on. I've always thought revolutionary texts should be as simple to understand as possible so any member of the oppressed classes can comprehend them. This was an easy read beginning to end and its something I'd kept hearing about. I'm glad we were able to check it out and I look forward to listening to the episode. SOLIDARITY!!!