Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

This is the first installment in our hopefully long term series 'In Dialogue with Anarchism' feat Jon of Working Class History.

Files

Comments

Becerra Carlos

I excited to hear this one! 😎🎧

Rev Left Radio

HOpefully this is the first of many! We already have another scheduled for May.

Petty Bourgeois Individualist

After listening to the podcast, I realized that it isn't necessarily a debate between anarchism and marxism, but different tendencies within each. I think your guest mentioned this in the beginning. For example, coming from a more anarchist tendency, I always find common cause with libertarian Marxists or heterodox marxism. For example, I love Federici and the Wages for House Work movement completely changed the way I view feminism. The Italian autonomia movement has also influenced me greatly. When I find conflict it is generally with MLs and MLMs only because I think that they don't focus on Marx, but generally look to those who expanded on his theories in a variety of different ways (Lenin, Stalin, Mao etc.)

Petty Bourgeois Individualist

Obviously, as someone who is influenced by ML, you would probably find more common ground with Platformism ala the Black Rose Anarchist Federation (though I also like them as well). Sorry for the long comment! I just wanted to share some thoughts.

Shane

Super wholesome

Rev Left Radio

Yea, I can definitely see that! and I really liked the way he framed that in the show as well, I hadnt really thought about it that way. Speaking as a ML, I do think we focus on those leaders who put Marxism into action in the form of successful proletarian revolutions, because at the end of the day, I truly believe that we should value efficacy in the real world highly, and I think theory can only really be tested in a meaningful way in those areas where it meets practice and explodes into actually buidling and defending socialism. Lenin particularly is important for me because I think Leninism represents Marxism in the age of Imperialism, and Lenin defends Marx and Engels against a whole slew of opportunists and misinterpretations while also updating the science of marxism through real world revolutionary movement. I dont think thats a weakness of MLs, personally, I think its a stregth. WE all agree that we arent marxists because we adhere to whatever Marx as a person said and thought, but rather because we carry forward his analysis and methodology, and that means Marxism must always be growing and developing alongside the development of capitalism and teh development of movements combatting it. In any case, its a great point and I appreciate teh feedback AND we are doing another episode of IN Dialogue with Anarchism this week, so hopefully youll like that as well! <3