Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this bonus episode, Breht reads and responds to questions from patrons. 

Files

Comments

Rum Hamburglar

I'd push back on the the "no revolution in Europe/the hyper-industrialized countries" comment by citing both the Paris Commune and the German Revolution of 1918-1919. The latter topic in particular is woefully under-discussed in modern leftist discourse. Might be a promising episode topic?

Yung Simba

today i learned: part of becoming a communist is being a crybaby for your own life & realizing that you're actually a crybaby for humanity also i really appreciate the future episodes on movements/leaders/nations of the global south. How Europe Underdeveloped Africa by Walter Rodney is literally one of the reasons i started to consider marxism as a legit science.

Petty Bourgeois Individualist

As an anarchist, I found your discussion of liberals turning into anarchists interesting. It is true, I have met folks who identify as anarchists, but haven't read a single piece of theory besides maybe an old Crimethinc zine. That being said, I want to counter a few things you mentioned. I think one of the reasons that folks are drawn to anarchism over "Marxism" or Marxist-Leninism more specifically is the shadow that the USSR has had on our society. It's very hard for folks to see past "Stalin was a totalitarian" and the USSR was a "police state." Obviously much of this is just ideology and propaganda that has been fed to them, but MLs (at least the edgy online ones) are not doing any service by making light of some of the more questionable aspects of the Soviet Union, forced labor, prison camps etc. Furthermore, why is it that some MLs have to give unilateral support for the USSR? Why not take what's good and leave the rest?

Rev Left Radio

Yea, I guess I meant successful revolutions in the sense that they toppled the powers that be and successfully implemented socialism. Surely plenty of revolutionary uprisings, insurrections, etc. occurred. I do plan on doing a German Rev epiosde soon too, btw! It is happening!

Rev Left Radio

A Walter Rodney episode is in the works right now! :)

Rev Left Radio

I agree with all of that, actually. I go out of my way to acknowledge the failures of the USSR while also acknowledging their successes precisely because over-emphasizing one to the exclusion of the other is a form of dogmatism. We have to be honest about what worked and what didnt so we can move forward. The cold war fucked up everyone, from the "radicals" who still parrot its talking points, to the dogmatists who, in an attempt to defend the good aspects of these formations, err on the side of discounting or ignoring or downplaying the faliures. Both are dangerous, but the former still bothers me more personally haha.

Rev Left Radio

I do think defending the USSR and China against bourgeous propaghanda is important though for sure, it just needs to be done in a principled way.

Petty Bourgeois Individualist

Thanks for responding. I agree with this as well. I might add that anarchists are guilty of blindly supporting radical projects from the past as well as unfairly criticizing certain revolutionary anarchist formations. All historical projects, Anarchist or Leninist have engaged in questionable activities that need to be investigated. I just hope that folks can discuss these civilly. Unfortunately, Twitter exists...

Jamie Sims

Nice! Just finished How Europe Underdeveloped Africa this weekend. He wrote a book on the Russian Revolution which is also excellent (The Russian Revolution: A View From the Third World). Would also love to see more on socialism in the Caribbean in general as I just read Grenada: The Struggle Against Destablisation by Chris Searle and its a region where I don't know much about the revolutionary history (beyond Cuba I mean).