Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

For this month's patreon episode, we will be combining the patreons for Red Menace and Rev Left into a big Live-Streamed Q and A episode scheduled for the end of this month!

PLEASE USE THIS THREAD TO ASK ANY QUESTIONS you have for me and/or Alyson. We will answer some questions live from callers and some from this thread.

Comments

Blargh

Would you ever do an episode on the civil war in el salvador or south america during the time of operation condor?

Loge

I've been stuck thinking about subjectivity since your talk with Todd McGowan and when y'all covered Fanon. Is there a better mesh between some sort of subject-analysis and Marxism than psychoanalysis?

Forrest

Perhaps you’ve already touched on this but I’m curious: What is your position on economic growth in general? Due to environmental catastrophe would you advocate for a zero or negative growth economy even if it were democratically controlled? Why or why not? What are your primary considerations?

Shaun Mueller

Is there any chance of doing an episode on Robespierre?

Seeaiey

What topics do you have planned for future episodes? And what do you think about doing some more lightweight episodes on Michael Parenti? Thank you for producing a magnificent show!

Goth_Duck

I know Bernie Sanders isn’t the answer to what’s wrong with the country or our politics here in the US, but for the sake of argument let’s say one chooses to participate and to vote for the lesser of two evils... I keep hearing arguments revolving around a paper or article that Sanders wrote that included a rape fantasy as a reason why one shouldn’t vote for him... So, I was wondering about the facts surrounding said paper/article(?), and your thoughts on Sanders being the lesser of evils vote?

Soap Scum

After the death of Kobe Bryant, there were some leftists who said some things negative about the guy because he was a rich guy who played a sport. What are your thoughts on sports, sport figures and the importance they can have in peoples minds?

larchlad

Have you thought doing an episode on Palestine?

Isabella Fawson

Thoughts on the recent Proles of the Round Table breakup?

Shane

Young Karl Marx? Yes? Sorry, I know I keep asking haha

Zac Thomas

Can you recommend any books on the Naxalite movement in India that aren’t anti-communist? The best I can find are author’s who take “unbiased” approaches. Also interested to hear any thoughts or opinions you and Alyson have on the Naxals.

Winfield

Marxism-Lenism-Maoism is seen as the next stage of ML for that part of the 20th century when it was formalized by the Shining Path in Peru. I know that there is “Marxism-Leninism-Maoism-Gonzalo Thought” and that leads me to the question of whether there are MLM philosophers/revolutionaries/activist(etc.) who are working to develop that next stage of Marxism, a ‘Marxism adapted to the 21st century’. And if they are, how will we know it’s “real” and not revisionist? Would that require people’s war?

Gaige

I would love to hear their response to this one

Oscar Fitzpatrick

I've been struggling to find decent organisations that actually seem to take a meaningful stance towards combating capital over where I am in the UK. From my experience there seem to be a lot of high subscription fees and a lot of selling newspapers without much material action. What are your experiences with organising, are they similar, and what material projects do you think we can be doing day to day? I thought black socialists of America's dual power map was pretty cool, for example.

Free Lobotomy

Yes we want the hot gossip;) But really, I think a principled analysis of the breakup could be very productive.

DD

These question are for both Breht and Alyson: Theory question: In Breht's recent episode on electoralism with Max from working people, Breht explained that a Communist party is not just a reading group that declares itself to be one, but is instead built up from mass work and the genuine support of the masses. Breht gave examples of tenants unions and community organising as this kind of basis for a communist party, and in other episodes, he has pointed out the mass work of the Black Panthers to indicate that were the most developed communist party that the US has ever seen. However, in Alyson's article "Party Organising in the 21st Century", she noted the need for there to be a party structure alongside mass work, and listed advantages of doing so, such as sharing strategies and allowing for struggles at the national and international levels. With all this in mind: what are the steps that push local base-building organisations towards an effective communist party? In Alyson's original article, she mentions the Marxist Centre as a possible vector for such a change, but given that this specific path has fallen through, do you have any general points on how groups of community organisers can develop into a genuine communist party? Wholesome off-topic question: What's a recent piece of media (TV show, book, film, music, etc.) that you have recently enjoyed as something a little more light-hearted and a way to relax and enjoy yourselves? Would you recommend it it to your listeners?

Dylan Durie

Apologies if this has been done to death I’m only a recent patron but I’d love to hear about your best tips and techniques for bringing people on the journey to Marxist analysis and being pro-Socialist. Most of my friends and family are left liberals, hearts of gold but staunch defenders of capitalism. No matter what facts I present they cling to their cartoon caricature of totalitarian socialism with everybody living in identical drab apartments, lining up for bread and being forced to cheer at military parades or be sent to gulag. I get all the cliches: human nature! 100 million victims! No consumer choice! Totalitarianism! Tips, techniques and resources PLEASE! (I can’t take it anymore. My dad spent 5 minutes lecturing me on the Holodomor after I told him the USSR eradicated homelessness and unemployment)

Jonah Lynd-Porter

This is a bit of a dark one and a bit posadist, I've heard you two reference several times the need for a revolution pre global warming becoming an epic catastrophe. I do not think that will happen. Wed need a rev within 5 to 10 years and I don't see it. So assuming it doesn't, what effect do you think the fact that the usa and much of the capitalist world is in no way prepared for climate change will have on social stability and possibilities for future uprisings? Do you think a fascist outcome, or even just extinction is likely? Again sorry its dark i dont want this to happen but i increasingly think the only pragmatic view is that were not gonna pull this off before things really heat up. Solidarity.

Mixed Lenin

what are your thoughts on the communist parties here in the usa, psl, cpusa, wwp ect. ?

Dan

Hey, I live in England and I'm a member of a trot party (The Socialist Party, english section of the Committee for a Worker's International). I'm not really sure if I'm a trot/ML etc, I'm still learning. I have sympathies and doubts with both ideologies. But the SP were the only party active in my region, so I started there. I know you guys have doubts about trots and their ability to organise effectively, I certainly have plenty of criticisms of the party. They're set up in the "vanguard party" format, with full time "revolutionaries" and subs from all members, I pay a significant amount towards my branch. I've been active in my branch (I'm actually the chair now) and helping to organise, as well as pushing to do base level revolutionary organising with actual workers (ie build an actual interface with working people rather than just the activist layer and labour aristocracy/trade union leadership who are already involved that the sp usually work with) and pushing back against some of the liberal/tailist tendencies that I see across the party. I feel like I've had a fairly promising response, but I wanted to know what you thought about working within parties that aren't ML, and whether I'm being dumb to contribute money and time towards it. I don't want to put so much energy into something that might end up to fall into complete counter-revolutionary liberalism. I'd appreciate your thoughts. ps, your work is incredible, it gave me so much insight into texts I'd already read. Thank you and keep it up

MLDad

In one of the 2 episodes on addiction you have mentioned Portugal as an example of public policy regarding addiction. The legal framework regarding drugs was actually designed by communists, and particularly communist doctors, and the head of the drug institute was and is a communist cadre. Very much the same mentality is behind the portuguese communists' thought regarding prostitution. In Portugal prostitution is not a crime, prostitutes have access to the NHS and in some contexts to support from social workers (although insufficient). Portuguese communists believe they deserve all manners of support from NHS, social security and police. Recent moves from all political tendencies (except communists) are seeking to "legalize" prostitution, arguing that it is simply a profession like any other. I have read some comments on "sex work" by Federici which I found disturbing, namely that married women do unpaid sex work and that prostitution is pretty much the same but with payment. Well, as communists we should fight for the liberation of women from situations of dependency that throw them into the types of relationships that she mentions. Prostituted women are in an even more vulnerable situation. "Legalizing" prostitution (which really means legalizing PIMPING and opening up the "market" for corporations) has has as direct consequence in multiple instances around the world a surge in people trafficking (predominantly women and children). Of course everyone is forced to work in capitalism. It is not an option. But whereas in regular jobs you sell your work force to operate on constant capital, in prostitution you sell the use you of your body by someone else. This can only be the result of extreme need, coercion or extreme emotional damage. And it can only result in degradation of body and spirit, among other things because no one would have to pay you for something you were willing to do the first place. Also, in Portugal prostituted women are able to pay social security as independent workers and have the same (few) benefits that all independent workers get. Questions: How do you view tendencies across left and right to defend the formalization of prostitution as an economic activity as opposed to prosecuting pimps and protecting prostitutes as victims of sexual violence? How do you view the accusation that people who hold the latter stance are simply patronizing (or shaming) prostituted women to justify the “prostitution” that goes on (still) in many traditional households? I honestly want to hear your opinion on this, you can bash me if you will, but I think it IS a difficult topic rarely discussed in a principled manner.

DD

Another wholesome question: if you could do a podcast on anything, anything at all, without worrying about what anyone else would say, what would you do it on?

DD

Aaaaaaaaaaand another political question: do either of you follow the work of BlackRedGuard? If you are, do you have plans to invite him onto one of the shows/collab with him? If not, you might find him well worth looking into. He's also a Marxist-Leninist-Maoist with a serious focus on decolonisation, anti-revisionism and practically applying communist thought through mass work and party organising.

Merrilyn

Hi Breht and Alyson- y’all are my favorite podcast and I have listened to every episode of both since inception (although I’m afraid I couldn’t bear the Proles-as-guests- one because they were just too annoying with the incessant inside joke laughter allll the time.) Anyway- just like the British SWP comrade above, I was introduced to communism by a Trotskyist back in my freshman year of college (1991). It’s hard to not have a soft spot and be sympathetic to so much of what LD has written. I know you had one episode on Trotsky but it was largely unintelligible because the recording was really shite and crackly and I couldn’t hear what your guest from Colorado said - and I tried to listen to it four times and at half speed (no joke) -but I think we need at least one more non-hater Trotsky episode. Could you maybe consider doing a Red Menace episode on “the revolution betrayed”? Second request, having worked in the Philippines with the legal representatives of the New People’s Army and learning a lot about the protracted peoples’ war there/Joma Sison etc, esp.as a Maoist, would you consider doing an episode on the Philippines and the NPA? If you wanted a guest speaker or two, I know of a couple bad asses in Quezon City to put y’all in touch with. Thank you both for all of your work. I cannot tell you how much I learn each time I listen to both RM and Rev Left and much I appreciate how humble and sincere (like Malcolm!) and incredibly knowledgeable you both are. Y’all rule!

Rev Left Radio

We did do an episode on Palestine with Abby Martin a year or two ago! But def need to do one again.

Rev Left Radio

Its a great question and you NEVER have to worry about being bashed as our patron, my friend. Thats not how I operate. IF someone asks something in good faith, I try my best to answer in good faith. I too have many doubts on this question, so never feel bad for earnestly thinking through these difficult topics! Your heart is absolutley in the right place.

Rev Left Radio

I like him a lot, though I only know him through his YT channel. I have MLM friends who have worked with him directly. Id love to talk to him.