Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Please use this thread to submit any and all questions you'd like me to answer in an upcoming AMA bonus episode!

I hope you are all staying safe! <3

Comments

Amanda Wilson

How do you answer the “what about Stalin it proves communism doesn’t work” argument

Amanda Wilson

What’s the best way to go forward with Biden as the democratic nominee? Vote or abstaine?

Amanda Wilson

How do you start a local tenets union in the time of corona?

my cute friend craig

why does it seem like there’s an uptick in the slander of AES or figures in AES lately? is this because i’m online more due to the quarantine? i genuinely think it’s incredibly damaging to combatting growing contradictions when frustrated liberals who’re looking into socialism are told by folks like Libcom that Lenin was a reactionary tyrant or whatever.

Steven Phillips

Are there any examples of written material that explains how a wage free system would work? I hear the phrase “classless, moneyless” system all the time, but what would that look like on a global scale?

Amanda Wilson

Forgive me, what does AES stand for? A google search was useless

ODA555

Do you watch anime and if yes, which is your favourite?

Amanda Wilson

Why do you think America can’t pass any worker based laws (maternity leave, 15/hour min wage, universal heathcare, the fucking ERA) and if the revolution happens what would the new American economy look like?

Raised By Bats

I feel like people are too hasty to overlook The Conquest of Bread in this sense, while not particularly useful on the building of socialism, it goes into what full communism may look like and why it's sustainable whereas I think that's lacking in traditional Marxist theory.

Amanda Wilson

Silly question: remember in the past when we had backyard bbqs in the summer? What did you eat and drink? I always got one of each, and drank any pop available

Raised By Bats

Do you have a favorite Chinese leader after Mao? How about a least favourite?

Steven Phillips

Yeah. I had to google this too. I got the AES from Britain. Then I had to google NEP, which led to Stalin and the Great Break. And then.... well, you know how the internet goes

Amanda Wilson

how did you become a socialist leader? What was your journey?

Steven Phillips

Awesome that I just started reading CoB this morning!!

Amanda Wilson

is a non authoritarian government under socialism possible with a single party?

Kat Es

what kind of "plan of action" would you suggest in terms of educating myself as an ML/communist? I've been reading lenin, parenti, federici but i feel constantly intimidated by the amount of theory/books out there that i still have to read and am haunted by the feeling of being a "baby communist", no matter how much i read i feel like i still don't know anything! i also feel an obligation to keep up with current events and so its hard to manage reading theory and other left texts along with that. my question essentially then is a) what books/texts do you feel were the most influential to developing as ML and in what order should i read them b) dealing with feeling like youre not smart enough to be on the left. i hope this question makes sense, and thank you for inspiring me every day, i hope to someday have the knowledge that you do

Joe Goff

Hey Breht, love the show so my tysm for getting me through some long boring ass shifts at work. Been loving the recent eps about spiritualism/materialism and I'm wondering if you could reccomend any books that are useful for getting into meditation/zen stuff, you made it sound like such a useful tool in your own life, thanks!

Kat Es

and: what global iterations of socialism have you not covered yet that you would like to/which would you like to know more about? for instance, yugoslavia, kerala, fmln. it would also be interesting to see more about israel/palestine from you, i think you touched briefly on it with abby martin but there is much more to talk about it from a left perspective

Kat Es

to be fair, there might have been an increase of online discourse re lenin in the past few days bc of his bday

Dexter Theodore

Thank you for keeping up w/ this project. I first started listening when you had your first episode with Sole on the Solecast. Do you ever go back and listen to your early episodes? Just wondering what your reflections are on RevLeft since you’ve now been doing this for a few years. Lastly — I have an episode request🙂 May you please do another episode on the dialectical materialist method? Something similar to the first Red Menace episode and like the contradictions episode with bad mouse. Like more of a “how-to” apply the dialectical method. Thank you everything you do!

Andrew Labrot

Do you have any plans to do another episode about a leftist musician/musical act? I really enjoyed the Nina Simone ep and would love to hear another. I've been listening to a lot Phil Oches and Johnny Cash (specifically his prison recordings) recently, maybe their careers and personal lives are worth a deep dive. Other than that, what have you been listening to lately? Thank you!

Dakota Geimer

How can communism be disguised in a way that makes it “patriotic” in the American sense? To convince people something like, “what is more American than coming together with your neighbor in times of yada-yada-yada.” How can be turn the idea of communism and solidarity into mainstream American culture?

Amanda Wilson

How will socialism help disabled people

Amanda Wilson

Oh my god if I see one more ad from coke or dole about how they love all people I’m going to barf

Petty Bourgeois Individualist

Considering that many of us on the left are trying to create a mass movement, do you think the invocation of Stalin either in organizing or as memes can hurt us in our attempt to spread socialism among the masses?

Ricardo de Souza

Hey Breht, thanks for the amazing show, man! Perhaps you could share with listeners some views and thoughts about this beautiful renaissance of socialist initiatives in America. I know a lot of people out of this vibe and out of the US who first react somewhat in disbelief when hearing that there is genuinely revolutionary left brewing in the US. This is an outstanding sociopolitical and cultural shift. Just out of a wild guess, I wouldn't be too afraid to bet that maybe the growth rate of support for socialism in America might be leaving much of the world behind.

ThwaitesAwaits

Breht, What is your opinion of Kropotkin? I have been listening to his works and I'd like to know what you think.

ThwaitesAwaits

Not sure if asking two is allowed, but I thought of another related to my first question. I have heard from others that Lenin spoke well of Kroptikin. Is this true, or false? I haven't been able to verify it.

Drew

Breht, Thank you for all that you do. Like you, I am interested in Buddhism. I have been having some difficulty with the ideas around compassion and, sort of, not letting the world affect you emotionally, and squaring that with my socialist goals. To paraphrase Che - I DO tremble with indignation at every injustice, and I worry that Buddhism may make me complacent. What are your thoughts?

Ethan

Hi Breht, I previously submitted this question by email but not sure if you got it. I was wondering if you know anything about/have considered doing an episode on or if you have any recommendations for resources to check out on the recent history of Southeast Asia. How should communists in the west today understand the history of the Khmer Rouge, the Pathet Lao, and post-US Vietnam? How successful were these attempts in establishing socialist states and what can we learn from them? It's hard to find fair and balanced information on Asian communist history in the west, and your episodes on Vietnam and China have been super enlightening. Thanks and solidarity!

Naomi

Hey Breht, love the show thanks for everything you do. I was wondering if you have listened to The East is a Podcast or The Red Nation? Both have become two of my favorite podcasts since discovering them and they seem to fall in line with the principled left wing analysis you put out on Rev Left and Red Menace. Additionally if you're familiar would you consider having Nick or Sina on the show?

Brent R.

What are a few books that were pivotal to your political development?

Antoine lourdin

Hey comrade I live in Stockton California and we have a very big poverty and homelessness problem that I’m sure will increase with this current crisis. In my city as I’m sure is the case in many other cities, there are homeless camps all over, under bridges, the side of freeways, along the train tracks, and near parks. I’ve been thinking that one thing that could help is planting fruit trees at parks, on the side of freeways, or even along the sidewalks. Parks already have sprinkler systems set up for watering, and they always plant other shrubs or trees along the freeways and sidewalks. I think this would be a small but easily achievable and environmentally friendly step to help with hunger on a local scale. I guess my question is what are your thoughts on this ?

Ryan Tardiff

When it comes to left orgs, what do you think the best work comes out of: groups with a measured political line or one that allows for a larger tent but maybe a less sharp political line? Or is that a false dichotomy?

Joseph

I was recently reading JT Murphy's "Growth of Social-Fascism" from the CPGB in 1930. I feel like it is still very relevant. You should give it a read, if you have not. It discusses how social-democracy creates class collaboration to the level of crushing, sometimes violently, revolutionary movements to save the capitalist system. What is your position on this topic, in terms of left unity or working with leftists who are more toward the "center" of the political spectrum? I consider this topic complicated because we want to improve the conditions of the working class, yet we want to avoid the road toward fascism.

Tomme

Pulling from this thread, do you have any interest in third parties? Greens/PSL/etc

Tomme

Hey Breht, I’ve really enjoyed your engagement with Maoism with JMP, a favorite philosopher of mine, as well as your discussion with Indigenous communists and the de colonial discourse more broadly. I’m very interested to hear your thoughts on J Sakai’s Settlers? and similar critical labor history’s of white workers as well as Third Worldism generally, less from a simple approve/disapprove, but more what you feel these discourses have to offer communist thought today?

Dusty

Have you seen Cuck Philosophy's video "Marx was not a 'statist'"? If you have, what are your thoughts on it?

Jamie Sims

I'm listened to your episode on DMT and I'm about half way through reading 'How to Change Your Mind'. I'm thinking about how we should understand the historical/social/'spiritual' impact of psychedelics as Marxists. Clearly Marxists agree that nature and technology (the spiritual and therapeutic practices that Pollan describes are some combination of the two) can shape social evolution and therefore its not necessarily anti-materialist to look at how LSD drove the counter-culture etc. However, 'How To Change Your Mind' also profiles people who thought if we could just give the elite LSD or psilocybin then there would be peace and socialism. This strikes me as implausible. Not least because psychedelics have become trendy in sections of the elite without this happening. For instance, Pollan talks about the way Silicon Valley's culture was rooted in LSD - if doing psychedelics leads to transcendental, universal love and wisdom etc why did people like Steve Jobs channel their LSD-inspired creativity into becoming awful monopoly capitalists? I don't think you're claiming this kind of bullshit, of course, but I'm just wondering how we reckon with that contradiction between the determining role of social relations and class vs. the genuinely powerful individual impact of 'spiritual' technologies like psychedelics (or the same would apply to Buddhism and meditation I think).

Ethan

I love this question and I'd love to hear what Breht has to say about this. There is a great chapter in Team Human by Douglas rushkoff (who was interviewed on Rev Left) that outlines how the LSD inspired transcendentalist movement in California paved the way for anti-human techno capitalism of Silicon Valley. Also talks about how the psychedelic movement was co-opted by neoliberal capitalism into the new age self-help industry that put the emphasis on individual growth over universal connectedness. Fascinating stuff

Jamie Sims

I'd be really interested to read that! Pollan's book is interesting but clearly not overly materialist or left-wing.

Jamie Sims

I think perhaps part of the answer here is that psychedelic experiences draw on people's existing ideas and there's a big 'expectancy effect'. Pollan talks about how people with different religious views had 'mystical experiences' which aligned with their pre-existing religious views; also that therapeutic trips tended to align with the therapists' favoured psychoanalytic worldview - e.g. Freudian pyschoanalysts induced trips where people reported all the stuff you'd expect about desires etc, whereas patients treated by Jungians claimed to access the collective unconscious. So, to quote Marx, social being still determines consciousness to some extent. Most people don't think they're the bad guys and could easily end up seeing their ruling class project as consistent with love and compassion I guess. But I do worry about collapsing everything down to pre-existing ideological conditioning. We need some reckoning with the specificity of the psychadelic experience and the genuine and profound changes in people's worldviews.

David

I was listening to an earlier episode (Refuting Common Arguments Against The Left), where you identified as an anarcho-communist. I'd be interested in hearing about what influenced your development from that to MLM.

MLDad

I don't have the brain to place a question atm, but would like to suggest the very best Max Romeo's "socialism is love" for the outro of some upcoming episode 😁 Solidarity, take care and be kind everyone

MLDad

What was Mao if not an anarcho-communist 😊

Kat Es

whoa that wasn't even that long ago! i would want to know what specifically was a causal factor for switching over, people's development as leftists/communists whatever you want to call it is itself quite a journey that deserves ample analysis