Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

We are finally getting to a Q and A bonus episode this month, please ask any and all questions in this thread, and Breht will answer as many as he can in the next patreon episode!

Thank you for your continued support. It means the world to us and our families. 

Comments

Quém é

Did you have an ideological 'cringe' phase as a young person (e.g. Objectivism, etc.)? If so, how do you, feel that impacted your journey to Leninism, and what about your 'cringe' appealed to you in the first place?

Dexter Theodore

I really liked your episode on Althusser and ideology. I would like to hear your thoughts on Soviet psychology, or if you’ve ever read Evald Ilyenkov?

Ethan

How did you get into/learn to practice meditation? Where would you suggest someone interested in the practice to begin? Have you used apps like Headspace and Calm and do you think these can be helpful tools or are a simply consumerist co-optation?

Kat Es

did you ever do an ama from the last post where we asked you questions (like a month ago)? if not, my question was: what global iterations of socialism have you not covered yet that you would like to/which would you like to know more about? ie like yugoslavia (where i live now, and it is very interesting) or fmln or palestine. my other question would be which texts do you feel were fundamental to your development as ML?

Ryan Tardiff

I just read Freedom Dreams by Robin Kelly and he talked at length about surrealism and it's link with communist thought. Between that and it's link to psychedelia, any thought of doing a surrealism episode and/or do you have thoughts on surrealism?

Winfield

What are your thoughts on the CR-CPUSA?

Eric Knight

How do people with class privilege and/or family wealth best support working-class organizing? Is there a place for members of the bourgeoisie in Marxist organizing other than simply materially supporting it and redistributing the wealth they have access to? Other than Engels are there any prominent examples in history for those with class privilege to model their praxis on?

Blargh

Hey there! I asked a few times but never heard back, but can you do an episode on operation condor? I feel that many should know about the brutality of South American dictators and the deaths of comrades fighting for a better world.

Ethan

also have you seen the Soviet film I Am Cuba? it's a truly amazing portrayal of Cuba leading up to/during the revolution and shot in the direct aftermath. certainly made to be propagandistic and I've heard some criticism that the Cuban characters are somewhat stereotyped but taking the criticisms into account i think it still holds up as a beautiful example of revolutionary cinema with some really incredible cinematography, highly recommend for anyone to check out

Rev Left Radio

I used a few for our RM patreon with the intention to do a RLR one, but it just got skipped over for other stuff. But I will go back and pick a few from that old thread too! Ill try to make this Q and A a long ass one answering as many questions as possible, including this one!! Thank you.

Rev Left Radio

Great Question! ill answer it on the episode, but for now ill just point out that Che was from a middle class family and could have become a doctor, and Fidel started off as a lawyer. Both professional class and relatively wealthy people who gave it up to fight for liberation. Lenin was a Lawyer, Marx came from a relatively well off family; Engles obviously did too. So yes, there are LOTS of examples of revolutionaries who came from the ranks of classes other than the proletariat proper. There is NOTHING about socialism or communism that rejects participation from any class. If you are willing to fight for others, if you are willing to betray your upper class interests for the interests of everyone, then you are a comrade!

Rev Left Radio

Great question. Absolutely I will get to this!!! Its a great idea and I have a few guests already in mind who could be perfect for it!

Ally

Hey Breht! I'm not sure if you've done an episode on this and I just missed it, but what are your thoughts on state surveillance, especially in this time of social media and digital organizing? It's something I've been thinking about a lot lately with the uprisings, and I'm trying to understand its affect on other organizers in the present day. I know we probably won't know the extent to which activists and organizers are being surveilled until years, maybe decades, from now, but just wanted to hear your perspective on the topic. Thanks for all that you do!

Southern Fried Bolshevik

Are there any podcasts by and for Black socialists and communists that you would recommend?

Silent Mandible

I wanna add that Georges Bataille has a collection of essays on surrealism that’s being sold by Verso, who describes it as an application of Marxism. I have it but haven’t read yet.

Silent Mandible

What are your thoughts on Juche? Will you ever do an episode on it?

Crawdad

Have you lost any friends or loved ones to the Q conspiracy cult? I’m curious how you would address that or respond to their nonstop fear mongering and paranoia that seems to be tearing apart relationships across the US

DW

For Marxists/the Left today, what would you say is the biggest insight from Marx that we misunderstand to the point that it impedes our analysis and ability to effectively fight capitalism?

Fidolith

I’ve been wondering what your thoughts are on prison abolition, “gulags” or re-education facilities for reactionaries, and what that may look like in the US (or USSA or a Balkanized US controlled by Indigenous and Black Peoples)

DW

Another question, I was looking through old episodes for things to put on my “listen to” list and listened to a bit of the Libertarian Marxist one where Breht debated the minarchist. This was back in 2017 but in it you discussed how “fascist” gets overused on the Left and you didn’t think it described Obama or Trump. Do you still have that assessment of Trump? If not, when was the moment you reassessed your analysis?