Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

J. Moufawad-Paul lives in Toronto and works as casualized contract faculty at York University where he received his PhD in philosophy. He is the author of Austerity Apparatus, Continuity and Rupture, and Demarcation and Demystification.

 In this episode, Breht and JMP discuss intra-Maoist lines of thought, examine their differences, and argue for a specific strain of Maoist thought as most in line with a scientific approach to socialism; one that avoids the traps of dogmatism, eclecticism, and opportunism.  

Get the 2nd Edition of The Communist Necessity  HERE

Get Critique of Maoist Reason  HERE

Check out JMP's website HERE

Outro Music: 'JU$T' by Run The Jewels (feat. Pharrell Williams and Zach de la Rocha)

LEARN MORE ABOUT REV LEFT RADIO: www.revolutionaryleftradio.com

Files

Comments

Petty Bourgeois Individualist

Thanks, this is great. For someone who has always been skeptical of Maoism because of how I perceived it as dogmatic, this conversation really cleared a lot of stuff up for me. Thanks for doing this.

Chris torres

Im still struggling to understand dogmatism vs. eclecticism. On one hand JMP says we cant fall into dogmatism and on the other he says we cant fall into eclecticism. He says to read everything. Whats the point of reading everything if we aren’t supposed to pick and choose from them? How do we apply something theory written into 1800s exactly the way it is for our time period? If we do it makes us dogmatic, but we shouldn’t be dogmatic. Im sorry if this isn’t clear but its just confusing to me and I really want to get a grasp on these concepts. Can anyone lace me with game?

Rev Left Radio

Totally fair question! So dogmatism is when you replace critical and scientific thinking with slogans and doctrines; this is an abandonment of dialectics. Ecclecticism is when you pick and choose from a bunch of different and disparate political theorists and texts on an individualist basis; choosing what tickles your fancy for its own sake. You can and should read widely, but critically, and from a principled historical materialist perspective. For example, I can read postmodern theory, liberal philosophy, and anarchist political thinkers without randomly taking on board any of it as a part of my political outlook, but while letting it sharpen my understanding of my position and others, and bringing in aspects of those theories when its advantageous to; i.e. when it assists in making revolution or advancing the class struggle. But it has to be subordinated to the scientific socialist outlook. IN the same way that, for example, a climate scientist can read a bunch of pseudo-scientific rants and even detailed arguments from climate skeptics, without taking those positions up for themselves. But by reading them, the climate scientist gets a much better understanding of where people deviate from teh science, what the opposition to his scientific endeavors is premised on, and how to more effectively reach those who may be skeptical. Thats not eclecticism, thats scientific rigor. IF that same scientist instead began to cherry pick from the pseudo-scientists and the climate skeptics ideas that he personally liked, and attempted to bring those into his scientific endeavors, then he would be abandoning science in favor of eclecticism. tl/dr: critically engaging with other texts from a solid foundation of historical and dialectical materialism is not eclecticism. Non-critically engaging with them without that foundation, and taking on board aspects of other positions that personally resonate with you is eclecticism. I hope that helps! LMK if ive failed to bring clarity here and Ill try again! These are difficult ideas for sure, and they revolve around the idea that Marxism is a science. If you want to hear more on that then check out our previous episdoe with JMP called "Marxism as Science: Ruthless Critique of all that Exists", and that may help!

Chris torres

Ive heard all of the talks with JMP and it always leaves me confused about this subject. Haha I guess i miss a part where he explains what you just told me or something, not sure what happens. The climate scientists example helps a lot. That clears it up a little more. I just need to study more and become more grounded in my scientific socialism. I definitely a few more thoughts and a few questions but i will work them out elsewhere, i know you are mad busy. Thanks big homie for responding so clearly and quickly. Yee!

Rev Left Radio

Hey, no problem at all! You support the show, so I am ALWAYS here for you. If you ever have any other questions or anything, never hesitate to ask. Ill do my best to answer! :)