Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode Breht reads, and responds to, the essay by the Indian Maoist intellectual Ajith entitled "To Be in Communion with our Social Selves" from the collection of essays titled "Critiquing Brahmanism".

Breht talks about misunderstandings surrounding meditation, the Marxist analysis of religion, the one-sidedness of critiques from both sides of this particular debate, and much  more. 

Files

Comments

Stephen CM

I'm helping start a meditation group within a local Marxist project. We're using this discussion as a jumping off point to discuss and understand the two topics. Thanks!

Yves Chan-You

Congratulations on your wife's pregnancy!

Trey Kassed

Congratulations on your wife’s pregnancy, Breht! This was a great episode, and I truly love the spiritual focus of some of your recent episodes! You’ve inspired me to begin looking into Buddhism myself now, and I want to thank you for that! I only just recently became a patron and I’m beyond happy that I did.

Jamie Sims

Very excited to listen to this one! I think I'm going to hold off until I've read Critiquing Brahmanism so I have a fair and complete understanding of Ajith's position before engaging with critiques and reviews of it. Hoping to do a big deep dive on Indian politics, history, and communist movements over the coming months. At the moment I'm reading a very broad, non-Marxist history of India to ground myself a bit in the main events, figures, and historical eras. Once I've finished that, the Ajith book is next :)

Ash

Congratulations! Recent patron so let me just say thanks for expanding my understanding in a bunch of ways and for being a resource I can send to family and friends. Solidarity :)

Rev Left Radio

That is so wonderful to hear. Thank you SO much for the support, my friend. <3

Rev Left Radio

Thats awesome! Good for you. While I disagree with a few things in the essay, overall our conclusions converge in basic agreement! I think once you listen, youll see there is more agreement than disagreement overall. In any case, good luck with your deep dive and thank you for your support!

Rev Left Radio

Thats great to hear! Thank YOU for your support, it means the world to me.

Susie F

I always enjoy your podcasts that talk about Buddhism and meditation. It was through my own spiritual study that I found my way to Marxism in the first place. (After a yoga retreat I began to research vegan diets and eco-feminism and that led me to the wonderful Mexie at Vegan Vanguard which is where I first heard of Rev Left!) I vividly see the connection between my spirituality and my social justice work as I work to go deeper into both. And congratulations!!! I have three children myself and I've spend the last year reading Silvia Federici as I attempt to reconcile Motherhood and Marxism.

blursville

Congratulations, Breht!

Abigail Highland

I have been wrestling with the *appearance* of the lack of space in the Marxist community for the power of spirituality. Thank you for highlighting that the space exists. Your conversation about this, liberation theology, etc. is so appreciated and feels incredibly inclusive and mind-blowingly spot-on.

eholar

Congratulations Breht, and also thanks for making meditation accessible to those of us put off by the prevailing supernatural framing. And yet, despite the importance of the introspective to counter the "monkey-mind" inducing world we must navigate, I wonder whether social values are really there to be "found", or whether they are brought in from the outside. I've been put off by most teachers (e.g. the ones Michael Brooks recommended), and wonder if there are any you know of that are also socialists. If not, I wonder how that is possible if the compassionate insight is endemic to a higher practice. Thanks.

Jamie Sims

Just listened to the episode. Thought it was really wonderful and touched on a lot of things I was uncomfortable in with Ajith's argument, but you articulated from a much deeper knowledge of these issues than I have which was very helpful. His discussion of neuroscience was interesting but I don't feel like it was really the great refutation of meditation he thought it was. It feels like a misapplication of materialism to say well these insights and practices have a basis in brain activity so they're fake; he talks about the importance of overcoming alienation and a spirit of serving the people - couldn't someone with a similarly reductionist position also say "well there's nothing very deep or profound about committing yourself to serving the people. Look we did an MRI and found this brain area lights up when you think about serving others!" I read Resurrecting Jesus since your last meditation episode and Adyashanti also came to mind when I read Ajith talking about the importance of abstract and associative thought. Resurrecting Jesus is quite clearly not the work of someone who's mental capacity has been addled by some "absolutist" pursuit of "spiritual bliss" (in Ajith's words). I also think that book ironically traces a similar argument to Ajith in terms of how religions arise as radical critiques and then are recuperated. Adyashanti makes that point about how Christianity emerges as a critique of the ossified Judaism of the Pharisees but has become institutionalised and therefore become no different to the Pharisees.