Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

For our next Q and A I want to focus on any questions you may have regarding meditation or buddhism specifically, given the enormous feedback I've received about our recent guided meditation. So if you have any questions on that front, this is the perfect vehicle for them!

Beyond that though, feel free to ask me anything you want in the comments below, and I will choose a few to answer on an upcoming Q and A episode! 

Comments

Trey Kassed

After listening to your recent episodes focused on Buddhism and meditation, I have begun reading a lot about Buddhism and meditating more often. I’ve been reading this great book called “What the Buddha Taught” and I have learned a lot about the philosophy of Buddhism. And with all of the talk about impermanence and about how the world is a constantly moving process, and about how the Buddha’s teachings were essentially an analysis of how the material world impacts people’s mental/“spiritual” states, I feel like Buddhism is fundamentally a Dialectical Materialist philosophy. Would you agree that Buddhism is a Dialectical Materialist philosophy, or am I misunderstanding it in some way?

tlance

What do you think of spiritual justice? Stirner's Unique and It's Property describes the modern (1800's) human as driven mainly by spirituality, whereas pre-modern humans were focused on materiality. Stirner argued for a new human (post-modern) who could simulataneously seek material and spiritual goals, he criticized Marx for his focus on materiality (though I think there was more to Marx than Stirner gave credit). Pre-modern (per Stirner) would have derived enchantment/mysticism from the natural, physical world, they had not yet created ideas of a singular god that produced everything. Abrahamic faiths brought about monotheist movements that litteraly, killed, burried, or appropriated the past state of human spirituality. In various ways and forms, spirituality was monopolized, or detractors were quieted. My question is whether or not, our language about the many forms of justice, needs to include bringing equity to spiritualities. Not just for the sake of reperations, but to free our individual human psyches from the threats and incentives, not to leave underlying contradictons. Do you have any guest ideas to discuss this topic?

Thomas

Was Marx wrong to say religion is the opiate of the masses?

Eoghan

From what I understand that there are different meditative "schools" such as Zen, and Theravada in Buddhism, Dhyāna in Hinduism, as well as other more controversial (but seemingly popular) ones like Transcendental Meditation. What are your thoughts on the different techniques and which one would you subscribe to if any?

M F

do you believe meditation can provide the same benefits as psychedelics for those with depression, anxiety, PTSD, addiction, etc? do you see the illegality of plant-based therapies as just a way to control commodities/profits or is it something more menacing? studies show psilocybin makes people smarter and more compassionate because it dissolves the ego and creates an awareness of the interconnectedness with all things. i'm a fan of paul stamets (6 ways mushrooms can save the world) and just watched dosedmovie and fantastic fungi documentaries so the idea of the way we evolved to live with nature and the way capitalism punishes people who do is on my mind.

Samuel Komack

Would you care to speak on how spiritual practice could be used as one method to help maintain a mentally healthy revolutionary base and prevent burnout?

J Hagler

Are there meditative traditions in other religions? Also is there any data regarding "trait openness" is affected by meditation?

Anthony Tous

Thank you so much Comrade for doing what you do 💖 Question: Have you found it difficult at times, to sustain a Spiritual Practice while engaging in Communist Contemplations and Action? Currently I find myself cultivating a deeper understanding of Communist projects during Life phases we might roughly label as "Dark Nights of the Soul"... As if those Truths are hidden within the Underworld itself. The Flames of Revolution and those of Hell can seem indistinguishable during those periods. It feels like an Alchemical Operation. Personal Reflection: One thought I've been really "sitting" with is the notion of the 'Astral' being on Fire (if I'm not mistaken this is how Eliphas Levi the famed French Occultist and Utopian Socialist, described the Astral, in his work on Transcendental Magic) a kind of protracted Apocalypse-Event revealing the Protean and Pandaemonic character of the Collective "Imaginal" of our Species... Wherein the old Powers and Principalities lose their Dominion and the Ideological landscape of Humanity as a whole is drastically transformed and given new shapes, geographies, and architectures. The Emancipatory Politics of Communism, seems to be a sort of terrifying but liberating Baphomet in our present time. It feels all to easy to fall into a state of despair and rage while navigating these spaces and collecting the pearls of wisdom and compassion, of Truth. I believe a developed spiritual regimen among other techniques can prove vital for those of us involved in these Struggles. We cannot lose sight of the principles that inform and animate our Political Action and Philosophical Contemplations. We risk becoming burnt out shells otherwise. Recommendation: Hegel and the Hermetic Tradition by Glenn Magee is a fascinating text and does an excellent job of laying out a genealogy connecting Hegelian Idealism with Hermetic Philosophy and Alchemy. Critical-Negative Thinking as the Alkahest, the Philosophical Mercury that's essential to the 'Solve et Coagula' of Transmutation. Hegelian Thought (and I would by extension argue, Marxian Thought) is a form of Speculative Alchemy.

Workers' Lit

What are your thoughts present day China/would you interview a Chinese communist?

Rev Left Radio

Great question. You are 100% correct in identifying it as a dialectical philosophy and a process philosophy. However, the materialist part depends on which traditions and which thinkers you engage with. There can be both materialist and idealist forms of dialectics within buddhism and within much of East Asian philosophy. There can also be dialectics which remains agnostic on the question of materialism and idealism!, or combine them into what is often called "neutral monism". In any case, Ill answer it and go more in depth with this in the episode! :)

Petty Bourgeois Individualist

The Left seems to be debating the need for the creation of some kind of Left Wing Party. Some say we need to have the traditional Leninist Democratic Centralist model, while others are proposing something more akin to the party as a "network" of various groups. How do you envision a Communist Party in the 21st Century?

Joely

I know this is a question for Breht, but in response to your first question, from what I've learned about it - the speed at which the effects take place also correlates with the speed at which they dissipate. So, psychedelics are a great quick short cut to ego dissolution, but the effects may not last as long as say a daily meditation practice. Where a meditation practice may not bear fruit nearly as fast, but will sustain much longer. Both are great for different circumstances really. Awesome questions by the way! Looking forward to Breht's response.

Anthony Giorgio

Liberation Theology as I understand it is largely a Christian phenomenon, but are there instances in history where Buddhism has served a role as the local theology of liberation? Are there any Buddhist revolutionaries that we can look to? I know Yuri Kochiyama (who was Christian) was a fan of the poetry of Thich Nhat Hanh — do you have any thoughts on him and his practice of “engaged Buddhism”?

Jamie Sims

Have you read any of Kim Stanley Robinson's science fiction? He's a socialist author who is also into Buddhism, for instance his book The Years of Rice and Salt is an alternate world history told through the lives of a group of characters who meet in the bardo and are reincarnated over and over again in different historical eras.

Luci

So I started listening to Red Menace back in April which opened me up to a plethora of Leftist media which I’ve tried to integrate more pervasively in my life — I’m very new to this stuff. To be honest, I feel like a good 65% of this stuff just goes over my head, but I keep listening (reading is really hard for me) in hopes that this stuff will start to sink in and click more and more as I keep studying (which has already happened some). My guess is that that’s just how it kinda has to be especially due to the complexities of this stuff and my lack off background in economics, philosophy, politics, etc. (I am, however, training to become a therapist so the Franz Fannon episode was huge for me). At high risk of asking a boringly basic question, I guess my question is this: where might be the best place to find communist responses to capitalist critiques of communism? Things like that have often been nuggets that seem to boost my learning forward and help all the other stuff come together. Thanks for your time! Super grateful for your work here!

Jordan Wyner

Breht, I got an important question: what the hell is your intro music??that stuff is dope

Andrea Cristina

Will you do an episode on religion? From what I’ve heard of your show, you don’t seem very critical of it/them.

Rev Left Radio

For sure. We have done some episodes on Christian Socialism and LIberation Theology. I just released an episode on Buddhism, and have planned an episode on Sufi Islam. So yes, much more religious explorations coming.

Aryon Shahidzadeh

I'm pumped for your episode on Sufi Islam!! Absolutely loved your episode on Buddhism.