Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Alyson and Breht discuss recent events, and what they mean going forward. 

Files

Comments

Sorge's ghost

I would like to offer some constructive criticism of your position that this was only a "riot". Im not understanding your incoherent defition of riot or insurrection or how you are making a distinction between them. This clearly fits the definition of an insurrection or rebellion or putch, because it did have a political goal of changing the function of government and who was in power, no matter how stupid, incompetent, motivated by false consciousness or unlikely to succeed it was. You are using idealists definitions of these words and it is leading you to incorrect conclusions. It is inconsistent to compare this to " the beer hall putch" then say it was only a riot. It was in fact a poorly organized insurrection by a minority group of fascist idiots, much like the beer hall putch.

Brian

Alyson, what was the book on fascism that you mentioned?

Sparrow

haven't listened yet so not sure if you mention this but just had an interesting discussion that this was permitted to happen in order to crack down harder on left protesters going forward during Biden admin. especially w/characterization that this had potential to truly be a coup. edit: in response to his intent to introduce new """domestic terrorism""" laws, patriot act II

Rachel

Incredible episode. Thank you for making it, and making it so fast!! When I saw the notification i thought, “they must have started recording while it was still happening!”

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I actually agree with you. This critique was advanced by another listener on twitter, and I accepted it as legitimate, and have changed my position. This does absolutely meet the definitional requirements of an insurrection. However, you said I am using idealist definitions that lead to incorrect conclusions; did you simply mean incorrect conclusions about what this action was, or were there bigger downstream conclusions that fall out of the semantic mistake? I just wanna make sure I fully understand your critique.

Rev Left Radio

Id probably argue, based on the evidence we have at this point, that nobody really "let it happen" with some long range scheming in mind, but rather it was a mix of incompetence, under-preparedness, and some significant portion of the police simply siding with the rioters, or at least not dehumanizing them like they do to left wing protestors. That said, I do agree that this will be used as a pretext to expand the police state which will always disporpotionatley fall on the heads of black and brown organizers and thier communities first and foremost, and then on the left more broadly. We should not let the ruling class use fascist insurrection as a pretext for expanding the already enormous carceral and police state.

Sorge's ghost

First let me compliment you; I love that you receive and respond to criticism so well, you are truly a good example of how MLM praxis should work. As to your question of my critique, my answer is both. If you redefine thier actions incorrectly, it will likely lead you to challenge liberal beliefs about this being an insurrection, incorrectly. My concern is that Liberals will define and name this correctly as an insurrection (which they are already doing) and then use that conclusion for justification to expand the police state (which they will do later). The problem is if we fail to accept the correct part of the premise of their argument we will be ineffective in arguing against their incorrect conclusion. By downplaying the insurrection as a mere riot, you will instead play to the "both sides argument" that Liberals already believe since their language to address the actions of the " far left" and the "far right" have been framed as equivalent, i.e both unorganized riots from out of control people lacking clear demands. This will reinforce their false conclusion: to address the problem with expansion of police powers against the "extremists". We should instead be differentiating our side from thiers, by correctly labeling our actions as mostly peaceful protest against dangerous state violence and thiers as violent and dangerous insurrection against and sympathetic and mostly peaceful state.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Listening to this episode for a second time after I listened to all of Brian Becker's takes on the same same subject on The Social Program. I wonder if you could do another episode about updates regarding Jan. 6 or the continued failures of the government to confront the fascist menace (which of course they won't because capitalism relies on fascism to maintain itself). Or perhaps, you could add this into a future questions from listeners episode. I think it's almost a guarantee that there will be a resurgence during the next election, especially the next presidential election.