Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

For this AMA, Alyson and I will be taking questions from patrons of both shows!

Please submit any and all questions as comments in this thread, and we will answer as many as we can!

Thank you all for your continued support! Stay safe out there.

Comments

Trey Kassed

This is definitely a controversial one, but I’m curious on your thoughts on Stalin. I’ve listened to the Rev Left episode on Stalin, and I’ve also seen criticisms of the episode saying that it glosses over some of the legitimate bad things he’s done. I’ve seen a lot of Marxist-Leninists basically say that most of what we hear about him is propaganda, and though he was far from perfect, he was in an impossible situation and made some great decisions and some very bad decisions because of that. I totally understand if you want to avoid the topic, but I’m curious if either of you were comfortable sharing your thoughts on Stalin and his legacy. Thanks comrades!

Nik Arnoldi

What art inspires you most? Is there a certain artist or art movement that resonates with you or that you carry with you?

Steven Phillips

Does minimum wage increases lead to commodity price increases? Marx says it doesn’t have to in Value, Price and Profit, so why does it seem to me that it does? Or is it just the capitalist creating a false need for higher prices?

Itachi the Bolshevik

What are some good resources for learning how to get active in your own community? Should it involve joining a communist party of some kind? I think a lot of people get stuck in the bourgeois Electoralism trap because they don’t really know what they can do immediately to help. Thank you so much for all that you do comrades!

NoName

What do you think of the revolutionary potential of the lumpenproletariat. Do you think there's an essential criminal element that must be present for any revolution?

Socialist Chicagoan

I’m a sophomore in college. I was really exited to take this global history after 1500 class but the very first class the teacher not only compared trump to hitler and stalin and also talked about bs like the holodomor and the uyghur genocide. I’m a ML so I disagree with that comparison and those “genocides” aren’t actually genocides. And now I found out that not only is my teacher a center right liberal but specializes in the Russian revolution. Ik both of y’all have experience in higher education. How do y’all recommend dealing with a anti-communist, America praising history teacher? If she says one more positive thing about the American government I’m gonna just go off on my professor in front of the whole class on zoom lol

Mitchell Kuwahara

I have recently become interested in philosophy and I know that the two of you studied it in college. To what extent does philosophy help shape/guide your everyday lives, given that you both prescribe to a dialectical materialist world view? Also, I would love to see more episodes regarding famous (or personally impactful) philosophers through a Marxist lens!

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I am tasked with creating a contemporary world history class at the school I work at. Do you, or others on the Patreon, know of a quality leftist source (textbook or other) to construct a curriculum from? Thank you in advance.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I’d love to hear about this. A common critique of the left is we’re not armed enough in case we need it. A remedy to this might be recruiting the lumpenproletariat from gangs, etc. And it’s not like it can’t be done. My understanding is a lot of the recruits from the BPP, Young Patriots, and Young Lords were former gang members.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Supplement it with more eps of Rev Left and other revolutionary podcasts. That’s what I had to do when I was in my undergrad.

Socialist Chicagoan

@Jeffery Maddox II I’ve got a decent understanding of communist history and why my teacher is wrong I already listen to lots of rev left. I just need to figure out how to push back against the propaganda filled historical narratives my professor is teaching.

Hazel

i'd also like to hear your thoughts on organising the lumpen or underclass, both historically and in the present moment, as the young lords are pretty famous but i wonder how things are different now, what examples are there if any? how has neoliberalism changed the class composition? etc

Hazel

this was also pretty much my question regarding should building a party be the main method of organisation. there's a lot of pros and cons to different structures, it would be awesome to hear your thoughts on parties, unions, and other forms of organisation as part of a revolutionary strategy.

Lyxxrr

Beat the teacher at their own game. When writing papers, doing presentations, or doing class discussions, put forward ideas and narratives that challenge that worldview. If you have the proper sources for your claims and can communicate them well, then you should be able to get the grade as well as challenge their worldview in front of the class. Use the terrain of academia to your advantage. Try to keep a cool head, the teacher will have a tougher time pushing back against you if you have well sourced arguments that are being delivered in a tone that doesn't come off as dogmatic. Maybe if they say something you know is wrong, you could try and frame your pushback on that in the form of a question in front of the class.

Jay

Is there any reading/do you have any thoughts on why the USSR didn’t reestablish the soviets? I heard you say on your Collab with Srsly Wrong that they dissolved them because workers would sell the business to a capitalist or just cease working-I’m wondering if there were any attempts later on to reestablish them, and if not what the reasoning is. Which leads into my second question, how would the state begin to dissolve following a transitory socialist state? I’ve just finished Blackshirts and Reds which helped me see through a lot of the propaganda about socialist states, but it still listed multiple legitimate issues they faced. I’m curious if a sort of “pure socialist” changes I.e. reestablishing soviets/worker councils is a viable step after socialist states have attained a measurable level of security

Of course

Thoughts on the Teamsters strike and resolution at the Hunts Point, Bronx, distribution facility. Some points to consider: the role of the pandemic and the idea of sufficiently paying and protecting "essential workers," local vs national union officials, the media - including social media like YouTube, and the Democratic Party, including AOC and Bernie Sanders.

Computers Care

Building off these great questions, the mass line. It was touched on briefly in an early episode but I'd like more. Why hasn't the mass line been adopted and successful inside the imperial core to build political engagement and education? Thinking of using it as a vanguard party outreach tool in the george jackson sense to disrupt the system not legitimate it. To take community feedback of political problems, synthesize it to a revolutionary edfe, and then convert the synthesis to mass actions demanding the changes. The point to either claw power from capital to the people or delegitimize bourgeois democracy. Why hasn't this been used/ successful? Are there flaws in this strategy? What are some resources to implement this strategy? -Jeremy

Sergio

I've recently read "How the World Works" by Paul Cockshott and thought it was excellent.

Sergio

Have either of you read/seen the work of Paul Cockshott? He's doing a lot of great stuff in figuring out how a 21st century planned economy would work, was wondering your thoughts on it all.

R&L

I second this one. A consensus I often read is that he is a fantastic read on the issues of planned economy and historical materialism, but quite wrong on trans-issues and questions of national liberation.

Arizona Johnston

Breht, i’m curious about your perspective on Delleuzian philosophy, there’s a pretty interesting lecture series on youtube from manuel de landa about it that’s quite helpful. thanks :)

Sergio

@Lars yeah, he’s good with economy/historical issues but not so good on some social issues.

Sergio

@Jeffery it’s essentially a history book through a historical materialist lens, with an emphasis on how different technologies changed social relations from primitive communist societies to modern socialist states.

John O

What were some of your favorite musical releases from last year?

DG

Have you thought about doing an episode on World Systems Theory? I have been getting into Immanuel Wallerstein and Samir Amin and I think they have an interesting perspective that would be cool to have an episode on!

Dexter Theodore

Hello, many episodes cover topics that could be entire podcasts so it’s understandable content will be summarized. Would there ever be the consideration to revisit topics at a more intermediate level? I personally think that would be great to hear even more in-depth dives into previously featured topics. Especially since your outlooks may have changed or have been further enriched. Is there anything like that in the works?

Dexter Theodore

I’m reading Dance of the Dialectic, Steps in Marx’s Method by Bertell Ollman. Have either of you read this text? If so what are your thoughts? In the past I’ve asked (more or less) how either of you approach a topic dialectically. Alyson mentioned that she researches various sources when approaching a topic. I know there aren’t codified steps to looking into something dialectically but are there “steps” either of you take when using the dialectical method? Moreover how do you ensure it doesn’t veer away into non-materialist terrain?

Joe B

Have you ever done or considered doing an episode about the caste system in India, or particularly about the Dalit community? I’ve lately been reading more about caste, including reading “Annihilation of Caste” by BR Ambedkar. I’d be interested to get a left-wing take on the caste system, especially since at least some Dalit activists seem to regularly criticize the approach of (upper-caste) socialists or communists in India as too narrowly focused on caste as a simply an economic class issue.

linda jean

TRUE ANON COLLAB!!! lol ❤️

Ciaran Geaney

what do you think of mutual aid orgs like food not bombs? do you think they are effective? also what are your thoughts on veganism?

Ren Rets

Thoughts on cryptocurrency?

Adrian Antonioli

I would love to hear your thoughts on combatting western imperialism in regards to anti-china propaganda