Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everyone, please use this thread to ask any and all questions you may have, and Ill answer a bunch of them for the next Patreon exclusive.

Thank you all for your continued support! This month, I used a huge chunk of our patreon money to prevent yet another person from being evicted and becoming homeless. Your support also allowed me to help an unemployed friend get his power turned back on. He had just used SNAP to fill his fridge with food, when the power company cut off his electricity. We were able to get it turned back on before his food went bad. Just a reminder that on top of providing for my family and Dave's, you are also helping to make immediate and direct material interventions in people's lives, quite literally saving them from falling through the yawning cracks in our society. Thank you! 

Comments

Derek B Local Man

Hey I am a new patron so pardon me if this question has been asked before. I am sure it has. Have you considered doing an episode on the FARC (and ELN) in Colombia?

Xochitl Pereira

This may have been addressed elsewhere, but what socialist organizations do you suggest organizing with? What should one look for when vetting them?

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Can you do an episode about the state of leftism in capitalist Asia, like Japan or South Korea? I feel like we never hear about these countries in leftist circles.

marxistmariner

How do you reconcile views on spirituality and existentialism (ie: no self and determinism), with a material approach to political struggle?

DD

Hi Breht, After listening to your interview with Kim Stanley Robinson, I'm still not sure whether to buy the ministry for the future. I've read large chunks of KSR before, including 2 of the Mars trilogy books, the Wild Shore and Pacific Edge. I've consistently found that while he comes up with truly brilliant and unique ideas such as the terraforming of Mars, plotting the course out of climate change or a parallel world where the black plague wiped out Europe, his prose does not match his ideas. I gave up on him when reading about a technologically advanced, eco-friendly future California became like reading the minutes of a PTA meeting. Can you say anything about the actual writing of Ministry for the Future that might get me to change my mind? Does he have any particular characters or pieces of dialogue that stood out to you as interesting or profound? (I struggle to remember any of the characters I followed for over 1,000 pages in his Mars Series.) What about any sections of prose that would be worth reading even if they weren't tied to a discussion of imminent climate collapse? Perhaps if you read a short section out loud, that might be enough to convince me or any other fence-sitters. Thanks.

Rev Left Radio

Great question!!!!!! Thank you. Ill def tackle this one.

Rev Left Radio

Very interesting question! Ill definitely try to come up with something for this!

National Endowment for Democracy

Hi Brett, my question is as follows: Do you think it is worth while to try to keep some version of the political polity of the lower 48 US states in a post revolution scenario with autonomous regions (like with the Chinese Revolution), or should we strive for some kind of regional break up for the sake of ensuring complete decolonial rule. More generally, how do we ensure decolonization in a country with a white super majority?

John Emmanuel

I am wondering if you could do an episode (or point me to it) of a full criticism of capitism. I've seen a lot of defending of socialism but I want to have something to go to tear down capitalism. Thank you for what you do Breht! I am a working family man as well and your work helps me stay sharp in a world where I have very very little time to read and sit down.

Justine Rojas

Hey Breht, Love your show. It has provided me with countless hours of education during my now approaching 1 year of unemployment. Thank you! After I listened to one of your episodes with Alexander Aviña in the summer, I bought Open Veins of Latin America by Eduardo Galeano because he spoke highly of it and Galeano. I finally started reading it last week. I don’t want to put it down. Brilliant book. Haunting, but brilliant. It is also one of the most riveting books on political economy I have ever read, both for content and prose. It got me to thinking, I would love to hear Alexander Aviña and you discuss the book. I know it is a massive part of history to cover, but I have heard podcasts of Walter Rodney’s How Europe Underdeveloped Africa before and I think this book is a parallel to that book, but for Latin America. It also feels like such an important foundation to all the resource extraction the global north continues to exploit from central and South America and the Caribbean, as well as the United States continued interference in left wing governments and movements in these regions. Again, thank you for the amazing programming and content Rev Left provides us with.

Hazel

I was wondering what your methodology is? How do you research topics, how do you find speakers, how do you build your personal knowledge and how do you also do it for the show?

kylewiebe

Amazing place to start with RevLeft and Breht, lots of great episodes that gets into this, for ex. Capitalist Realism https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/capitalist-realism-is-there-no-alternative https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/socialist-workplace Other great channels and critiques of capitalism: Richard Wolff https://youtube.com/c/democracyatwrk Abby Martin and Empire Files interview with sociologist Peter Phillips about his book Giants [Empire Files] Episode 81 - Giants: Who Really Rules The World? #empireFiles https://podcastaddict.com/episode/68118876 via @PodcastAddict Chris Hedges on Imperialism https://youtu.be/XkNkcKQnMR0 [Leaflets] 12 - Capitalism and Mental Health ft. It's Not Just In Your Head 🅴 #leaflets https://podcastaddict.com/episode/117044324 via @PodcastAddict Noam Chomsky and 5 filters of mass media machine https://youtu.be/34LGPIXvU5M Class consciousness (change the subtitles to English) by Rita the Tempora Drag https://youtu.be/lmT7H09jR18 @Breht , I think you'd love to talk with Rita and visit her channel Lots of quality material out there comrade, welcome to the journey of Marxism and being critical of Neoliberal Capitalism!

kylewiebe

I would love to hear some of your thoughts about dismantling our inner patriarchy, objectification of women, and pornography. Thoughts on how we can unite to talk about this with other men? Thanks Breht (and family) for your incredible work, you are an incredible light for my wife and I! In solidarity

Ciaran Geaney

hi Breht, i was wondering what you think about mutual aid groups like food not bomvbs?

rsomc

hi Breht, im echoing the same question i and another person had during the Q&A from last month, particularly since you had KSR on and i myself am a communist writer of scifi: i’ve heard it claimed often by leftists in general and in particular the dirtbag milieu that art and creative pursuits in general don’t seem to have much material function during the actual course of revolutionary activity. what is the role of the artist/creative in terms of furthering the revolution? can an artist engage critically with whatever media they work within in order to act as propagandizers? do artists and creatives simply because mouthpieces for agitation and propaganda, or is there a different role their work can take on?

John Emmanuel

Thank you comrades. You are full of so much compassion and love 🥰 I'll be sure to take some time to listen this morning.

Sergio

Hope this isn’t too late! Breht, what are your thoughts on the role of markets and money in a socialist society? To me socialism is the dialectical negation of capitalism, so it should do away with markets and money. But I do know some socialists disagree and I wonder where you fall in this debate

Anthony Giorgio

2 ideas: - a behind-the-scenes episode about how the show is written and produced and on what kind of a schedule, even a short one would be cool - an episode on Amiri Baraka, his journey to third-world Marxism, and the black arts movement more broadly

Freddy

Hi Breht, I began studying Buddhism around the same time that I came across rev left and started to learn about political theory and Marxism specifically. Thich Nhat Hahn in the book "the heart of buddhas teachings" mentions nonviolence and how in the Buddhist tradition, any form of violence is avoided whenever possible. This sentiment is in contradiction to the absolute need for revolution, and likely a violent one. I can sort of resolve this contradiction by saying that violence in self defense is justified, and it seems that most leftist revolutions are violent primarily because of the bourgeoisie's reaction to revolution, therefore the violence from the left is self-defense. That being said, I know I understand very little about revolution, and even less about Buddhism, so if someone as wise as Thich Nhat Hahn opposes any violent revolution even if the conditions call for it, I certainly have to consider that he understands a deeper truth than I do. As a Buddhist yourself, do you have thoughts on this? Is violence justified from a Buddhist sense in revolution? Is it possible to change the material conditions of our society without any violence? I'd love to hear your thoughts on this topic. Thanks so much for everything you do, listening to the podcast keeps my dishwashing job quite exciting and enjoyable!

online Leftist Archive Project (LARP)

Other good stuff from revleft is material on Marxist dialectics and political economy, and on the 2008 crash. I feel like those are the best way to get the critique of capitalism. https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/red-menace-the-fundamentals-of-marxism-historical-materialism-dialectics-political-economy, https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/the-fundamentals-of-marxism-intro-to-political-economy, AND https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/capitalist-chaos-and-crimes-the-great-recession-of-2008

MLMinPractice

I’d be interested in hearing your thoughts about building an anti imperialist/anti war movement in the US/imperialist core. What is the proper approach in your opinion to some of the tougher questions like working with liberal forces, veterans, workers in war industries, etc. and should it any way particularly different from the general principles to be upheld in other forms of struggle? What form of struggle & mobilization can be feasibly waged against other, potentially non military forms of imperialist aggression and incursion? When I was in highschool and we successfully ended in-school presence of military recruiters, and looking at past anti war mobilizations and anti WTO protests, I believe there is potential for a stronger anti war and anti imperialist movement & organizations, but am a bit stumped trying to think of forms of mass organization and struggle that can intensify and diversify/nuance that struggle to properly make use of that potential. Side note: told Alyson I’d be very happy about a red menace episode about either ARAK (Activist Study on the FLP website) or Mass Work by the CPP (or both), two works which I consider of highest universal significance from the Filipino revolutionary movement. If you do chose to pursue it, I would be *very* enthusiastic to help deepen the understanding of what is written by talking about how the concepts are put into practice.

Scott

Just listened to the new episode on the Art of Loving. Made me wonder if you had read any bell hooks. I think it would be worthwhile and maybe even do an episode on her and/or the dialogue between her and Paulo Freire's ideas. Much of their work is centered around love as a concept we find and create in comunion with one another. Anyway I think you'd find a lot of value in her work if you haven't already.

Elisha Arafel

I would be really interested to hear your thoughts on entryism and the the state of socialist organizing in the US currently, especially around groups like Socialist Alternative, DSA, the PSL, etc. IK you've talked briefly about this before but I would love a more in depth take.

online Leftist Archive Project (LARP)

Breht I have a question that might seem obscure on the surface, but I think has a LOT more implications for organizing than people realize. I was wondering if you could do a philosophy/theory heavy segment on Marxism as a science. I see the abandonment of scientific class analysis in the DSA and it's easy to see the massive theoretical confusion this has resulted in, not least of which is this debate around the PMC pseudo-class. We were debating whether to teach Marxism in our chapter and the overwhelming sentiment from the members was that Marxism is not a science. I know you went into this a little bit in Fundamentals of Marxism (an amazing episode) but was wondering if we could get into the weeds on this even more. Thanks!!

Sorge's ghost

I hate his prose and style of writing as well and found Ministry of The Future to share those problems. I felt his radlib perspective came through strongly in the book to the point it annoyed and bored me.

DD

I agree about the Radlib bit too. I'm glad Breht was a good host and didn't interrupt KSR, but I cringed when his "solution" to left unity was "oh we can have socialism and anarchism in 20 years, right now we have to *dem talking points*"

Eoghan

Bit late to the comments here so you probably won't get to this but hey: Would be interested to hear how your own local organising has been going throughout COVID. I know in Ireland at least that the pandemic has forced most orgs to organise mostly online, which has unfortunately left a vacuum on the streets that the far right has taken advantage of to draw in COVID conspirators and people frustrated with the lockdowns etc. Also I know you've got a long list of topics you wanna cover in future topics but would love to hear an episode on the EU. The jingoism surrounding Brexit has unfortunately made most left-inclined people default to a pro-EU stance, and it's become difficult to explain to people that the EU is an undemocratic neoliberal organisation without sounding like you're aligning yourself with the right-wing elements of the Brexit debate.

online Leftist Archive Project (LARP)

Another question I had was if you could talk about different countries' Covid responses in more depth, that's something that really fascinates me. Socialist countries have obviously done a lot better, but there's also the example of New Zealand, Taiwan, South Korea.

Trey Kassed

It's a bit late since you posted this so you may not see this comment, but I have been recently getting very into learning about Buddhism and spirituality in general, in large part due to your podcast. I was wondering if you could share a list of some of the books that have been most impactful to you in your learning about Buddhism and spirituality. I know that you have previously said that you don't like to share a list as like a "list for beginners" due to everybody having different directions, but I was wondering if you could just share some books that have been most important to you in your spiritual journey?

Andrea Cristina

Hello! I would just love to have a small list of songs you recommend 🤚🏽 I love all the ones that play at the end of your episodes & I have been playing “rät” on repeat all day long.

~+

Been listing to a ton of Bambu and Dead Prez. What other recommendations for radical hip hop? Thank you!!

Rev Left Radio

I love that!! haha I am so glad some of you genuinely enjoy the music I like. :)

Ethan

have you seen I Am Cuba? Soviet film about the revolution made in Cuba in the direct aftermath. it's my favorite movie, revolutionary in both form and content with some really amazing filmmaking. would be interested to hear your thoughts