Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Alyson and Breht answer a bunch of your questions on a wide range of topics! 

Files

Comments

Sergio

Hi Breht and Alyson! Thanks for answering my question. I liked the nuanced answer you both gave, and I agree that given the context of the hegemony of money & markets it’s difficult to imagine current socialist experiments being able to deviate much from them. Some of it was informed by my recent reading of marxist economist Foley’s Alternatives to Capitalism (https://www.economicpolicyresearch.org/resource-library/download/181_df7f2627d355e7fd3c02e693d231f853, https://www.economicpolicyresearch.org/resource-library/download/182_07b9904695aacc432d64148dbd03a6dc) I recommend it as a reading if either of you are interested in the econ side of things. It’s fascinating to consider what a fully realized socialist or communist could look like.

DD

Hi, 'tis me, the fence-sitter! Sorry, but I think the passage you read from KSR kind of confirmed my previous opinions on his writing. If you're looking for a book that I like that covers a really interesting post-climate collapse world that has (in my opinion), great dialogue, interesting, well-written characters and a more exciting plot, I'd strongly recommend "the Windup Girl" by Paolo Bacigalupi. I'm going to put a small sample of it from the first chapter here: "I've spent years building this," Yates said, "and you tell me it's not personal." He waved toward the office's observation windows where they overlooked the manufacturing floor. "I've got kinksprings the size of my fist that hold a gigajoule of power. Quadruple the capacity-weight ratio of any other spring on the market. I'm sitting on a revolution in energy storage, and you're throwing it away." He leaned forward. "We haven't had power this portable since gasoline." "Only if you can produce it." "We're close," Yates insisted. "Just the algae baths. They're the only sticking point." Anderson said nothing. Yates seemed to take this as encouragement. "The fundamental concept is sound. Once the baths are producing in sufficient quantities—" "You should have informed us when you first saw the nightshades in the markets. The Thais have been successfully growing potatoes for at least five seasons. They're obviously sitting on top of aseedbank, and yet we heard nothing from you." "Not my department. I do energy storage. Not production." Anderson snorted. "Where are you going to get the calories to wind your fancy kink-springs if a crop fails? Blister rust is mutating every three seasons now. Recreational generippers are hacking into our designs for TotalNutrient Wheat and SoyPRO. Our last strain of HiGro Corn only beat weevil predation by sixty percent, and now we suddenly hear you're sitting on top of a genetic gold mine. People are starving—" Yates laughed. "Don't talk to me about saving lives. I saw what happened with the seedbank in Finland." "We weren't the ones who blew the vaults. No one knew the Finns were such fanatics." "Any fool on the street could have anticipated. Calorie companies do have a certain reputation. " "It wasn't my operation." Yates laughed again. "That's always our excuse, isn't it? The company goes in somewhere and we all stand back and wash our hands. Pretend like we weren't the ones responsible. The company pulls SoyPRO from the Burmese market, and we all stand aside, saying intellectual property disputes aren't our department. But people starve just the same." He sucked on his cigarette, blew smoke. "I honestly don't know how someone like you sleeps at night." "It's easy. I say a little prayer to Noah and Saint Francis, and thank God we're still one step ahead of blister rust." "That's it then? You'll shut the factory down?" "No. Of course not. The kink-spring manufacturing will continue." "Oh?" Yates leaned forward, hopeful. Anderson shrugged. "It's a useful cover."

DD

The only Caveat I'd add is that the book is sometimes very sexually explicit and has so fairly graphic discussions of sexual violence, so it might not be a book for anyone who doesn't want to read about that.

Rev Left Radio

Well I am at least glad we got it settled for ya! haha. I really appreciate the critique and the recommendation for this other book. Ill definitely check it out!! What others authors more broadly do you like for their prose? Do one or two stand out to you as being particularly representative of your preferred prose?

DD

Honestly, that's a very hard question that I couldn't give you a one-size-fits all answer to. I think it all comes down to how much you, the reader, are able to relate to what the author was trying to convey. I love Tolkien's writing style because he really makes the landscapes that the characters are walking over feel alive and brimming with history. I loved Octavia Butler's parable books because of the way they demonstrated a burning desire to make the world a better place in the end of brutal, unending violence. Terry Pratchett's fantasy worlds are brimming with wit and irreverence while also managing to have real heart and caring about the characters that live in his world. KSR, sadly, all too often feels like he came up with a good idea and he just read you his cliff notes instead of presenting it in a way that was engaging.

Jamie Sims

Really enjoyed this. Great thoughtful answer on the Buddhism and revolution question. I think the question of revolution here shouldn't just be about the ethics of violence, but about the degree of social transformation required to actualise universal love, the cessation or lessening of desire, the alleviation of suffering, full respect for nature, etc - similar to Fromm's discussion of the relative rarity of mature love under capitalism. Part of my problem with some of the literature on nonviolence, e.g. Gandhi, is the lack of a programme for fully ending class society. Enjoyed the questions about areas of study and skills you've learned and want to learn. For me, the last year has involved learning about Buddhism and meditation (a mix of practice, books, youtube, podcasts like yours and Tricycle Talks) as well as learning more about foraging (particularly mushrooms) and my goals for the upcoming year involve a deeper dive into African and Indian politics and history. In the spirit of asking for guests not topics, I was wondering if you'd had any luck contacting Ian Scott Horst about his book on the Ethiopian Revolution?

Rev Left Radio

Totally agree about violence/non-violence! Love your interests too! We are very much on similiar paths it seems! :) As for Ian Scott Horst, YES! We are actually considering doing an episode with him on Guerrilla History, but if that falls through I will have him on RLR!