Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Brigid Ó Coileáin and Esperanza Fonseca join Breht to discuss proletarian and Marxist feminism, the history and power dynamics of the sex trade, the rhetoric and ideology of liberal feminism, the role pornography plays in society, the importance of anti-imperialism for women's emancipation, and much, much more!

Check out the Probably Cancelled Podcast here: https://probablycancelledpod.libsyn.com/website

Check out Esperanza's writings here: https://proletarianfeminist.medium.com/

Learn more here: https://linktr.ee/estrellaroja

Outro Music: "The Men Who Rule the World" by Garbage

Files

Comments

M

Thank you for putting words to a feeling that I've always had. The one thing that didn't sit with me was the idea that this is only profession where you are selling your body instead of your labor. I would love resources (or y'all's own thoughts) about how professional sports is not also the selling of bodies (not saying it's the same thing as the sex trade, just pondering the concept of selling proletariat bodies particularly for the purpose of consumer pleasure instead of fulfilling a societal need), specifically the NFL given the severe and permanent damage it causes so many players who are disproportionately men of color?

online Leftist Archive Project (LARP)

Thanks to Breht and the guests for this. I've been thinking this for a while now but kept it to myself since I was afraid that I was being stodgy or, worse, maybe even misogynistic in some way I didn't understand. One of the biggest flaws of liberalism is its narrow conception of what coercion is - a key insight, maybe even the most important insight, of socialism is that economic coercion IS coercion. It's odd that we forget this insight once sex work comes up. Also odd that we're for DEcommodifying everything, but sex work commodifies human sexuality, but taboo for woke people to critique. Weird that this is so prevalent in DSA too.

online Leftist Archive Project (LARP)

Also it was really cool to see this concept that's explored in The Principal Contradiction applied to this topic! Where one of the guests speaks on the fact that liberals mistake the principal contradiction as between sex workers / police, where it's actually between purchaser / seller of sex work. I mean how obvious can it get that this is an objectively antagonistic relation.

Jonathan Wood

Esperanza Fonseca was also a recent guest on a Red Nation podcast episode on the sex trade and its role in the settler-colonial, imperial, indigenous context. If you aren't familiar with The Red Nation, I highly recommend it. Indigenous, Marxist, anti-colonial, anti-racist, anti-capitalist voices.

Inmybirkin

Seriously great episode

Rev Left Radio

Understood. Sorry you feel that way. I haven't followed the twitter comments or QT's, but I know this is a controversial episode and discussing it openly and honestly will result in blowback. I would have hoped that being a supporter of the show you'd know we operate in good faith and sincerity and explore difficult topics with an open mind, even if one sometimes disagrees with our guests or topics. But you are absolutely free to pull your support at any time. In any case, I wish you the best and appreciate your support up until this point.

Sparrow

what is this big twitter fight?? i am so confused. they seem to think your guests were SWERFs who are also adjacent to TERF organizations & somehow right wingers? The episode just endorsed the standard ML line---decommodify bodies. in the near term make things better for the exploited.

Sparrow

do you really believe that the two guests were TERFs or Heritage Foundation cronies or unironic believers in some Soros conspiracy? they sounded like well-grounded & unapologetic ML/M comrades.

Jeremy Eugene

You'll never get a more comprehensive explanation of anyone's issues with a group than what's in that document... if you're gonna respond by saying it didn't explain anything, then there's no point in talking further.

Eoghan

Just got around to that ep and although I agree with a lot of what was said I think the dicothomy of "we're proletarian feminists and everyone who disagrees with us is a neoliberal coloniser" was pretty disingenuous, along with Brehts disappointing response to criticism of this ep as a "liberal smear campaign". There's plenty of principled Marxists and SW who would take issue with a lot of the points and conclusions made in that ep. The critique of the Liberal feminist position outlined was sound but they made it out that their position was the only other differing opinion on this matter. And the point made that it's a "traditional communist stance to be sex work abolitionists throughout history" (paraphrasing) is not exactly a strong one because the traditional communist stance towards LGBT rights for example was not exactly progressive for a lot of its history, and something most communists have thankfully developed their positions on. This is going solely of the episode content, I understand others have issues with the group the guests are associated with but I had never heard of them before this so can't comment on that. I would be interested in another episode with an alternative balancing opinion such as with Juno Mac and Molly Smith maybe who wrote a good book on this topic.

Darren Mack

Very informative episode. Thanks!!

Rev Left Radio

Eoghan, first and foremost thank you for the feedback! Its constructive and I appreciate it. I will first clear up the misunderstanding that I dismissed all criticism of this ep as a smear campaign. I did not - and i made this clear - dismiss any good faith, substantive critique of the content. Ive engaged comrades privately about just that and am engaging you hear on just that. What I was talking about in that infamous tweet was people *attacking my guests instead of the content*; calling them transphobic or against sex workers or even, absurdly, antisemitic. All of which are simply false and all of which my guests have responded to. Moreover, This didnt happen in a vacuum either, my guests told me they were targeted, harrassed, and even had people doxed just for platforming them by a specific group of people online. So when I said "if you have anything negative to say about guests IDC, I specifically meant this group of people and the attempt to hurl baseless accusations at my guests instead of offering substantive and good faith critiques of certain arguments. I really want to make that clear, because people ran with it as if I was closing off any and substantive critique and anyone who knows me or the show knows thats not the case. I always engage with constructive feedback and make it a point to do so. Ill also add that twitter is not a platform of principled critique or meaningfull dialogue. Its all about dunking on people, interpreting them in the least favorable light possible, and showing off for others. I will never treat it as a platform for substantive, meaningful dialogue because it simply isnt.

Rev Left Radio

Now as for your critiques themselves, while that dichotomy you bring up is one way of interpreting the position laid out, I would say that we went above that by juxtaposing specific branches of feminism: prole feminism v. radical feminism, or prole feminism v. liberal feminism in some detail! However, we could have probably done more on that front, I agree. AS for the traditional communist stance point: I understand why on its own it doesnt mean much given your example of LGBTQ movements and people; BUT I think its substantially different in that Kollontai, Sankara, Engels, Zetkin, Marx, etc. offered up a critique of the sex trade as a form of exploitation under class society, as a form of patriarchy, and as an extension of the logic of private property. So your comparison doesnt hold in that this is not an issue communists have been ignorant or flippant about, but have been very principled about and clear about for a long time. I think that is relevant to the overall convo. I would also be totally open to covering this topic from another viewpoint. I would only say in our defense taht we have had pro-sex workers on many times; a patreon episode with a sex worker, a feminist episode or two where the guests were explicitly pro-sex work as such, AND an episode where we dismantled policy like SESTA-FOSTA. As often happens with our show, we will do a controversial topic, people will be unaware of other episodes weve done on that topic, and then assert that we are one-sided when in fact that is not the case. Ill end it there, lmk if I missed anything. Thank you again for your comradely and principled feedback, I do take it seriously and in retrospect, I would have rephrased that tweet regarding negative comments about my guests to be clearer on what I was saying. - Brett

Eoghan

Thanks for the reply Brett, I admit that I did see that there was some vague controversy about the episode before listening without looking into any specifics, so went into it already primed to disagree, but was genuinely surprised at how much I did actually end up agreeing with, and as a whole I do agree with the overarching point that in a post-class society abolition is the principled position to strive for. It was largely the framing of the argument that I took issue with really, and some of the "we're not anti-sex worker, we're anti-pimp and anti-john" points that the guests made sounded uncomfortably similar to those that proponents of the "Nordic Model" (something we have in Ireland which has been a disaster for SWers) also make, even though they did say that they were in favour of decriminalisation, + a few other points that I won't get into here because I'm not really looking for a debate lol. I take your point about previous episodes, I had actually forgotten about those so this episode is likely a balancing one rather than one that needs another one to be balanced against (so to speak).

Rev Left Radio

Fair points! and again, I really appreciate how you approached this disagreement and how you framed your substantive critiques in a constructive way. Reasonable people can disagree on complex topics such as this, but at the end of the day we all want human beings to be safe, protected, have control over their daily lives, and have their voices heard. <3