Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Kristen R. Ghodsee returns to the show, this time to discuss the life, work, and legacy of the Bolshevik leader and famous Marxist Feminist Alexandra Kollontai. We discuss her life, her radicalization, her relationship with other famous revolutionaries, her enduring contributions to feminism, Marxism, and proletarian history, and much, much more. 

Check out AK-47, Kristen's podcast dedicated to Kollontai here: https://kristenghodsee.com/podcast

Here are all the previous episodes of RLR that Kristen has been a guest on:

Red Hangover: https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/red-hangover-legacies-of-20th-century-communism-w-dr-kristen-r-ghodsee

International Women's Day: https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/womens-day

Women Behind the Iron Curtain: https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/women-under-socialism

Outro Song: Blame Game by Beach Bunny


Files

Comments

MLDad

I liked the episode, but had a hard time with the anti-stalin ranting without proper explanation. Kristen assumes you're supposed to hate the man who led the efforts to defend the revolution and humanity from the most vile counterrevolutionary efforts imaginable. Attributing the purges to Stalin personally without analyzing the material conditions and the social dimension is miles below what we as marxists would accept as minimum standards in any other topic.

MLDad

Anyway, although it bothers me I know how dominant this prejudice is and can understand how hard it is to question the anti-stalin paradigm. I don't think it otherwise lessens Kristens work or that it alone makes her unprincipled.

MLDad

I find the killing of members of the Workers Opposition VERY upsetting, but pinning it on Stalin personally harms our ability to understand and prevent future iterations of this process.

Rev Left Radio

I can largely agree with this, but I also think sometimes people aren't really willing to put ANY blame at Stalin's feet. I agree that one person isnt fully culpable, but I also think Stalin does deserve some legitimate criticism for the role he played in the purges. Slaughtering people is never going to be an acceptable way to handle disagreement among revolutionaries, imo, and that doesnt change even when all the other variables are taken into sober account. What are your thoughts on that?

MLDad

Idk. I mean I have my paths of inquiry and doubts. At the very least the cult built around Joeys figure was harmful to the revolution. There's testimony and documents that reveal that he sensed that it was so, and yet he did not make sufficient efforts to stop it. Maybe he was divided, maybe he thought it was useful to mobilize the masses (I'd tend to disagree), or maybe it was a failing of character. I'm in no place to say what it was. Regarding the purges, including the 37 ones, they were a mass process, directed and assisted by the Central Committee (an organ of hundreds of members), in am effort that could be seen as an embryo of the principles behind the Cultural Revolution. It had the huge failing of not grounding the process, as was the case with a lot of the things going on in the USSR, in the framework of class struggle under socialism, which was then deficiently recognized by the CPSU. All power did not lay on Stalin's hands. The Workers Opposition appealed to the Communist International and received no support. Was Clara Zetkin a puppet? Was Kollontai? I find this concept somewhat patronizing and disturbing. Purged members were subject to trials assisted by diplomats from all over the world and conducted by procurators. Stalin did not conduct the process personally. I am against the death penalty in any circumstances and I think that things having escalated to the point where honest revolutionaries like Shliapnikov being tried reveals deeper problems in the handling (or lack thereof) of internal contradictions in the CPSU. If you ever have the time check out this work by Swedish marxist Mario Sousa analyzing the process of the purges mainly from archives captured by germans in Smolensk and later by Americans. http://www.mariosousa.se/TheclassstruggleduringthethirtiesintheSovietUnion050801.html I invite Stalin's critics to present the objective criticism regarding his personal failings, but my argument is that they're relatively unimportant compared to what it's made out to be. I'm no expert, no groupie of Stalin, I'm just a sleep deprived dad from Portugal and base level communist militant.

Shane

Man y'all I am so confused about Stalin. On one hand I understand that we mustn't be reactionaries every time he's mentioned, but I really have a hard time deciphering whether he was a political figure even worth defending or not. Did he just go off the deep end, but had good intentions at first? I reckon that's kind of dialectical though right that things are imperfect

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I know this is unrelated but you should do a call-in show again. I think you did that a few times with Dr. Bones back in the day.

Adam Martin

If you haven't already, you should listen to the episode from a few years back that presents a defense of Stalin. To be honest, I think Ghodsee is too quick to accept the notion of Stalin as an all-powerful villain who had his hand deeply involved in every bad thing that happened in the USSR. The fact that she thinks that Kollontai was just "scared" to oppose him and that she just got "tired" honestly seems really ignorant, and even insulting to her character. But yeah, a lot of what she said is just blatantly skewed, especially the "Old Bolshevik" nonsense, considering that the majority of the Old Bolsheviks were not executed in the Purges. And to be clear, I don't agree with many on the Left that Stalin had nothing to do with any of these problems, I think it's just important to realize that there were a lot more figures involved, and he was constantly having to make judgment calls from the top based on information given by others.

Sara & Josh

Those were so cool, right?

EspressoCinephile

Hey, just wanted to say that this episode changed me in a significant way. Kollontai, like Luxemburg, was a true visionary and I sincerely think Dr. Ghodsee does her justice instead of tokenizing her and besmirching her legacy as I unfortunately have seen some do. I furthermore wholeheartedly appreciate Ghodsee's critical lens and it has inspired me to start thinking much more critically and less dogmatically about especially the early USSR, its legacy, and its implications for the Left. We don't get anywhere by saying "X person did everything wrong/right", "X either didn't happen, or if it did it must have been good ans justified", or by simply getting defensive when guests criticize figures we might have certain preconceived notions about. I feel that we must truly strive for a "ruthless criticism of everything that exists", and I thank you Breht for imo truly embodying this sentiment here at Rev Left and for platforming many different varieties of discourse.