Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Alyson and I are doing a big AMA for Red Menace's public episode this month, please use this thread to ask any and all questions!

We appreciate it! 

Comments

East Was Red

What do you think about about the contributions to Maoism made by MIM and refined upon later by 'Third Worldists' and would you consider having an actual Third Worldist on to discuss? The only time I've heard you talk about it was with a guest who was a very biased First Worldist. I think his conflation of the LLCO cult with the actually groundbreaking historical and theoretical work done by the pre-LLCO comrades (see Monkey Smashes Heaven) was disingenuous.

Ryan Spencer

What do you guys think are the most important ways to bring people to the Left? What do you consider necessary requirements for someone to be a comrade, if any? I find that there are people who don’t identify with the Left that are against the status quo. I feel that just about everyone recognizes the cruelty of our society, but how should we navigate conversations with these people to bring them toward the Left and how much should we work together with these various groups when they oppose capitalism, whether they know it or not? What advice/information to give to people who are brand new to the Left and are seeking guidance? I sometimes get confused when people talk about contradictions in our society and I start to think in terms of logical contradictions. Can you explain and give a few examples of contradictions in our society? As communists, with our goal being the establishment of a classless, stateless, moneyless society by first achieving socialism, I have thought about our relationship to Capitalism now and Socialism in the future. Right now we critique Capitalism and seek its destruction in the form of a Revolution, but once Socialism is established, I have thought that the role of Communists would be to critique Socialism and seek its progress into Communism, and that just like today, there would be people who aren’t necessarily reactionaries trying to go back to Capitalism, but people who just want to stay in early Socialism and resist movement toward Communism. In this way, I have thought about Communists becoming the enemies of Socialism in the same way we are enemies of Capitalism today. Is this a fair understanding? How would you push back against this way of thinking? Thanks for all you guys do. Sorry if any of my questions are stupid or uninformed, I’m learning and trying my best to grow. Solidarity!

Thomas

Can you talk about good orgs to join?

Cory

Hey Brett would ever consider recording a guided meditation I would love to meditate with your voice it’s soothing to me also might help some listeners get into it

Ryan Spencer

Do you have any content about praxis you’re planning on doing? I feel like I have a lot of theory but not so much explicit direction on how to use it

Reagan White

Hi Brent and Alyson! Could you please share some film/tv series recommendations? Both of your podcasts have led me to documentaries, movies, and shows that have taught me so much (Exterminate All the Brutes and a Pervert’s Guide to Ideology to name some examples). I’d love to hear about any visual media that taught you about history or helped frame Marxist concepts clearer in your mind, or anything you think marxists would benefit from watching. I appreciate the work you both do!!!

Ryan Spencer

He actually has a few here on Patreon and one in an episode about Buddhism called something like “The Four Noble Truths”

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

As a high school teacher (social sciences), leftist podcasts are always shitting on public education saying that it’s a system of indoctrination and that we cannot rely on public education for political education. While I agree with some of that to an extent, I think it does a disservice to the left because it erases all the educators who are trying to work within the confines of the state (we have no other options) to advance an anti-imperialist education to the next generation. I’m am curious if you and Alyson have any suggestions about how teachers in public education should approach curriculum while navigating a hostile political environment that infiltrates most schools in this country, especially in rural, mostly all white schools like what’s in Nebraska? The area of critical pedagogy seems to be a space that Bret doesn’t step into very often so it’d be dope af if you and Alyson did a close reading of Paulo Freire’s Pedagogy of the Oppressed.

Klaus Zimmermann Mayo

I would love to hear specifics on agrarian reform, how it actually works. Maybe looking at places like China, Cuba, the Zapatistas, and more. I am a farmer here in the Midwest trying to do a lot: produce healthy food for our community, build soil and sequester carbon, build community, build power and obtain land, while creating models of replicable systems which support people and work towards land back and the abolition of private property. All while surviving within bureaucratic capitalism. It’s a lot to balance while keeping the farm going, and I’m not even sure where to look for resources on specifics of how other revolutionary projects have implemented agrarian reform. How do we balance of contradictions of the commons vs autonomy? What does decision making look like? And what are some ideas of how to begin building these systems and culture within our current reality of colonial / imperial capitalism?

Blargh

Hey Y'all, Would Breht consider making an episode on Latin American socialism? or events such as Operation Condor and American involvement in Latin America. Many are still unaware of American involvement in the region, and it would be a good topic to discuss since we are now having U.S. involvement in Cuba again....

Ryan Spencer

I’m teaching my first year at a Middle School this Fall — very much interested in the same questions. Also I want to know classroom management and organizational procedures that reflect leftist philosophy on power and all. The authoritarian style of teaching where the teacher stands up front and downloads their brain into the students I feel is not reflective of leftist philosophy, but I have a hard time thinking of good alternatives

Leo Schmitz

I would be very interested in an episode on modern Chinese socialism. Maybe through the lense of either John Ross's new book china's great road or Roland Boer's socialism with chinese characteristics or any other.

Kyle

Can you speak about the history of tenant organizing, heroes of that specific struggle here in the US or abroad in the past and what tenant organizing is specifically and speak to how to start a tenant union? With more and more people having to rent I think this is one of the lefts best opportunities for organizing and putting our beliefs into practice

Benjamin

iOS like to hear more about capitalist alienation, and its relationship to the ever growing mental health/substance abuse crisis.

DD

Wholesome off-topic question: what are you two looking forward to doing more as coronavirus restrictions lift? And is there anything positive you were able to take away from lockdown that you're going to make part of your lives going forward?

Ciaran Geaney

not a super deep question, but how do y’all read so much? it takes me forever to read theory and i was wondering if you have any tips to get through reading material in a reasonable amount of time.

anon corgi

love this! I'm a farmer myself in Texas and also ponder these questions

Zachary

Hey Breht and Alyson, could you share some tips on how y’all prepare research? I’m relatively new to identifying my left tendencies and I do a lot of reading but I feel like my retention isn’t the best and find myself forgetting the information I have read or failing to properly represent my thoughts from my readings. I guess just giving out tips on how you take notes, organize your information, how to present back to others in your own words, etc. Any other thoughts you two have about this would greatly appreciated. Thanks!

Demarchic Communism Podcast

This could be a good opportunity to do a collaboration with Little Red Schoolhouse podcast.

Hazel

Where is the line between reformism and revolutionary organising? I often see specific movements or orgs criticised by others (or I criticise them myself) for not having a totally revolutionary aim - but I think this is also unrealistic for on the ground organising. To explain briefly the line of thinking, I'm currently looking into cooperatives and also Cooperation Jackson - I'm aware Alyson has been critical of coops and the solidarity economy before. But what if coops (for example, but you could also use tenant organising or union activities as another example) are part of a wider revolutionary strategy? Can they be? Why not if not?

Tyler

What do you think a productive application of the mass line in largely white/reactionary neighborhoods would look like? I just finished the RevLeft collab with Faith and Capital, and found Breht’s comment about avoiding chauvinistic and patronizing applications of the mass line (ex: white PMC types going into largely POC neighborhoods without the support of a pre-existing group made up of members of that community) thought provoking.

Quém é

Hi Breht and Aly! Two related questions-- (1) I'm at a point in my self-ed where I feel like I'm ready to tackle dialectics in a more complex way. I've accrued a pretty basic understanding via podcasts and educational videos, but I don't really know where to start for intermediate resources. What were some resources that gave you breakthroughs in your understandings of dialectics? (2) Do either of you apply dialectical methods in practical, day-to-day organizing efforts, or in predicting near-future politicL phenomena? If so, can either of you provide some examples where you've done so? Thanks! You're both superb and I'm immensely grateful for the work you do.

Trey Kassed

What are some tips you have for people who are new to organizing? Also, what are your thoughts on Freedom Road Socialist Organization?

Forrest

As a Midwesterner, this is something I think about so much: How should revolutionaries approach the urban vs rural cultural/social/economic divide in the US? It seems like a massive obstacle to large scale collective action. And, especially as climate change becomes more of an immediate threat to supply chains, the division seems like it will have increasingly material and detrimental effects on the working class. Are there modern examples of leftist organizing efforts that have successfully navigated this division without tolerating either white supremacy or diluted liberal reform? Some of the Black Panthers’ efforts come to mind but post-Reagan I’m not aware of many examples.

Sorge's ghost

Communist farmers in Texas. I thought I was the only one. I am very interested in this question as well, especially with a decolonization perspective toward Norteno/ Indigenous peoples.

Ryan Spencer

Maybe less a Red Menace and more of a RevLeft question, but could you tell us about what led you to Buddhism and the books that formed you? Also, I find that a barrier to bringing especially religious people to the Left is the idea that leftism is inherently atheistic (referencing Marx’s quote about the opium of the masses and being a “materialist” but having no idea what that means lol as well as actions done in the USSR and other socialist formations against specific religious institutions or against religion broadly). I have a few people who are definitely taking baby steps leftward but one of them just read a book about communist persecution of Christians in their words. What misunderstandings and propaganda surround this topic and how would you talk about it with them?

H

1. How will climate change & our worsening ecological crisis change the conditions for revolution? Example: Alyson mentioned in a Red Menace episode that there might be entire areas that are abandoned by the state. What are the implications of this? 2. How should our organizing today be climate-informed? (Example: preparing communities for climate refugee support) 3. What differentiates mutual aid and acts of solidarity from good MLM strategy and mass line work? Example: Black red guard spoke about how giving food and talking about Mao isn’t enough, but that it can be, since they used it as an “in” for tenant organizing. What changed and why is the latter considered good organizing?

Rev Left Radio

I can definitely do more. I was thinking about recording a body meditation for sleep actually. If there is a desire out there for more, I will def do them! :)

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely! Love the cosmo comrades, and really respect their work all around! Some of them have my phone number and email, and I am ALWAYS open to discussing anythign with them!

Rev Left Radio

short answer: yes they can be. WE need people working on all fronts and trying to connect up different struggles and programs. Cooperation Jackson is great form what I know about them!

Workers' Lit

Do you forsee the growing wave of south american socialist movements as a cohesive movement, or as a bunch of independent ones. How can we support our comrades from Bolivia to Brazil to Chile to Venezuela past posting useless infographics and the occasional donation?

Klaus Zimmermann Mayo

This closely relates to the question about agrarian/agricultural reform/revolution in the United States.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

This is a good question. I asked a similar question to this on a live show since I live in a rural area and some of the listeners (the show was simultaneously being streamed on YouTube) derided me for being overly intellectual and that I need to “organize my people.” The reality about rural organizing is you are facing more obstacles than urban organizers. There’s usually zero infrastructure, local residents have little to no existing political education outside the two-party system, and if you’re outwardly socialist/communist you put your reputation at risk. Plus, so many “leftist” organizers are so obsessed with political purity that they’ll write off rural whites at racist and a waste of time. As leftists we should never excuse anybody’s racism, sexism, etc. However, there will never be a socialist revolution in this country if it is based on principles of political purity which is really just liberalism cloaked in identitarianism and presented as radical politics, which is really meant to make liberals feel good about themselves.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

If I remember correctly, he did in the past (or the other way around) but I don't believe it's a topic he's ever explored specifically.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Could you add to it the basics of buddhism for people interested in possibly adopting the practice? I've been doing some research and lots of sources are saying you need to be taught by a practitioner and/or be with people to engage in Zen. I have no prior knowledge about Buddhism really outside of what I've heard on this show. How does one get started if they don't live near a buddhist temple?

Shane

So have you finally seen "The Young Karl Marx" ? What did you think? I like to hear your takes Breht (Alyson too. I just remember I asked you about it a lot a couple years ago haha)

Ethan

How do you square the industrialization necessary to maintain a socialist/anti-imperialist bloc and/or reach the phase of capitalism necessary for successful socialist revolution with the global need to de-industrialize in the face of climate change? I know this has been discussed in relation to fossil fuels, for example the issue of predicating a socialist movement on oil sovereignty in Venezuela, but the issue runs deeper than fossil fuel concerns. As the IPCC warned, in order to stop global catastrophe, we will need to change our entire way of life, which will mean cutting into other sectors like tourism and consumer goods, main sources of revenue for Cuba and China respectively. Further industrialization across the global south will likely rely on the current western standards in consumption, which will need to be drastically decreased in order to meet the emissions goals to prevent catastrophic warming. Do you see current and future revolutionary movements responding to this by de-centering the role of industrial workers a la Mao? How else can we envision the overthrow of imperialism on a global scale without the luxury of mass industrialization? And can Marxist-Leninists learn and take cues from other ideologies (anarcho-primitivism for example) on how to build a more equitable world without relying on the old, extractivist dichotomy between “nature” and “civilization”?

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I'm going to post this here too because I don't know if anyone actually uses the community page for this show on Patreon so I apologize in advance if it's out of place. It didn't look like there was a lot of posts there. So I am teaching contemporary world history class for 11th graders this year. I would like to get into psyops, propaganda, and related topics. However, you cannot find anything about this stuff online that is geared toward teaching, especially high schoolers. You can find some propaganda lessons but it only focuses on Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union (go figure). Does anyone have any suggestions about how to go about this? I don't know if I really want to make materials for this because I know the topic itself is pretty dense and complicated, especially for high schoolers. I do plan to teach a unit on media literacy but of course a lot of the information about that is the BlueAnon theory that Trump was elected by Putin or very shallow analysis of disinformation. Thanks in advance!

H

I’m also interested in this question! I think it ties in well with the recent discourse on the imperative of “degrowth”

Blargh

This might be a late reply, but I would like to learn more about Deng Xiaoping and his contributions and criticisms from some on the left.

HailZeus

Hello I just recently joined but was wondering if you have considered inviting Fred Hampton Jr or doing any sort of collaboration with him and/or the Panther Cubs?

HailZeus

"political purity which is really just liberalism cloaked in identitarianism and presented as radical politics, which is really meant to make liberals feel good about themselves." You have given words and articulation to my thoughts. Thank You.