Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht reads, comments upon, and critiques an article in the NYT: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/29/magazine/sopranos.html

Files

Comments

Matt Pierce

I was so excited when I got the notification you had done this! The Sopranos is my favorite show of all time, and one of the most trenchant critiques of the violence, ugliness, and stupidity of American imperial decline ever produced. Just a great episode. Love and solidarity as always.

Jacob Gimbel

I looked up the NYT author, their Twitter bio proclaims their age as 36. Your critiques hold nonetheless. Though rather than their ending thoughts characterized by condescension, I took their nihilistic / sardonic comments as self-absorbed and defeatist. As you mention, they use "we" as if lefty millennials are a monolith and share their moderate privilege and woeful inaction. I would guess they belong to a broad group of mostly-online "leftists" who are newly disillusioned by the DNC / electoralism and either haven't yet conceived of alternative means to change or have turned to nihilism. So they continue "lamenting the sad state of affairs while doing almost exactly nothing to improve ourselves, or anything at all".

Rev Left Radio

ah, I didnt know! Great follow up and feedback. You hit the nail on the head!

Steven Phillips

Your timing is impeccable. I just started watching sopranos for the first time last week.

Zendo Cat

This as an apertif made watching the new movie so much more enjoyable. You should make this public. I think it would make a great gateway to share w/ new listeners.

Abram Zewuster

Hej Breht this was great I never watched the Sopranos but I'm defenitly gonna when time allows it. I think your critiques of the 2nd part of the article are spot on! As for you being able to continue to do the show I sincerely hope you can and will from a selfish point of view just because it's a delight to listen to it and learn from it and share with others and because I think it's so good to see somebody do something they realy enjoy and are good at, that doesn't happen enough in this fucking system we live in. Just listened back a lot of episodes from a while back ( Fred Hampton, Malcom X, the Vietnam War etc...) and the ep on red patriotism so good! But also the sister podcasts Red Menace and Guerrilla History are perfect learning material and entertaining and props to the other hosts as well. All this just to say keep up the good work and most important of all keep doing what you like! Love and Solidarity!

Squiggle

Hey Breht, I'm a white genx man who does real well and maxes out Patreon. While my peers consume Sam Harris, Vaush, and Joe Rogan, I'm forever pointing them to your show. My partner is also genx. She spent her career as a biodynamic farmer, and now she's full time mom. She's penniless. I watched the Sopranos as it aired. I was in my 30s. I found it predictable and depressing. Slacker meets Goodfellas, meh. I prefer the outrage and light comedy of something like MASH, or the futures that can be in Star Trek, with the history of Earth nearly destroyed by capitalism coming back alive in communism. I want to help organize. I want to help smash capital. I'm 100% exhausted with my job and raising two young children, and I want to find my place in the revolution. I beg you to start engaging orgs on the pod. To start weighing the pros and cons of different organizing principles and actions. The "Reading Capital with Comrades" got me more interested in the PSL and actually engaging Capital. Let's talk about Dual Power and building the party. Let's talk about things we can do now to empower the poorest and teach the young. KEEP GOING! You have a real talent for this. We are with you. You have enriched my life considerably, and I've turned on a dozen people to your pods. Solidarity

Rev Left Radio

Thank you very much. Love and Solidarity to you as well, my friend!!! <3

Rev Left Radio

I really appreciate this feedback and your kind words. Your experience of the Sopranoes is interesting for sure (and I love Star Trek as well haha). I feel you on being exhausted. A beaten down, precarious, stressed out worker is more likely to be obedient and not have time to organize. The system works this way for a reason! Ive had lots of orgs on the show before but I agree I havent for a while - for no reason really, it just kinda happened that way. But I am always looking out for more orgs to have on the show! Thank you again for the kind and encouraging words. It means a lot to me. Solidarity!

Melissa

Hey Breht - Enjoyed this episode a lot and had many of the same thoughts when I read the article. I wonder if you've seen Random Acts of Flyness, specifically S1 E5? The "White Angel/White Devil" segment kind of blew my mind and has forever changed how I view white male antiheroes on prestige TV shows (or, in pop culture generally). I think you'd really appreciate the Jungian approach, too. My partner and I are both first gen college grads from working class families, saddled with a shit-ton of debt, and existing in a weird no man's land where we're aliens to our families as well as the professional middle class folks in our peer group. We're also both on the generational cusp of X and Millennial (now known as Xennials or Elder Millennials to marketers - eye roll). I have become so exhausted by the "generation wars" because it often becomes another way to obscure the real source of inequality as well as potential points of solidarity, and it just does not speak to my or my family's experience, but damn if it doesn't always feel like xers and boomers are putting the rest of us on the defensive with this crap. I am sick be being portrayed as lazy or dim because I not only don't have access to the middle class American dream, but also, I don't want it! It's a fucking lie and a source of misery for so many. Mostly, I wanted to comment because I was really moved by your expression of gratitude at the end of the episode because I feel so grateful to you for this show. My partner and I have been listening for about 3 years and it has genuinely improved many aspects of our life - intellectually, relationally - how we engage with others and our community, how we approach organizing, even how I approach my job (I'm a librarian - ask me about how libraries are a great model for socialist distribution of goods and services:)) So thank YOU! all the love & solidarity <3

online Leftist Archive Project (LARP)

I feel your pain on the spilling of the coffee. Very few things make me more instantly bewildered and enraged hahaha. As for the end of this piece.... Fucking thank you!! Totally correct analysis. Especially on the climate stuff. The rub is that, well, so many of the emissions ARE coming from 5 large corporations and the American military. I'm imagining someone in the antebellum era, saying, "Hey these abolitionists are so dumb. If you don't like slavery, just don't purchase anything with cotton in it." When it's so interwoven into our economy in such a fundamental way, people can't just willpower their way out of participating. This is what separates a bullshit liberal analysis (par for the course for NYT magazine) from a materialist analysis.