Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Corey Mohler (Existential Comics) and Zach Weinersmith (Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal) join Breht to discuss free will, determinism, the role of consciousness, the role of the self, and the implications of the debate for society. Corey also articulates his compatibillist position as Zach and Breht raise questions and offer possible critiques.

Check out Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal here: https://www.smbc-comics.com/

Follow Zach on twitter: https://twitter.com/ZachWeiner

Check out Existential Comics here: http://existentialcomics.com/

Follow Corey on Twitter @ExistentialComs

Outro Music: "Freewill" by Rush

Files

Comments

Josh Ruston

So excited for this one!

Harry

Awesome episode y’all, it’s great to see the dialectic between contrasting views fleshed out! 😆 Reminds me of arguing with my friend about a phrase I became convinced of at 16, “we do as we must.” Needless to say my thoughts are slightly more nuanced now, thanks to people like y’all and experiences like this. I, uhm, know y’all are busy as all hell, but I just wanted to mention I left a pretty spicy question, or uh, ponderation, in the discord I’m feeling increasingly guilty about… that’d likely be better off deleted than given any attention to. I’m experiencing some terrible cognitive dissonance right now cause although I’d delete it myself I could really use your and really everyone’s thoughts on the matter, despite thinking such discussion might be better off not had... So, with that said. If you do get a chance to read… please do delete. 😝 Thank you so much for everything you do Breht.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Harry, I am really glad the episode was interesting to you. To be honest, I have not been on the discord - or any discord - since we first made it. I just dont have enough time in the day - especially with multiple kids - to balance all the platforms, or even to respond to every message on here! I apologize.

Harry

Oh man absolutely no apologies necessary, I already can’t thank you enough!! 🙌😭 I’ll see what discussion I can drum up among the comrades— may life bless you and the fam with unexpected moments of serenity and love! 🙏

Let’s go

Absolutely loved this episode. A great topic, great perspectives, communicated in easy to understand language.

EspressoCinephile

Always love to see Rev Left foray into more philosophical territory. I know Corey was just on, but I think it would be fascinating to hear him come on to talk about Dostoevsky sometime since he has brought it up on several episodes already. I think Corey would be the perfect person to tackle this, as the topic of Dostoevsky obviously doesn't seem to be on the surface very "revolutionary" (hell, he even wrote an entire book called The Devils to satirize early Russian revolutionaries, as well as the novella Notes From Underground to explicitly disagree with Chernyshevsky, one of Lenin's most formative influences), but I think he would be able to do a good job showing the profound breadth of Dostoevsky's life & work (such as the deeply existential themes, his earlier involvement with utopian socialist circles associated with other revolutionary intellectuals such as Nikolai Nekrasov & Vissarion Belinsky, his kind of grassroots tendencies, etc.). In my own experience, one does not have to necessarily agree with Dostoevsky's messages in order to appreciate both his writing style and his work.

Rev Left Radio

Great idea. I will literally send him this and see if he is interested! Stay tuned!

Nico Gouveia

Very neat episode. I enjoy every time Buddhism is brought up lol. Has anyone seen the documentary “The Cruise”(1998)? It deals w this tour guide/philosopher in NYC and his perception of the world. I think an increase in consciousness (perception?) can itself be revolutionary. A phenomenological approach towards seeing the world can reveal the liveliness in it, creating a greater appreciation for it. This is something capital fights against and is also something we can consciously choose to develop. Would love to hear more history about the concept of consciousness from a left wing perspective. Keep it up Brett! :)

Jack Sauer

There's an FX limited series called "DEVS" that came out recently, it's streaming on Hulu. The premise is that a tech company built a quantum computer that can predict the future / show any point in the past because the universe is deterministic and the computer can calculate exactly how it unfolds all the way to the Big Bang. Amazing show that deals with a lot of these concepts, highly recommend.